diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_primary_source_inventory.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_primary_source_inventory.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..11f27f2c2 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_primary_source_inventory.json @@ -0,0 +1,28 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-source-inventory-v1", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "scope": "DOM049 prisons: 70 primary-source public statements", + "claim_boundary": "Inventory acceptance proves only that the named public PDF was fetched with the recorded SHA-256 and yielded extractable text. It does not approve a claim or establish the truth of statements in the source.", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "already_registered_primary_claims": 4344, + "remaining_claims": 70, + "expected_total_primary_claims": 4414, + "sources": [{ + "domain_code": "DOM049", + "domain_title": "Prisons", + "remaining_target": 70, + "source_subdir": "dom049", + "source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "pdf_pages": 52, + "content_start_page": 1, + "content_end_page": 52, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "min_quote_characters": 60, + "min_quote_words": 10, + "reject_pattern": "Figure \\\\d|Table \\\\d|Source:|Note:|Acknowledg|References|(?-i:^[a-z])" + }] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..40e4397a8 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 2", + "public_claim_text": "No use of this publication may be made for resale or any other commercial purpose whatsoever without prior permission in writing from UNODC.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "No use of this publication may be made for resale or any other commercial purpose whatsoever without prior permission in writing from UNODC." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 4", + "public_claim_text": "Globally, imprisonment rates have returned to pre-pandemic levels following a COVID-19 induced dip, while aggregated data–such as global level figures–often mask very high levels of prison use in certain places.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Globally, imprisonment rates have returned to pre-pandemic levels following a COVID-19 induced dip, while aggregated data–such as global level figures–often mask very high levels of prison use in certain places." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 4", + "public_claim_text": "The survey results, which reveal widespread recognition of the importance of rehabilitation in prison, are presented in this first edition of Prison Matters. ………………………………………………………………… UNODC, ‘The United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules)’, Rule 4, 2015.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The survey results, which reveal widespread recognition of the importance of rehabilitation in prison, are presented in this first edition of Prison Matters. ………………………………………………………………… UNODC, ‘The United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules)’, Rule 4, 2015." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 11", + "public_claim_text": "World prison population on the increase, after a hiatus during the COVID-19 pandemic Following a decrease during the COVID-19 pandemic, the number of people held in prison worldwide has started to rise again.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "World prison population on the increase, after a hiatus during the COVID-19 pandemic Following a decrease during the COVID-19 pandemic, the number of people held in prison worldwide has started to rise again." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 11", + "public_claim_text": "The vast majority of prisoners worldwide are men, representing almost 94 per cent of the prison population or 10.8 million prisoners in 2022.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The vast majority of prisoners worldwide are men, representing almost 94 per cent of the prison population or 10.8 million prisoners in 2022." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 12", + "public_claim_text": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation between 2019 and 2020 before increasing again in 2021 and 2022 (respectively to 143 and 144 prisoners per 100,000 population).6 In 2022, about half of the global population in prison was incarcerated in Asia, almost four percentage points more than in 2012, and a third in the Americas.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation between 2019 and 2020 before increasing again in 2021 and 2022 (respectively to 143 and 144 prisoners per 100,000 population).6 In 2022, about half of the global population in prison was incarcerated in Asia, almost four percentage points more than in 2012, and a third in the Americas." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 12", + "public_claim_text": "Estimates for 2022 indicate that people in the Americas were nearly 4 times more likely to be in prison than those living in Africa.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Estimates for 2022 indicate that people in the Americas were nearly 4 times more likely to be in prison than those living in Africa." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 13", + "public_claim_text": "Nearly a third of the global prison population remains in pre-trial detention, masking wide regional disparities In 2022, around 3.5 million prisoners worldwide were held in pre-trial detention.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Nearly a third of the global prison population remains in pre-trial detention, masking wide regional disparities In 2022, around 3.5 million prisoners worldwide were held in pre-trial detention." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 13", + "public_claim_text": "Tracking the overall increase in the number of persons held in prison globally, the percentage of unsentenced prisoners among all prisoners has remained almost stable at around 30 per cent since 2012.9 ………………………………………………………………… Ibid.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Tracking the overall increase in the number of persons held in prison globally, the percentage of unsentenced prisoners among all prisoners has remained almost stable at around 30 per cent since 2012.9 ………………………………………………………………… Ibid." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 14", + "public_claim_text": "Across global regions, the highest proportion of unsentenced prisoners among the overall prison population is reported in Africa and Oceania (both at 36 per cent in 2022), and the lowest in Europe (18 per cent).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Across global regions, the highest proportion of unsentenced prisoners among the overall prison population is reported in Africa and Oceania (both at 36 per cent in 2022), and the lowest in Europe (18 per cent)." + } + ] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..804451353 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 14", + "public_claim_text": "Breaking down these data to subregion level, the situation is particularly concerning in Southern Asia where almost two thirds of detainees (63 per cent) are held unsentenced.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Breaking down these data to subregion level, the situation is particularly concerning in Southern Asia where almost two thirds of detainees (63 per cent) are held unsentenced." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 15", + "public_claim_text": "In some regions women face a higher risk of pre-trial detention than men In 2022, a total of 3,311,000 men and 216,000 women were held in pre-trial detention worldwide.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In some regions women face a higher risk of pre-trial detention than men In 2022, a total of 3,311,000 men and 216,000 women were held in pre-trial detention worldwide." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 15", + "public_claim_text": "Oceania has the highest gender gap, with 43 per cent of women compared to 35 per cent of men held without a sentence.13 ………………………………………………………………… Ibid.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Oceania has the highest gender gap, with 43 per cent of women compared to 35 per cent of men held without a sentence.13 ………………………………………………………………… Ibid." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 16", + "public_claim_text": "Prisons are overcrowded in more than 60 per cent of countries worldwide, sparking concerns about health and human rights of those detained in these prisons Overcrowding remains a significant concern in many prisons.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Prisons are overcrowded in more than 60 per cent of countries worldwide, sparking concerns about health and human rights of those detained in these prisons Overcrowding remains a significant concern in many prisons." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 16", + "public_claim_text": "This situation is particularly concerning in Africa and the Americas, where more than 70 per cent of countries with available data report overcrowded prison systems operating at more than 100 per cent of their planned capacity.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "This situation is particularly concerning in Africa and the Americas, where more than 70 per cent of countries with available data report overcrowded prison systems operating at more than 100 per cent of their planned capacity." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 17", + "public_claim_text": "Enhanced efforts are required to prevent deaths in prison; more than 1 in 10 deaths occurring in prison is a suicide The number and type of deaths occurring in prisons can provide insight into prison conditions and safety in prisons.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Enhanced efforts are required to prevent deaths in prison; more than 1 in 10 deaths occurring in prison is a suicide The number and type of deaths occurring in prisons can provide insight into prison conditions and safety in prisons." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 17", + "public_claim_text": "While data on mortality in prison remain limited in Africa, Asia and Oceania, it is possible to produce a global average based on data from 95 countries.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "While data on mortality in prison remain limited in Africa, Asia and Oceania, it is possible to produce a global average based on data from 95 countries." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 18", + "public_claim_text": "This is nearly three times lower than the crude death rate18 globally in 2022 (8.4 deaths per 1,000 people),19 reflecting the fact that people in prison are on average much younger than the general population.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "This is nearly three times lower than the crude death rate18 globally in 2022 (8.4 deaths per 1,000 people),19 reflecting the fact that people in prison are on average much younger than the general population." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 18", + "public_claim_text": "However, countries in the Americas with data had a much higher number of intentional homicides per 100,000 prisoners than countries in other regions, at 18.3 victims of intentional homicide per 100,000 prisoners.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "However, countries in the Americas with data had a much higher number of intentional homicides per 100,000 prisoners than countries in other regions, at 18.3 victims of intentional homicide per 100,000 prisoners." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 19", + "public_claim_text": "Based on available data in 95 countries worldwide, in 2022, 34.2 prisoners out of every 100,000 prisoners committed suicide, a rate that is more than three times higher than the 2019 global crude suicide rate of 9.2 deaths per 100,000 general population.23 The share of deaths due to suicide, among all deaths in prison, was the highest in Europe, at close to 18 per cent, followed by the Americas at 12 per cent.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Based on available data in 95 countries worldwide, in 2022, 34.2 prisoners out of every 100,000 prisoners committed suicide, a rate that is more than three times higher than the 2019 global crude suicide rate of 9.2 deaths per 100,000 general population.23 The share of deaths due to suicide, among all deaths in prison, was the highest in Europe, at close to 18 per cent, followed by the Americas at 12 per cent." + } + ] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2bbae15c2 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 19", + "public_claim_text": "Suicide was, however, the reported cause of death for less than 5 per cent of the deaths of prisoners in countries of Asia and Africa with data.24 ………………………………………………………………… World Health Organisation, ‘The Global Health Observatory, Suicide Rates’, The World Health Organisation, 2024.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Suicide was, however, the reported cause of death for less than 5 per cent of the deaths of prisoners in countries of Asia and Africa with data.24 ………………………………………………………………… World Health Organisation, ‘The Global Health Observatory, Suicide Rates’, The World Health Organisation, 2024." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 20", + "public_claim_text": "In some countries, prisons are under-staffed, reducing safety and undermining efforts to foster a rehabilitative prison environment Significant differences exist in prison staffing between different regions of the world.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In some countries, prisons are under-staffed, reducing safety and undermining efforts to foster a rehabilitative prison environment Significant differences exist in prison staffing between different regions of the world." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 20", + "public_claim_text": "In 2022, they had the second highest number of prison staff relative to their general population, at 52.9 prison staff per 100,000 population.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2022, they had the second highest number of prison staff relative to their general population, at 52.9 prison staff per 100,000 population." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 21", + "public_claim_text": "The share of women employed in prisons varies across regions with the highest share of women among all prison staff at 34.4 per cent in countries with data in Europe and the lowest at 18.7 per cent in countries with data in Africa.27 Rate of prison personnel per 100,000 population, 2022 or latest year available Notes: Regional and global figures are averages of countries with data weighted by their population.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The share of women employed in prisons varies across regions with the highest share of women among all prison staff at 34.4 per cent in countries with data in Europe and the lowest at 18.7 per cent in countries with data in Africa.27 Rate of prison personnel per 100,000 population, 2022 or latest year available Notes: Regional and global figures are averages of countries with data weighted by their population." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 21", + "public_claim_text": "Globally, nearly 7 out of 10 those working in prisons are responsible for the surveillance of prisoners, while slightly more than 2 out of 10 are part of the prison administration and 1 out of 10 are employed to support prisoner health (including ………………………………………………………………… Ibid.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Globally, nearly 7 out of 10 those working in prisons are responsible for the surveillance of prisoners, while slightly more than 2 out of 10 are part of the prison administration and 1 out of 10 are employed to support prisoner health (including ………………………………………………………………… Ibid." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 22", + "public_claim_text": "A positive answer could potentially reflect that rehabilitation is being actively supported at an operational level, but it might equally reflect that rehabilitation is listed as one of the overall objectives of imprisonment, such as in penal legislation.32 All the same, looking at the regional breakdown, dedicated rehabilitation planning is reported to be underway in all regions. ………………………………………………………………… Ibid.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "A positive answer could potentially reflect that rehabilitation is being actively supported at an operational level, but it might equally reflect that rehabilitation is listed as one of the overall objectives of imprisonment, such as in penal legislation.32 All the same, looking at the regional breakdown, dedicated rehabilitation planning is reported to be underway in all regions. ………………………………………………………………… Ibid." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 23", + "public_claim_text": "The UNODC survey also asked responding jurisdictions about the level of priority that they would assign to a number of goals to establish a prison environment conducive to rehabilitation.33 All these goals, a number of respondents observed, are core goals for prison administration and the task of fostering a rehabilitative prison environment; therefore, caution is required when interpreting their relative priorities.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The UNODC survey also asked responding jurisdictions about the level of priority that they would assign to a number of goals to establish a prison environment conducive to rehabilitation.33 All these goals, a number of respondents observed, are core goals for prison administration and the task of fostering a rehabilitative prison environment; therefore, caution is required when interpreting their relative priorities." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 23", + "public_claim_text": "Three goals were consistently ranked as high priority: fair and dignified prisoner treatment; torture prevention mechanisms; and safety and security.34 These are the bedrocks of good prison management.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Three goals were consistently ranked as high priority: fair and dignified prisoner treatment; torture prevention mechanisms; and safety and security.34 These are the bedrocks of good prison management." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 24", + "public_claim_text": "Responding jurisdictions were asked to identify a maximum of five highest priorities and a maximum of five lowest priorities relative to their rehabilitation objectives.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Responding jurisdictions were asked to identify a maximum of five highest priorities and a maximum of five lowest priorities relative to their rehabilitation objectives." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 24", + "public_claim_text": "First, individualized case management for every prisoner, and second, high-quality inter-agency cooperation between custodial and post-release agencies, such as probation or parole services.36 Almost half of jurisdictions with a rehabilitation strategy report the engagement of prisoners as stakeholders during planning Many stakeholders can be involved in the development of rehabilitation strategies in prison, among which are prisoners and their families.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "First, individualized case management for every prisoner, and second, high-quality inter-agency cooperation between custodial and post-release agencies, such as probation or parole services.36 Almost half of jurisdictions with a rehabilitation strategy report the engagement of prisoners as stakeholders during planning Many stakeholders can be involved in the development of rehabilitation strategies in prison, among which are prisoners and their families." + } + ] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..28287ac0c --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 25", + "public_claim_text": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation traditional feature of justice sector policy and planning, it is increasingly recognised by penal policy makers and prison managers as an element of best practice in prisons and offender management.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation traditional feature of justice sector policy and planning, it is increasingly recognised by penal policy makers and prison managers as an element of best practice in prisons and offender management." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 25", + "public_claim_text": "Evidence from other areas where it is a more established practice, such as in healthcare, has shown it is associated with superior outcomes and satisfaction.37 Among the 46 jurisdictions that answered the question, around half (49 per cent) reported that they had taken into account the views and experience of prisoners, former prisoners and/or their families, while a further 15 per cent indicated that such engagement processes were being planned.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Evidence from other areas where it is a more established practice, such as in healthcare, has shown it is associated with superior outcomes and satisfaction.37 Among the 46 jurisdictions that answered the question, around half (49 per cent) reported that they had taken into account the views and experience of prisoners, former prisoners and/or their families, while a further 15 per cent indicated that such engagement processes were being planned." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 26", + "public_claim_text": "These can be divided into two sorts: those that focus on improving general prison management; and those that focus directly upon the prisoner.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "These can be divided into two sorts: those that focus on improving general prison management; and those that focus directly upon the prisoner." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 26", + "public_claim_text": "The latter emphasizes practices that directly support behaviour change (rehabilitation, desistance) processes at the individual level.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The latter emphasizes practices that directly support behaviour change (rehabilitation, desistance) processes at the individual level." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 27", + "public_claim_text": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation Responding jurisdictions reported fewer activities supporting effective rehabilitation and social reintegration by involving a range of different stakeholders and as per community standards.41 The least reported of these, at 43 per cent, were measures to ”normalise“ prison life.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation Responding jurisdictions reported fewer activities supporting effective rehabilitation and social reintegration by involving a range of different stakeholders and as per community standards.41 The least reported of these, at 43 per cent, were measures to ”normalise“ prison life." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 27", + "public_claim_text": "These are measures to ensure prisoners have the same access to services, such as healthcare, as they would in the community, that the prison’s routines are designed to reduce institutionalisation as far as possible, and that a degree of normal contact, such as with family, is maintained while the prisoner is in custody.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "These are measures to ensure prisoners have the same access to services, such as healthcare, as they would in the community, that the prison’s routines are designed to reduce institutionalisation as far as possible, and that a degree of normal contact, such as with family, is maintained while the prisoner is in custody." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 31", + "public_claim_text": "A considerable body of evidence, much of it from low- and middle-income countries, now illustrates the feasibility, sustainability and cost-benefits of reducing the use of pre trial detention45 46 47 and of non-custodial measures.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "A considerable body of evidence, much of it from low- and middle-income countries, now illustrates the feasibility, sustainability and cost-benefits of reducing the use of pre trial detention45 46 47 and of non-custodial measures." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 31", + "public_claim_text": "Estimates based on evidence from prisons in Malawi and Uganda, for example, suggest that effective paralegal programmes can be implemented for a cost of US$20 per prisoner and produce savings of three times that.48 ………………………………………………………………… Open Society Foundations and UNDP, ‘The Socioeconomic Impact of Pretrial Detention: A Global Pretrial Justice Report’, Open Society Justice Initiative (New York, NY, 2011).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Estimates based on evidence from prisons in Malawi and Uganda, for example, suggest that effective paralegal programmes can be implemented for a cost of US$20 per prisoner and produce savings of three times that.48 ………………………………………………………………… Open Society Foundations and UNDP, ‘The Socioeconomic Impact of Pretrial Detention: A Global Pretrial Justice Report’, Open Society Justice Initiative (New York, NY, 2011)." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 32", + "public_claim_text": "In summary, the impact of overcrowding multiplies the challenges faced by prison services in preserving the integrity of prison management, ensuring the health, safety and well-being of prisoners, maintaining a rehabilitative prison regime and preserving prison security.49 Research has extensively documented these pernicious effects of overcrowding.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In summary, the impact of overcrowding multiplies the challenges faced by prison services in preserving the integrity of prison management, ensuring the health, safety and well-being of prisoners, maintaining a rehabilitative prison regime and preserving prison security.49 Research has extensively documented these pernicious effects of overcrowding." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 32", + "public_claim_text": "Stéphanie Baggio et al., ‘Do Overcrowding and Turnover Cause Violence in Prison?’, Frontiers in Psychiatry 10 (24 January 2020): 1015.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Stéphanie Baggio et al., ‘Do Overcrowding and Turnover Cause Violence in Prison?’, Frontiers in Psychiatry 10 (24 January 2020): 1015." + } + ] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c0b7a69fa --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 33", + "public_claim_text": "A study in the United States, for example, has shown that almost 90 per cent of imprisoned fathers report that their female partner is taking care of their child.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "A study in the United States, for example, has shown that almost 90 per cent of imprisoned fathers report that their female partner is taking care of their child." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 33", + "public_claim_text": "Jo Taylor et al., ‘A Rapid Review of the Evidence on Models of Service Delivery for Correctional Centre-Based Mothers and Children’s Units: Does Our Approach Need to Change?’, BMJ Global Health 9, no.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Jo Taylor et al., ‘A Rapid Review of the Evidence on Models of Service Delivery for Correctional Centre-Based Mothers and Children’s Units: Does Our Approach Need to Change?’, BMJ Global Health 9, no." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 34", + "public_claim_text": "A toxicology study of all deaths in Irish prisons between 2009-2014, for example, found that in 30 per cent of suicide cases in prisons the person tested positive for drugs at time of death, even though the immediate cause of death was usually hanging.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "A toxicology study of all deaths in Irish prisons between 2009-2014, for example, found that in 30 per cent of suicide cases in prisons the person tested positive for drugs at time of death, even though the immediate cause of death was usually hanging." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 34", + "public_claim_text": "One systematic review of 38 high-quality suicide prevention studies from seven countries identified cognitive behavioural interventions as one of the most ………………………………………………………………… Róisín Mulgrew, ‘Prisoner Lives Cut Short: The Need to Address Structural, Societal and Environmental Factors to Reduce Preventable Prisoner Deaths’, Human Rights Law Review 23, no.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "One systematic review of 38 high-quality suicide prevention studies from seven countries identified cognitive behavioural interventions as one of the most ………………………………………………………………… Róisín Mulgrew, ‘Prisoner Lives Cut Short: The Need to Address Structural, Societal and Environmental Factors to Reduce Preventable Prisoner Deaths’, Human Rights Law Review 23, no." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 35", + "public_claim_text": "In Europe, for example, significant differences exist both within and between subregions as far as prison staffing levels are concerned.74 The burden of shortages appears to fall most heavily on specialised staff and health professionals, such as psychologists, nurses, and social workers.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Europe, for example, significant differences exist both within and between subregions as far as prison staffing levels are concerned.74 The burden of shortages appears to fall most heavily on specialised staff and health professionals, such as psychologists, nurses, and social workers." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 35", + "public_claim_text": "Marcelo F Aebi, Edoardo Cocco, and Lorena Molnar, ‘Prisons and Prisoners in Europe 2022: Key Findings of the SPACE I Report’, Series UNILCRIM (Council of Europe and University of Lausanne, 2023).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Marcelo F Aebi, Edoardo Cocco, and Lorena Molnar, ‘Prisons and Prisoners in Europe 2022: Key Findings of the SPACE I Report’, Series UNILCRIM (Council of Europe and University of Lausanne, 2023)." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 36", + "public_claim_text": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation found that mental ill health increased violent recidivism by 20 per cent in men and 40 per cent in women after all other risk factors had been accounted for.77 Fostering rehabilitation of prisoners A key aspect of prison management is to foster the rehabilitation and social reintegration prospects of prisoners.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation found that mental ill health increased violent recidivism by 20 per cent in men and 40 per cent in women after all other risk factors had been accounted for.77 Fostering rehabilitation of prisoners A key aspect of prison management is to foster the rehabilitation and social reintegration prospects of prisoners." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 36", + "public_claim_text": "Some forms of prison programming ensure fundamental rights, such as educational programming,79 while others, including vocational training and employment, provide experience in a key pathway out of crime, which is stable employment.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Some forms of prison programming ensure fundamental rights, such as educational programming,79 while others, including vocational training and employment, provide experience in a key pathway out of crime, which is stable employment." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 37", + "public_claim_text": "At global level, there remains a wide gap in the access of prisoners to rehabilitation programmes and other constructive activities in support of their social reintegration prospects, with such access being severely limited in resource constrained environments in particular. ………………………………………………………………… Flora Fitzalan Howard and Helen Wakeling, ‘Evaluating the Impact of “Rehabilitative Adjudications” in Four English Prisons’, Psychology, Crime & Law 27, no.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "At global level, there remains a wide gap in the access of prisoners to rehabilitation programmes and other constructive activities in support of their social reintegration prospects, with such access being severely limited in resource constrained environments in particular. ………………………………………………………………… Flora Fitzalan Howard and Helen Wakeling, ‘Evaluating the Impact of “Rehabilitative Adjudications” in Four English Prisons’, Psychology, Crime & Law 27, no." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 41", + "public_claim_text": "In 2024, UNODC invited Member States’ prison administrations and other relevant bodies, as identified by their respective governments, to participate in a survey on prison rehabilitation and rehabilitative environments.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2024, UNODC invited Member States’ prison administrations and other relevant bodies, as identified by their respective governments, to participate in a survey on prison rehabilitation and rehabilitative environments." + } + ] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..92bda95cd --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 41", + "public_claim_text": "The objective of the survey was to examine Member States’ priorities, frameworks and practices of prison rehabilitation to understand how prison rehabilitative environments can be made possible.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The objective of the survey was to examine Member States’ priorities, frameworks and practices of prison rehabilitation to understand how prison rehabilitative environments can be made possible." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 42", + "public_claim_text": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation Prison rehabilitation strategies A key finding of this survey is the extent to which rehabilitation is recognised as a top priority for penal policy and penal administration and to which rehabilitation goals have become a focus of strategic planning.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation Prison rehabilitation strategies A key finding of this survey is the extent to which rehabilitation is recognised as a top priority for penal policy and penal administration and to which rehabilitation goals have become a focus of strategic planning." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 42", + "public_claim_text": "90 An important theme arising in the evidence of work on rehabilitation is the importance of culturally appropriate, or suitably tailored, schemes, initiatives and tools.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "90 An important theme arising in the evidence of work on rehabilitation is the importance of culturally appropriate, or suitably tailored, schemes, initiatives and tools." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 43", + "public_claim_text": "In almost all cases, jurisdictions that had developed a rehabilitation strategy, model or framework also had in place some form of implementation arrangements.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In almost all cases, jurisdictions that had developed a rehabilitation strategy, model or framework also had in place some form of implementation arrangements." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 44", + "public_claim_text": "Supporting descriptions and documents showed that many of the higher income jurisdictions have dedicated research and evaluation capacities that publish extensively the results of their work.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Supporting descriptions and documents showed that many of the higher income jurisdictions have dedicated research and evaluation capacities that publish extensively the results of their work." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 44", + "public_claim_text": "92 In some jurisdictions, these monitoring and evaluation efforts are required to fulfil statutory obligations and in some cases the prison service has key performance indicators associated with rehabilitation-related goals.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "92 In some jurisdictions, these monitoring and evaluation efforts are required to fulfil statutory obligations and in some cases the prison service has key performance indicators associated with rehabilitation-related goals." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 45", + "public_claim_text": "94 A second approach responding jurisdictions identified to develop a more rehabilitative prison environment was work undertaken to improve the social climate of prisons and the relationship between prisoners and prison staff.In one of the Baltic states, dynamic security is emphasised as an important component not only of institutional safety and security but so too of effective rehabilitation and resocialisation.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "94 A second approach responding jurisdictions identified to develop a more rehabilitative prison environment was work undertaken to improve the social climate of prisons and the relationship between prisoners and prison staff.In one of the Baltic states, dynamic security is emphasised as an important component not only of institutional safety and security but so too of effective rehabilitation and resocialisation." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 45", + "public_claim_text": "A rehabilitative index has been developed from this research, improving understanding of how prison environments influence different aspects.95 Finally, efforts to understand how rehabilitation is best achieved and to apply the results of research to rethinking the prison itself are reflected in new prison models.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "A rehabilitative index has been developed from this research, improving understanding of how prison environments influence different aspects.95 Finally, efforts to understand how rehabilitation is best achieved and to apply the results of research to rethinking the prison itself are reflected in new prison models." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 46", + "public_claim_text": "Second, more specialized rehabilitation programmes that target root causes of offending were implemented in around two thirds (68 per cent) of jurisdictions.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Second, more specialized rehabilitation programmes that target root causes of offending were implemented in around two thirds (68 per cent) of jurisdictions." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 46", + "public_claim_text": "Further, only about half of these jurisdictions (54 per cent) reported that programmes were developed on an evidence-based model or one that has a clear theory of change, and only slightly more (59 per cent) reported that these programmes were subject to regular monitoring and evaluation to inform improvements in practice.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Further, only about half of these jurisdictions (54 per cent) reported that programmes were developed on an evidence-based model or one that has a clear theory of change, and only slightly more (59 per cent) reported that these programmes were subject to regular monitoring and evaluation to inform improvements in practice." + } + ] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5691a86c4 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 47", + "public_claim_text": "Even there, questions have been raised about the relevance and impact of such “effective” practices for minority groups, including indigenous offenders.102 103 The available evidence base for what is an effective rehabilitation programme in prisons in other regional contexts remains slim.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Even there, questions have been raised about the relevance and impact of such “effective” practices for minority groups, including indigenous offenders.102 103 The available evidence base for what is an effective rehabilitation programme in prisons in other regional contexts remains slim." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 47", + "public_claim_text": "The apparent success of rehabilitative elements of this training is captured in the reports of around three quarters (76 per cent) of jurisdictions that they had achieved prison officer buy-in to rehabilitative objectives.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The apparent success of rehabilitative elements of this training is captured in the reports of around three quarters (76 per cent) of jurisdictions that they had achieved prison officer buy-in to rehabilitative objectives." