diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_primary_source_inventory.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_primary_source_inventory.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e4f4cfffa --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_primary_source_inventory.json @@ -0,0 +1,28 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-source-inventory-v1", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "scope": "DOM050 migration services: 70 primary-source public statements", + "claim_boundary": "Inventory acceptance proves only that the named public PDF was fetched with the recorded SHA-256 and yielded extractable text. It does not approve a claim or establish the truth of statements in the source.", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "already_registered_primary_claims": 4414, + "remaining_claims": 70, + "expected_total_primary_claims": 4484, + "sources": [{ + "domain_code": "DOM050", + "domain_title": "Migration services", + "remaining_target": 70, + "source_subdir": "dom050", + "source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "pdf_pages": 384, + "content_start_page": 1, + "content_end_page": 384, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "min_quote_characters": 60, + "min_quote_words": 10, + "reject_pattern": "Figure \\\\d|Table \\\\d|Source:|Note:|Acknowledg|References|(?-i:^[a-z])" + }] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4105017f1 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 4", + "public_claim_text": "The World Migration Report 2024 project commenced in May 2022 and culminated in the launch of the report in May 2024 by the Director General.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The World Migration Report 2024 project commenced in May 2022 and culminated in the launch of the report in May 2024 by the Director General." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 8", + "public_claim_text": "With a combined landmass of a little over half a square kilometre, these islands are home to 2,000 islanders who live a simplified rural lifestyle where they fish, grow food, build their homes, and rely on the resources available to them on the miniature islands.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "With a combined landmass of a little over half a square kilometre, these islands are home to 2,000 islanders who live a simplified rural lifestyle where they fish, grow food, build their homes, and rely on the resources available to them on the miniature islands." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 14", + "public_claim_text": "This is particularly critical in the three areas in which IOM places high priority outlined in IOM’s new Strategic Plan 2024–2028: Saving lives and protecting people on the move; Driving solutions to displacement; and Facilitating pathways for regular migration.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "This is particularly critical in the three areas in which IOM places high priority outlined in IOM’s new Strategic Plan 2024–2028: Saving lives and protecting people on the move; Driving solutions to displacement; and Facilitating pathways for regular migration." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 14", + "public_claim_text": "The current United Nations estimate is that there are about 281 million international migrants in the world, which equates to 3.6 per cent of the global population.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The current United Nations estimate is that there are about 281 million international migrants in the world, which equates to 3.6 per cent of the global population." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 17", + "public_claim_text": "Introduction It has been more than two years since the release of the World Migration Report 2022, which provided an overview of the global transformations intensely affecting migration and displacement around the world.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Introduction It has been more than two years since the release of the World Migration Report 2022, which provided an overview of the global transformations intensely affecting migration and displacement around the world." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 18", + "public_claim_text": "The “asymmetry of power” in AI for migration globally is an ongoing problem, likely to be exacerbated with every new advance.14 However, it is not just inequality between States that will impact migrants.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The “asymmetry of power” in AI for migration globally is an ongoing problem, likely to be exacerbated with every new advance.14 However, it is not just inequality between States that will impact migrants." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 19", + "public_claim_text": "A great deal has happened in migration in the last two years since the release of the last World Migration Report in late 2021.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "A great deal has happened in migration in the last two years since the release of the last World Migration Report in late 2021." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 22", + "public_claim_text": "In the face of negatively skewed discussions, it can be easy to lose sight of the fact that international migration remains relatively uncommon, with a mere 3.6 per cent (or 281 million) of the world being international migrants (see discussion in Chapter 2 of this report).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In the face of negatively skewed discussions, it can be easy to lose sight of the fact that international migration remains relatively uncommon, with a mere 3.6 per cent (or 281 million) of the world being international migrants (see discussion in Chapter 2 of this report)." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 22", + "public_claim_text": "We also know that most international migration is safe, orderly and regular.23 Long-term research and analysis also tells us unequivocally that migration is a driver of human development and can generate significant benefits for migrants, their families and countries of origin.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "We also know that most international migration is safe, orderly and regular.23 Long-term research and analysis also tells us unequivocally that migration is a driver of human development and can generate significant benefits for migrants, their families and countries of origin." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 23", + "public_claim_text": "Analysis of 25 years of international migrant stock data clearly shows that the regular pathways for migrants from developing countries have narrowed considerably, while pathways for those from developed countries have expanded (see Chapter 4 of this report).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Analysis of 25 years of international migrant stock data clearly shows that the regular pathways for migrants from developing countries have narrowed considerably, while pathways for those from developed countries have expanded (see Chapter 4 of this report)." + } + ] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..307296b42 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 23", + "public_claim_text": "For increasing numbers of people around the world, therefore, irregular migration – including use of the asylum pathway – is the only option available to them.25 Humanitarian crises due to displacement remain the exception, but they are also on the rise.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "For increasing numbers of people around the world, therefore, irregular migration – including use of the asylum pathway – is the only option available to them.25 Humanitarian crises due to displacement remain the exception, but they are also on the rise." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 24", + "public_claim_text": "International remittances, for example, have grown from an estimated USD 128 billion to USD 831 billion (up by around 650%), underscoring the salience of international migration as a driver of development.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "International remittances, for example, have grown from an estimated USD 128 billion to USD 831 billion (up by around 650%), underscoring the salience of international migration as a driver of development." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 24", + "public_claim_text": "The World Migration Report 2000’s contribution to migration policy as well as migration studies was timely, and its success heralded the World Migration Report series.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The World Migration Report 2000’s contribution to migration policy as well as migration studies was timely, and its success heralded the World Migration Report series." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 25", + "public_claim_text": "Launched in May 2021, and updated regularly, the interactive data visualizations allow users to read both the “headline” summaries on long-term trends, while also interacting with data points to explore specific time periods, corridors or countries.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Launched in May 2021, and updated regularly, the interactive data visualizations allow users to read both the “headline” summaries on long-term trends, while also interacting with data points to explore specific time periods, corridors or countries." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 27", + "public_claim_text": "Analysis of international migrant stock and human development index data show that between 1995 and 2020, migration from low- and medium-development countries increased, but only slightly, reconfirming existing macroeconomic analyses showing that international migration from low-income countries has historically been limited.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Analysis of international migrant stock and human development index data show that between 1995 and 2020, migration from low- and medium-development countries increased, but only slightly, reconfirming existing macroeconomic analyses showing that international migration from low-income countries has historically been limited." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 36", + "public_claim_text": "To keep within the scope of this report, statistics utilized in this chapter were current as at 30 June 2023, unless otherwise stated.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "To keep within the scope of this report, statistics utilized in this chapter were current as at 30 June 2023, unless otherwise stated." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 38", + "public_claim_text": "The latest estimates were released in January 2021, based on mid-2020 data – reasonably early in the COVID-19 pandemic and at the height of international travel restrictions.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The latest estimates were released in January 2021, based on mid-2020 data – reasonably early in the COVID-19 pandemic and at the height of international travel restrictions." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 39", + "public_claim_text": "The corridor between the Russian Federation and Ukraine takes up spots three and five among the largest corridors in the world, which is due to a range of underpinning reasons over time (including, for example, displacement from Ukraine following Russian Federation invasions in 2014 and 2022).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The corridor between the Russian Federation and Ukraine takes up spots three and five among the largest corridors in the world, which is due to a range of underpinning reasons over time (including, for example, displacement from Ukraine following Russian Federation invasions in 2014 and 2022)." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 39", + "public_claim_text": "Revisions have been made based on large-scale displacement from Ukraine to neighbouring countries (as at end October 2023).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Revisions have been made based on large-scale displacement from Ukraine to neighbouring countries (as at end October 2023)." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 40", + "public_claim_text": "In 2000, the male to female split was 50.6 to 49.4 per cent (or 88 million male migrants and 86 million female migrants).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2000, the male to female split was 50.6 to 49.4 per cent (or 88 million male migrants and 86 million female migrants)." + } + ] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a5eae0ee1 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 40", + "public_claim_text": "The share of female migrants has been decreasing since 2000, while the share of male migrants has increased by 1.3 percentage points.