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 48", + "public_claim_text": "Less than one in three jurisdictions (30 per cent) had some level of research staff capacity to support evidence-based learning and approaches.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Less than one in three jurisdictions (30 per cent) had some level of research staff capacity to support evidence-based learning and approaches." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 48", + "public_claim_text": "Specialist staff working with prisoners also appear to present a challenge, with fewer than half (41 per cent) of reporting jurisdictions having an adequate number of specialist personnel, including doctors, psychologists, psychiatrists, therapists, instructors and educators.105 Regional data indicated a broad trend toward more specialist staff and research capacity being available in higher income jurisdictions.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Specialist staff working with prisoners also appear to present a challenge, with fewer than half (41 per cent) of reporting jurisdictions having an adequate number of specialist personnel, including doctors, psychologists, psychiatrists, therapists, instructors and educators.105 Regional data indicated a broad trend toward more specialist staff and research capacity being available in higher income jurisdictions." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 49", + "public_claim_text": "Rehabilitation Rehabilitation can broadly be defined as “processes and practices that aim at the successful reintegration of those who have offended.”107 Since the 1990s, a dominant model of rehabilitation practice has emerged that focuses on a small set of programming targets (termed “criminogenic needs”) based on their empirically established relationship with reducing recidivism.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Rehabilitation Rehabilitation can broadly be defined as “processes and practices that aim at the successful reintegration of those who have offended.”107 Since the 1990s, a dominant model of rehabilitation practice has emerged that focuses on a small set of programming targets (termed “criminogenic needs”) based on their empirically established relationship with reducing recidivism." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 49", + "public_claim_text": "Seena Fazel et al., ‘An Updated Evidence Synthesis on the Risk-Need-Responsivity (RNR) Model: Umbrella Review and Commentary’, Journal of Criminal Justice 92 (1 May 2024): 1021-97.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Seena Fazel et al., ‘An Updated Evidence Synthesis on the Risk-Need-Responsivity (RNR) Model: Umbrella Review and Commentary’, Journal of Criminal Justice 92 (1 May 2024): 1021-97." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 50", + "public_claim_text": "Since studies of post-prison recidivism began in the 1920s, however, they have been plagued with problems of measurement.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Since studies of post-prison recidivism began in the 1920s, however, they have been plagued with problems of measurement." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 50", + "public_claim_text": "A systematic review of recidivism statistics concluded that “only 10 out of 50 countries with the largest prison populations reported recidivism statistics”, and most used slightly varying definitions.115 Two-year reconviction rates were the most common recidivism measure among the 33 countries globally that report post-prison reoffending, all but three of which are high income economies.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "A systematic review of recidivism statistics concluded that “only 10 out of 50 countries with the largest prison populations reported recidivism statistics”, and most used slightly varying definitions.115 Two-year reconviction rates were the most common recidivism measure among the 33 countries globally that report post-prison reoffending, all but three of which are high income economies." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 51", + "public_claim_text": "Research done on positive prison climates and on developing a more rehabilitative culture within prisons (see below) are examples of approaches that can contribute to understanding how prisons can be reformed to support prisoner rehabilitation and social reintegration.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Research done on positive prison climates and on developing a more rehabilitative culture within prisons (see below) are examples of approaches that can contribute to understanding how prisons can be reformed to support prisoner rehabilitation and social reintegration." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 51", + "public_claim_text": "Nevertheless, improving prison conditions generally, and redesigning prison regimes with a view to supporting rehabilitation more specifically, are key elements as highlighted, for example, in the ASEAN region.118 One suggested approach to understanding and designing more rehabilitative prison environments has been to focus on the social climate of the prison.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Nevertheless, improving prison conditions generally, and redesigning prison regimes with a view to supporting rehabilitation more specifically, are key elements as highlighted, for example, in the ASEAN region.118 One suggested approach to understanding and designing more rehabilitative prison environments has been to focus on the social climate of the prison." + } + ] +} diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G01-2026-07-23.json index d5db63b65..ff80d6bdb 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2345191628&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 2. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q7245853$AB3662D6-F08A-47A5-97DD-09F3E75721AA in revision 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes genre (P136) with value heavy metal music (Q38848).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P136\",\"hash\":\"bf0495756d3e88441ee73e8549419f5cd10014b9\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":38848,\"id\":\"Q38848\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q7245853$AB3662D6-F08A-47A5-97DD-09F3E75721AA\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"fa278ebfc458360e5aed63d5058cca83c46134f1\",\"snaks\":{\"P143\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P143\",\"hash\":\"e4f6d9441d0600513c4533c672b5ab472dc73694\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":328,\"id\":\"Q328\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P143\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2345191628&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q7245853; claims.P136; statement Q7245853$AB3662D6-F08A-47A5-97DD-09F3E75721AA", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-05-05T23:12:07Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "82b5c98aa692cb79333a252011327324cbebb3072a8864533ea826707d6c1a44", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "No use of this publication may be made for resale or any other commercial purpose whatsoever without prior permission in writing from UNODC.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "No use of this publication may be made for resale or any other commercial purpose whatsoever without prior permission in writing from UNODC.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 2", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "7b5c2f27805efafaa9e000547e49d1eed11d30670280f871729f6efbb9a816eb", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2345191628; entity Q7245853; source SHA-256 82b5c98aa692cb79333a252011327324cbebb3072a8864533ea826707d6c1a44; statement SHA-256 87dc5006abd0c9e4366b955f0d05e1c2d3f8b1dea56b597190409874d13b4cc6; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 7b5c2f27805efafaa9e000547e49d1eed11d30670280f871729f6efbb9a816eb; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3364, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "6349158764b6d7ff5eebed3c98a9e9dce4cecdb9eafbab1f97e76ca18783b22d", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q7245853$AB3662D6-F08A-47A5-97DD-09F3E75721AA in revision 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes genre (P136) with value heavy metal music (Q38848).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q7245853$AB3662D6-F08A-47A5-97DD-09F3E75721AA", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q7245853) / P136", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2345191628 at 2025-05-05T23:12:07Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "No use of this publication may be made for resale or any other commercial purpose whatsoever without prior permission in writing from UNODC.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 2", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G01-2026-07-23.svg index 3ec104197..79d4fb17b 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q7245853$AB3662D6-F08A-47A5-97DD-09F3E75721AA in revision - 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes genre (P136) with value heavy + No use of this publication may be made for resale or any other commercial purpose + whatsoever without prior permission in writing from UNODC. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T01-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q7245853) / P136 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2345191628 at 2025-05-05T23:12:07Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q7245853$AB3662D6-F08A-47A5-97DD-09F3E75721AA - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 2 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G02-2026-07-23.json index b39efd85b..e2167d9ff 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2345191628&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 4. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement q7245853$7D0FEA32-11F9-4B2A-A431-5AA1CB4814CB in revision 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes follows (P155) with value Ashes to Embers (Q4804899).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P155\",\"hash\":\"a8bacdc0b3e984d5c9e6d8bbd06a29713d73f23c\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":4804899,\"id\":\"Q4804899\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"q7245853$7D0FEA32-11F9-4B2A-A431-5AA1CB4814CB\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"fa278ebfc458360e5aed63d5058cca83c46134f1\",\"snaks\":{\"P143\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P143\",\"hash\":\"e4f6d9441d0600513c4533c672b5ab472dc73694\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":328,\"id\":\"Q328\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P143\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2345191628&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q7245853; claims.P155; statement q7245853$7D0FEA32-11F9-4B2A-A431-5AA1CB4814CB", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-05-05T23:12:07Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "82b5c98aa692cb79333a252011327324cbebb3072a8864533ea826707d6c1a44", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Globally, imprisonment rates have returned to pre-pandemic levels following a COVID-19 induced dip, while aggregated data–such as global level figures–often mask very high levels of prison use in certain places.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Globally, imprisonment rates have returned to pre-pandemic levels following a COVID-19 induced dip, while aggregated data–such as global level figures–often mask very high levels of prison use in certain places.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 4", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "ba173e9b7fe6d8646ae0948c7c9dbdd11da42881a945dafb9435e28e7db05201", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2345191628; entity Q7245853; source SHA-256 82b5c98aa692cb79333a252011327324cbebb3072a8864533ea826707d6c1a44; statement SHA-256 98c033118d84703cd606c097e2d20798d5c33b52a7a399f8cb37522bb7807260; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 ba173e9b7fe6d8646ae0948c7c9dbdd11da42881a945dafb9435e28e7db05201; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3365, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "6349158764b6d7ff5eebed3c98a9e9dce4cecdb9eafbab1f97e76ca18783b22d", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement q7245853$7D0FEA32-11F9-4B2A-A431-5AA1CB4814CB in revision 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes follows (P155) with value Ashes to Embers (Q4804899).", - "artifact_ref": "statement q7245853$7D0FEA32-11F9-4B2A-A431-5AA1CB4814CB", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q7245853) / P155", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2345191628 at 2025-05-05T23:12:07Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Globally, imprisonment rates have returned to pre-pandemic levels following a COVID-19 induced dip, while aggregated data–such as global level figures–often mask very high levels of prison use in certain places.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 4", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G02-2026-07-23.svg index 8bf152da5..26d37b120 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement q7245853$7D0FEA32-11F9-4B2A-A431-5AA1CB4814CB in revision - 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes follows (P155) with value Ashes + Globally, imprisonment rates have returned to pre-pandemic levels following a + COVID-19 induced dip, while aggregated data–such as global level figures–often mask Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T01-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q7245853) / P155 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2345191628 at 2025-05-05T23:12:07Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement q7245853$7D0FEA32-11F9-4B2A-A431-5AA1CB4814CB - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 4 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G03-2026-07-23.json index 784c54942..98a459880 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2345191628&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 4. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q7245853$2d5a7789-cbee-4f67-8181-b818af82f0dc in revision 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes producer (P162) with value Matt Bayles (Q1909140).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P162\",\"hash\":\"1d0ff01d27849b52e46cb2ab174d18d8623f24b4\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":1909140,\"id\":\"Q1909140\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q7245853$2d5a7789-cbee-4f67-8181-b818af82f0dc\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"fa278ebfc458360e5aed63d5058cca83c46134f1\",\"snaks\":{\"P143\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P143\",\"hash\":\"e4f6d9441d0600513c4533c672b5ab472dc73694\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":328,\"id\":\"Q328\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P143\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2345191628&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q7245853; claims.P162; statement Q7245853$2d5a7789-cbee-4f67-8181-b818af82f0dc", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-05-05T23:12:07Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "82b5c98aa692cb79333a252011327324cbebb3072a8864533ea826707d6c1a44", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The survey results, which reveal widespread recognition of the importance of rehabilitation in prison, are presented in this first edition of Prison Matters. ………………………………………………………………… UNODC, ‘The United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules)’, Rule 4, 2015.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The survey results, which reveal widespread recognition of the importance of rehabilitation in prison, are presented in this first edition of Prison Matters. ………………………………………………………………… UNODC, ‘The United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules)’, Rule 4, 2015.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 4", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "0d7914e86564c7b5c9e2fceb42e31cf6ffb5a2cbad16286f7d44de4120f9abde", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2345191628; entity Q7245853; source SHA-256 82b5c98aa692cb79333a252011327324cbebb3072a8864533ea826707d6c1a44; statement SHA-256 d5a5c99ba7c551f8a76f032aeb4a19ba12b2130cde3dc3e5d3553d9cb4d48c4f; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 0d7914e86564c7b5c9e2fceb42e31cf6ffb5a2cbad16286f7d44de4120f9abde; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3366, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "6349158764b6d7ff5eebed3c98a9e9dce4cecdb9eafbab1f97e76ca18783b22d", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q7245853$2d5a7789-cbee-4f67-8181-b818af82f0dc in revision 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes producer (P162) with value Matt Bayles (Q1909140).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q7245853$2d5a7789-cbee-4f67-8181-b818af82f0dc", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q7245853) / P162", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2345191628 at 2025-05-05T23:12:07Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The survey results, which reveal widespread recognition of the importance of rehabilitation in prison, are presented in this first edition of Prison Matters. ………………………………………………………………… UNODC, ‘The United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules)’, Rule 4, 2015.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 4", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G03-2026-07-23.svg index e71871d39..4f89cb8b2 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q7245853$2d5a7789-cbee-4f67-8181-b818af82f0dc in revision - 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes producer (P162) with value Matt + The survey results, which reveal widespread recognition of the importance of + rehabilitation in prison, are presented in this first edition of Prison Matters. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T01-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q7245853) / P162 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2345191628 at 2025-05-05T23:12:07Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q7245853$2d5a7789-cbee-4f67-8181-b818af82f0dc - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 4 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G04-2026-07-23.json index 1cd69edc5..602f31924 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2345191628&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 11. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement q7245853$8948AD1B-FEB6-4E0B-AAC1-BA70BA40595C in revision 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes performer (P175) with value Eyes of Fire (Q5422818).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P175\",\"hash\":\"dcbafb5c3088a497bb76d9896ef8c5069a6bd423\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5422818,\"id\":\"Q5422818\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"q7245853$8948AD1B-FEB6-4E0B-AAC1-BA70BA40595C\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"fa278ebfc458360e5aed63d5058cca83c46134f1\",\"snaks\":{\"P143\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P143\",\"hash\":\"e4f6d9441d0600513c4533c672b5ab472dc73694\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":328,\"id\":\"Q328\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P143\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2345191628&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q7245853; claims.P175; statement q7245853$8948AD1B-FEB6-4E0B-AAC1-BA70BA40595C", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-05-05T23:12:07Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "82b5c98aa692cb79333a252011327324cbebb3072a8864533ea826707d6c1a44", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "World prison population on the increase, after a hiatus during the COVID-19 pandemic Following a decrease during the COVID-19 pandemic, the number of people held in prison worldwide has started to rise again.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "World prison population on the increase, after a hiatus during the COVID-19 pandemic Following a decrease during the COVID-19 pandemic, the number of people held in prison worldwide has started to rise again.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 11", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "68207aed9854ee386a888b7bfccbbe3e8c4f8d8879c9cd263fb64f9c1ecdfbc6", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2345191628; entity Q7245853; source SHA-256 82b5c98aa692cb79333a252011327324cbebb3072a8864533ea826707d6c1a44; statement SHA-256 9b109076120d040878f9f1b38bbcd7971733d8f2252adc9eb88183c63b0d3191; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 68207aed9854ee386a888b7bfccbbe3e8c4f8d8879c9cd263fb64f9c1ecdfbc6; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3367, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "6349158764b6d7ff5eebed3c98a9e9dce4cecdb9eafbab1f97e76ca18783b22d", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement q7245853$8948AD1B-FEB6-4E0B-AAC1-BA70BA40595C in revision 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes performer (P175) with value Eyes of Fire (Q5422818).", - "artifact_ref": "statement q7245853$8948AD1B-FEB6-4E0B-AAC1-BA70BA40595C", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q7245853) / P175", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2345191628 at 2025-05-05T23:12:07Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "World prison population on the increase, after a hiatus during the COVID-19 pandemic Following a decrease during the COVID-19 pandemic, the number of people held in prison worldwide has started to rise again.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 11", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G04-2026-07-23.svg index 2bcfd8d03..bd586dac4 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement q7245853$8948AD1B-FEB6-4E0B-AAC1-BA70BA40595C in revision - 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes performer (P175) with value + World prison population on the increase, after a hiatus during the COVID-19 pandemic + Following a decrease during the COVID-19 pandemic, the number of people held in Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T01-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q7245853) / P175 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2345191628 at 2025-05-05T23:12:07Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement q7245853$8948AD1B-FEB6-4E0B-AAC1-BA70BA40595C - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 11 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G05-2026-07-23.json index c230d63bf..3c77608f3 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2345191628&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 11. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement q7245853$8106F8E7-8272-46B3-90BC-43F3802C9D5B in revision 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes record label (P264) with value Century Media Records (Q158867).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P264\",\"hash\":\"1ba4c4bced944505b5ed46b0f78d1d5833a18730\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":158867,\"id\":\"Q158867\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"q7245853$8106F8E7-8272-46B3-90BC-43F3802C9D5B\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"fa278ebfc458360e5aed63d5058cca83c46134f1\",\"snaks\":{\"P143\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P143\",\"hash\":\"e4f6d9441d0600513c4533c672b5ab472dc73694\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":328,\"id\":\"Q328\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P143\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2345191628&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q7245853; claims.P264; statement q7245853$8106F8E7-8272-46B3-90BC-43F3802C9D5B", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-05-05T23:12:07Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "82b5c98aa692cb79333a252011327324cbebb3072a8864533ea826707d6c1a44", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The vast majority of prisoners worldwide are men, representing almost 94 per cent of the prison population or 10.8 million prisoners in 2022.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The vast majority of prisoners worldwide are men, representing almost 94 per cent of the prison population or 10.8 million prisoners in 2022.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 11", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "6bacee67b6a46ac2154f11f7faa8a3ff58ca4105dc65c745a222cbce3d2a1ead", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2345191628; entity Q7245853; source SHA-256 82b5c98aa692cb79333a252011327324cbebb3072a8864533ea826707d6c1a44; statement SHA-256 a8d36f7a3b85b3b932bd637847e75c184ce5d2a5d5ac279016f59fb566ee409d; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 6bacee67b6a46ac2154f11f7faa8a3ff58ca4105dc65c745a222cbce3d2a1ead; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3368, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "6349158764b6d7ff5eebed3c98a9e9dce4cecdb9eafbab1f97e76ca18783b22d", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement q7245853$8106F8E7-8272-46B3-90BC-43F3802C9D5B in revision 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes record label (P264) with value Century Media Records (Q158867).", - "artifact_ref": "statement q7245853$8106F8E7-8272-46B3-90BC-43F3802C9D5B", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q7245853) / P264", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2345191628 at 2025-05-05T23:12:07Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The vast majority of prisoners worldwide are men, representing almost 94 per cent of the prison population or 10.8 million prisoners in 2022.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 11", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G05-2026-07-23.svg index 6c2f74f0f..75afee7d5 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement q7245853$8106F8E7-8272-46B3-90BC-43F3802C9D5B in revision - 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes record label (P264) with value + The vast majority of prisoners worldwide are men, representing almost 94 per cent of + the prison population or 10.8 million prisoners in 2022. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T01-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q7245853) / P264 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2345191628 at 2025-05-05T23:12:07Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement q7245853$8106F8E7-8272-46B3-90BC-43F3802C9D5B - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 11 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G06-2026-07-23.json index 3e147c65d..cda6aabe9 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2345191628&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 12. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement q7245853$C7D72A33-CD11-4C09-8667-3BDB01600928 in revision 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes instance of (P31) with value album (Q482994).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P31\",\"hash\":\"dc16d32b615bf1c6edf1919941065eedccacb8e4\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":482994,\"id\":\"Q482994\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"q7245853$C7D72A33-CD11-4C09-8667-3BDB01600928\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"fa278ebfc458360e5aed63d5058cca83c46134f1\",\"snaks\":{\"P143\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P143\",\"hash\":\"e4f6d9441d0600513c4533c672b5ab472dc73694\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":328,\"id\":\"Q328\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P143\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2345191628&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q7245853; claims.P31; statement q7245853$C7D72A33-CD11-4C09-8667-3BDB01600928", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-05-05T23:12:07Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "82b5c98aa692cb79333a252011327324cbebb3072a8864533ea826707d6c1a44", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation between 2019 and 2020 before increasing again in 2021 and 2022 (respectively to 143 and 144 prisoners per 100,000 population).6 In 2022, about half of the global population in prison was incarcerated in Asia, almost four percentage points more than in 2012, and a third in the Americas.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation between 2019 and 2020 before increasing again in 2021 and 2022 (respectively to 143 and 144 prisoners per 100,000 population).6 In 2022, about half of the global population in prison was incarcerated in Asia, almost four percentage points more than in 2012, and a third in the Americas.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 12", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "3e3dec81357ba53c5da8a7ccb40a5002d6b0735ca77f1af5ce6c8419549bab78", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2345191628; entity Q7245853; source SHA-256 82b5c98aa692cb79333a252011327324cbebb3072a8864533ea826707d6c1a44; statement SHA-256 8ab29a9462c7107452def77f7d86d9b48cdc43023603874cb5e06ec5233446b1; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 3e3dec81357ba53c5da8a7ccb40a5002d6b0735ca77f1af5ce6c8419549bab78; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3369, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "6349158764b6d7ff5eebed3c98a9e9dce4cecdb9eafbab1f97e76ca18783b22d", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement q7245853$C7D72A33-CD11-4C09-8667-3BDB01600928 in revision 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes instance of (P31) with value album (Q482994).", - "artifact_ref": "statement q7245853$C7D72A33-CD11-4C09-8667-3BDB01600928", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q7245853) / P31", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2345191628 at 2025-05-05T23:12:07Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation between 2019 and 2020 before increasing again in 2021 and 2022 (respectively to 143 and 144 prisoners per 100,000 population).6 In 2022, about half of the global population in prison was incarcerated in Asia, almost four percentage points more than in 2012, and a third in the Americas.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 12", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G06-2026-07-23.svg index 62f53077b..6c46f5ab1 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement q7245853$C7D72A33-CD11-4C09-8667-3BDB01600928 in revision - 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes instance of (P31) with value + PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation + between 2019 and 2020 before increasing again in 2021 and 2022 (respectively to 143 Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T01-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q7245853) / P31 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2345191628 at 2025-05-05T23:12:07Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement q7245853$C7D72A33-CD11-4C09-8667-3BDB01600928 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 12 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G07-2026-07-23.json index de6dd9b4d..57ce4e255 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2345191628&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 12. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q7245853$F6484A14-0E31-4F56-B8F3-1F2709DF375E in revision 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes publication date (P577) with value +2006-00-00T00:00:00Z.", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P577\",\"hash\":\"dc4188996de539672ceb455087c518d143bc1637\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2006-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q7245853$F6484A14-0E31-4F56-B8F3-1F2709DF375E\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"fa278ebfc458360e5aed63d5058cca83c46134f1\",\"snaks\":{\"P143\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P143\",\"hash\":\"e4f6d9441d0600513c4533c672b5ab472dc73694\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":328,\"id\":\"Q328\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P143\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2345191628&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q7245853; claims.P577; statement Q7245853$F6484A14-0E31-4F56-B8F3-1F2709DF375E", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-05-05T23:12:07Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "82b5c98aa692cb79333a252011327324cbebb3072a8864533ea826707d6c1a44", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Estimates for 2022 indicate that people in the Americas were nearly 4 times more likely to be in prison than those living in Africa.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Estimates for 2022 indicate that people in the Americas were nearly 4 times more likely to be in prison than those living in Africa.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 12", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "3f392734a860cf78a13e3c1b9071dcad71081d67a06d7ba58e9b81296e6ed6ab", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2345191628; entity Q7245853; source SHA-256 82b5c98aa692cb79333a252011327324cbebb3072a8864533ea826707d6c1a44; statement SHA-256 41a211f4d6a88ae8a59b2e5a6490370b9b2d881d91e7572a9cddafae1cd108ff; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 3f392734a860cf78a13e3c1b9071dcad71081d67a06d7ba58e9b81296e6ed6ab; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3370, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "6349158764b6d7ff5eebed3c98a9e9dce4cecdb9eafbab1f97e76ca18783b22d", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q7245853$F6484A14-0E31-4F56-B8F3-1F2709DF375E in revision 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes publication date (P577) with value +2006-00-00T00:00:00Z.", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q7245853$F6484A14-0E31-4F56-B8F3-1F2709DF375E", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q7245853) / P577", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2345191628 at 2025-05-05T23:12:07Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Estimates for 2022 indicate that people in the Americas were nearly 4 times more likely to be in prison than those living in Africa.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 12", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G07-2026-07-23.svg index c8e41efc6..f1147d4ae 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q7245853$F6484A14-0E31-4F56-B8F3-1F2709DF375E in revision - 2345191628 asserts that Prisons (Q7245853) publishes publication date (P577) with + Estimates for 2022 indicate that people in the Americas were nearly 4 times more + likely to be in prison than those living in Africa. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T01-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q7245853) / P577 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2345191628 at 2025-05-05T23:12:07Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q7245853$F6484A14-0E31-4F56-B8F3-1F2709DF375E - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 12 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G08-2026-07-23.json index 1f784a294..2646a7924 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 13. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$6f72618d-40fb-12f4-ee33-ffa130b30f5f in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes topic's main Wikimedia portal (P1151) with value Portal:Prisons (Q14616093).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1151\",\"hash\":\"6fdb20f72ad832b4f39241758505b5211f4c5882\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":14616093,\"id\":\"Q14616093\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$6f72618d-40fb-12f4-ee33-ffa130b30f5f\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1151; statement Q40357$6f72618d-40fb-12f4-ee33-ffa130b30f5f", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Nearly a third of the global prison population remains in pre-trial detention, masking wide regional disparities In 2022, around 3.5 million prisoners worldwide were held in pre-trial detention.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Nearly a third of the global prison population remains in pre-trial detention, masking wide regional disparities In 2022, around 3.5 million prisoners worldwide were held in pre-trial detention.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 13", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "444a699916d0c9053559e879e4e60a725d5707eeef7a8ad33f688969859ffcf3", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 da18ceea9352e1e2096955521c24b4ff8fb06cdd63d2d0bc5f04b54a2631e6c0; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 444a699916d0c9053559e879e4e60a725d5707eeef7a8ad33f688969859ffcf3; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3371, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "6349158764b6d7ff5eebed3c98a9e9dce4cecdb9eafbab1f97e76ca18783b22d", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$6f72618d-40fb-12f4-ee33-ffa130b30f5f in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes topic's main Wikimedia portal (P1151) with value Portal:Prisons (Q14616093).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$6f72618d-40fb-12f4-ee33-ffa130b30f5f", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1151", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Nearly a third of the global prison population remains in pre-trial detention, masking wide regional disparities In 2022, around 3.5 million prisoners worldwide were held in pre-trial detention.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 13", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G08-2026-07-23.svg index 52989a635..14fdb476d 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$6f72618d-40fb-12f4-ee33-ffa130b30f5f in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes topic's main Wikimedia portal + Nearly a third of the global prison population remains in pre-trial detention, + masking wide regional disparities In 2022, around 3.5 million prisoners worldwide Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T01-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1151 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$6f72618d-40fb-12f4-ee33-ffa130b30f5f - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 13 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G09-2026-07-23.json index 041905c1e..4c57f855c 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 13. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$2ba09370-40f3-177a-9bfe-90b2f6e566d0 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes OpenStreetMap tag (P1282) with value \"amenity=prison\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1282\",\"hash\":\"7731112df2cc13e124d07f014ae62840ed414ce8\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"amenity=prison\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$2ba09370-40f3-177a-9bfe-90b2f6e566d0\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1282; statement Q40357$2ba09370-40f3-177a-9bfe-90b2f6e566d0", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Tracking the overall increase in the number of persons held in prison globally, the percentage of unsentenced prisoners among all prisoners has remained almost stable at around 30 per cent since 2012.9 ………………………………………………………………… Ibid.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Tracking the overall increase in the number of persons held in prison globally, the percentage of unsentenced prisoners among all prisoners has remained almost stable at around 30 per cent since 2012.9 ………………………………………………………………… Ibid.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 13", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "0fb0fc856ea11db8463bd1e174a220cea5a5e46db099efcc89089bd32e0d7581", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 a260b2beec67bc70b2deb29017a8e8e305b06ee399d2f0412c61c24f67128fd8; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 0fb0fc856ea11db8463bd1e174a220cea5a5e46db099efcc89089bd32e0d7581; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3372, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "6349158764b6d7ff5eebed3c98a9e9dce4cecdb9eafbab1f97e76ca18783b22d", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$2ba09370-40f3-177a-9bfe-90b2f6e566d0 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes OpenStreetMap tag (P1282) with value \"amenity=prison\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$2ba09370-40f3-177a-9bfe-90b2f6e566d0", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1282", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Tracking the overall increase in the number of persons held in prison globally, the percentage of unsentenced prisoners among all prisoners has remained almost stable at around 30 per cent since 2012.9 ………………………………………………………………… Ibid.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 13", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G09-2026-07-23.svg index 0ce01678b..e6b623b4a 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$2ba09370-40f3-177a-9bfe-90b2f6e566d0 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes OpenStreetMap tag (P1282) with + Tracking the overall increase in the number of persons held in prison globally, the + percentage of unsentenced prisoners among all prisoners has remained almost stable Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T01-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1282 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$2ba09370-40f3-177a-9bfe-90b2f6e566d0 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 13 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G10-2026-07-23.json index f834de1ed..35b2eb95d 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 14. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$d3e697d1-4cab-1bfb-273f-3ed5caf94c0c in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Explanatory Dictionary of the Living Great Russian Language (Q1970746).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1343\",\"hash\":\"ecb04d74140f2ee856c06658b03ec90a21c2edf2\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":1970746,\"id\":\"Q1970746\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P805\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P805\",\"hash\":\"0fe439d5a152718b655fd48016e4038057618357\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":30200535,\"id\":\"Q30200535\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P805\"],\"id\":\"Q40357$d3e697d1-4cab-1bfb-273f-3ed5caf94c0c\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1343; statement Q40357$d3e697d1-4cab-1bfb-273f-3ed5caf94c0c", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Across global regions, the highest proportion of unsentenced prisoners among the overall prison population is reported in Africa and Oceania (both at 36 per cent in 2022), and the lowest in Europe (18 per cent).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Across global regions, the highest proportion of unsentenced prisoners among the overall prison population is reported in Africa and Oceania (both at 36 per cent in 2022), and the lowest in Europe (18 per cent).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 14", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "0d77ca4931cee33bc85c33e921ee9c7267171fc8b2dcc99ed0e301d9a59d8db6", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 192b3f29f8c95191977eef0e835b8552338da24706888e2b305d5e979d0d7c64; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 0d77ca4931cee33bc85c33e921ee9c7267171fc8b2dcc99ed0e301d9a59d8db6; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3373, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "6349158764b6d7ff5eebed3c98a9e9dce4cecdb9eafbab1f97e76ca18783b22d", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$d3e697d1-4cab-1bfb-273f-3ed5caf94c0c in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Explanatory Dictionary of the Living Great Russian Language (Q1970746).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$d3e697d1-4cab-1bfb-273f-3ed5caf94c0c", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1343", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Across global regions, the highest proportion of unsentenced prisoners among the overall prison population is reported in Africa and Oceania (both at 36 per cent in 2022), and the lowest in Europe (18 per cent).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 14", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G10-2026-07-23.svg index 1c2fcd999..00163b13b 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$d3e697d1-4cab-1bfb-273f-3ed5caf94c0c in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with + Across global regions, the highest proportion of unsentenced prisoners among the + overall prison population is reported in Africa and Oceania (both at 36 per cent in Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T01-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1343 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$d3e697d1-4cab-1bfb-273f-3ed5caf94c0c - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 14 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G01-2026-07-23.json index 46098b4d6..e9a8a1a41 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 14. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$0843f209-457e-8f89-e527-97c9caeb8a63 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Brockhaus and Efron Encyclopedic Dictionary (Q602358).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1343\",\"hash\":\"88389772f86dcd7d415ddd029f601412e5cc894a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":602358,\"id\":\"Q602358\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P805\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P805\",\"hash\":\"657f3014c133f79d1b0e001bbecc32a1a85bb513\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":24497840,\"id\":\"Q24497840\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P805\"],\"id\":\"Q40357$0843f209-457e-8f89-e527-97c9caeb8a63\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1343; statement Q40357$0843f209-457e-8f89-e527-97c9caeb8a63", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Breaking down these data to subregion level, the situation is particularly concerning in Southern Asia where almost two thirds of detainees (63 per cent) are held unsentenced.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Breaking down these data to subregion level, the situation is particularly concerning in Southern Asia where almost two thirds of detainees (63 per cent) are held unsentenced.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 14", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "6dd2283b2636209ded4418dac9e1ab150e918573a4fba8516783bf553f1ab8ff", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 cbab6c8cf8a9c2a59f673ec0534149a79c8de8143308a3128b2bd5a17d36609d; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 6dd2283b2636209ded4418dac9e1ab150e918573a4fba8516783bf553f1ab8ff; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3374, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3d532531720680a2517d3d72b13f1ff44bc17a30defd46836ac92af71caa3c81", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$0843f209-457e-8f89-e527-97c9caeb8a63 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Brockhaus and Efron Encyclopedic Dictionary (Q602358).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$0843f209-457e-8f89-e527-97c9caeb8a63", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1343", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Breaking down these data to subregion level, the situation is particularly concerning in Southern Asia where almost two thirds of detainees (63 per cent) are held unsentenced.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 14", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G01-2026-07-23.svg index e91fc2f0e..a2db5f4fe 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$0843f209-457e-8f89-e527-97c9caeb8a63 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with + Breaking down these data to subregion level, the situation is particularly + concerning in Southern Asia where almost two thirds of detainees (63 per cent) are Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T02-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1343 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$0843f209-457e-8f89-e527-97c9caeb8a63 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 14 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G02-2026-07-23.json index 35d64e97b..050425031 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 15. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$efb3c0ab-4d80-f7ef-55c3-888c03eb90d6 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Brockhaus and Efron Encyclopedic Dictionary (Q602358).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1343\",\"hash\":\"88389772f86dcd7d415ddd029f601412e5cc894a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":602358,\"id\":\"Q602358\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P805\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P805\",\"hash\":\"76e43721d7f74798f72e3b5e633eb1d92367b826\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":24497842,\"id\":\"Q24497842\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P805\"],\"id\":\"Q40357$efb3c0ab-4d80-f7ef-55c3-888c03eb90d6\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1343; statement Q40357$efb3c0ab-4d80-f7ef-55c3-888c03eb90d6", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In some regions women face a higher risk of pre-trial detention than men In 2022, a total of 3,311,000 men and 216,000 women were held in pre-trial detention worldwide.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In some regions women face a higher risk of pre-trial detention than men In 2022, a total of 3,311,000 men and 216,000 women were held in pre-trial detention worldwide.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 15", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "43eef4af614f7db685ac019558229062910398e849d709a8b3596ce8d70dece6", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 cefd70e32c268d74411a6234abe8dd8b4ffbee30692bb20d3376563d0061d753; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 43eef4af614f7db685ac019558229062910398e849d709a8b3596ce8d70dece6; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3375, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3d532531720680a2517d3d72b13f1ff44bc17a30defd46836ac92af71caa3c81", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$efb3c0ab-4d80-f7ef-55c3-888c03eb90d6 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Brockhaus and Efron Encyclopedic Dictionary (Q602358).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$efb3c0ab-4d80-f7ef-55c3-888c03eb90d6", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1343", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In some regions women face a higher risk of pre-trial detention than men In 2022, a total of 3,311,000 men and 216,000 women were held in pre-trial detention worldwide.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 15", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G02-2026-07-23.svg index a0e0efd3e..dddeaf3d3 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$efb3c0ab-4d80-f7ef-55c3-888c03eb90d6 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with + In some regions women face a higher risk of pre-trial detention than men In 2022, a + total of 3,311,000 men and 216,000 women were held in pre-trial detention worldwide. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T02-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1343 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$efb3c0ab-4d80-f7ef-55c3-888c03eb90d6 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 15 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G03-2026-07-23.json index bfea7ae2e..dc62a04bf 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 15. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$0e3a8667-4b92-f651-03e4-8589863c2898 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Brockhaus and Efron Encyclopedic Dictionary (Q602358).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1343\",\"hash\":\"88389772f86dcd7d415ddd029f601412e5cc894a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":602358,\"id\":\"Q602358\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P805\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P805\",\"hash\":\"f239fd4db9efd4d4be7b28b227cfc673d8ae46cc\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":24497848,\"id\":\"Q24497848\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P805\"],\"id\":\"Q40357$0e3a8667-4b92-f651-03e4-8589863c2898\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1343; statement Q40357$0e3a8667-4b92-f651-03e4-8589863c2898", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Oceania has the highest gender gap, with 43 per cent of women compared to 35 per cent of men held without a sentence.13 ………………………………………………………………… Ibid.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Oceania has the highest gender gap, with 43 per cent of women compared to 35 per cent of men held without a sentence.13 ………………………………………………………………… Ibid.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 15", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "099d61a6ce81e673c3f19a4652a3664498b9879f1edd9eb53d7d107a94bda5e2", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 543218d79562314cf5efcc3dcbe43615aab9766ba45ed84f8bbe2a724c25a729; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 099d61a6ce81e673c3f19a4652a3664498b9879f1edd9eb53d7d107a94bda5e2; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3376, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3d532531720680a2517d3d72b13f1ff44bc17a30defd46836ac92af71caa3c81", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$0e3a8667-4b92-f651-03e4-8589863c2898 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Brockhaus and Efron Encyclopedic Dictionary (Q602358).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$0e3a8667-4b92-f651-03e4-8589863c2898", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1343", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Oceania has the highest gender gap, with 43 per cent of women compared to 35 per cent of men held without a sentence.13 ………………………………………………………………… Ibid.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 15", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G03-2026-07-23.svg index df31b8c3d..1fb6fec32 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$0e3a8667-4b92-f651-03e4-8589863c2898 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with + Oceania has the highest gender gap, with 43 per cent of women compared to 35 per + cent of men held without a sentence.13 ………………………………………………………………… Ibid. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T02-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1343 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$0e3a8667-4b92-f651-03e4-8589863c2898 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 15 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G04-2026-07-23.json index 7f4914493..da8f3df96 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 16. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$a9b7da5b-40d6-d0b6-6373-6c567bfba02a in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Brockhaus and Efron Encyclopedic Dictionary (Q602358).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1343\",\"hash\":\"88389772f86dcd7d415ddd029f601412e5cc894a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":602358,\"id\":\"Q602358\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P805\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P805\",\"hash\":\"1f584c69f3cf9befe184b511afe2ffab4df9779f\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":24334251,\"id\":\"Q24334251\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P805\"],\"id\":\"Q40357$a9b7da5b-40d6-d0b6-6373-6c567bfba02a\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1343; statement Q40357$a9b7da5b-40d6-d0b6-6373-6c567bfba02a", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Prisons are overcrowded in more than 60 per cent of countries worldwide, sparking concerns about health and human rights of those detained in these prisons Overcrowding remains a significant concern in many prisons.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Prisons are overcrowded in more than 60 per cent of countries worldwide, sparking concerns about health and human rights of those detained in these prisons Overcrowding remains a significant concern in many prisons.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 16", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "236f7a1edf57a031c9362fb89ce35197ff96a5d747fbdb19ffd7f0a5cf3a6967", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 510e95c2495b87149972f976313aa3617bebdd7b4786fea54eb9f4957326bf23; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 236f7a1edf57a031c9362fb89ce35197ff96a5d747fbdb19ffd7f0a5cf3a6967; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3377, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3d532531720680a2517d3d72b13f1ff44bc17a30defd46836ac92af71caa3c81", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$a9b7da5b-40d6-d0b6-6373-6c567bfba02a in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Brockhaus and Efron Encyclopedic Dictionary (Q602358).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$a9b7da5b-40d6-d0b6-6373-6c567bfba02a", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1343", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Prisons are overcrowded in more than 60 per cent of countries worldwide, sparking concerns about health and human rights of those detained in these prisons Overcrowding remains a significant concern in many prisons.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 16", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G04-2026-07-23.svg index 80165dab6..4f20a05df 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$a9b7da5b-40d6-d0b6-6373-6c567bfba02a in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with + Prisons are overcrowded in more than 60 per cent of countries worldwide, sparking + concerns about health and human rights of those detained in these prisons Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T02-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1343 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$a9b7da5b-40d6-d0b6-6373-6c567bfba02a - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 16 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G05-2026-07-23.json index 8d27571f7..0c1dcf3c4 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 16. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$ea37bf55-4cc7-2437-6a16-461c5d53f44f in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Small Brockhaus and Efron Encyclopedic Dictionary (Q19180675).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1343\",\"hash\":\"42346dfe9209b7359c1f5db829a368b38d407797\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":19180675,\"id\":\"Q19180675\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P805\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P805\",\"hash\":\"0e05e34878d56b6dcf9374ba4d9b71d5d9e9831d\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":24752411,\"id\":\"Q24752411\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P805\"],\"id\":\"Q40357$ea37bf55-4cc7-2437-6a16-461c5d53f44f\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1343; statement Q40357$ea37bf55-4cc7-2437-6a16-461c5d53f44f", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "This situation is particularly concerning in Africa and the Americas, where more than 70 per cent of countries with available data report overcrowded prison systems operating at more than 100 per cent of their planned capacity.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "This situation is particularly concerning in Africa and the Americas, where more than 70 per cent of countries with available data report overcrowded prison systems operating at more than 100 per cent of their planned capacity.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 16", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "62249e5a6c7257d5bd456427727da664b116472ccf589de6fddb59efc7850245", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 a83d17ecef9429891dbbbf12511bf3440e6e8a8904d016b5ac58c54a71bf980e; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 62249e5a6c7257d5bd456427727da664b116472ccf589de6fddb59efc7850245; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3378, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3d532531720680a2517d3d72b13f1ff44bc17a30defd46836ac92af71caa3c81", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$ea37bf55-4cc7-2437-6a16-461c5d53f44f in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Small Brockhaus and Efron Encyclopedic Dictionary (Q19180675).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$ea37bf55-4cc7-2437-6a16-461c5d53f44f", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1343", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "This situation is particularly concerning in Africa and the Americas, where more than 70 per cent of countries with available data report overcrowded prison systems operating at more than 100 per cent of their planned capacity.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 16", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G05-2026-07-23.svg index ee432bc9d..d9231adbf 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$ea37bf55-4cc7-2437-6a16-461c5d53f44f in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with + This situation is particularly concerning in Africa and the Americas, where more + than 70 per cent of countries with available data report overcrowded prison systems Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T02-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1343 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$ea37bf55-4cc7-2437-6a16-461c5d53f44f - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 16 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G06-2026-07-23.json index 05de38b50..22644cb90 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 17. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$85f3aeec-3e1f-4925-9f3d-ba217db202df in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Q30059240 (Q30059240).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1343\",\"hash\":\"30ae3c19e2efa0dd9fecc0501065766eae4e3d12\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":30059240,\"id\":\"Q30059240\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P805\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P805\",\"hash\":\"e06d4db5ff49b90a4410fc477829f67512d187ee\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":45176665,\"id\":\"Q45176665\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P805\"],\"id\":\"Q40357$85f3aeec-3e1f-4925-9f3d-ba217db202df\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1343; statement Q40357$85f3aeec-3e1f-4925-9f3d-ba217db202df", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Enhanced efforts are required to prevent deaths in prison; more than 1 in 10 deaths occurring in prison is a suicide The number and type of deaths occurring in prisons can provide insight into prison conditions and safety in prisons.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Enhanced efforts are required to prevent deaths in prison; more than 1 in 10 deaths occurring in prison is a suicide The number and type of deaths occurring in prisons can provide insight into prison conditions and safety in prisons.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 17", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "9530028eb05d0b3f2d12f5fb5f795bbced0663f5e020e7b6b41cdf3855abf661", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 04893e372002047c838aa37f4ef2effb850d54dc357bce4711af580898f9fff8; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 9530028eb05d0b3f2d12f5fb5f795bbced0663f5e020e7b6b41cdf3855abf661; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3379, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3d532531720680a2517d3d72b13f1ff44bc17a30defd46836ac92af71caa3c81", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$85f3aeec-3e1f-4925-9f3d-ba217db202df in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Q30059240 (Q30059240).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$85f3aeec-3e1f-4925-9f3d-ba217db202df", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1343", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Enhanced efforts are required to prevent deaths in prison; more than 1 in 10 deaths occurring in prison is a suicide The number and type of deaths occurring in prisons can provide insight into prison conditions and safety in prisons.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 17", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G06-2026-07-23.svg index bb0fc1625..71d97eaf6 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$85f3aeec-3e1f-4925-9f3d-ba217db202df in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with + Enhanced efforts are required to prevent deaths in prison; more than 1 in 10 deaths + occurring in prison is a suicide The number and type of deaths occurring in prisons Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T02-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1343 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$85f3aeec-3e1f-4925-9f3d-ba217db202df - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 17 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G07-2026-07-23.json index 35d53af5e..e122dc987 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 17. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$a496d999-5e33-47bc-af1a-59a64ffd6944 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Granat Encyclopedic Dictionary (Q4532138).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1343\",\"hash\":\"9d0d1c63dc98d865b8382e988f529b9243bdab73\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":4532138,\"id\":\"Q4532138\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P805\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P805\",\"hash\":\"bd2aa0c383031733cf460d3c4322da5ddc0f93e2\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":87337142,\"id\":\"Q87337142\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P805\"],\"id\":\"Q40357$a496d999-5e33-47bc-af1a-59a64ffd6944\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1343; statement Q40357$a496d999-5e33-47bc-af1a-59a64ffd6944", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "While data on mortality in prison remain limited in Africa, Asia and Oceania, it is possible to produce a global average based on data from 95 countries.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "While data on mortality in prison remain limited in Africa, Asia and Oceania, it is possible to produce a global average based on data from 95 countries.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 17", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "1c27567483918fa9695a3067e1566b8b035fea0b4530cfee2b367b3be44d3917", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 b9e46f331f163013505bd4921d7ad163619664fc4a0c7a68133927f2bdecca2f; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 1c27567483918fa9695a3067e1566b8b035fea0b4530cfee2b367b3be44d3917; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3380, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3d532531720680a2517d3d72b13f1ff44bc17a30defd46836ac92af71caa3c81", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$a496d999-5e33-47bc-af1a-59a64ffd6944 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Granat Encyclopedic Dictionary (Q4532138).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$a496d999-5e33-47bc-af1a-59a64ffd6944", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1343", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "While data on mortality in prison remain limited in Africa, Asia and Oceania, it is possible to produce a global average based on data from 95 countries.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 17", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G07-2026-07-23.svg index 5f5dd6104..d18a4b67c 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$a496d999-5e33-47bc-af1a-59a64ffd6944 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with + While data on mortality in prison remain limited in Africa, Asia and Oceania, it is + possible to produce a global average based on data from 95 countries. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T02-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1343 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$a496d999-5e33-47bc-af1a-59a64ffd6944 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 17 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G08-2026-07-23.json index d91e26976..8b5a62b22 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 18. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$66EA4229-267F-4348-A50D-42009F0C777D in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Gujin Tushu Jicheng (Q1768721).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1343\",\"hash\":\"75dd89e79770a3e631dbba27144940f8f1bc1773\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":1768721,\"id\":\"Q1768721\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P805\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P805\",\"hash\":\"f1a07436fbe356b30aeeface2c03357696d44d37\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":96601089,\"id\":\"Q96601089\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P805\"],\"id\":\"Q40357$66EA4229-267F-4348-A50D-42009F0C777D\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1343; statement Q40357$66EA4229-267F-4348-A50D-42009F0C777D", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "This is nearly three times lower than the crude death rate18 globally in 2022 (8.4 deaths per 1,000 people),19 reflecting the fact that people in prison are on average much younger than the general population.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "This is nearly three times lower than the crude death rate18 globally in 2022 (8.4 deaths per 1,000 people),19 reflecting the fact that people in prison are on average much younger than the general population.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 18", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "b5a8cecbe263280e396688f621b1436012cb986ebf1a53922bd9bf5e18e63018", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 def905ace71c6f1d89fc1847565cbc423dc4199a94d6bfc1c0338a14d2a168ef; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 b5a8cecbe263280e396688f621b1436012cb986ebf1a53922bd9bf5e18e63018; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3381, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3d532531720680a2517d3d72b13f1ff44bc17a30defd46836ac92af71caa3c81", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$66EA4229-267F-4348-A50D-42009F0C777D in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Gujin Tushu Jicheng (Q1768721).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$66EA4229-267F-4348-A50D-42009F0C777D", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1343", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "This is nearly three times lower than the crude death rate18 globally in 2022 (8.4 deaths per 1,000 people),19 reflecting the fact that people in prison are on average much younger than the general population.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 18", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G08-2026-07-23.svg index 80c23ccc2..93c4c942a 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$66EA4229-267F-4348-A50D-42009F0C777D in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with + This is nearly three times lower than the crude death rate18 globally in 2022 (8.4 + deaths per 1,000 people),19 reflecting the fact that people in prison are on average Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T02-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1343 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$66EA4229-267F-4348-A50D-42009F0C777D - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 18 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G09-2026-07-23.json index 3cc4d2e46..9d8f05b86 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 18. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$8779DEFE-B017-475B-948A-79B4793FD712 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Green Map Icons (Q103892210).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1343\",\"hash\":\"351e9e75911c3cdfde46f49fecb9279d51acc1fb\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":103892210,\"id\":\"Q103892210\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P2699\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2699\",\"hash\":\"25a836009e77a2361fb0924177e48c9eb221c1d9\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/new.opengreenmap.org\\/browse\\/sites?icon=5ca7bfdeecd8490100cab9cc\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P2699\"],\"id\":\"Q40357$8779DEFE-B017-475B-948A-79B4793FD712\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1343; statement Q40357$8779DEFE-B017-475B-948A-79B4793FD712", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "However, countries in the Americas with data had a much higher number of intentional homicides per 100,000 prisoners than countries in other regions, at 18.3 victims of intentional homicide per 100,000 prisoners.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "However, countries in the Americas with data had a much higher number of intentional homicides per 100,000 prisoners than countries in other regions, at 18.3 victims of intentional homicide per 100,000 prisoners.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 18", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "23b9bdd5b55422d5b573fd2ad3f33a15507389827613f597b5582fd0550b54b5", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 12ff86b1303e91dc4c06c4e37ca3aa25425db14650a5fb4bcb4d7d8e1e1b8bbe; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 23b9bdd5b55422d5b573fd2ad3f33a15507389827613f597b5582fd0550b54b5; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3382, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3d532531720680a2517d3d72b13f1ff44bc17a30defd46836ac92af71caa3c81", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$8779DEFE-B017-475B-948A-79B4793FD712 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Green Map Icons (Q103892210).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$8779DEFE-B017-475B-948A-79B4793FD712", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1343", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "However, countries in the Americas with data had a much higher number of intentional homicides per 100,000 prisoners than countries in other regions, at 18.3 victims of intentional homicide per 100,000 prisoners.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 18", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G09-2026-07-23.svg index a1b2bf3f7..0796653e4 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$8779DEFE-B017-475B-948A-79B4793FD712 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with + However, countries in the Americas with data had a much higher number of intentional + homicides per 100,000 prisoners than countries in other regions, at 18.3 victims of Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T02-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1343 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$8779DEFE-B017-475B-948A-79B4793FD712 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 18 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G10-2026-07-23.json index a324e5828..18f067a99 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 19. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$8C5A6537-F4FD-441C-8CDB-2A3ECEA4CC80 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Metropolitan Museum of Art Tagging Vocabulary (Q106727050).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1343\",\"hash\":\"d5011798f92464584d8ccfc5f19f18f3659668bb\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":106727050,\"id\":\"Q106727050\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P1810\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1810\",\"hash\":\"58bff1ff387e6668fb7ffed3fcad4a28ffb07010\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"Prisons\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"ffb837135313cad3b2545c4b9ce5ee416deda3e2\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2021-05-07T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P1810\",\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q40357$8C5A6537-F4FD-441C-8CDB-2A3ECEA4CC80\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1343; statement Q40357$8C5A6537-F4FD-441C-8CDB-2A3ECEA4CC80", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Based on available data in 95 countries worldwide, in 2022, 34.2 prisoners out of every 100,000 prisoners committed suicide, a rate that is more than three times higher than the 2019 global crude suicide rate of 9.2 deaths per 100,000 general population.23 The share of deaths due to suicide, among all deaths in prison, was the highest in Europe, at close to 18 per cent, followed by the Americas at 12 per cent.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Based on available data in 95 countries worldwide, in 2022, 34.2 prisoners out of every 100,000 prisoners committed suicide, a rate that is more than three times higher than the 2019 global crude suicide rate of 9.2 deaths per 100,000 general population.23 The share of deaths due to suicide, among all deaths in prison, was the highest in Europe, at close to 18 per cent, followed by the Americas at 12 per cent.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 19", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "c024da22519e2df2ed55b40136540461b21105770399da0000e66d31d031fa8a", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 2b8a65bf8e037b9675f51d3f0f074d8d68eaba24bf51a902d1f4b13cae2c967f; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 c024da22519e2df2ed55b40136540461b21105770399da0000e66d31d031fa8a; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3383, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3d532531720680a2517d3d72b13f1ff44bc17a30defd46836ac92af71caa3c81", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$8C5A6537-F4FD-441C-8CDB-2A3ECEA4CC80 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Metropolitan Museum of Art Tagging Vocabulary (Q106727050).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$8C5A6537-F4FD-441C-8CDB-2A3ECEA4CC80", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1343", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Based on available data in 95 countries worldwide, in 2022, 34.2 prisoners out of every 100,000 prisoners committed suicide, a rate that is more than three times higher than the 2019 global crude suicide rate of 9.2 deaths per 100,000 general population.23 The share of deaths due to suicide, among all deaths in prison, was the highest in Europe, at close to 18 per cent, followed by the Americas at 12 per cent.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 19", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G10-2026-07-23.svg index cdb85139d..56a70c443 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$8C5A6537-F4FD-441C-8CDB-2A3ECEA4CC80 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with + Based on available data in 95 countries worldwide, in 2022, 34.2 prisoners out of + every 100,000 prisoners committed suicide, a rate that is more than three times Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T02-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1343 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$8C5A6537-F4FD-441C-8CDB-2A3ECEA4CC80 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 19 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json index b113134c9..e91057a08 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 19. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$24267bd4-be7e-4820-b7c6-8037d2770ad1 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Great Soviet Encyclopedia (1926–1947) (Q20078554).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1343\",\"hash\":\"18e6d3e5a4b2e8891df3becff7db1570f149a24e\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":20078554,\"id\":\"Q20078554\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P805\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P805\",\"hash\":\"a42d846282b4c31a82b90f4b93786eb3b60e3b72\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":110157625,\"id\":\"Q110157625\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P805\"],\"id\":\"Q40357$24267bd4-be7e-4820-b7c6-8037d2770ad1\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1343; statement Q40357$24267bd4-be7e-4820-b7c6-8037d2770ad1", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Suicide was, however, the reported cause of death for less than 5 per cent of the deaths of prisoners in countries of Asia and Africa with data.24 ………………………………………………………………… World Health Organisation, ‘The Global Health Observatory, Suicide Rates’, The World Health Organisation, 2024.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Suicide was, however, the reported cause of death for less than 5 per cent of the deaths of prisoners in countries of Asia and Africa with data.24 ………………………………………………………………… World Health Organisation, ‘The Global Health Observatory, Suicide Rates’, The World Health Organisation, 2024.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 19", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "3cbf4ab369ec64825dd787ee13047a7da0deb3dc0a6519f6191ca8032f65ff54", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 d28fc4e74e69eb3a93f4ce928b839e29eab364ef4aa565268713ca31001b2ab4; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 3cbf4ab369ec64825dd787ee13047a7da0deb3dc0a6519f6191ca8032f65ff54; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3384, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "32edc06f9838dfe0fa56719fe737d0333b6e723ef37ed9f5ab684d736ecce069", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$24267bd4-be7e-4820-b7c6-8037d2770ad1 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Great Soviet Encyclopedia (1926–1947) (Q20078554).