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The share of female migrants has been decreasing since 2000, while the share of male migrants has increased by 1.3 percentage points." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 42", + "public_claim_text": "This pattern is broadly similar in top 20 origin countries, with only slight differences between females and males, except in a handful of origin countries such as India, the Syrian Arab Republic, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Myanmar and Egypt, where the share of male migrants as a percentage of total emigrants from these countries is significant and considerably higher than that of female international migrants.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "This pattern is broadly similar in top 20 origin countries, with only slight differences between females and males, except in a handful of origin countries such as India, the Syrian Arab Republic, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Myanmar and Egypt, where the share of male migrants as a percentage of total emigrants from these countries is significant and considerably higher than that of female international migrants." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 43", + "public_claim_text": "The Arab States region is one of the top destinations for international migrant workers, where they comprise 41.4 per cent of the entire working population, often dominating in key sectors.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The Arab States region is one of the top destinations for international migrant workers, where they comprise 41.4 per cent of the entire working population, often dominating in key sectors." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 44", + "public_claim_text": "In many of these countries, the outflows were due to temporary labour movements, such as for Pakistan (net flow of −16.5 million), India (−3.5 million), Bangladesh (−2.9 million), Nepal (−1.6 million) and Sri Lanka (−1.0 million).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In many of these countries, the outflows were due to temporary labour movements, such as for Pakistan (net flow of −16.5 million), India (−3.5 million), Bangladesh (−2.9 million), Nepal (−1.6 million) and Sri Lanka (−1.0 million)." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 44", + "public_claim_text": "Furthermore, migratory movements are often hard to separate from non-migratory travel, such as tourism or business.12 Tracking migratory movements also requires considerable resources, infrastructure and ICT/knowledge systems.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Furthermore, migratory movements are often hard to separate from non-migratory travel, such as tourism or business.12 Tracking migratory movements also requires considerable resources, infrastructure and ICT/knowledge systems." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 45", + "public_claim_text": "Entry and border management, for example, is particularly challenging in some regions because of archipelagic and isolated borders, and is further complicated by traditions of informal migration for work.13 Conflating “migration” and “migrant” In a general sense, migration is the process of moving from one place to another.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Entry and border management, for example, is particularly challenging in some regions because of archipelagic and isolated borders, and is further complicated by traditions of informal migration for work.13 Conflating “migration” and “migrant” In a general sense, migration is the process of moving from one place to another." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 46", + "public_claim_text": "They found that the publicly available Facebook Social Connectedness Index is a strong predictor of diaspora populations within 27 European Union Member States, which is itself predictive of displacement trajectories of those uprooted by conflict.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "They found that the publicly available Facebook Social Connectedness Index is a strong predictor of diaspora populations within 27 European Union Member States, which is itself predictive of displacement trajectories of those uprooted by conflict." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 47", + "public_claim_text": "IOM and other collaborators have helped guide the development of a global dataset estimating international migration flows, forthcoming in 2024, with analysis of country-to-country trends spanning the COVID-19 pandemic years.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "IOM and other collaborators have helped guide the development of a global dataset estimating international migration flows, forthcoming in 2024, with analysis of country-to-country trends spanning the COVID-19 pandemic years." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 49", + "public_claim_text": "COVID-19 impacts on mobility COVID-19 has been the most severe pandemic in a century, with its combination of high transmission, virus strains and the severity of the disease forcing policymakers into previously uncharted territory.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "COVID-19 impacts on mobility COVID-19 has been the most severe pandemic in a century, with its combination of high transmission, virus strains and the severity of the disease forcing policymakers into previously uncharted territory." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 49", + "public_claim_text": "COVID-19-related immobility became the “great disrupter” of migration.20 Governments around the world implemented various measures to limit the spread of the virus and a range of restrictions was introduced from early 2020, evolving over time.