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$24267bd4-be7e-4820-b7c6-8037d2770ad1", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1343", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Suicide was, however, the reported cause of death for less than 5 per cent of the deaths of prisoners in countries of Asia and Africa with data.24 ………………………………………………………………… World Health Organisation, ‘The Global Health Observatory, Suicide Rates’, The World Health Organisation, 2024.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 19", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G01-2026-07-23.svg index 506731ea1..216e4e970 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$24267bd4-be7e-4820-b7c6-8037d2770ad1 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with + Suicide was, however, the reported cause of death for less than 5 per cent of the + deaths of prisoners in countries of Asia and Africa with data.24 Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T03-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1343 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$24267bd4-be7e-4820-b7c6-8037d2770ad1 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 19 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json index 13614726e..8ca6a8b9c 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 20. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$DE9D8F5B-D1B6-4B2C-BDB9-FE49B7E0BBF5 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Encyclopædia Britannica 11th edition (Q867541).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1343\",\"hash\":\"1e87e0f7d2db06ab0ef5ccabd7c6275641f36553\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":867541,\"id\":\"Q867541\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P805\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P805\",\"hash\":\"5ba848b638ba8b8a3bf0418c315a1da66b81ccc4\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":84693786,\"id\":\"Q84693786\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P805\",\"hash\":\"435d330442be2829007eccd5b10a0f0d1f870575\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":84692128,\"id\":\"Q84692128\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P805\"],\"id\":\"Q40357$DE9D8F5B-D1B6-4B2C-BDB9-FE49B7E0BBF5\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1343; statement Q40357$DE9D8F5B-D1B6-4B2C-BDB9-FE49B7E0BBF5", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In some countries, prisons are under-staffed, reducing safety and undermining efforts to foster a rehabilitative prison environment Significant differences exist in prison staffing between different regions of the world.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In some countries, prisons are under-staffed, reducing safety and undermining efforts to foster a rehabilitative prison environment Significant differences exist in prison staffing between different regions of the world.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 20", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "204cf94a27372a8d5bbe3d4e2c93084ff9acd512c170aabddf5f7d468e509819", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 29087d9a4a7eaa9a5188ec12ffb9e35ae346a9a4253358cc4792798b41355081; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 204cf94a27372a8d5bbe3d4e2c93084ff9acd512c170aabddf5f7d468e509819; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3385, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "32edc06f9838dfe0fa56719fe737d0333b6e723ef37ed9f5ab684d736ecce069", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$DE9D8F5B-D1B6-4B2C-BDB9-FE49B7E0BBF5 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Encyclopædia Britannica 11th edition (Q867541).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$DE9D8F5B-D1B6-4B2C-BDB9-FE49B7E0BBF5", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1343", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In some countries, prisons are under-staffed, reducing safety and undermining efforts to foster a rehabilitative prison environment Significant differences exist in prison staffing between different regions of the world.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 20", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G02-2026-07-23.svg index d7766a2de..fa1b7ee50 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$DE9D8F5B-D1B6-4B2C-BDB9-FE49B7E0BBF5 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with + In some countries, prisons are under-staffed, reducing safety and undermining + efforts to foster a rehabilitative prison environment Significant differences exist Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T03-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1343 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$DE9D8F5B-D1B6-4B2C-BDB9-FE49B7E0BBF5 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 20 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json index d6f88f7e5..f8fa10829 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 20. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$FD011009-65F7-4FDB-975B-8D3EE527CA59 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Collier's New Encyclopedia, 1921 (Q19047539).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1343\",\"hash\":\"108cf6c8b367e807f49b5394330121eb212625a5\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":19047539,\"id\":\"Q19047539\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P805\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P805\",\"hash\":\"681e7d3786ab994dd274e01f3503634c41f87f7e\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":123949211,\"id\":\"Q123949211\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P805\"],\"id\":\"Q40357$FD011009-65F7-4FDB-975B-8D3EE527CA59\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1343; statement Q40357$FD011009-65F7-4FDB-975B-8D3EE527CA59", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In 2022, they had the second highest number of prison staff relative to their general population, at 52.9 prison staff per 100,000 population.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2022, they had the second highest number of prison staff relative to their general population, at 52.9 prison staff per 100,000 population.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 20", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "d1ddfbf3639b87045f88717d5206493d1629c20faad6332790e6703f384d0807", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 03c6e53f98a3c206a521f44c2e107cbb458f4af68a192c112976e1ad41d121d5; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 d1ddfbf3639b87045f88717d5206493d1629c20faad6332790e6703f384d0807; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3386, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "32edc06f9838dfe0fa56719fe737d0333b6e723ef37ed9f5ab684d736ecce069", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$FD011009-65F7-4FDB-975B-8D3EE527CA59 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Collier's New Encyclopedia, 1921 (Q19047539).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$FD011009-65F7-4FDB-975B-8D3EE527CA59", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1343", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In 2022, they had the second highest number of prison staff relative to their general population, at 52.9 prison staff per 100,000 population.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 20", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G03-2026-07-23.svg index 2c945088b..a356dfac8 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$FD011009-65F7-4FDB-975B-8D3EE527CA59 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with + In 2022, they had the second highest number of prison staff relative to their + general population, at 52.9 prison staff per 100,000 population. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T03-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1343 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$FD011009-65F7-4FDB-975B-8D3EE527CA59 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 20 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json index 3cb250f3e..c094d5210 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 21. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$6912D94F-90D5-42FA-8B52-F36DD881B10B in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Pauly–Wissowa (Q1138524).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1343\",\"hash\":\"5b0ef3d5413cd39d887fbe70d2d3b3f4a94ea9d8\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":1138524,\"id\":\"Q1138524\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P805\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P805\",\"hash\":\"54ed6dc41d34e3a8d396e634fa60c759ef232594\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":34610295,\"id\":\"Q34610295\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P805\"],\"id\":\"Q40357$6912D94F-90D5-42FA-8B52-F36DD881B10B\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"feaed3df9aed096470de45373941c5cd7e8790da\",\"snaks\":{\"P143\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P143\",\"hash\":\"6831ac7a9664960f0fc42cb1693f941f74afbc9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":15522295,\"id\":\"Q15522295\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P143\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1343; statement Q40357$6912D94F-90D5-42FA-8B52-F36DD881B10B", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The share of women employed in prisons varies across regions with the highest share of women among all prison staff at 34.4 per cent in countries with data in Europe and the lowest at 18.7 per cent in countries with data in Africa.27 Rate of prison personnel per 100,000 population, 2022 or latest year available Notes: Regional and global figures are averages of countries with data weighted by their population.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The share of women employed in prisons varies across regions with the highest share of women among all prison staff at 34.4 per cent in countries with data in Europe and the lowest at 18.7 per cent in countries with data in Africa.27 Rate of prison personnel per 100,000 population, 2022 or latest year available Notes: Regional and global figures are averages of countries with data weighted by their population.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 21", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "38ee3f4ddeb0e970feee0e3d000cb0130e50cdf8e505ba4107983547e364a62c", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 9b6b7dcd72a08f37e79286991da80822879a18469c17409188c1f715f56b90ea; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 38ee3f4ddeb0e970feee0e3d000cb0130e50cdf8e505ba4107983547e364a62c; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3387, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "32edc06f9838dfe0fa56719fe737d0333b6e723ef37ed9f5ab684d736ecce069", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$6912D94F-90D5-42FA-8B52-F36DD881B10B in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with value Pauly–Wissowa (Q1138524).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$6912D94F-90D5-42FA-8B52-F36DD881B10B", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1343", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The share of women employed in prisons varies across regions with the highest share of women among all prison staff at 34.4 per cent in countries with data in Europe and the lowest at 18.7 per cent in countries with data in Africa.27 Rate of prison personnel per 100,000 population, 2022 or latest year available Notes: Regional and global figures are averages of countries with data weighted by their population.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 21", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G04-2026-07-23.svg index 943291792..3e82455ac 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$6912D94F-90D5-42FA-8B52-F36DD881B10B in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes described by source (P1343) with + The share of women employed in prisons varies across regions with the highest share + of women among all prison staff at 34.4 per cent in countries with data in Europe Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T03-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1343 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$6912D94F-90D5-42FA-8B52-F36DD881B10B - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 21 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json index d07c66af8..18fcc2ba7 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 21. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$9a7b2aa9-4c14-a801-2bdd-aafed068ffc8 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes named after (P138) with value Tyr (Q172713).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P138\",\"hash\":\"ec16fd837f8d120f5a7505bc227b1a90197e0746\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":172713,\"id\":\"Q172713\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P5168\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P5168\",\"hash\":\"762f754c9e04abe6a2c58df959100440591e4add\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"text\":\"\\u0442\\u044e\\u0440\\u044c\\u043c\\u0430\",\"language\":\"ru\"},\"type\":\"monolingualtext\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P5168\"],\"id\":\"Q40357$9a7b2aa9-4c14-a801-2bdd-aafed068ffc8\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"0723282bb80042897ca697416c050b4bf7fb5428\",\"snaks\":{\"P887\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P887\",\"hash\":\"2009eafb2646ea71bee7372b061e8521ee613fc2\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":69652283,\"id\":\"Q69652283\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P887\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P138; statement Q40357$9a7b2aa9-4c14-a801-2bdd-aafed068ffc8", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Globally, nearly 7 out of 10 those working in prisons are responsible for the surveillance of prisoners, while slightly more than 2 out of 10 are part of the prison administration and 1 out of 10 are employed to support prisoner health (including ………………………………………………………………… Ibid.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Globally, nearly 7 out of 10 those working in prisons are responsible for the surveillance of prisoners, while slightly more than 2 out of 10 are part of the prison administration and 1 out of 10 are employed to support prisoner health (including ………………………………………………………………… Ibid.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 21", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "376d19cf610e1e2e80aa07af3aa2755d05bc0941b2de5c2e79caefa5365ccdd1", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 6ab7fdcc2aedb550c735aa28557f0f3e8a43c9ba4692338687825518f5152fb0; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 376d19cf610e1e2e80aa07af3aa2755d05bc0941b2de5c2e79caefa5365ccdd1; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3388, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "32edc06f9838dfe0fa56719fe737d0333b6e723ef37ed9f5ab684d736ecce069", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$9a7b2aa9-4c14-a801-2bdd-aafed068ffc8 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes named after (P138) with value Tyr (Q172713).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$9a7b2aa9-4c14-a801-2bdd-aafed068ffc8", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P138", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Globally, nearly 7 out of 10 those working in prisons are responsible for the surveillance of prisoners, while slightly more than 2 out of 10 are part of the prison administration and 1 out of 10 are employed to support prisoner health (including ………………………………………………………………… Ibid.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 21", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G05-2026-07-23.svg index 36a08edd3..817893fa8 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$9a7b2aa9-4c14-a801-2bdd-aafed068ffc8 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes named after (P138) with value Tyr + Globally, nearly 7 out of 10 those working in prisons are responsible for the + surveillance of prisoners, while slightly more than 2 out of 10 are part of the Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T03-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P138 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$9a7b2aa9-4c14-a801-2bdd-aafed068ffc8 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 21 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json index 7dca818d6..420f6adbd 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 22. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$a6212006-441b-a212-9871-9767c3fda2a0 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes topic has template (P1424) with value Template:Infobox prison (Q8784047).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1424\",\"hash\":\"f18afacbb32c6e0eb2940e934a1addbdf1ac9f86\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":8784047,\"id\":\"Q8784047\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$a6212006-441b-a212-9871-9767c3fda2a0\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1424; statement Q40357$a6212006-441b-a212-9871-9767c3fda2a0", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "A positive answer could potentially reflect that rehabilitation is being actively supported at an operational level, but it might equally reflect that rehabilitation is listed as one of the overall objectives of imprisonment, such as in penal legislation.32 All the same, looking at the regional breakdown, dedicated rehabilitation planning is reported to be underway in all regions. ………………………………………………………………… Ibid.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "A positive answer could potentially reflect that rehabilitation is being actively supported at an operational level, but it might equally reflect that rehabilitation is listed as one of the overall objectives of imprisonment, such as in penal legislation.32 All the same, looking at the regional breakdown, dedicated rehabilitation planning is reported to be underway in all regions. ………………………………………………………………… Ibid.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 22", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "7a60b7de07533adec51b728b0872b449f48afebd8fdf4c2fbc5b292d6ac19544", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 40c27f48d48e630e236f9fb2c7fab29b5da6c733bad52f27f5ba8f90e7b5e19c; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 7a60b7de07533adec51b728b0872b449f48afebd8fdf4c2fbc5b292d6ac19544; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3389, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "32edc06f9838dfe0fa56719fe737d0333b6e723ef37ed9f5ab684d736ecce069", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$a6212006-441b-a212-9871-9767c3fda2a0 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes topic has template (P1424) with value Template:Infobox prison (Q8784047).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$a6212006-441b-a212-9871-9767c3fda2a0", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1424", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "A positive answer could potentially reflect that rehabilitation is being actively supported at an operational level, but it might equally reflect that rehabilitation is listed as one of the overall objectives of imprisonment, such as in penal legislation.32 All the same, looking at the regional breakdown, dedicated rehabilitation planning is reported to be underway in all regions. ………………………………………………………………… Ibid.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 22", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G06-2026-07-23.svg index 07339e044..724b6230e 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$a6212006-441b-a212-9871-9767c3fda2a0 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes topic has template (P1424) with + A positive answer could potentially reflect that rehabilitation is being actively + supported at an operational level, but it might equally reflect that rehabilitation Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T03-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1424 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$a6212006-441b-a212-9871-9767c3fda2a0 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 22 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json index 26a8dda91..4b5629227 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 23. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$a97547a3-44ef-0c23-ff9d-6ea0f7c84af6 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes main Wikidata property (P1687) with value place of detention (P2632).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1687\",\"hash\":\"a1468e2e9e8d97195c1333657f1448fce4d30152\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"property\",\"numeric-id\":2632,\"id\":\"P2632\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$a97547a3-44ef-0c23-ff9d-6ea0f7c84af6\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1687; statement Q40357$a97547a3-44ef-0c23-ff9d-6ea0f7c84af6", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The UNODC survey also asked responding jurisdictions about the level of priority that they would assign to a number of goals to establish a prison environment conducive to rehabilitation.33 All these goals, a number of respondents observed, are core goals for prison administration and the task of fostering a rehabilitative prison environment; therefore, caution is required when interpreting their relative priorities.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The UNODC survey also asked responding jurisdictions about the level of priority that they would assign to a number of goals to establish a prison environment conducive to rehabilitation.33 All these goals, a number of respondents observed, are core goals for prison administration and the task of fostering a rehabilitative prison environment; therefore, caution is required when interpreting their relative priorities.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 23", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "ed57a96c4f0820ab0b31cc5b739821bf3162607bed37a10b18e384752bc523db", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 12b5e42e8be43179adcd78847e1e4ada65f99e7098af6a412f9ba8e031e9bbc4; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 ed57a96c4f0820ab0b31cc5b739821bf3162607bed37a10b18e384752bc523db; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3390, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "32edc06f9838dfe0fa56719fe737d0333b6e723ef37ed9f5ab684d736ecce069", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$a97547a3-44ef-0c23-ff9d-6ea0f7c84af6 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes main Wikidata property (P1687) with value place of detention (P2632).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$a97547a3-44ef-0c23-ff9d-6ea0f7c84af6", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1687", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The UNODC survey also asked responding jurisdictions about the level of priority that they would assign to a number of goals to establish a prison environment conducive to rehabilitation.33 All these goals, a number of respondents observed, are core goals for prison administration and the task of fostering a rehabilitative prison environment; therefore, caution is required when interpreting their relative priorities.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 23", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G07-2026-07-23.svg index fd73054ed..b18fa804a 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$a97547a3-44ef-0c23-ff9d-6ea0f7c84af6 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes main Wikidata property (P1687) + The UNODC survey also asked responding jurisdictions about the level of priority + that they would assign to a number of goals to establish a prison environment Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T03-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1687 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$a97547a3-44ef-0c23-ff9d-6ea0f7c84af6 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 23 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json index 12df060fc..7aaa62edc 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 23. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$a09112a5-4901-e112-a2c3-d2d4152430e9 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes different from (P1889) with value prison organization (Q17567322).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1889\",\"hash\":\"7a62f854f6a7d89c2a206762d7c56a4c6fe178c6\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17567322,\"id\":\"Q17567322\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$a09112a5-4901-e112-a2c3-d2d4152430e9\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1889; statement Q40357$a09112a5-4901-e112-a2c3-d2d4152430e9", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Three goals were consistently ranked as high priority: fair and dignified prisoner treatment; torture prevention mechanisms; and safety and security.34 These are the bedrocks of good prison management.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Three goals were consistently ranked as high priority: fair and dignified prisoner treatment; torture prevention mechanisms; and safety and security.34 These are the bedrocks of good prison management.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 23", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "2ba14292fe2031687b1e453ad2ad94cc628740d56c5313e712ebd29f5e581c10", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 ab722ec85a4362d0ccd5ffd167d6c5aba46f6a294dd0d5a5a61c86dfee93d785; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 2ba14292fe2031687b1e453ad2ad94cc628740d56c5313e712ebd29f5e581c10; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3391, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "32edc06f9838dfe0fa56719fe737d0333b6e723ef37ed9f5ab684d736ecce069", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$a09112a5-4901-e112-a2c3-d2d4152430e9 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes different from (P1889) with value prison organization (Q17567322).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$a09112a5-4901-e112-a2c3-d2d4152430e9", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1889", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Three goals were consistently ranked as high priority: fair and dignified prisoner treatment; torture prevention mechanisms; and safety and security.34 These are the bedrocks of good prison management.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 23", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G08-2026-07-23.svg index f95c1b970..cb266e9fe 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$a09112a5-4901-e112-a2c3-d2d4152430e9 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes different from (P1889) with value + Three goals were consistently ranked as high priority: fair and dignified prisoner + treatment; torture prevention mechanisms; and safety and security.34 These are the Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T03-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1889 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$a09112a5-4901-e112-a2c3-d2d4152430e9 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 23 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json index ee33e80ac..8745ceaa8 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 24. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$8f7780bf-4d7c-3829-b78d-b71a01c153d5 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes different from (P1889) with value Prison (Q128034364).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1889\",\"hash\":\"28262add6d119bd4db3d26b0514f5f22f7d8c003\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":128034364,\"id\":\"Q128034364\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P1013\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1013\",\"hash\":\"94271bee1daecc0a84c7ff0e80a6f5e76c330944\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":27924673,\"id\":\"Q27924673\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P1013\"],\"id\":\"Q40357$8f7780bf-4d7c-3829-b78d-b71a01c153d5\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1889; statement Q40357$8f7780bf-4d7c-3829-b78d-b71a01c153d5", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Responding jurisdictions were asked to identify a maximum of five highest priorities and a maximum of five lowest priorities relative to their rehabilitation objectives.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Responding jurisdictions were asked to identify a maximum of five highest priorities and a maximum of five lowest priorities relative to their rehabilitation objectives.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 24", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "2b8b52ab08df06dc48ed447aef0c975f5eea140de8467ec74424fe4ff790461d", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 cade451b17ba9f3d5fcc63894f1d170dc83c7de28a7f435df59fcecb08ee19fa; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 2b8b52ab08df06dc48ed447aef0c975f5eea140de8467ec74424fe4ff790461d; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3392, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "32edc06f9838dfe0fa56719fe737d0333b6e723ef37ed9f5ab684d736ecce069", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$8f7780bf-4d7c-3829-b78d-b71a01c153d5 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes different from (P1889) with value Prison (Q128034364).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$8f7780bf-4d7c-3829-b78d-b71a01c153d5", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1889", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Responding jurisdictions were asked to identify a maximum of five highest priorities and a maximum of five lowest priorities relative to their rehabilitation objectives.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 24", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G09-2026-07-23.svg index 28f799301..5c89e107b 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$8f7780bf-4d7c-3829-b78d-b71a01c153d5 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes different from (P1889) with value + Responding jurisdictions were asked to identify a maximum of five highest priorities + and a maximum of five lowest priorities relative to their rehabilitation objectives. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T03-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1889 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$8f7780bf-4d7c-3829-b78d-b71a01c153d5 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 24 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json index 69fa372b4..cc5eea46d 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 24. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$da04b5be-4446-0d91-a325-b924a6064626 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes different from (P1889) with value prison building (Q137591045).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1889\",\"hash\":\"0e3ed897c288a1309e30b1c12df366f59c600eee\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":137591045,\"id\":\"Q137591045\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$da04b5be-4446-0d91-a325-b924a6064626\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P1889; statement Q40357$da04b5be-4446-0d91-a325-b924a6064626", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "First, individualized case management for every prisoner, and second, high-quality inter-agency cooperation between custodial and post-release agencies, such as probation or parole services.36 Almost half of jurisdictions with a rehabilitation strategy report the engagement of prisoners as stakeholders during planning Many stakeholders can be involved in the development of rehabilitation strategies in prison, among which are prisoners and their families.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "First, individualized case management for every prisoner, and second, high-quality inter-agency cooperation between custodial and post-release agencies, such as probation or parole services.36 Almost half of jurisdictions with a rehabilitation strategy report the engagement of prisoners as stakeholders during planning Many stakeholders can be involved in the development of rehabilitation strategies in prison, among which are prisoners and their families.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 24", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "3d10cdf43810be38476f6c5a88537e6f9122f6c178846dab02bb570d2884310f", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 22f9c2be50c1a1f34c49c56ded4c3b902b17e6b7d6ebbecd325dd264eae93bbb; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 3d10cdf43810be38476f6c5a88537e6f9122f6c178846dab02bb570d2884310f; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3393, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "32edc06f9838dfe0fa56719fe737d0333b6e723ef37ed9f5ab684d736ecce069", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$da04b5be-4446-0d91-a325-b924a6064626 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes different from (P1889) with value prison building (Q137591045).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$da04b5be-4446-0d91-a325-b924a6064626", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P1889", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "First, individualized case management for every prisoner, and second, high-quality inter-agency cooperation between custodial and post-release agencies, such as probation or parole services.36 Almost half of jurisdictions with a rehabilitation strategy report the engagement of prisoners as stakeholders during planning Many stakeholders can be involved in the development of rehabilitation strategies in prison, among which are prisoners and their families.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 24", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G10-2026-07-23.svg index 61e986351..8a47a1442 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$da04b5be-4446-0d91-a325-b924a6064626 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes different from (P1889) with value + First, individualized case management for every prisoner, and second, high-quality + inter-agency cooperation between custodial and post-release agencies, such as Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T03-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P1889 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$da04b5be-4446-0d91-a325-b924a6064626 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 24 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json index 4a62b5270..d96947ab6 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 25. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$289b4d4b-4ef0-cbc4-945e-b7d5a60bc669 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes history of topic (P2184) with value history of prisons (Q113861613).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2184\",\"hash\":\"83b55cc51afa29ce9e11c86f2a8c82e4bf2d3027\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":113861613,\"id\":\"Q113861613\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$289b4d4b-4ef0-cbc4-945e-b7d5a60bc669\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P2184; statement Q40357$289b4d4b-4ef0-cbc4-945e-b7d5a60bc669", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation traditional feature of justice sector policy and planning, it is increasingly recognised by penal policy makers and prison managers as an element of best practice in prisons and offender management.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation traditional feature of justice sector policy and planning, it is increasingly recognised by penal policy makers and prison managers as an element of best practice in prisons and offender management.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 25", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "61d67e4e89d668ea0fc960718aae8db43b22771ec21f20a7db58eaefcd841c2a", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 ad39a335774e7aa65e9fdc56ff7e6b49542d9448b96c522108ea1588ad6f4a5e; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 61d67e4e89d668ea0fc960718aae8db43b22771ec21f20a7db58eaefcd841c2a; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3394, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "66919cec37bf5bf69c790ce6f7fe88e0ee958215fc81812a4e48ffe705fade58", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$289b4d4b-4ef0-cbc4-945e-b7d5a60bc669 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes history of topic (P2184) with value history of prisons (Q113861613).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$289b4d4b-4ef0-cbc4-945e-b7d5a60bc669", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P2184", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation traditional feature of justice sector policy and planning, it is increasingly recognised by penal policy makers and prison managers as an element of best practice in prisons and offender management.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 25", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G01-2026-07-23.svg index ea7dc9250..be952a6f2 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$289b4d4b-4ef0-cbc4-945e-b7d5a60bc669 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes history of topic (P2184) with + PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation + traditional feature of justice sector policy and planning, it is increasingly Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T04-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P2184 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$289b4d4b-4ef0-cbc4-945e-b7d5a60bc669 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 25 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json index b7a758cc6..8f7f14c0f 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 25. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$48ab0134-4b11-031d-9555-1d409e998b1e in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes position held by head of the organization (P2388) with value prison director (Q51530959).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2388\",\"hash\":\"b59a3d62572c0be624f133efa875a18cdc975bc3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":51530959,\"id\":\"Q51530959\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$48ab0134-4b11-031d-9555-1d409e998b1e\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P2388; statement Q40357$48ab0134-4b11-031d-9555-1d409e998b1e", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Evidence from other areas where it is a more established practice, such as in healthcare, has shown it is associated with superior outcomes and satisfaction.37 Among the 46 jurisdictions that answered the question, around half (49 per cent) reported that they had taken into account the views and experience of prisoners, former prisoners and/or their families, while a further 15 per cent indicated that such engagement processes were being planned.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Evidence from other areas where it is a more established practice, such as in healthcare, has shown it is associated with superior outcomes and satisfaction.37 Among the 46 jurisdictions that answered the question, around half (49 per cent) reported that they had taken into account the views and experience of prisoners, former prisoners and/or their families, while a further 15 per cent indicated that such engagement processes were being planned.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 25", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "331a4911c214a472bbb9fbb6eccc4cb2b54dc04b7436adb1bc2e58f8defa2577", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 dc0d52dd5121126c46d0c8df96d9cb556f239e66cc7810e09b15a4606a3edda3; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 331a4911c214a472bbb9fbb6eccc4cb2b54dc04b7436adb1bc2e58f8defa2577; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3395, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "66919cec37bf5bf69c790ce6f7fe88e0ee958215fc81812a4e48ffe705fade58", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$48ab0134-4b11-031d-9555-1d409e998b1e in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes position held by head of the organization (P2388) with value prison director (Q51530959).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$48ab0134-4b11-031d-9555-1d409e998b1e", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P2388", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Evidence from other areas where it is a more established practice, such as in healthcare, has shown it is associated with superior outcomes and satisfaction.37 Among the 46 jurisdictions that answered the question, around half (49 per cent) reported that they had taken into account the views and experience of prisoners, former prisoners and/or their families, while a further 15 per cent indicated that such engagement processes were being planned.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 25", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G02-2026-07-23.svg index 8330a9c3f..892f4d561 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$48ab0134-4b11-031d-9555-1d409e998b1e in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes position held by head of the + Evidence from other areas where it is a more established practice, such as in + healthcare, has shown it is associated with superior outcomes and satisfaction.37 Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T04-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P2388 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$48ab0134-4b11-031d-9555-1d409e998b1e - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 25 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json index eba3bf70c..ef21c8660 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 26. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$3cf9a2bf-43de-1f3f-fd81-482abd97251f in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes studied by (P2579) with value prison studies (Q15920600).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2579\",\"hash\":\"f718164dbdbd1aaa32cb5fbefaa46b0553a1e8cf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":15920600,\"id\":\"Q15920600\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$3cf9a2bf-43de-1f3f-fd81-482abd97251f\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P2579; statement Q40357$3cf9a2bf-43de-1f3f-fd81-482abd97251f", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "These can be divided into two sorts: those that focus on improving general prison management; and those that focus directly upon the prisoner.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "These can be divided into two sorts: those that focus on improving general prison management; and those that focus directly upon the prisoner.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 26", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "85bc7b4d86f6ae142bf429d9edaa70a740cea9ce702719f1646648c467f884e2", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 f4da06e005b92176ba6c52585872927c7ca2e84e2f2d77cb1c57e757bd08c61f; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 85bc7b4d86f6ae142bf429d9edaa70a740cea9ce702719f1646648c467f884e2; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3396, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "66919cec37bf5bf69c790ce6f7fe88e0ee958215fc81812a4e48ffe705fade58", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$3cf9a2bf-43de-1f3f-fd81-482abd97251f in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes studied by (P2579) with value prison studies (Q15920600).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$3cf9a2bf-43de-1f3f-fd81-482abd97251f", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P2579", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "These can be divided into two sorts: those that focus on improving general prison management; and those that focus directly upon the prisoner.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 26", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G03-2026-07-23.svg index e82a9ccb0..66eaecf50 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$3cf9a2bf-43de-1f3f-fd81-482abd97251f in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes studied by (P2579) with value + These can be divided into two sorts: those that focus on improving general prison + management; and those that focus directly upon the prisoner. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T04-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P2579 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$3cf9a2bf-43de-1f3f-fd81-482abd97251f - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 26 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json index b84ea2321..0eb1ec3aa 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 26. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$cfab6310-4484-ca72-b7db-aa037986f04c in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes subclass of (P279) with value architectural structure (Q811979).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P279\",\"hash\":\"8ff4e7b1c4dc70a3040ada762cc38f39f95dfadd\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":811979,\"id\":\"Q811979\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$cfab6310-4484-ca72-b7db-aa037986f04c\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P279; statement Q40357$cfab6310-4484-ca72-b7db-aa037986f04c", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The latter emphasizes practices that directly support behaviour change (rehabilitation, desistance) processes at the individual level.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The latter emphasizes practices that directly support behaviour change (rehabilitation, desistance) processes at the individual level.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 26", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "3d5fa80f7c936bb9eaa7129830cbb76dd151f07a91e0848569f9b91192ca9912", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 7fa071af0357014385657b660c406a6eff1411b194f58a56842b9050ecd177fa; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 3d5fa80f7c936bb9eaa7129830cbb76dd151f07a91e0848569f9b91192ca9912; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3397, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "66919cec37bf5bf69c790ce6f7fe88e0ee958215fc81812a4e48ffe705fade58", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$cfab6310-4484-ca72-b7db-aa037986f04c in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes subclass of (P279) with value architectural structure (Q811979).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$cfab6310-4484-ca72-b7db-aa037986f04c", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P279", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The latter emphasizes practices that directly support behaviour change (rehabilitation, desistance) processes at the individual level.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 26", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G04-2026-07-23.svg index 40d91cae1..c4ebd0b2f 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$cfab6310-4484-ca72-b7db-aa037986f04c in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes subclass of (P279) with value + The latter emphasizes practices that directly support behaviour change + (rehabilitation, desistance) processes at the individual level. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T04-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P279 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$cfab6310-4484-ca72-b7db-aa037986f04c - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 26 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json index 58499d519..74cdd6092 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 27. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$0e42e2ff-4bf9-ffe2-d80d-bf45d8626076 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes subclass of (P279) with value prison facility (Q137864285).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P279\",\"hash\":\"6f705e8832c4ef0f52b11c84703f18a27a6c890d\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":137864285,\"id\":\"Q137864285\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$0e42e2ff-4bf9-ffe2-d80d-bf45d8626076\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P279; statement Q40357$0e42e2ff-4bf9-ffe2-d80d-bf45d8626076", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation Responding jurisdictions reported fewer activities supporting effective rehabilitation and social reintegration by involving a range of different stakeholders and as per community standards.41 The least reported of these, at 43 per cent, were measures to ”normalise“ prison life.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation Responding jurisdictions reported fewer activities supporting effective rehabilitation and social reintegration by involving a range of different stakeholders and as per community standards.41 The least reported of these, at 43 per cent, were measures to ”normalise“ prison life.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 27", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "80208b026080f37c273090dc5d0f0465039d76e39c945f0a5f6124547f03c39d", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 64b4030dd20c74ca21ab714aba43284ffc58ebdb045735cad94e2ec50ffccf24; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 80208b026080f37c273090dc5d0f0465039d76e39c945f0a5f6124547f03c39d; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3398, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "66919cec37bf5bf69c790ce6f7fe88e0ee958215fc81812a4e48ffe705fade58", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$0e42e2ff-4bf9-ffe2-d80d-bf45d8626076 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes subclass of (P279) with value prison facility (Q137864285).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$0e42e2ff-4bf9-ffe2-d80d-bf45d8626076", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P279", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation Responding jurisdictions reported fewer activities supporting effective rehabilitation and social reintegration by involving a range of different stakeholders and as per community standards.41 The least reported of these, at 43 per cent, were measures to ”normalise“ prison life.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 27", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G05-2026-07-23.svg index d1ab0aba1..f19e25352 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$0e42e2ff-4bf9-ffe2-d80d-bf45d8626076 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes subclass of (P279) with value + PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation + Responding jurisdictions reported fewer activities supporting effective Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T04-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P279 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$0e42e2ff-4bf9-ffe2-d80d-bf45d8626076 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 27 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json index 08cd4018a..18ec4edd3 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 27. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$2db8f076-481a-503b-a2ad-18b594821943 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes subclass of (P279) with value institution (Q178706).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P279\",\"hash\":\"7009f44589a55fc7fb0f6a133712b5a1ad1b4429\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":178706,\"id\":\"Q178706\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$2db8f076-481a-503b-a2ad-18b594821943\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P279; statement Q40357$2db8f076-481a-503b-a2ad-18b594821943", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "These are measures to ensure prisoners have the same access to services, such as healthcare, as they would in the community, that the prison’s routines are designed to reduce institutionalisation as far as possible, and that a degree of normal contact, such as with family, is maintained while the prisoner is in custody.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "These are measures to ensure prisoners have the same access to services, such as healthcare, as they would in the community, that the prison’s routines are designed to reduce institutionalisation as far as possible, and that a degree of normal contact, such as with family, is maintained while the prisoner is in custody.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 27", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "4f4e5ede89589ff329e786ffc8c191fb2b033c2d15ca7092c421598d372559ef", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 669f79d1df4048c5e0b6f0e7c9bff8f1219d150d756363aa4aa3aa6a5dd24caf; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 4f4e5ede89589ff329e786ffc8c191fb2b033c2d15ca7092c421598d372559ef; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3399, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "66919cec37bf5bf69c790ce6f7fe88e0ee958215fc81812a4e48ffe705fade58", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$2db8f076-481a-503b-a2ad-18b594821943 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes subclass of (P279) with value institution (Q178706).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$2db8f076-481a-503b-a2ad-18b594821943", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P279", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "These are measures to ensure prisoners have the same access to services, such as healthcare, as they would in the community, that the prison’s routines are designed to reduce institutionalisation as far as possible, and that a degree of normal contact, such as with family, is maintained while the prisoner is in custody.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 27", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G06-2026-07-23.svg index 5bb95414a..08ec188b9 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$2db8f076-481a-503b-a2ad-18b594821943 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes subclass of (P279) with value + These are measures to ensure prisoners have the same access to services, such as + healthcare, as they would in the community, that the prison’s routines are designed Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T04-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P279 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$2db8f076-481a-503b-a2ad-18b594821943 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 27 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json index 4721ff96d..dea6355c7 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 31. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$917e8d7a-4ea5-7776-53f3-0e2b3edb5e5a in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes instance of (P31) with value type of prison facility (Q137863866).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P31\",\"hash\":\"bc25d794ce4abae6206de9ce82de542269f21c9d\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":137863866,\"id\":\"Q137863866\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$917e8d7a-4ea5-7776-53f3-0e2b3edb5e5a\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P31; statement Q40357$917e8d7a-4ea5-7776-53f3-0e2b3edb5e5a", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "A considerable body of evidence, much of it from low- and middle-income countries, now illustrates the feasibility, sustainability and cost-benefits of reducing the use of pre trial detention45 46 47 and of non-custodial measures.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "A considerable body of evidence, much of it from low- and middle-income countries, now illustrates the feasibility, sustainability and cost-benefits of reducing the use of pre trial detention45 46 47 and of non-custodial measures.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 31", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "a3ea85ae5bbef817edaa0655df26655ddc0a774dd7925ff9f0d29c2092a7daa4", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 757007b02762a900af8b8f3257b2131412dc6f8e1ad78365e6ce64792d9fa754; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 a3ea85ae5bbef817edaa0655df26655ddc0a774dd7925ff9f0d29c2092a7daa4; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3400, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "66919cec37bf5bf69c790ce6f7fe88e0ee958215fc81812a4e48ffe705fade58", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$917e8d7a-4ea5-7776-53f3-0e2b3edb5e5a in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes instance of (P31) with value type of prison facility (Q137863866).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$917e8d7a-4ea5-7776-53f3-0e2b3edb5e5a", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P31", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "A considerable body of evidence, much of it from low- and middle-income countries, now illustrates the feasibility, sustainability and cost-benefits of reducing the use of pre trial detention45 46 47 and of non-custodial measures.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 31", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G07-2026-07-23.svg index f7d15d63e..72ad70405 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$917e8d7a-4ea5-7776-53f3-0e2b3edb5e5a in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes instance of (P31) with value type + A considerable body of evidence, much of it from low- and middle-income countries, + now illustrates the feasibility, sustainability and cost-benefits of reducing the Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T04-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P31 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$917e8d7a-4ea5-7776-53f3-0e2b3edb5e5a - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 31 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json index d0e8f7431..973e43e72 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 31. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$c802548f-4538-5f5d-bbdb-dd702a0e9115 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes part of (P361) with value corrections (Q328616).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P361\",\"hash\":\"2de4086fed37ec6e1a4e8237ea9b5f2de01982a7\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":328616,\"id\":\"Q328616\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$c802548f-4538-5f5d-bbdb-dd702a0e9115\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P361; statement Q40357$c802548f-4538-5f5d-bbdb-dd702a0e9115", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Estimates based on evidence from prisons in Malawi and Uganda, for example, suggest that effective paralegal programmes can be implemented for a cost of US$20 per prisoner and produce savings of three times that.48 ………………………………………………………………… Open Society Foundations and UNDP, ‘The Socioeconomic Impact of Pretrial Detention: A Global Pretrial Justice Report’, Open Society Justice Initiative (New York, NY, 2011).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Estimates based on evidence from prisons in Malawi and Uganda, for example, suggest that effective paralegal programmes can be implemented for a cost of US$20 per prisoner and produce savings of three times that.48 ………………………………………………………………… Open Society Foundations and UNDP, ‘The Socioeconomic Impact of Pretrial Detention: A Global Pretrial Justice Report’, Open Society Justice Initiative (New York, NY, 2011).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 31", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "a423affa1592b13b803a3e41734112e7ddbbf7dd6022a5f12498e68cb1610bd7", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 a5768cbc11ce155d5f090ac513ce0ebe75775512013908bb54c881e0f3983a85; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 a423affa1592b13b803a3e41734112e7ddbbf7dd6022a5f12498e68cb1610bd7; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3401, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "66919cec37bf5bf69c790ce6f7fe88e0ee958215fc81812a4e48ffe705fade58", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$c802548f-4538-5f5d-bbdb-dd702a0e9115 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes part of (P361) with value corrections (Q328616).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$c802548f-4538-5f5d-bbdb-dd702a0e9115", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P361", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Estimates based on evidence from prisons in Malawi and Uganda, for example, suggest that effective paralegal programmes can be implemented for a cost of US$20 per prisoner and produce savings of three times that.48 ………………………………………………………………… Open Society Foundations and UNDP, ‘The Socioeconomic Impact of Pretrial Detention: A Global Pretrial Justice Report’, Open Society Justice Initiative (New York, NY, 2011).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 31", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G08-2026-07-23.svg index 9c29aaea2..2016f88c0 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$c802548f-4538-5f5d-bbdb-dd702a0e9115 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes part of (P361) with value + Estimates based on evidence from prisons in Malawi and Uganda, for example, suggest + that effective paralegal programmes can be implemented for a cost of US$20 per Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T04-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P361 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$c802548f-4538-5f5d-bbdb-dd702a0e9115 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 31 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json index 3017432ef..c7f035997 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 32. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$df873b02-4752-de4b-6ebc-8f78c7bdd3e2 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes part of (P361) with value government building (Q16831714).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P361\",\"hash\":\"3098e47b0f1178cdf842c4e3b780dab8eed9dca3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":16831714,\"id\":\"Q16831714\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$df873b02-4752-de4b-6ebc-8f78c7bdd3e2\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P361; statement Q40357$df873b02-4752-de4b-6ebc-8f78c7bdd3e2", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In summary, the impact of overcrowding multiplies the challenges faced by prison services in preserving the integrity of prison management, ensuring the health, safety and well-being of prisoners, maintaining a rehabilitative prison regime and preserving prison security.49 Research has extensively documented these pernicious effects of overcrowding.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In summary, the impact of overcrowding multiplies the challenges faced by prison services in preserving the integrity of prison management, ensuring the health, safety and well-being of prisoners, maintaining a rehabilitative prison regime and preserving prison security.49 Research has extensively documented these pernicious effects of overcrowding.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 32", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "b33ade18fe18ce9f26d912adb508b935541903f023c25c0c47a1feaa5adfea7a", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 4b7ef433cb96e11f9110c8c47e94e9ae171b8a938cb234b0cbc419d83c3d1af3; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 b33ade18fe18ce9f26d912adb508b935541903f023c25c0c47a1feaa5adfea7a; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3402, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "66919cec37bf5bf69c790ce6f7fe88e0ee958215fc81812a4e48ffe705fade58", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$df873b02-4752-de4b-6ebc-8f78c7bdd3e2 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes part of (P361) with value government building (Q16831714).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$df873b02-4752-de4b-6ebc-8f78c7bdd3e2", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P361", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In summary, the impact of overcrowding multiplies the challenges faced by prison services in preserving the integrity of prison management, ensuring the health, safety and well-being of prisoners, maintaining a rehabilitative prison regime and preserving prison security.49 Research has extensively documented these pernicious effects of overcrowding.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 32", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G09-2026-07-23.svg index af951dfa1..8dd2a0481 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$df873b02-4752-de4b-6ebc-8f78c7bdd3e2 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes part of (P361) with value + In summary, the impact of overcrowding multiplies the challenges faced by prison + services in preserving the integrity of prison management, ensuring the health, Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T04-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P361 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$df873b02-4752-de4b-6ebc-8f78c7bdd3e2 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 32 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json index 98fb62f3f..d6a6e067a 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 32. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$020248cf-4baa-17db-b2fd-461946c0ec3a in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes part of (P361) with value human settlement (Q486972).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P361\",\"hash\":\"460632e936ef3bf268af7a1e4911973c951aaa34\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":486972,\"id\":\"Q486972\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$020248cf-4baa-17db-b2fd-461946c0ec3a\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P361; statement Q40357$020248cf-4baa-17db-b2fd-461946c0ec3a", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Stéphanie Baggio et al., ‘Do Overcrowding and Turnover Cause Violence in Prison?’, Frontiers in Psychiatry 10 (24 January 2020): 1015.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Stéphanie Baggio et al., ‘Do Overcrowding and Turnover Cause Violence in Prison?’, Frontiers in Psychiatry 10 (24 January 2020): 1015.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 32", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "4d8163efad165b1355a2a417b8882d8a6fb0c47374614bc22218a05979c54592", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 dd106857d12d386a38bf8a9f3e19a4c369fa8060e18f02f5bcf7162f191e370f; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 4d8163efad165b1355a2a417b8882d8a6fb0c47374614bc22218a05979c54592; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3403, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "66919cec37bf5bf69c790ce6f7fe88e0ee958215fc81812a4e48ffe705fade58", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$020248cf-4baa-17db-b2fd-461946c0ec3a in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes part of (P361) with value human settlement (Q486972).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$020248cf-4baa-17db-b2fd-461946c0ec3a", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P361", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Stéphanie Baggio et al., ‘Do Overcrowding and Turnover Cause Violence in Prison?’, Frontiers in Psychiatry 10 (24 January 2020): 1015.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 32", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G10-2026-07-23.svg index 0ba742b11..095bfbad9 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$020248cf-4baa-17db-b2fd-461946c0ec3a in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes part of (P361) with value human + Stéphanie Baggio et al., ‘Do Overcrowding and Turnover Cause Violence in Prison?’, + Frontiers in Psychiatry 10 (24 January 2020): 1015. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T04-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P361 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$020248cf-4baa-17db-b2fd-461946c0ec3a - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 32 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json index e94c55d11..005507ad9 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 33. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$b628a120-4c00-36d4-be15-a793944472aa in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes has use (P366) with value punishment (Q186361).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P366\",\"hash\":\"114c75b51c096afd16bfe0bb4ce1a0e957984064\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":186361,\"id\":\"Q186361\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$b628a120-4c00-36d4-be15-a793944472aa\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P366; statement Q40357$b628a120-4c00-36d4-be15-a793944472aa", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "A study in the United States, for example, has shown that almost 90 per cent of imprisoned fathers report that their female partner is taking care of their child.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "A study in the United States, for example, has shown that almost 90 per cent of imprisoned fathers report that their female partner is taking care of their child.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 33", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "2cc54b7ee551f6347a9d80e475373b4ac5f9f9111bc27c343c4ca988faa8151d", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 103f7fc7953ef09b0f80667de6877042a337e6a8a102874e844236030b34c536; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 2cc54b7ee551f6347a9d80e475373b4ac5f9f9111bc27c343c4ca988faa8151d; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3404, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "23f973e862c3c45f933d353d909daadcb72ea5aba4105cd9dcd57d7d436c8ea5", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$b628a120-4c00-36d4-be15-a793944472aa in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes has use (P366) with value punishment (Q186361).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$b628a120-4c00-36d4-be15-a793944472aa", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P366", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "A study in the United States, for example, has shown that almost 90 per cent of imprisoned fathers report that their female partner is taking care of their child.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 33", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G01-2026-07-23.svg index 8f44e7a56..5653114f7 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$b628a120-4c00-36d4-be15-a793944472aa in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes has use (P366) with value + A study in the United States, for example, has shown that almost 90 per cent of + imprisoned fathers report that their female partner is taking care of their child. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T05-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P366 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$b628a120-4c00-36d4-be15-a793944472aa - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 33 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json index 7db947893..cbdc97983 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 33. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$216f6a5b-465b-bb48-d8d9-b34c1883f231 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes has use (P366) with value reform (Q900406).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P366\",\"hash\":\"0edbe55eb0485a7003905994a37660de45b5c2da\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":900406,\"id\":\"Q900406\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$216f6a5b-465b-bb48-d8d9-b34c1883f231\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P366; statement Q40357$216f6a5b-465b-bb48-d8d9-b34c1883f231", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Jo Taylor et al., ‘A Rapid Review of the Evidence on Models of Service Delivery for Correctional Centre-Based Mothers and Children’s Units: Does Our Approach Need to Change?’, BMJ Global Health 9, no.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Jo Taylor et al., ‘A Rapid Review of the Evidence on Models of Service Delivery for Correctional Centre-Based Mothers and Children’s Units: Does Our Approach Need to Change?’, BMJ Global Health 9, no.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 33", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "590d546d12be5138e1c085d3d744654f9973a800b19cc5dda3e8825a6ecd5196", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 f884e5e2a2ab21899aa955706c823cb862c7a59f532f25502e4fc51d3deb625e; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 590d546d12be5138e1c085d3d744654f9973a800b19cc5dda3e8825a6ecd5196; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3405, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "23f973e862c3c45f933d353d909daadcb72ea5aba4105cd9dcd57d7d436c8ea5", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$216f6a5b-465b-bb48-d8d9-b34c1883f231 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes has use (P366) with value reform (Q900406).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$216f6a5b-465b-bb48-d8d9-b34c1883f231", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P366", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Jo Taylor et al., ‘A Rapid Review of the Evidence on Models of Service Delivery for Correctional Centre-Based Mothers and Children’s Units: Does Our Approach Need to Change?’, BMJ Global Health 9, no.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 33", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G02-2026-07-23.svg index 1e1b29f79..7a66aefd5 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$216f6a5b-465b-bb48-d8d9-b34c1883f231 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes has use (P366) with value reform + Jo Taylor et al., ‘A Rapid Review of the Evidence on Models of Service Delivery for + Correctional Centre-Based Mothers and Children’s Units: Does Our Approach Need to Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T05-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P366 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$216f6a5b-465b-bb48-d8d9-b34c1883f231 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 33 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json index 381fab99d..a9ac180e8 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 34. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$41059e10-48df-8a25-b938-b76e1f3a0751 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes has use (P366) with value incarceration (Q853735).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P366\",\"hash\":\"b2de4f079e8cad8a800e0837558a8ab1f55a0b32\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":853735,\"id\":\"Q853735\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$41059e10-48df-8a25-b938-b76e1f3a0751\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P366; statement Q40357$41059e10-48df-8a25-b938-b76e1f3a0751", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "A toxicology study of all deaths in Irish prisons between 2009-2014, for example, found that in 30 per cent of suicide cases in prisons the person tested positive for drugs at time of death, even though the immediate cause of death was usually hanging.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "A toxicology study of all deaths in Irish prisons between 2009-2014, for example, found that in 30 per cent of suicide cases in prisons the person tested positive for drugs at time of death, even though the immediate cause of death was usually hanging.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 34", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "ae4ef1d8517d066342074db1c309522d4ccb8ca0a1b3e3cc87dfff4fdfb5cd91", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 11e36c8b33799e0e10f2b07b58d629af0bbd2d922ea771290d1b57220b968846; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 ae4ef1d8517d066342074db1c309522d4ccb8ca0a1b3e3cc87dfff4fdfb5cd91; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3406, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "23f973e862c3c45f933d353d909daadcb72ea5aba4105cd9dcd57d7d436c8ea5", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$41059e10-48df-8a25-b938-b76e1f3a0751 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes has use (P366) with value incarceration (Q853735).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$41059e10-48df-8a25-b938-b76e1f3a0751", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P366", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "A toxicology study of all deaths in Irish prisons between 2009-2014, for example, found that in 30 per cent of suicide cases in prisons the person tested positive for drugs at time of death, even though the immediate cause of death was usually hanging.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 34", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G03-2026-07-23.svg index e42de92ba..12a8286ca 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$41059e10-48df-8a25-b938-b76e1f3a0751 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes has use (P366) with value + A toxicology study of all deaths in Irish prisons between 2009-2014, for example, + found that in 30 per cent of suicide cases in prisons the person tested positive for Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T05-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P366 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$41059e10-48df-8a25-b938-b76e1f3a0751 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 34 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json index e26d45c6f..8a24e9757 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 34. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$54e011c1-45b0-682c-f022-4004c0592031 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes has use (P366) with value prison agency (Q7162158).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P366\",\"hash\":\"bed619d712bc5cc4afd9fab0da19c131608cf10d\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":7162158,\"id\":\"Q7162158\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$54e011c1-45b0-682c-f022-4004c0592031\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P366; statement Q40357$54e011c1-45b0-682c-f022-4004c0592031", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "One systematic review of 38 high-quality suicide prevention studies from seven countries identified cognitive behavioural interventions as one of the most ………………………………………………………………… Róisín Mulgrew, ‘Prisoner Lives Cut Short: The Need to Address Structural, Societal and Environmental Factors to Reduce Preventable Prisoner Deaths’, Human Rights Law Review 23, no.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "One systematic review of 38 high-quality suicide prevention studies from seven countries identified cognitive behavioural interventions as one of the most ………………………………………………………………… Róisín Mulgrew, ‘Prisoner Lives Cut Short: The Need to Address Structural, Societal and Environmental Factors to Reduce Preventable Prisoner Deaths’, Human Rights Law Review 23, no.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 34", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "1026cb1aeea26113b066e5b6baae96167c33ab92dcc7ab7f8f96a8426caf4ebe", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 5851749021abe8888608312ccacd50236a6836e8a6daad0438be2e534d302078; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 1026cb1aeea26113b066e5b6baae96167c33ab92dcc7ab7f8f96a8426caf4ebe; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3407, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "23f973e862c3c45f933d353d909daadcb72ea5aba4105cd9dcd57d7d436c8ea5", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$54e011c1-45b0-682c-f022-4004c0592031 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes has use (P366) with value prison agency (Q7162158).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$54e011c1-45b0-682c-f022-4004c0592031", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P366", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "One systematic review of 38 high-quality suicide prevention studies from seven countries identified cognitive behavioural interventions as one of the most ………………………………………………………………… Róisín Mulgrew, ‘Prisoner Lives Cut Short: The Need to Address Structural, Societal and Environmental Factors to Reduce Preventable Prisoner Deaths’, Human Rights Law Review 23, no.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 34", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G04-2026-07-23.svg index 8baf50c46..34ace8153 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$54e011c1-45b0-682c-f022-4004c0592031 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes has use (P366) with value prison + One systematic review of 38 high-quality suicide prevention studies from seven + countries identified cognitive behavioural interventions as one of the most Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T05-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P366 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$54e011c1-45b0-682c-f022-4004c0592031 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 34 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json index fb692f0d4..7301a22bb 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 35. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$6bb73a7f-4b49-3785-1c7e-5b91b45d43f5 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes has use (P366) with value imprisonment (Q841236).