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "COVID-19-related immobility became the “great disrupter” of migration.20 Governments around the world implemented various measures to limit the spread of the virus and a range of restrictions was introduced from early 2020, evolving over time." + } + ] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..94870ebe6 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 50", + "public_claim_text": "It is also important to note that categories are COVID-19-related only and do not reflect other travel restrictions that may have already been in place, such as those related to visa restrictions, entry bans based on specific citizens, and departure/ exit restrictions.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "It is also important to note that categories are COVID-19-related only and do not reflect other travel restrictions that may have already been in place, such as those related to visa restrictions, entry bans based on specific citizens, and departure/ exit restrictions." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 50", + "public_claim_text": "We can see from long-term air passenger figures that COVID-19 travel restrictions had a major impact on both international and domestic air travel in 2020.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "We can see from long-term air passenger figures that COVID-19 travel restrictions had a major impact on both international and domestic air travel in 2020." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 51", + "public_claim_text": "See additional data, research and analysis in the thematic Chapter 9 in this report, which provides an update on COVID-19 impacts on migration and mobility globally.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "See additional data, research and analysis in the thematic Chapter 9 in this report, which provides an update on COVID-19 impacts on migration and mobility globally." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 51", + "public_claim_text": "In particular, the World Bank’s annual remittances data sets (ibid.), Migration and Development Brief 38 (Ratha et al., 2023), and its 13 June press release (World Bank, 2023b) are key sources of information.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In particular, the World Bank’s annual remittances data sets (ibid.), Migration and Development Brief 38 (Ratha et al., 2023), and its 13 June press release (World Bank, 2023b) are key sources of information." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 52", + "public_claim_text": "Mexico was the second-largest remittance recipient in 2022, a position it also held in 2021 after overtaking China, which historically had been the second-biggest recipient after India.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Mexico was the second-largest remittance recipient in 2022, a position it also held in 2021 after overtaking China, which historically had been the second-biggest recipient after India." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 52", + "public_claim_text": "It should be noted, however, that the majority of inflows are not household transfers, but relate to salaries of cross-border workers who work in Switzerland while residing in France or Germany.29 High-income countries are almost always the main source of international remittances.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "It should be noted, however, that the majority of inflows are not household transfers, but relate to salaries of cross-border workers who work in Switzerland while residing in France or Germany.29 High-income countries are almost always the main source of international remittances." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 55", + "public_claim_text": "Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 10.C commits countries to reducing the transaction costs of migrant remittances to less than 3 per cent.32 The 3 per cent transaction cost is intended as the global average of sending USD 200.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 10.C commits countries to reducing the transaction costs of migrant remittances to less than 3 per cent.32 The 3 per cent transaction cost is intended as the global average of sending USD 200." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 55", + "public_claim_text": "In 2022, average costs were lowest in South Asia (4.6%), followed by East Asia and Pacific, and Latin America and the Caribbean (both around 5.8%).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2022, average costs were lowest in South Asia (4.6%), followed by East Asia and Pacific, and Latin America and the Caribbean (both around 5.8%)." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 57", + "public_claim_text": "In 2001, there were around 1 million internationally mobile female students (45% of the total) and 1.2 million male students (54%).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2001, there were around 1 million internationally mobile female students (45% of the total) and 1.2 million male students (54%)." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 57", + "public_claim_text": "In 2021, more than 1 million internationally mobile students were from China, by far the highest number globally and more than double the number of students from India, which ranks second (around 508,000).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2021, more than 1 million internationally mobile students were from China, by far the highest number globally and more than double the number of students from India, which ranks second (around 508,000)." + } + ] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e7feef33a --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 58", + "public_claim_text": "In 2022, over 904,000 migration health assessments were conducted, of which 15 per cent were among refugees and 85 per cent were among immigrants.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2022, over 904,000 migration health assessments were conducted, of which 15 per cent were among refugees and 85 per cent were among immigrants." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 58", + "public_claim_text": "In 2022 alone, almost 2.9 million asylum applications were registered in 162 countries, the highest number of individual asylum applications on record.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2022 alone, almost 2.9 million asylum applications were registered in 162 countries, the highest number of individual asylum applications on record." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 59", + "public_claim_text": "Around 5.7 million Ukrainians had been forced to flee their country by the end of 2022, making Ukraine the second-largest origin country of refugees in the world after the Syrian Arab Republic.