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P366\",\"hash\":\"0965e65d6018b55504e6e7663dec5de10edf3f56\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":841236,\"id\":\"Q841236\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$6bb73a7f-4b49-3785-1c7e-5b91b45d43f5\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P366; statement Q40357$6bb73a7f-4b49-3785-1c7e-5b91b45d43f5", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In Europe, for example, significant differences exist both within and between subregions as far as prison staffing levels are concerned.74 The burden of shortages appears to fall most heavily on specialised staff and health professionals, such as psychologists, nurses, and social workers.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Europe, for example, significant differences exist both within and between subregions as far as prison staffing levels are concerned.74 The burden of shortages appears to fall most heavily on specialised staff and health professionals, such as psychologists, nurses, and social workers.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 35", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "64c7fb4c50cd31a7286b68e650eab0710c7b70da84ac83e35652e0be2c8cdb96", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 5fd7edc99eff4f8e109ae60265dcc6182a9874ec897c0c972b136874bb8037ad; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 64c7fb4c50cd31a7286b68e650eab0710c7b70da84ac83e35652e0be2c8cdb96; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3408, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "23f973e862c3c45f933d353d909daadcb72ea5aba4105cd9dcd57d7d436c8ea5", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$6bb73a7f-4b49-3785-1c7e-5b91b45d43f5 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes has use (P366) with value imprisonment (Q841236).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$6bb73a7f-4b49-3785-1c7e-5b91b45d43f5", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P366", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In Europe, for example, significant differences exist both within and between subregions as far as prison staffing levels are concerned.74 The burden of shortages appears to fall most heavily on specialised staff and health professionals, such as psychologists, nurses, and social workers.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 35", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G05-2026-07-23.svg index 262c82fe4..6bbf9495d 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$6bb73a7f-4b49-3785-1c7e-5b91b45d43f5 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes has use (P366) with value + In Europe, for example, significant differences exist both within and between + subregions as far as prison staffing levels are concerned.74 The burden of shortages Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T05-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P366 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$6bb73a7f-4b49-3785-1c7e-5b91b45d43f5 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 35 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json index 68caad673..9e6f06b28 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 35. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement q40357$111CABDA-797B-4A53-BCB8-E2471CF2DD39 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes Commons category (P373) with value \"Prisons\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P373\",\"hash\":\"b514aa3841ba850dfac60458946287bf5d147db7\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"Prisons\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"q40357$111CABDA-797B-4A53-BCB8-E2471CF2DD39\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P373; statement q40357$111CABDA-797B-4A53-BCB8-E2471CF2DD39", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Marcelo F Aebi, Edoardo Cocco, and Lorena Molnar, ‘Prisons and Prisoners in Europe 2022: Key Findings of the SPACE I Report’, Series UNILCRIM (Council of Europe and University of Lausanne, 2023).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Marcelo F Aebi, Edoardo Cocco, and Lorena Molnar, ‘Prisons and Prisoners in Europe 2022: Key Findings of the SPACE I Report’, Series UNILCRIM (Council of Europe and University of Lausanne, 2023).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 35", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "f4b574337bb369fe8dd676f5cf4974c158c0e59b9cf676706423cc9636106295", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 b8dce91ff12697d321afba02ef6b8db439924410adc3d4f5eb09eb68fd98326c; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 f4b574337bb369fe8dd676f5cf4974c158c0e59b9cf676706423cc9636106295; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3409, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "23f973e862c3c45f933d353d909daadcb72ea5aba4105cd9dcd57d7d436c8ea5", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement q40357$111CABDA-797B-4A53-BCB8-E2471CF2DD39 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes Commons category (P373) with value \"Prisons\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement q40357$111CABDA-797B-4A53-BCB8-E2471CF2DD39", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P373", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Marcelo F Aebi, Edoardo Cocco, and Lorena Molnar, ‘Prisons and Prisoners in Europe 2022: Key Findings of the SPACE I Report’, Series UNILCRIM (Council of Europe and University of Lausanne, 2023).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 35", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G06-2026-07-23.svg index 1ad0903c1..9f70bd2fd 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement q40357$111CABDA-797B-4A53-BCB8-E2471CF2DD39 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes Commons category (P373) with value + Marcelo F Aebi, Edoardo Cocco, and Lorena Molnar, ‘Prisons and Prisoners in Europe + 2022: Key Findings of the SPACE I Report’, Series UNILCRIM (Council of Europe and Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T05-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P373 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement q40357$111CABDA-797B-4A53-BCB8-E2471CF2DD39 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 35 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json index 769b5cf89..fbef1914e 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 36. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$EBD2DD51-7C7C-4A11-A84E-D520D438A2B7 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes on focus list of Wikimedia project (P5008) with value Wikipedia:Vital articles/Level/4 (Q6173448).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P5008\",\"hash\":\"136e3fbe19158e73e4bfebf3f2d98a9df8638b7e\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":6173448,\"id\":\"Q6173448\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"7661f66dd5b82a1ea92515ddb16c09ce3088edea\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2022-10-31T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q40357$EBD2DD51-7C7C-4A11-A84E-D520D438A2B7\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P5008; statement Q40357$EBD2DD51-7C7C-4A11-A84E-D520D438A2B7", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation found that mental ill health increased violent recidivism by 20 per cent in men and 40 per cent in women after all other risk factors had been accounted for.77 Fostering rehabilitation of prisoners A key aspect of prison management is to foster the rehabilitation and social reintegration prospects of prisoners.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation found that mental ill health increased violent recidivism by 20 per cent in men and 40 per cent in women after all other risk factors had been accounted for.77 Fostering rehabilitation of prisoners A key aspect of prison management is to foster the rehabilitation and social reintegration prospects of prisoners.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 36", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "e715ae6765642cfd79bf1b3b39967675f35d40add49c0b7bbc39dc112ede1b01", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 ac93ddc446d2ef2d4f9090f8163b4cbc59755e558f4b4fbef90f1e3d019fe608; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 e715ae6765642cfd79bf1b3b39967675f35d40add49c0b7bbc39dc112ede1b01; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3410, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "23f973e862c3c45f933d353d909daadcb72ea5aba4105cd9dcd57d7d436c8ea5", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$EBD2DD51-7C7C-4A11-A84E-D520D438A2B7 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes on focus list of Wikimedia project (P5008) with value Wikipedia:Vital articles/Level/4 (Q6173448).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$EBD2DD51-7C7C-4A11-A84E-D520D438A2B7", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P5008", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation found that mental ill health increased violent recidivism by 20 per cent in men and 40 per cent in women after all other risk factors had been accounted for.77 Fostering rehabilitation of prisoners A key aspect of prison management is to foster the rehabilitation and social reintegration prospects of prisoners.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 36", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G07-2026-07-23.svg index 1b73ddf81..78b49a15b 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$EBD2DD51-7C7C-4A11-A84E-D520D438A2B7 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes on focus list of Wikimedia project + PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation + found that mental ill health increased violent recidivism by 20 per cent in men and Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T05-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P5008 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$EBD2DD51-7C7C-4A11-A84E-D520D438A2B7 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 36 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json index 6b44cc06b..8346c1837 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 36. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$5ea97146-4e92-f394-6eea-a3fe682b2948 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes maintained by WikiProject (P6104) with value WikiProject Crime and Criminal Biography (Q15298836).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P6104\",\"hash\":\"1ecfb2d2e43e78ba4217ed85b333435e786df729\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":15298836,\"id\":\"Q15298836\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$5ea97146-4e92-f394-6eea-a3fe682b2948\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P6104; statement Q40357$5ea97146-4e92-f394-6eea-a3fe682b2948", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Some forms of prison programming ensure fundamental rights, such as educational programming,79 while others, including vocational training and employment, provide experience in a key pathway out of crime, which is stable employment.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Some forms of prison programming ensure fundamental rights, such as educational programming,79 while others, including vocational training and employment, provide experience in a key pathway out of crime, which is stable employment.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 36", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "0839fffd4cfb7819452421a9f3ec9f616f982e2c4dfa7b24449f9156d60e6e80", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 38421c05488fbd9df03e31bec5538a9c2800560ce42fa3704933892192c77ed0; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 0839fffd4cfb7819452421a9f3ec9f616f982e2c4dfa7b24449f9156d60e6e80; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3411, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "23f973e862c3c45f933d353d909daadcb72ea5aba4105cd9dcd57d7d436c8ea5", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$5ea97146-4e92-f394-6eea-a3fe682b2948 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes maintained by WikiProject (P6104) with value WikiProject Crime and Criminal Biography (Q15298836).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$5ea97146-4e92-f394-6eea-a3fe682b2948", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P6104", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Some forms of prison programming ensure fundamental rights, such as educational programming,79 while others, including vocational training and employment, provide experience in a key pathway out of crime, which is stable employment.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 36", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G08-2026-07-23.svg index cefe3836a..28d775e43 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$5ea97146-4e92-f394-6eea-a3fe682b2948 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes maintained by WikiProject (P6104) + Some forms of prison programming ensure fundamental rights, such as educational + programming,79 while others, including vocational training and employment, provide Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T05-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P6104 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$5ea97146-4e92-f394-6eea-a3fe682b2948 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 36 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json index 6ef152d80..c41ad6984 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 37. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$294a64b9-49af-d398-f2d6-9b4bc41e5ea1 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes maintained by WikiProject (P6104) with value WikiProject Correction and Detention Facilities (Q21829825).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P6104\",\"hash\":\"c736944a9abfe03a8904691c4e9505856cb15fef\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":21829825,\"id\":\"Q21829825\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$294a64b9-49af-d398-f2d6-9b4bc41e5ea1\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P6104; statement Q40357$294a64b9-49af-d398-f2d6-9b4bc41e5ea1", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "At global level, there remains a wide gap in the access of prisoners to rehabilitation programmes and other constructive activities in support of their social reintegration prospects, with such access being severely limited in resource constrained environments in particular. ………………………………………………………………… Flora Fitzalan Howard and Helen Wakeling, ‘Evaluating the Impact of “Rehabilitative Adjudications” in Four English Prisons’, Psychology, Crime & Law 27, no.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "At global level, there remains a wide gap in the access of prisoners to rehabilitation programmes and other constructive activities in support of their social reintegration prospects, with such access being severely limited in resource constrained environments in particular. ………………………………………………………………… Flora Fitzalan Howard and Helen Wakeling, ‘Evaluating the Impact of “Rehabilitative Adjudications” in Four English Prisons’, Psychology, Crime & Law 27, no.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 37", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "9ab4f51afa2b4e8a3928cfd325d2445b07a44ceae0298f478ef891f2b633fe85", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 fec0296259e7915e941723ff924046c4d4950e4acc9a9f850fc3e29e8702f6bf; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 9ab4f51afa2b4e8a3928cfd325d2445b07a44ceae0298f478ef891f2b633fe85; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3412, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "23f973e862c3c45f933d353d909daadcb72ea5aba4105cd9dcd57d7d436c8ea5", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$294a64b9-49af-d398-f2d6-9b4bc41e5ea1 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes maintained by WikiProject (P6104) with value WikiProject Correction and Detention Facilities (Q21829825).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$294a64b9-49af-d398-f2d6-9b4bc41e5ea1", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P6104", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "At global level, there remains a wide gap in the access of prisoners to rehabilitation programmes and other constructive activities in support of their social reintegration prospects, with such access being severely limited in resource constrained environments in particular. ………………………………………………………………… Flora Fitzalan Howard and Helen Wakeling, ‘Evaluating the Impact of “Rehabilitative Adjudications” in Four English Prisons’, Psychology, Crime & Law 27, no.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 37", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G09-2026-07-23.svg index 6cf46a9df..d0823ddd5 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$294a64b9-49af-d398-f2d6-9b4bc41e5ea1 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes maintained by WikiProject (P6104) + At global level, there remains a wide gap in the access of prisoners to + rehabilitation programmes and other constructive activities in support of their Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T05-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P6104 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$294a64b9-49af-d398-f2d6-9b4bc41e5ea1 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 37 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json index 7ffa48e73..0ada3d0ca 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 41. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q40357$4D81793F-E556-48C3-AB9A-C98DBD477092 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes topic's main category (P910) with value Category:Prisons (Q7214719).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P910\",\"hash\":\"a10925b0cbcb3517b23809e05fc195ecad18ee64\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":7214719,\"id\":\"Q7214719\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q40357$4D81793F-E556-48C3-AB9A-C98DBD477092\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2522585670&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q40357; claims.P910; statement Q40357$4D81793F-E556-48C3-AB9A-C98DBD477092", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In 2024, UNODC invited Member States’ prison administrations and other relevant bodies, as identified by their respective governments, to participate in a survey on prison rehabilitation and rehabilitative environments.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2024, UNODC invited Member States’ prison administrations and other relevant bodies, as identified by their respective governments, to participate in a survey on prison rehabilitation and rehabilitative environments.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 41", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "7cff84ade1ea822925e0ba0181473a11eb794805474c230d01160188e335d0a2", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2522585670; entity Q40357; source SHA-256 b3de427e1a082bdf7d3bc92bf2be1563fb50a297a75a64dfce6763fc7b7420c5; statement SHA-256 262c9d4e9f555fe8b0a7ce185a0fba7949dee619f865fdbc188daaadb4447a18; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 7cff84ade1ea822925e0ba0181473a11eb794805474c230d01160188e335d0a2; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3413, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "23f973e862c3c45f933d353d909daadcb72ea5aba4105cd9dcd57d7d436c8ea5", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q40357$4D81793F-E556-48C3-AB9A-C98DBD477092 in revision 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes topic's main category (P910) with value Category:Prisons (Q7214719).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q40357$4D81793F-E556-48C3-AB9A-C98DBD477092", - "candidate_definition": "prison (Q40357) / P910", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In 2024, UNODC invited Member States’ prison administrations and other relevant bodies, as identified by their respective governments, to participate in a survey on prison rehabilitation and rehabilitative environments.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 41", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G10-2026-07-23.svg index a18ad58df..220b79f14 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q40357$4D81793F-E556-48C3-AB9A-C98DBD477092 in revision - 2522585670 asserts that prison (Q40357) publishes topic's main category (P910) with + In 2024, UNODC invited Member States’ prison administrations and other relevant + bodies, as identified by their respective governments, to participate in a survey on Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T05-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - prison (Q40357) / P910 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2522585670 at 2026-07-25T17:27:03Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q40357$4D81793F-E556-48C3-AB9A-C98DBD477092 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 41 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json index 3c47ce5bd..9cfe6ec73 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2174266654&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 41. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q114548900$62C03AB6-532E-40D6-88D1-7C53C849DEDB in revision 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes title (P1476) with value Prisons.", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1476\",\"hash\":\"3683e7151c54ae7723e8ed90da3506611b10e160\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"text\":\"Prisons\",\"language\":\"en\"},\"type\":\"monolingualtext\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q114548900$62C03AB6-532E-40D6-88D1-7C53C849DEDB\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2174266654&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q114548900; claims.P1476; statement Q114548900$62C03AB6-532E-40D6-88D1-7C53C849DEDB", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2024-06-08T06:40:54Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b37b9f08b4016430e24af57a7fdd306a40cab564aaee8494ad32f9fc0b9e1604", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The objective of the survey was to examine Member States’ priorities, frameworks and practices of prison rehabilitation to understand how prison rehabilitative environments can be made possible.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The objective of the survey was to examine Member States’ priorities, frameworks and practices of prison rehabilitation to understand how prison rehabilitative environments can be made possible.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 41", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "7348dc92e1df447ec5c2d489c4d1c20d21e83e112fcf1310272952f8d6d90ba6", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2174266654; entity Q114548900; source SHA-256 b37b9f08b4016430e24af57a7fdd306a40cab564aaee8494ad32f9fc0b9e1604; statement SHA-256 4d5d20fe96de2d4b313f57e62e1072189d08322ce1d9659cc489bfaa3b68b227; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 7348dc92e1df447ec5c2d489c4d1c20d21e83e112fcf1310272952f8d6d90ba6; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3414, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "409e0efbf097edeb1a54f8a634dc4eb270d22bf26a074465d1cef96b19885aa9", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q114548900$62C03AB6-532E-40D6-88D1-7C53C849DEDB in revision 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes title (P1476) with value Prisons.", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q114548900$62C03AB6-532E-40D6-88D1-7C53C849DEDB", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q114548900) / P1476", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2174266654 at 2024-06-08T06:40:54Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The objective of the survey was to examine Member States’ priorities, frameworks and practices of prison rehabilitation to understand how prison rehabilitative environments can be made possible.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 41", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G01-2026-07-23.svg index 75015ce9a..b8b3e9594 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q114548900$62C03AB6-532E-40D6-88D1-7C53C849DEDB in revision - 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes title (P1476) with value + The objective of the survey was to examine Member States’ priorities, frameworks and + practices of prison rehabilitation to understand how prison rehabilitative Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T06-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q114548900) / P1476 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2174266654 at 2024-06-08T06:40:54Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q114548900$62C03AB6-532E-40D6-88D1-7C53C849DEDB - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 41 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json index 07fccb673..6f8fc8553 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2174266654&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 42. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q114548900$393C483D-8078-408E-975B-8152D718C022 in revision 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes follows (P155) with value Bridges (Q114480175).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P155\",\"hash\":\"a376c1dd8bd22a4d12945bb87735155032c829e9\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":114480175,\"id\":\"Q114480175\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q114548900$393C483D-8078-408E-975B-8152D718C022\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2174266654&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q114548900; claims.P155; statement Q114548900$393C483D-8078-408E-975B-8152D718C022", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2024-06-08T06:40:54Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b37b9f08b4016430e24af57a7fdd306a40cab564aaee8494ad32f9fc0b9e1604", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation Prison rehabilitation strategies A key finding of this survey is the extent to which rehabilitation is recognised as a top priority for penal policy and penal administration and to which rehabilitation goals have become a focus of strategic planning.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation Prison rehabilitation strategies A key finding of this survey is the extent to which rehabilitation is recognised as a top priority for penal policy and penal administration and to which rehabilitation goals have become a focus of strategic planning.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 42", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "1a342e4e1889dff45dda8585eb0c3cf28599c7608a6443e2d1a30c92662bccc9", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2174266654; entity Q114548900; source SHA-256 b37b9f08b4016430e24af57a7fdd306a40cab564aaee8494ad32f9fc0b9e1604; statement SHA-256 26c5092a33d0cd743198eb8453f9a5b4f7318b6c206842fc02b18cfa8e498179; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 1a342e4e1889dff45dda8585eb0c3cf28599c7608a6443e2d1a30c92662bccc9; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3415, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "409e0efbf097edeb1a54f8a634dc4eb270d22bf26a074465d1cef96b19885aa9", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q114548900$393C483D-8078-408E-975B-8152D718C022 in revision 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes follows (P155) with value Bridges (Q114480175).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q114548900$393C483D-8078-408E-975B-8152D718C022", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q114548900) / P155", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2174266654 at 2024-06-08T06:40:54Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation Prison rehabilitation strategies A key finding of this survey is the extent to which rehabilitation is recognised as a top priority for penal policy and penal administration and to which rehabilitation goals have become a focus of strategic planning.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 42", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G02-2026-07-23.svg index 67f61f8e4..9c9f52088 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q114548900$393C483D-8078-408E-975B-8152D718C022 in revision - 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes follows (P155) with value + PRISON MATTERS 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends; A Focus on Rehabilitation + Prison rehabilitation strategies A key finding of this survey is the extent to which Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T06-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q114548900) / P155 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2174266654 at 2024-06-08T06:40:54Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q114548900$393C483D-8078-408E-975B-8152D718C022 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 42 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json index ed5db3425..b1e0fe4dc 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2174266654&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 42. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q114548900$B43D998D-7948-4B2E-9374-9B66AAA79E68 in revision 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes followed by (P156) with value Gadgets (Q114492032).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P156\",\"hash\":\"b4f3e890dc30db013d1af05c99df2a0ebeadee2e\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":114492032,\"id\":\"Q114492032\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q114548900$B43D998D-7948-4B2E-9374-9B66AAA79E68\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2174266654&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q114548900; claims.P156; statement Q114548900$B43D998D-7948-4B2E-9374-9B66AAA79E68", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2024-06-08T06:40:54Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b37b9f08b4016430e24af57a7fdd306a40cab564aaee8494ad32f9fc0b9e1604", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "90 An important theme arising in the evidence of work on rehabilitation is the importance of culturally appropriate, or suitably tailored, schemes, initiatives and tools.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "90 An important theme arising in the evidence of work on rehabilitation is the importance of culturally appropriate, or suitably tailored, schemes, initiatives and tools.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 42", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "c8fdda2f609d89512622a1a7c643e2c2ca6ebd23045ea79013b87baa812647b3", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2174266654; entity Q114548900; source SHA-256 b37b9f08b4016430e24af57a7fdd306a40cab564aaee8494ad32f9fc0b9e1604; statement SHA-256 8152866dcf67864f5e36b228730dc8a94b7f6c367afb96d6463a59ba81c26489; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 c8fdda2f609d89512622a1a7c643e2c2ca6ebd23045ea79013b87baa812647b3; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3416, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "409e0efbf097edeb1a54f8a634dc4eb270d22bf26a074465d1cef96b19885aa9", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q114548900$B43D998D-7948-4B2E-9374-9B66AAA79E68 in revision 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes followed by (P156) with value Gadgets (Q114492032).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q114548900$B43D998D-7948-4B2E-9374-9B66AAA79E68", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q114548900) / P156", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2174266654 at 2024-06-08T06:40:54Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "90 An important theme arising in the evidence of work on rehabilitation is the importance of culturally appropriate, or suitably tailored, schemes, initiatives and tools.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 42", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G03-2026-07-23.svg index 5a95b0fa8..d99487b1b 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q114548900$B43D998D-7948-4B2E-9374-9B66AAA79E68 in revision - 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes followed by (P156) with value + 90 An important theme arising in the evidence of work on rehabilitation is the + importance of culturally appropriate, or suitably tailored, schemes, initiatives and Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T06-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q114548900) / P156 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2174266654 at 2024-06-08T06:40:54Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q114548900$B43D998D-7948-4B2E-9374-9B66AAA79E68 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 42 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json index 21c0a457e..32a89d9a1 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2174266654&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 43. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q114548900$7617EBC9-3609-432E-BC20-9A22FACF8FB8 in revision 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes part of the series (P179) with value Modern Marvels (Q2512604).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P179\",\"hash\":\"5058238ca79fe5344cdae7bfc0c0090b27fed6ea\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":2512604,\"id\":\"Q2512604\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P1545\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1545\",\"hash\":\"25c38d10e53fd1c6c6290e41fca80df1f6b93045\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"112\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P1545\"],\"id\":\"Q114548900$7617EBC9-3609-432E-BC20-9A22FACF8FB8\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2174266654&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q114548900; claims.P179; statement Q114548900$7617EBC9-3609-432E-BC20-9A22FACF8FB8", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2024-06-08T06:40:54Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b37b9f08b4016430e24af57a7fdd306a40cab564aaee8494ad32f9fc0b9e1604", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In almost all cases, jurisdictions that had developed a rehabilitation strategy, model or framework also had in place some form of implementation arrangements.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In almost all cases, jurisdictions that had developed a rehabilitation strategy, model or framework also had in place some form of implementation arrangements.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 43", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "6fd67e986fdca09a718441ba7f01181532414a62044dc182f6cb4a70110f5813", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2174266654; entity Q114548900; source SHA-256 b37b9f08b4016430e24af57a7fdd306a40cab564aaee8494ad32f9fc0b9e1604; statement SHA-256 aad7be8a508407da0a8ba2f219b4563bc8c9ba4cb76ec38701c919449915ada8; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 6fd67e986fdca09a718441ba7f01181532414a62044dc182f6cb4a70110f5813; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3417, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "409e0efbf097edeb1a54f8a634dc4eb270d22bf26a074465d1cef96b19885aa9", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q114548900$7617EBC9-3609-432E-BC20-9A22FACF8FB8 in revision 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes part of the series (P179) with value Modern Marvels (Q2512604).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q114548900$7617EBC9-3609-432E-BC20-9A22FACF8FB8", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q114548900) / P179", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2174266654 at 2024-06-08T06:40:54Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In almost all cases, jurisdictions that had developed a rehabilitation strategy, model or framework also had in place some form of implementation arrangements.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 43", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G04-2026-07-23.svg index 0d938fde8..77ead9b49 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q114548900$7617EBC9-3609-432E-BC20-9A22FACF8FB8 in revision - 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes part of the series (P179) + In almost all cases, jurisdictions that had developed a rehabilitation strategy, + model or framework also had in place some form of implementation arrangements. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T06-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q114548900) / P179 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2174266654 at 2024-06-08T06:40:54Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q114548900$7617EBC9-3609-432E-BC20-9A22FACF8FB8 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 43 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json index be440e767..b6bfd6d36 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2174266654&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 44. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q114548900$2BE79120-51DE-49DE-B217-AADD095EA9BE in revision 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes instance of (P31) with value television series episode (Q21191270).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P31\",\"hash\":\"2d3761f68cf1248dc8fbf0b5eaa1f7fff03df987\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":21191270,\"id\":\"Q21191270\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q114548900$2BE79120-51DE-49DE-B217-AADD095EA9BE\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2174266654&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q114548900; claims.P31; statement Q114548900$2BE79120-51DE-49DE-B217-AADD095EA9BE", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2024-06-08T06:40:54Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b37b9f08b4016430e24af57a7fdd306a40cab564aaee8494ad32f9fc0b9e1604", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Supporting descriptions and documents showed that many of the higher income jurisdictions have dedicated research and evaluation capacities that publish extensively the results of their work.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Supporting descriptions and documents showed that many of the higher income jurisdictions have dedicated research and evaluation capacities that publish extensively the results of their work.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 44", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "aba5ef37c84a2848228032b742ba04866221294b02f7d01831e98989fffb894e", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2174266654; entity Q114548900; source SHA-256 b37b9f08b4016430e24af57a7fdd306a40cab564aaee8494ad32f9fc0b9e1604; statement SHA-256 5f8230a28cbebae4c9c4e56f95af44f211203071d52abe6937c6306343b0c12b; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 aba5ef37c84a2848228032b742ba04866221294b02f7d01831e98989fffb894e; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3418, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "409e0efbf097edeb1a54f8a634dc4eb270d22bf26a074465d1cef96b19885aa9", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q114548900$2BE79120-51DE-49DE-B217-AADD095EA9BE in revision 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes instance of (P31) with value television series episode (Q21191270).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q114548900$2BE79120-51DE-49DE-B217-AADD095EA9BE", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q114548900) / P31", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2174266654 at 2024-06-08T06:40:54Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Supporting descriptions and documents showed that many of the higher income jurisdictions have dedicated research and evaluation capacities that publish extensively the results of their work.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 44", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G05-2026-07-23.svg index dd78fa6af..5a7feca2c 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q114548900$2BE79120-51DE-49DE-B217-AADD095EA9BE in revision - 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes instance of (P31) with value + Supporting descriptions and documents showed that many of the higher income + jurisdictions have dedicated research and evaluation capacities that publish Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T06-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q114548900) / P31 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2174266654 at 2024-06-08T06:40:54Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q114548900$2BE79120-51DE-49DE-B217-AADD095EA9BE - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 44 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json index 59bf8c2be..85cce6f1f 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2174266654&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 44. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q114548900$DFDB26B2-DE66-4ABA-AFF6-254066A0655F in revision 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes season (P4908) with value Modern Marvels, season 7 (Q114448294).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P4908\",\"hash\":\"9e0207b62522540b653fb68114a90dbc374c28e8\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":114448294,\"id\":\"Q114448294\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P1545\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1545\",\"hash\":\"9a4403310d2d27312d0a93830981a1e51b735843\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"7\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P1545\"],\"id\":\"Q114548900$DFDB26B2-DE66-4ABA-AFF6-254066A0655F\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2174266654&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q114548900; claims.P4908; statement Q114548900$DFDB26B2-DE66-4ABA-AFF6-254066A0655F", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2024-06-08T06:40:54Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b37b9f08b4016430e24af57a7fdd306a40cab564aaee8494ad32f9fc0b9e1604", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "92 In some jurisdictions, these monitoring and evaluation efforts are required to fulfil statutory obligations and in some cases the prison service has key performance indicators associated with rehabilitation-related goals.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "92 In some jurisdictions, these monitoring and evaluation efforts are required to fulfil statutory obligations and in some cases the prison service has key performance indicators associated with rehabilitation-related goals.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 44", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "3f78b09806650ae9c4aeee006dc44767c7931088a4354ec9402e775a29b0265b", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2174266654; entity Q114548900; source SHA-256 b37b9f08b4016430e24af57a7fdd306a40cab564aaee8494ad32f9fc0b9e1604; statement SHA-256 f3bd4ae185c0bc768f25d34fc215382b5e611cc47e9531d75a4aa06b8dcb2e8f; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 3f78b09806650ae9c4aeee006dc44767c7931088a4354ec9402e775a29b0265b; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3419, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "409e0efbf097edeb1a54f8a634dc4eb270d22bf26a074465d1cef96b19885aa9", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q114548900$DFDB26B2-DE66-4ABA-AFF6-254066A0655F in revision 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes season (P4908) with value Modern Marvels, season 7 (Q114448294).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q114548900$DFDB26B2-DE66-4ABA-AFF6-254066A0655F", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q114548900) / P4908", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2174266654 at 2024-06-08T06:40:54Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "92 In some jurisdictions, these monitoring and evaluation efforts are required to fulfil statutory obligations and in some cases the prison service has key performance indicators associated with rehabilitation-related goals.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 44", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G06-2026-07-23.svg index bee279c47..5bf5f1bf9 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q114548900$DFDB26B2-DE66-4ABA-AFF6-254066A0655F in revision - 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes season (P4908) with value + 92 In some jurisdictions, these monitoring and evaluation efforts are required to + fulfil statutory obligations and in some cases the prison service has key Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T06-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q114548900) / P4908 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2174266654 at 2024-06-08T06:40:54Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q114548900$DFDB26B2-DE66-4ABA-AFF6-254066A0655F - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 44 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json index 0ddbaa199..8dc273bf5 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2174266654&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 45. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q114548900$C048A8A6-F733-4B7D-8099-6DAE75E3ACB0 in revision 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes publication date (P577) with value +2000-03-06T00:00:00Z.", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P577\",\"hash\":\"0135d41b530af74fd24f5ab3c7b100c43e2cff28\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2000-03-06T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q114548900$C048A8A6-F733-4B7D-8099-6DAE75E3ACB0\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2174266654&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q114548900; claims.P577; statement Q114548900$C048A8A6-F733-4B7D-8099-6DAE75E3ACB0", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2024-06-08T06:40:54Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "b37b9f08b4016430e24af57a7fdd306a40cab564aaee8494ad32f9fc0b9e1604", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "94 A second approach responding jurisdictions identified to develop a more rehabilitative prison environment was work undertaken to improve the social climate of prisons and the relationship between prisoners and prison staff.In one of the Baltic states, dynamic security is emphasised as an important component not only of institutional safety and security but so too of effective rehabilitation and resocialisation.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "94 A second approach responding jurisdictions identified to develop a more rehabilitative prison environment was work undertaken to improve the social climate of prisons and the relationship between prisoners and prison staff.In one of the Baltic states, dynamic security is emphasised as an important component not only of institutional safety and security but so too of effective rehabilitation and resocialisation.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 45", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "0bf65a705f97fbf8495e941467a83d0d8fd4ef1ba06a081335970a815b507b61", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2174266654; entity Q114548900; source SHA-256 b37b9f08b4016430e24af57a7fdd306a40cab564aaee8494ad32f9fc0b9e1604; statement SHA-256 374d17cc46298dce1b3d6ce074eebc8f203d97dc3454d27705c4d7194cd79333; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 0bf65a705f97fbf8495e941467a83d0d8fd4ef1ba06a081335970a815b507b61; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3420, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "409e0efbf097edeb1a54f8a634dc4eb270d22bf26a074465d1cef96b19885aa9", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q114548900$C048A8A6-F733-4B7D-8099-6DAE75E3ACB0 in revision 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes publication date (P577) with value +2000-03-06T00:00:00Z.", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q114548900$C048A8A6-F733-4B7D-8099-6DAE75E3ACB0", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q114548900) / P577", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2174266654 at 2024-06-08T06:40:54Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "94 A second approach responding jurisdictions identified to develop a more rehabilitative prison environment was work undertaken to improve the social climate of prisons and the relationship between prisoners and prison staff.In one of the Baltic states, dynamic security is emphasised as an important component not only of institutional safety and security but so too of effective rehabilitation and resocialisation.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 45", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G07-2026-07-23.svg index 82d24dd5b..bfbae7223 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q114548900$C048A8A6-F733-4B7D-8099-6DAE75E3ACB0 in revision - 2174266654 asserts that Prisons (Q114548900) publishes publication date (P577) with + 94 A second approach responding jurisdictions identified to develop a more + rehabilitative prison environment was work undertaken to improve the social climate Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T06-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q114548900) / P577 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2174266654 at 2024-06-08T06:40:54Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q114548900$C048A8A6-F733-4B7D-8099-6DAE75E3ACB0 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 45 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json index a7d5432ed..80354e183 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2376770842&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 45. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q92542991$11984D64-69E9-4BED-8629-C1BB85B02B8D in revision 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes creator (P170) with value Tamar Eytan (Q21984603).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P170\",\"hash\":\"da8061c94a4838f85152e4b867fe462c938a7c77\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":21984603,\"id\":\"Q21984603\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q92542991$11984D64-69E9-4BED-8629-C1BB85B02B8D\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"19d20afe1a666bb0ad692d7eedc41a2c4ea03857\",\"snaks\":{\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"1d84a430faf4106484eb229097cb0aade098354a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/museums.gov.il\\/he\\/items\\/Pages\\/ItemCard.aspx?IdItem=ICMS_BRD_ART519\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2376770842&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q92542991; claims.P170; statement Q92542991$11984D64-69E9-4BED-8629-C1BB85B02B8D", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-07-09T12:47:52Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "be74e6220d6148930657e4c7afe1a1adf0aa3af69aaded468641cba3588a4ff0", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "A rehabilitative index has been developed from this research, improving understanding of how prison environments influence different aspects.95 Finally, efforts to understand how rehabilitation is best achieved and to apply the results of research to rethinking the prison itself are reflected in new prison models.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "A rehabilitative index has been developed from this research, improving understanding of how prison environments influence different aspects.95 Finally, efforts to understand how rehabilitation is best achieved and to apply the results of research to rethinking the prison itself are reflected in new prison models.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 45", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "146f9b5a8c720139976b9a291cf645fd98a2179e5dedbab705fb4bb8ea790f1d", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2376770842; entity Q92542991; source SHA-256 be74e6220d6148930657e4c7afe1a1adf0aa3af69aaded468641cba3588a4ff0; statement SHA-256 828735c9d712de54cf32f9bce4603a82a2b51fde18437ae51f886259449c5e03; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 146f9b5a8c720139976b9a291cf645fd98a2179e5dedbab705fb4bb8ea790f1d; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3421, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "409e0efbf097edeb1a54f8a634dc4eb270d22bf26a074465d1cef96b19885aa9", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q92542991$11984D64-69E9-4BED-8629-C1BB85B02B8D in revision 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes creator (P170) with value Tamar Eytan (Q21984603).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q92542991$11984D64-69E9-4BED-8629-C1BB85B02B8D", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q92542991) / P170", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2376770842 at 2025-07-09T12:47:52Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "A rehabilitative index has been developed from this research, improving understanding of how prison environments influence different aspects.95 Finally, efforts to understand how rehabilitation is best achieved and to apply the results of research to rethinking the prison itself are reflected in new prison models.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 45", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G08-2026-07-23.svg index b756f694e..4b1acd2f9 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q92542991$11984D64-69E9-4BED-8629-C1BB85B02B8D in revision - 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes creator (P170) with value + A rehabilitative index has been developed from this research, improving + understanding of how prison environments influence different aspects.95 Finally, Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T06-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q92542991) / P170 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2376770842 at 2025-07-09T12:47:52Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q92542991$11984D64-69E9-4BED-8629-C1BB85B02B8D - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 45 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json index f178a2f01..1680e66f5 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2376770842&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 46. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q92542991$D6AA23B9-7187-4F55-B778-47EB8F016290 in revision 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes collection (P195) with value Bar-David Museum of Art and Judaica (Q56876015).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P195\",\"hash\":\"64acf69a939136c21e16e9bb716c56e60f5b99d1\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":56876015,\"id\":\"Q56876015\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q92542991$D6AA23B9-7187-4F55-B778-47EB8F016290\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"19d20afe1a666bb0ad692d7eedc41a2c4ea03857\",\"snaks\":{\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"1d84a430faf4106484eb229097cb0aade098354a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/museums.gov.il\\/he\\/items\\/Pages\\/ItemCard.aspx?IdItem=ICMS_BRD_ART519\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2376770842&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q92542991; claims.P195; statement Q92542991$D6AA23B9-7187-4F55-B778-47EB8F016290", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-07-09T12:47:52Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "be74e6220d6148930657e4c7afe1a1adf0aa3af69aaded468641cba3588a4ff0", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Second, more specialized rehabilitation programmes that target root causes of offending were implemented in around two thirds (68 per cent) of jurisdictions.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Second, more specialized rehabilitation programmes that target root causes of offending were implemented in around two thirds (68 per cent) of jurisdictions.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 46", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "a570a0d7d88a3734d5588c402fe4c523463d7972476ed407e30d373d5ba2226a", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2376770842; entity Q92542991; source SHA-256 be74e6220d6148930657e4c7afe1a1adf0aa3af69aaded468641cba3588a4ff0; statement SHA-256 4a95ec6dc8f12e62c977cfd45e1fa6ecf78e44b6d9fa00f7879ddd2da23a4a94; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 a570a0d7d88a3734d5588c402fe4c523463d7972476ed407e30d373d5ba2226a; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3422, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "409e0efbf097edeb1a54f8a634dc4eb270d22bf26a074465d1cef96b19885aa9", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q92542991$D6AA23B9-7187-4F55-B778-47EB8F016290 in revision 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes collection (P195) with value Bar-David Museum of Art and Judaica (Q56876015).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q92542991$D6AA23B9-7187-4F55-B778-47EB8F016290", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q92542991) / P195", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2376770842 at 2025-07-09T12:47:52Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Second, more specialized rehabilitation programmes that target root causes of offending were implemented in around two thirds (68 per cent) of jurisdictions.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 46", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G09-2026-07-23.svg index 96e230fdb..6e0e04302 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q92542991$D6AA23B9-7187-4F55-B778-47EB8F016290 in revision - 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes collection (P195) with value + Second, more specialized rehabilitation programmes that target root causes of + offending were implemented in around two thirds (68 per cent) of jurisdictions. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T06-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q92542991) / P195 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2376770842 at 2025-07-09T12:47:52Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q92542991$D6AA23B9-7187-4F55-B778-47EB8F016290 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 46 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json index 52a16171e..08466785a 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2376770842&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 46. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q92542991$593013E8-F92F-4FFE-A988-62974F0579EC in revision 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes length (P2043) with value +86.", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2043\",\"hash\":\"89eeb03aa8f28fec4e5d076911ab04bb14f78bff\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"amount\":\"+86\",\"unit\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q174728\"},\"type\":\"quantity\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q92542991$593013E8-F92F-4FFE-A988-62974F0579EC\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"19d20afe1a666bb0ad692d7eedc41a2c4ea03857\",\"snaks\":{\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"1d84a430faf4106484eb229097cb0aade098354a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/museums.gov.il\\/he\\/items\\/Pages\\/ItemCard.aspx?IdItem=ICMS_BRD_ART519\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2376770842&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q92542991; claims.P2043; statement Q92542991$593013E8-F92F-4FFE-A988-62974F0579EC", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-07-09T12:47:52Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "be74e6220d6148930657e4c7afe1a1adf0aa3af69aaded468641cba3588a4ff0", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Further, only about half of these jurisdictions (54 per cent) reported that programmes were developed on an evidence-based model or one that has a clear theory of change, and only slightly more (59 per cent) reported that these programmes were subject to regular monitoring and evaluation to inform improvements in practice.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Further, only about half of these jurisdictions (54 per cent) reported that programmes were developed on an evidence-based model or one that has a clear theory of change, and only slightly more (59 per cent) reported that these programmes were subject to regular monitoring and evaluation to inform improvements in practice.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 46", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "69bff75a839366502f7c5b5da35a45b588ca804ecb7cf125505abb370b44121d", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2376770842; entity Q92542991; source SHA-256 be74e6220d6148930657e4c7afe1a1adf0aa3af69aaded468641cba3588a4ff0; statement SHA-256 00cd71d5c25f2a4a73a4f32b456695fa6f1f7af3d244d537ff68c98cc7e7ff71; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 69bff75a839366502f7c5b5da35a45b588ca804ecb7cf125505abb370b44121d; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3423, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "409e0efbf097edeb1a54f8a634dc4eb270d22bf26a074465d1cef96b19885aa9", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q92542991$593013E8-F92F-4FFE-A988-62974F0579EC in revision 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes length (P2043) with value +86.", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q92542991$593013E8-F92F-4FFE-A988-62974F0579EC", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q92542991) / P2043", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2376770842 at 2025-07-09T12:47:52Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Further, only about half of these jurisdictions (54 per cent) reported that programmes were developed on an evidence-based model or one that has a clear theory of change, and only slightly more (59 per cent) reported that these programmes were subject to regular monitoring and evaluation to inform improvements in practice.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 46", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G10-2026-07-23.svg index be7792fac..2fa5f36f6 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q92542991$593013E8-F92F-4FFE-A988-62974F0579EC in revision - 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes length (P2043) with value +86. + Further, only about half of these jurisdictions (54 per cent) reported that + programmes were developed on an evidence-based model or one that has a clear theory Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T06-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q92542991) / P2043 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2376770842 at 2025-07-09T12:47:52Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q92542991$593013E8-F92F-4FFE-A988-62974F0579EC - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 46 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json index 5a26d2689..9d0c98b99 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2376770842&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 47. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q92542991$0F60DBE7-3BEC-4FD8-8D44-80871A3B5710 in revision 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes width (P2049) with value +56.", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2049\",\"hash\":\"09cbcbba8ee1103c4421e1717825d1568a3da196\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"amount\":\"+56\",\"unit\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q174728\"},\"type\":\"quantity\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q92542991$0F60DBE7-3BEC-4FD8-8D44-80871A3B5710\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"19d20afe1a666bb0ad692d7eedc41a2c4ea03857\",\"snaks\":{\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"1d84a430faf4106484eb229097cb0aade098354a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/museums.gov.il\\/he\\/items\\/Pages\\/ItemCard.aspx?IdItem=ICMS_BRD_ART519\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2376770842&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q92542991; claims.P2049; statement Q92542991$0F60DBE7-3BEC-4FD8-8D44-80871A3B5710", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-07-09T12:47:52Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "be74e6220d6148930657e4c7afe1a1adf0aa3af69aaded468641cba3588a4ff0", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Even there, questions have been raised about the relevance and impact of such “effective” practices for minority groups, including indigenous offenders.102 103 The available evidence base for what is an effective rehabilitation programme in prisons in other regional contexts remains slim.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Even there, questions have been raised about the relevance and impact of such “effective” practices for minority groups, including indigenous offenders.102 103 The available evidence base for what is an effective rehabilitation programme in prisons in other regional contexts remains slim.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 47", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "bb8c250daa5743e0b5171cfb6dc83d533c1526288ae60b90444ea778f8071a54", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2376770842; entity Q92542991; source SHA-256 be74e6220d6148930657e4c7afe1a1adf0aa3af69aaded468641cba3588a4ff0; statement SHA-256 d97cdb25fa04145bdfcfaef69467196ca94e9885e0476c75a2e970afd23a42b5; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 bb8c250daa5743e0b5171cfb6dc83d533c1526288ae60b90444ea778f8071a54; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3424, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "878ae5b42b89311ca3480735b24061cd033ee2803a23802d374011b34e345258", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q92542991$0F60DBE7-3BEC-4FD8-8D44-80871A3B5710 in revision 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes width (P2049) with value +56.", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q92542991$0F60DBE7-3BEC-4FD8-8D44-80871A3B5710", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q92542991) / P2049", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2376770842 at 2025-07-09T12:47:52Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Even there, questions have been raised about the relevance and impact of such “effective” practices for minority groups, including indigenous offenders.102 103 The available evidence base for what is an effective rehabilitation programme in prisons in other regional contexts remains slim.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 47", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G01-2026-07-23.svg index e5e18c92f..c2f244002 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q92542991$0F60DBE7-3BEC-4FD8-8D44-80871A3B5710 in revision - 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes width (P2049) with value +56. + Even there, questions have been raised about the relevance and impact of such + “effective” practices for minority groups, including indigenous offenders.102 103 Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T07-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q92542991) / P2049 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2376770842 at 2025-07-09T12:47:52Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q92542991$0F60DBE7-3BEC-4FD8-8D44-80871A3B5710 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 47 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json index 307a0b348..c31567434 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2376770842&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 47. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q92542991$68B92DEF-9D0D-460C-BFB2-009B03485ECB in revision 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes inventory number (P217) with value \"ART519\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P217\",\"hash\":\"9031ca640a2840d7f84289d1ef34849d326868c5\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"ART519\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P195\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P195\",\"hash\":\"64acf69a939136c21e16e9bb716c56e60f5b99d1\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":56876015,\"id\":\"Q56876015\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P195\"],\"id\":\"Q92542991$68B92DEF-9D0D-460C-BFB2-009B03485ECB\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"19d20afe1a666bb0ad692d7eedc41a2c4ea03857\",\"snaks\":{\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"1d84a430faf4106484eb229097cb0aade098354a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/museums.gov.il\\/he\\/items\\/Pages\\/ItemCard.aspx?IdItem=ICMS_BRD_ART519\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2376770842&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q92542991; claims.P217; statement Q92542991$68B92DEF-9D0D-460C-BFB2-009B03485ECB", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-07-09T12:47:52Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "be74e6220d6148930657e4c7afe1a1adf0aa3af69aaded468641cba3588a4ff0", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The apparent success of rehabilitative elements of this training is captured in the reports of around three quarters (76 per cent) of jurisdictions that they had achieved prison officer buy-in to rehabilitative objectives.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The apparent success of rehabilitative elements of this training is captured in the reports of around three quarters (76 per cent) of jurisdictions that they had achieved prison officer buy-in to rehabilitative objectives.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 47", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "fdbcc888a08aca7d9948d3259d3bed8b1f6353197dd35a42a17332bad47e401a", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2376770842; entity Q92542991; source SHA-256 be74e6220d6148930657e4c7afe1a1adf0aa3af69aaded468641cba3588a4ff0; statement SHA-256 6220176d0c1e88f455254498be08edec9e4ea160d86129b2a57bfebb13b07a48; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 fdbcc888a08aca7d9948d3259d3bed8b1f6353197dd35a42a17332bad47e401a; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3425, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "878ae5b42b89311ca3480735b24061cd033ee2803a23802d374011b34e345258", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q92542991$68B92DEF-9D0D-460C-BFB2-009B03485ECB in revision 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes inventory number (P217) with value \"ART519\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q92542991$68B92DEF-9D0D-460C-BFB2-009B03485ECB", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q92542991) / P217", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2376770842 at 2025-07-09T12:47:52Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The apparent success of rehabilitative elements of this training is captured in the reports of around three quarters (76 per cent) of jurisdictions that they had achieved prison officer buy-in to rehabilitative objectives.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 47", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G02-2026-07-23.svg index 0dabfacae..431c442f8 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q92542991$68B92DEF-9D0D-460C-BFB2-009B03485ECB in revision - 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes inventory number (P217) with + The apparent success of rehabilitative elements of this training is captured in the + reports of around three quarters (76 per cent) of jurisdictions that they had Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T07-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q92542991) / P217 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2376770842 at 2025-07-09T12:47:52Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q92542991$68B92DEF-9D0D-460C-BFB2-009B03485ECB - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 47 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json index 95fae82fd..7b0e9baff 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2376770842&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 48. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q92542991$E26896FC-8443-494D-ACFE-D545DA465510 in revision 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes location (P276) with value Bar-David Museum of Art and Judaica (Q56876015).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P276\",\"hash\":\"a621e7f94c57fb6a93783c0a4601e5b8e354ec57\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":56876015,\"id\":\"Q56876015\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q92542991$E26896FC-8443-494D-ACFE-D545DA465510\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"19d20afe1a666bb0ad692d7eedc41a2c4ea03857\",\"snaks\":{\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"1d84a430faf4106484eb229097cb0aade098354a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/museums.gov.il\\/he\\/items\\/Pages\\/ItemCard.aspx?IdItem=ICMS_BRD_ART519\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2376770842&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q92542991; claims.P276; statement Q92542991$E26896FC-8443-494D-ACFE-D545DA465510", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-07-09T12:47:52Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "be74e6220d6148930657e4c7afe1a1adf0aa3af69aaded468641cba3588a4ff0", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Less than one in three jurisdictions (30 per cent) had some level of research staff capacity to support evidence-based learning and approaches.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Less than one in three jurisdictions (30 per cent) had some level of research staff capacity to support evidence-based learning and approaches.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 48", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "43c2c0895d72f452ae119bb5c384bd58401362ad1e59173f2c457d501f6df420", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2376770842; entity Q92542991; source SHA-256 be74e6220d6148930657e4c7afe1a1adf0aa3af69aaded468641cba3588a4ff0; statement SHA-256 3a5e4b016404512591f18df5d023f68377953de17ee48738714a60357ff20cb0; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 43c2c0895d72f452ae119bb5c384bd58401362ad1e59173f2c457d501f6df420; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3426, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "878ae5b42b89311ca3480735b24061cd033ee2803a23802d374011b34e345258", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q92542991$E26896FC-8443-494D-ACFE-D545DA465510 in revision 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes location (P276) with value Bar-David Museum of Art and Judaica (Q56876015).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q92542991$E26896FC-8443-494D-ACFE-D545DA465510", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q92542991) / P276", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2376770842 at 2025-07-09T12:47:52Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Less than one in three jurisdictions (30 per cent) had some level of research staff capacity to support evidence-based learning and approaches.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 48", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G03-2026-07-23.svg index 0a0614290..9419e82b3 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q92542991$E26896FC-8443-494D-ACFE-D545DA465510 in revision - 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes location (P276) with value + Less than one in three jurisdictions (30 per cent) had some level of research staff + capacity to support evidence-based learning and approaches. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T07-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q92542991) / P276 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2376770842 at 2025-07-09T12:47:52Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q92542991$E26896FC-8443-494D-ACFE-D545DA465510 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 48 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json index e969c35e0..ee3ac7a62 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2376770842&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 48. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q92542991$5F4B6837-190C-4117-BB1B-4851F2F67D47 in revision 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes instance of (P31) with value visual artwork (Q4502142).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P31\",\"hash\":\"c9d17fa0813e03aad098cacfabfc7d70637fe161\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":4502142,\"id\":\"Q4502142\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q92542991$5F4B6837-190C-4117-BB1B-4851F2F67D47\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"19d20afe1a666bb0ad692d7eedc41a2c4ea03857\",\"snaks\":{\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"1d84a430faf4106484eb229097cb0aade098354a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/museums.gov.il\\/he\\/items\\/Pages\\/ItemCard.aspx?IdItem=ICMS_BRD_ART519\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2376770842&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q92542991; claims.P31; statement Q92542991$5F4B6837-190C-4117-BB1B-4851F2F67D47", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-07-09T12:47:52Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "be74e6220d6148930657e4c7afe1a1adf0aa3af69aaded468641cba3588a4ff0", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Specialist staff working with prisoners also appear to present a challenge, with fewer than half (41 per cent) of reporting jurisdictions having an adequate number of specialist personnel, including doctors, psychologists, psychiatrists, therapists, instructors and educators.105 Regional data indicated a broad trend toward more specialist staff and research capacity being available in higher income jurisdictions.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Specialist staff working with prisoners also appear to present a challenge, with fewer than half (41 per cent) of reporting jurisdictions having an adequate number of specialist personnel, including doctors, psychologists, psychiatrists, therapists, instructors and educators.105 Regional data indicated a broad trend toward more specialist staff and research capacity being available in higher income jurisdictions.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 48", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "65775072fa2f274f205da85536e5d16dc73bcb673a027822e10d9f95299c0ae7", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2376770842; entity Q92542991; source SHA-256 be74e6220d6148930657e4c7afe1a1adf0aa3af69aaded468641cba3588a4ff0; statement SHA-256 23b0405c548dbd8177da2e662ac6f2a9c0d7bb9d2862e540efa7ec396300ce32; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 65775072fa2f274f205da85536e5d16dc73bcb673a027822e10d9f95299c0ae7; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3427, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "878ae5b42b89311ca3480735b24061cd033ee2803a23802d374011b34e345258", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q92542991$5F4B6837-190C-4117-BB1B-4851F2F67D47 in revision 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes instance of (P31) with value visual artwork (Q4502142).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q92542991$5F4B6837-190C-4117-BB1B-4851F2F67D47", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons (Q92542991) / P31", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2376770842 at 2025-07-09T12:47:52Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Specialist staff working with prisoners also appear to present a challenge, with fewer than half (41 per cent) of reporting jurisdictions having an adequate number of specialist personnel, including doctors, psychologists, psychiatrists, therapists, instructors and educators.105 Regional data indicated a broad trend toward more specialist staff and research capacity being available in higher income jurisdictions.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 48", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G04-2026-07-23.svg index d96eb7252..a622929c9 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q92542991$5F4B6837-190C-4117-BB1B-4851F2F67D47 in revision - 2376770842 asserts that Prisons (Q92542991) publishes instance of (P31) with value + Specialist staff working with prisoners also appear to present a challenge, with + fewer than half (41 per cent) of reporting jurisdictions having an adequate number Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T07-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons (Q92542991) / P31 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2376770842 at 2025-07-09T12:47:52Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q92542991$5F4B6837-190C-4117-BB1B-4851F2F67D47 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 48 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json index f7b6228b8..c3f5ef1a8 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2307574426&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 49. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q76476875$A2A59232-9F86-4E12-AE5D-2CA075DD45BA in revision 2307574426 asserts that Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) publishes publisher (P123) with value Y Lolfa (Q3404425).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P123\",\"hash\":\"2a0ea3db978c77ec11c3f5d167ee3b6646e92e08\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":3404425,\"id\":\"Q3404425\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q76476875$A2A59232-9F86-4E12-AE5D-2CA075DD45BA\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"e34c1b550779780e103aefce8ecf23393ef26781\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"25e24371cead6b4a00142ea623f778c366d27d4a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":28913614,\"id\":\"Q28913614\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P6786\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P6786\",\"hash\":\"ba9ae971cf772c33e852fdbfd41970e23b62b763\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"99157223302419\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"d500445def71a8cfc1043892c89ed848413c6856\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2019-11-17T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P6786\",\"P813\"]},{\"hash\":\"6f167a5e67c7a7f5b122213634d3b327830aeead\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"3b8ad30045b4d7d93be11d9baa00d5e6f49d11d0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":1201876,\"id\":\"Q1201876\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P648\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P648\",\"hash\":\"5f94571110c5f32dc001b8e22e5170038fa6e599\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"OL43983020M\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"1575ca49a8251d397510ba63a1aa39bcb4661a88\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2025-02-05T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P648\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2307574426&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q76476875; claims.P123; statement Q76476875$A2A59232-9F86-4E12-AE5D-2CA075DD45BA", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-02-05T23:54:43Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "010b04a94a2dc22039df3ac324bed6364cebba6c7f46ba8fb91f87a6bef2dd63", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Rehabilitation Rehabilitation can broadly be defined as “processes and practices that aim at the successful reintegration of those who have offended.”107 Since the 1990s, a dominant model of rehabilitation practice has emerged that focuses on a small set of programming targets (termed “criminogenic needs”) based on their empirically established relationship with reducing recidivism.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Rehabilitation Rehabilitation can broadly be defined as “processes and practices that aim at the successful reintegration of those who have offended.”107 Since the 1990s, a dominant model of rehabilitation practice has emerged that focuses on a small set of programming targets (termed “criminogenic needs”) based on their empirically established relationship with reducing recidivism.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 49", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "ab2cd93cc8f7dd40b9a47f52b58c988a104879e8868f824f7fac35523921852c", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2307574426; entity Q76476875; source SHA-256 010b04a94a2dc22039df3ac324bed6364cebba6c7f46ba8fb91f87a6bef2dd63; statement SHA-256 254ba98204eebd68fdb08ab39bb0be7d0547fead884ee99028b763b7f5c4c12d; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 ab2cd93cc8f7dd40b9a47f52b58c988a104879e8868f824f7fac35523921852c; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3428, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "878ae5b42b89311ca3480735b24061cd033ee2803a23802d374011b34e345258", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q76476875$A2A59232-9F86-4E12-AE5D-2CA075DD45BA in revision 2307574426 asserts that Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) publishes publisher (P123) with value Y Lolfa (Q3404425).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q76476875$A2A59232-9F86-4E12-AE5D-2CA075DD45BA", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) / P123", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2307574426 at 2025-02-05T23:54:43Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Rehabilitation Rehabilitation can broadly be defined as “processes and practices that aim at the successful reintegration of those who have offended.”107 Since the 1990s, a dominant model of rehabilitation practice has emerged that focuses on a small set of programming targets (termed “criminogenic needs”) based on their empirically established relationship with reducing recidivism.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 49", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G05-2026-07-23.svg index 48e83d732..8d78bf310 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q76476875$A2A59232-9F86-4E12-AE5D-2CA075DD45BA in revision - 2307574426 asserts that Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) publishes publisher (P123) with + Rehabilitation Rehabilitation can broadly be defined as “processes and practices + that aim at the successful reintegration of those who have offended.”107 Since the Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T07-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) / P123 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2307574426 at 2025-02-05T23:54:43Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q76476875$A2A59232-9F86-4E12-AE5D-2CA075DD45BA - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 49 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json index 191a57fd9..fedeee097 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2307574426&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 49. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q76476875$309B86A8-2AD2-49E7-8C72-F91328B691EC in revision 2307574426 asserts that Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) publishes title (P1476) with value Prisons exposed.", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1476\",\"hash\":\"183fd31fa6cb0b1a95180ac446a7bb97da886948\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"text\":\"Prisons exposed\",\"language\":\"en-gb\"},\"type\":\"monolingualtext\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q76476875$309B86A8-2AD2-49E7-8C72-F91328B691EC\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"e34c1b550779780e103aefce8ecf23393ef26781\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"25e24371cead6b4a00142ea623f778c366d27d4a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":28913614,\"id\":\"Q28913614\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P6786\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P6786\",\"hash\":\"ba9ae971cf772c33e852fdbfd41970e23b62b763\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"99157223302419\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"d500445def71a8cfc1043892c89ed848413c6856\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2019-11-17T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P6786\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2307574426&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q76476875; claims.P1476; statement Q76476875$309B86A8-2AD2-49E7-8C72-F91328B691EC", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-02-05T23:54:43Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "010b04a94a2dc22039df3ac324bed6364cebba6c7f46ba8fb91f87a6bef2dd63", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Seena Fazel et al., ‘An Updated Evidence Synthesis on the Risk-Need-Responsivity (RNR) Model: Umbrella Review and Commentary’, Journal of Criminal Justice 92 (1 May 2024): 1021-97.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Seena Fazel et al., ‘An Updated Evidence Synthesis on the Risk-Need-Responsivity (RNR) Model: Umbrella Review and Commentary’, Journal of Criminal Justice 92 (1 May 2024): 1021-97.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 49", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "2f8a2a28fbeaf09223cd0ae90f4a65528a911fac1cfa9095f3dc8600b0abf3a1", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2307574426; entity Q76476875; source SHA-256 010b04a94a2dc22039df3ac324bed6364cebba6c7f46ba8fb91f87a6bef2dd63; statement SHA-256 885b8096433621fadd179ec4daa77d72f869bbf9457c0f8403864b66e416a2e7; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 2f8a2a28fbeaf09223cd0ae90f4a65528a911fac1cfa9095f3dc8600b0abf3a1; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3429, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "878ae5b42b89311ca3480735b24061cd033ee2803a23802d374011b34e345258", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q76476875$309B86A8-2AD2-49E7-8C72-F91328B691EC in revision 2307574426 asserts that Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) publishes title (P1476) with value Prisons exposed.", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q76476875$309B86A8-2AD2-49E7-8C72-F91328B691EC", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) / P1476", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2307574426 at 2025-02-05T23:54:43Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Seena Fazel et al., ‘An Updated Evidence Synthesis on the Risk-Need-Responsivity (RNR) Model: Umbrella Review and Commentary’, Journal of Criminal Justice 92 (1 May 2024): 1021-97.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 49", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G06-2026-07-23.svg index 74da788d4..f23ef2776 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q76476875$309B86A8-2AD2-49E7-8C72-F91328B691EC in revision - 2307574426 asserts that Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) publishes title (P1476) with + Seena Fazel et al., ‘An Updated Evidence Synthesis on the Risk-Need-Responsivity + (RNR) Model: Umbrella Review and Commentary’, Journal of Criminal Justice 92 (1 May Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T07-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) / P1476 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2307574426 at 2025-02-05T23:54:43Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q76476875$309B86A8-2AD2-49E7-8C72-F91328B691EC - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 49 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json index b4084aa06..a53569370 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2307574426&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 50. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q76476875$bd89f14e-4c88-1861-84bf-e28fed6999bb in revision 2307574426 asserts that Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) publishes title (P1476) with value Prisons Exposed.", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1476\",\"hash\":\"7a9a8e220a563249d679018a35dbb64e62958a23\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"text\":\"Prisons Exposed\",\"language\":\"en\"},\"type\":\"monolingualtext\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q76476875$bd89f14e-4c88-1861-84bf-e28fed6999bb\",\"rank\":\"preferred\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2307574426&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q76476875; claims.P1476; statement Q76476875$bd89f14e-4c88-1861-84bf-e28fed6999bb", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-02-05T23:54:43Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "010b04a94a2dc22039df3ac324bed6364cebba6c7f46ba8fb91f87a6bef2dd63", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Since studies of post-prison recidivism began in the 1920s, however, they have been plagued with problems of measurement.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Since studies of post-prison recidivism began in the 1920s, however, they have been plagued with problems of measurement.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 50", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "188fb97d82004011e36ec1bf846ac50b471d73cc2b83ab634b56f93cf47b2eff", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2307574426; entity Q76476875; source SHA-256 010b04a94a2dc22039df3ac324bed6364cebba6c7f46ba8fb91f87a6bef2dd63; statement SHA-256 169b04f351bde113e1797510b0626baffb8dd9e50080c7f35a2ec7f08463b050; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 188fb97d82004011e36ec1bf846ac50b471d73cc2b83ab634b56f93cf47b2eff; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3430, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "878ae5b42b89311ca3480735b24061cd033ee2803a23802d374011b34e345258", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q76476875$bd89f14e-4c88-1861-84bf-e28fed6999bb in revision 2307574426 asserts that Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) publishes title (P1476) with value Prisons Exposed.", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q76476875$bd89f14e-4c88-1861-84bf-e28fed6999bb", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) / P1476", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2307574426 at 2025-02-05T23:54:43Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Since studies of post-prison recidivism began in the 1920s, however, they have been plagued with problems of measurement.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 50", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G07-2026-07-23.svg index 3d439d5e1..f91dc971a 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q76476875$bd89f14e-4c88-1861-84bf-e28fed6999bb in revision - 2307574426 asserts that Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) publishes title (P1476) with + Since studies of post-prison recidivism began in the 1920s, however, they have been + plagued with problems of measurement. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T07-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) / P1476 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2307574426 at 2025-02-05T23:54:43Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q76476875$bd89f14e-4c88-1861-84bf-e28fed6999bb - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 50 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json index 6e82cb549..08a71107d 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2307574426&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 50. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q76476875$5F345F77-516A-451B-B086-8E71971EB7BF in revision 2307574426 asserts that Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Michael O'Brien\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2093\",\"hash\":\"29d38c16e680e88b0c43a67b63f01c85b8cb5f8c\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"Michael O'Brien\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P1545\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1545\",\"hash\":\"2a1ced1dca90648ea7e306acbadd74fc81a10722\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"1\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P1545\"],\"id\":\"Q76476875$5F345F77-516A-451B-B086-8E71971EB7BF\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"e34c1b550779780e103aefce8ecf23393ef26781\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"25e24371cead6b4a00142ea623f778c366d27d4a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":28913614,\"id\":\"Q28913614\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P6786\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P6786\",\"hash\":\"ba9ae971cf772c33e852fdbfd41970e23b62b763\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"99157223302419\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"d500445def71a8cfc1043892c89ed848413c6856\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2019-11-17T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P6786\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2307574426&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q76476875; claims.P2093; statement Q76476875$5F345F77-516A-451B-B086-8E71971EB7BF", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-02-05T23:54:43Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "010b04a94a2dc22039df3ac324bed6364cebba6c7f46ba8fb91f87a6bef2dd63", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "A systematic review of recidivism statistics concluded that “only 10 out of 50 countries with the largest prison populations reported recidivism statistics”, and most used slightly varying definitions.115 Two-year reconviction rates were the most common recidivism measure among the 33 countries globally that report post-prison reoffending, all but three of which are high income economies.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "A systematic review of recidivism statistics concluded that “only 10 out of 50 countries with the largest prison populations reported recidivism statistics”, and most used slightly varying definitions.115 Two-year reconviction rates were the most common recidivism measure among the 33 countries globally that report post-prison reoffending, all but three of which are high income economies.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 50", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "342908b34fd0f1242e1ec44e79d9472bb97e6a51f8ff4c4654fa2c88be4ee206", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2307574426; entity Q76476875; source SHA-256 010b04a94a2dc22039df3ac324bed6364cebba6c7f46ba8fb91f87a6bef2dd63; statement SHA-256 4c9d44bc9695b3bca8bccf02b698bcc57a14b913bc3bd4542fe0f6457fc39202; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 342908b34fd0f1242e1ec44e79d9472bb97e6a51f8ff4c4654fa2c88be4ee206; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3431, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "878ae5b42b89311ca3480735b24061cd033ee2803a23802d374011b34e345258", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q76476875$5F345F77-516A-451B-B086-8E71971EB7BF in revision 2307574426 asserts that Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Michael O'Brien\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q76476875$5F345F77-516A-451B-B086-8E71971EB7BF", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) / P2093", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2307574426 at 2025-02-05T23:54:43Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "A systematic review of recidivism statistics concluded that “only 10 out of 50 countries with the largest prison populations reported recidivism statistics”, and most used slightly varying definitions.115 Two-year reconviction rates were the most common recidivism measure among the 33 countries globally that report post-prison reoffending, all but three of which are high income economies.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 50", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G08-2026-07-23.svg index e79e27c72..7a875197a 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q76476875$5F345F77-516A-451B-B086-8E71971EB7BF in revision - 2307574426 asserts that Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) publishes author name string + A systematic review of recidivism statistics concluded that “only 10 out of 50 + countries with the largest prison populations reported recidivism statistics”, and Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T07-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) / P2093 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2307574426 at 2025-02-05T23:54:43Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q76476875$5F345F77-516A-451B-B086-8E71971EB7BF - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 50 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json index 11392a452..61106ba48 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2307574426&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 51. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q76476875$85B2DBC7-983E-4086-B108-EE792A4063E3 in revision 2307574426 asserts that Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) publishes place of publication (P291) with value Tal-y-bont (Q3398810).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P291\",\"hash\":\"e53548b9531d6872e72b6932da368fcb01ae7204\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":3398810,\"id\":\"Q3398810\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q76476875$85B2DBC7-983E-4086-B108-EE792A4063E3\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"e34c1b550779780e103aefce8ecf23393ef26781\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"25e24371cead6b4a00142ea623f778c366d27d4a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":28913614,\"id\":\"Q28913614\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P6786\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P6786\",\"hash\":\"ba9ae971cf772c33e852fdbfd41970e23b62b763\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"99157223302419\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"d500445def71a8cfc1043892c89ed848413c6856\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2019-11-17T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P6786\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2307574426&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q76476875; claims.P291; statement Q76476875$85B2DBC7-983E-4086-B108-EE792A4063E3", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-02-05T23:54:43Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "010b04a94a2dc22039df3ac324bed6364cebba6c7f46ba8fb91f87a6bef2dd63", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Research done on positive prison climates and on developing a more rehabilitative culture within prisons (see below) are examples of approaches that can contribute to understanding how prisons can be reformed to support prisoner rehabilitation and social reintegration.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Research done on positive prison climates and on developing a more rehabilitative culture within prisons (see below) are examples of approaches that can contribute to understanding how prisons can be reformed to support prisoner rehabilitation and social reintegration.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 51", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "1857ed7acac487fcb2634bf8b27d47f8d909237386aed1b378210a074583d0b6", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2307574426; entity Q76476875; source SHA-256 010b04a94a2dc22039df3ac324bed6364cebba6c7f46ba8fb91f87a6bef2dd63; statement SHA-256 98d2ac28624173201aa1052948ee254e720520758156a8a2321d44d94646a4f8; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 1857ed7acac487fcb2634bf8b27d47f8d909237386aed1b378210a074583d0b6; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3432, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "878ae5b42b89311ca3480735b24061cd033ee2803a23802d374011b34e345258", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q76476875$85B2DBC7-983E-4086-B108-EE792A4063E3 in revision 2307574426 asserts that Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) publishes place of publication (P291) with value Tal-y-bont (Q3398810).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q76476875$85B2DBC7-983E-4086-B108-EE792A4063E3", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) / P291", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2307574426 at 2025-02-05T23:54:43Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Research done on positive prison climates and on developing a more rehabilitative culture within prisons (see below) are examples of approaches that can contribute to understanding how prisons can be reformed to support prisoner rehabilitation and social reintegration.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 51", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G09-2026-07-23.svg index fe4bf2df7..c023e3e76 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q76476875$85B2DBC7-983E-4086-B108-EE792A4063E3 in revision - 2307574426 asserts that Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) publishes place of publication + Research done on positive prison climates and on developing a more rehabilitative + culture within prisons (see below) are examples of approaches that can contribute to Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T07-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) / P291 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2307574426 at 2025-02-05T23:54:43Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q76476875$85B2DBC7-983E-4086-B108-EE792A4063E3 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 51 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json index dfaa5813a..bc5d66cd2 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "prisons", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2307574426&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 51. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "official_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q76476875$0485ECAC-ECAC-4D64-9BC3-C0BD3ED3937D in revision 2307574426 asserts that Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) publishes instance of (P31) with value version, edition or translation (Q3331189).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P31\",\"hash\":\"7d261aaf92dd9be13f2bd79d7024b98d449f1f89\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":3331189,\"id\":\"Q3331189\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q76476875$0485ECAC-ECAC-4D64-9BC3-C0BD3ED3937D\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"e34c1b550779780e103aefce8ecf23393ef26781\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"25e24371cead6b4a00142ea623f778c366d27d4a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":28913614,\"id\":\"Q28913614\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P6786\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P6786\",\"hash\":\"ba9ae971cf772c33e852fdbfd41970e23b62b763\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"99157223302419\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"d500445def71a8cfc1043892c89ed848413c6856\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2019-11-17T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P6786\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2307574426&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q76476875; claims.P31; statement Q76476875$0485ECAC-ECAC-4D64-9BC3-C0BD3ED3937D", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-02-05T23:54:43Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "010b04a94a2dc22039df3ac324bed6364cebba6c7f46ba8fb91f87a6bef2dd63", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Nevertheless, improving prison conditions generally, and redesigning prison regimes with a view to supporting rehabilitation more specifically, are key elements as highlighted, for example, in the ASEAN region.118 One suggested approach to understanding and designing more rehabilitative prison environments has been to focus on the social climate of the prison.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Nevertheless, improving prison conditions generally, and redesigning prison regimes with a view to supporting rehabilitation more specifically, are key elements as highlighted, for example, in the ASEAN region.118 One suggested approach to understanding and designing more rehabilitative prison environments has been to focus on the social climate of the prison.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/Prison_brief_2024.pdf", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 51", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "c7c9b7350b1ac466a7938df06fe26a92d2dbfc037b63347f239d2f2e61c7a945", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2307574426; entity Q76476875; source SHA-256 010b04a94a2dc22039df3ac324bed6364cebba6c7f46ba8fb91f87a6bef2dd63; statement SHA-256 b523f65d14ca02d13a0251d923e69e9cea7794a62b0a0091fe267dd54a558edc; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 c2fffe100bbf3f525b590775f004cc139f783c91c225b59b21cb989118f59c23; quote SHA-256 c7c9b7350b1ac466a7938df06fe26a92d2dbfc037b63347f239d2f2e61c7a945; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3433, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "878ae5b42b89311ca3480735b24061cd033ee2803a23802d374011b34e345258", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q76476875$0485ECAC-ECAC-4D64-9BC3-C0BD3ED3937D in revision 2307574426 asserts that Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) publishes instance of (P31) with value version, edition or translation (Q3331189).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q76476875$0485ECAC-ECAC-4D64-9BC3-C0BD3ED3937D", - "candidate_definition": "Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) / P31", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2307574426 at 2025-02-05T23:54:43Z", - "target_definition": "Prisons" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Nevertheless, improving prison conditions generally, and redesigning prison regimes with a view to supporting rehabilitation more specifically, are key elements as highlighted, for example, in the ASEAN region.118 One suggested approach to understanding and designing more rehabilitative prison environments has been to focus on the social climate of the prison.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 51", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G10-2026-07-23.svg index c50cc5ca2..af074ea1e 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q76476875$0485ECAC-ECAC-4D64-9BC3-C0BD3ED3937D in revision - 2307574426 asserts that Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) publishes instance of (P31) with + Nevertheless, improving prison conditions generally, and redesigning prison regimes + with a view to supporting rehabilitation more specifically, are key elements as Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM049-T07-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends + https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/briefs/ Target / Candidate - Prisons - Prisons Exposed (Q76476875) / P31 + UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends public + statements Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2307574426 at 2025-02-05T23:54:43Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q76476875$0485ECAC-ECAC-4D64-9BC3-C0BD3ED3937D - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 51 + artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends bytes on 2026-08-17. It + does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit diff --git a/docs/registry/evidence_index.json b/docs/registry/evidence_index.json index 30fdc0f7f..3cc05166b 100644 --- a/docs/registry/evidence_index.json +++ b/docs/registry/evidence_index.json @@ -57178,15 +57178,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G01", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57195,15 +57195,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G02", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57212,15 +57212,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G03", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57229,15 +57229,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G04", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57246,15 +57246,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G05", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57263,15 +57263,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G06", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57280,15 +57280,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G07", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57297,15 +57297,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G08", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57314,15 +57314,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G09", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57331,15 +57331,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T01-G10", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T01-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57348,15 +57348,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G01", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57365,15 +57365,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G02", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57382,15 +57382,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G03", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57399,15 +57399,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G04", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57416,15 +57416,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G05", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57433,15 +57433,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G06", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57450,15 +57450,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G07", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57467,15 +57467,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G08", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57484,15 +57484,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G09", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57501,15 +57501,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T02-G10", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T02-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57518,15 +57518,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G01", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57535,15 +57535,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G02", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57552,15 +57552,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G03", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57569,15 +57569,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G04", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57586,15 +57586,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G05", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57603,15 +57603,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G06", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57620,15 +57620,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G07", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57637,15 +57637,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G08", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57654,15 +57654,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G09", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57671,15 +57671,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T03-G10", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57688,15 +57688,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G01", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57705,15 +57705,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G02", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57722,15 +57722,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G03", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57739,15 +57739,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G04", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57756,15 +57756,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G05", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57773,15 +57773,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G06", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57790,15 +57790,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G07", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57807,15 +57807,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G08", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57824,15 +57824,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G09", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57841,15 +57841,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T04-G10", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57858,15 +57858,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G01", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57875,15 +57875,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G02", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57892,15 +57892,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G03", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57909,15 +57909,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G04", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57926,15 +57926,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G05", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57943,15 +57943,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G06", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57960,15 +57960,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G07", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57977,15 +57977,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G08", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -57994,15 +57994,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G09", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58011,15 +58011,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T05-G10", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58028,15 +58028,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G01", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58045,15 +58045,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G02", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58062,15 +58062,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G03", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58079,15 +58079,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G04", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58096,15 +58096,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G05", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58113,15 +58113,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G06", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58130,15 +58130,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G07", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58147,15 +58147,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G08", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58164,15 +58164,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G09", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58181,15 +58181,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T06-G10", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58198,15 +58198,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G01", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58215,15 +58215,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G02", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58232,15 +58232,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G03", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58249,15 +58249,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G04", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58266,15 +58266,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G05", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58283,15 +58283,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G06", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58300,15 +58300,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G07", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58317,15 +58317,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G08", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58334,15 +58334,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G09", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58351,15 +58351,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM049-T07-G10", "domain": "prisons", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom049_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM049-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -137348,9 +137348,9 @@ "workplace-safety": 70 }, "by_record_type": { - "evidence_result": 3714, + "evidence_result": 3644, "reproduction_attempt": 14, - "source_audit": 4344 + "source_audit": 4414 }, "by_result_status": { "BLOCKED_SOURCE": 17, @@ -137499,6 +137499,7 @@ "UN IGME Levels and trends in child mortality: Report 2020": 10, "UN IGME Levels and trends in child mortality: Report 2023": 50, "UNHCR Global Trends 2024": 70, + "UNODC Prison Matters 2024: Global Prison Population and Trends": 70, "UNODC Public Safety and Police Service Delivery assessment guide": 70, "WHO Global Patient Safety Action Plan 2021–2030": 70, "WHO Immunization Agenda 2030 Mid-Term Review 2025": 50, @@ -137565,7 +137566,6 @@ "Wikidata revision 2173825898 (Q110754664)": 7, "Wikidata revision 2174264073 (Q114485201)": 7, "Wikidata revision 2174265719 (Q114531973)": 7, - "Wikidata revision 2174266654 (Q114548900)": 7, "Wikidata revision 2187646001 (Q19875663)": 5, "Wikidata revision 2194518776 (Q96324777)": 4, "Wikidata revision 2200923314 (Q126999757)": 7, @@ -137598,7 +137598,6 @@ "Wikidata revision 2294388822 (Q51152646)": 9, "Wikidata revision 2294979117 (Q52668226)": 13, "Wikidata revision 2304481558 (Q53309212)": 23, - "Wikidata revision 2307574426 (Q76476875)": 6, "Wikidata revision 2309508475 (Q66644964)": 11, "Wikidata revision 2311462979 (Q39862640)": 13, "Wikidata revision 2329283132 (Q5530999)": 4, @@ -137609,7 +137608,6 @@ "Wikidata revision 2336110387 (Q133841568)": 9, "Wikidata revision 2339916855 (Q20791850)": 10, "Wikidata revision 2344784169 (Q14208849)": 4, - "Wikidata revision 2345191628 (Q7245853)": 7, "Wikidata revision 2348603598 (Q4291415)": 4, "Wikidata revision 2356906974 (Q116739232)": 2, "Wikidata revision 2356911199 (Q22908333)": 7, @@ -137621,7 +137619,6 @@ "Wikidata revision 2364806770 (Q29032191)": 11, "Wikidata revision 2368310890 (Q7202100)": 10, "Wikidata revision 2375965455 (Q112939351)": 1, - "Wikidata revision 2376770842 (Q92542991)": 7, "Wikidata revision 2378076900 (Q66010794)": 1, "Wikidata revision 2380094585 (Q7973338)": 1, "Wikidata revision 2380651852 (Q104711404)": 2, @@ -137823,7 +137820,6 @@ "Wikidata revision 2522307365 (Q16560)": 1, "Wikidata revision 2522444087 (Q69883)": 15, "Wikidata revision 2522555093 (Q283)": 6, - "Wikidata revision 2522585670 (Q40357)": 43, "Wikidata revision 2522588472 (Q44497)": 34, "Wikidata revision 2522590744 (Q49389)": 28, "Wikidata revision 2522591633 (Q55488)": 62,