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Around 5.7 million Ukrainians had been forced to flee their country by the end of 2022, making Ukraine the second-largest origin country of refugees in the world after the Syrian Arab Republic." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 59", + "public_claim_text": "The protracted conflict in the Syrian Arab Republic meant that the country continued to be the largest origin of refugees in the world at the end of 2022 (6.5 million), although this was a decrease from 6.8 million in 2021.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The protracted conflict in the Syrian Arab Republic meant that the country continued to be the largest origin of refugees in the world at the end of 2022 (6.5 million), although this was a decrease from 6.8 million in 2021." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 60", + "public_claim_text": "Pakistan and the Islamic Republic of Iran were also among the top 10 refugee-hosting countries, as the two principal hosts of refugees from Afghanistan, the second-largest origin country.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Pakistan and the Islamic Republic of Iran were also among the top 10 refugee-hosting countries, as the two principal hosts of refugees from Afghanistan, the second-largest origin country." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 60", + "public_claim_text": "The vast majority (70%) of refugees and other people in need of international protection were hosted in countries neighbouring their countries of origin.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The vast majority (70%) of refugees and other people in need of international protection were hosted in countries neighbouring their countries of origin." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 61", + "public_claim_text": "In 2022, over 114,000 refugees were admitted for resettlement globally, double the number in 2021 (57,500) and a return to pre-COVID-19 pandemic levels.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2022, over 114,000 refugees were admitted for resettlement globally, double the number in 2021 (57,500) and a return to pre-COVID-19 pandemic levels." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 62", + "public_claim_text": "Migration and Migrants: A Global Overview Refugee resettlement has been increasing since 2021 and returned to pre-COVID-19 pandemic levels by the end of 2022.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Migration and Migrants: A Global Overview Refugee resettlement has been increasing since 2021 and returned to pre-COVID-19 pandemic levels by the end of 2022." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 63", + "public_claim_text": "In 2022, more than 120,700 persons travelled under IOM’s auspices through resettlement, humanitarian admissions and relocation programmes, with significant operations out of Türkiye, Lebanon, Jordan, Pakistan and Qatar.a Of the beneficiaries, 49 per cent were female and 51 per cent were male.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2022, more than 120,700 persons travelled under IOM’s auspices through resettlement, humanitarian admissions and relocation programmes, with significant operations out of Türkiye, Lebanon, Jordan, Pakistan and Qatar.a Of the beneficiaries, 49 per cent were female and 51 per cent were male." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 63", + "public_claim_text": "Of the above-mentioned figure, 710 persons in need of international protection were relocated from Greece, Italy and Cyprus to eight different European Economic Area countries, while 97 movements were conducted through complementary pathways from Eritrea, Afghanistan and the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Of the above-mentioned figure, 710 persons in need of international protection were relocated from Greece, Italy and Cyprus to eight different European Economic Area countries, while 97 movements were conducted through complementary pathways from Eritrea, Afghanistan and the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela." + } + ] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d644bbd5f --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 64", + "public_claim_text": "As with trends for refugees (discussed in the previous section), intractable and new conflicts have meant that the total number of persons internally displaced by conflict and violence has more than doubled since 2012.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "As with trends for refugees (discussed in the previous section), intractable and new conflicts have meant that the total number of persons internally displaced by conflict and violence has more than doubled since 2012." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 64", + "public_claim_text": "The Syrian Arab Republic had the highest number of people displaced due to conflict (nearly 6.9 million) by the end of 2022, followed by Ukraine (5.9 million).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The Syrian Arab Republic had the highest number of people displaced due to conflict (nearly 6.9 million) by the end of 2022, followed by Ukraine (5.9 million)." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 65", + "public_claim_text": "The population size used to calculate the percentage of conflict IDPs is based on the total resident population of the country per UN DESA population estimates (2022).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The population size used to calculate the percentage of conflict IDPs is based on the total resident population of the country per UN DESA population estimates (2022)." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 65", + "public_claim_text": "In 2022, the global total number of persons displaced by disasters was around 8.7 million persons across countries and territories.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2022, the global total number of persons displaced by disasters was around 8.7 million persons across countries and territories." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 66", + "public_claim_text": "Migration and Migrants: A Global Overview Displacements in 2022 By the end of 2022, there had been a total of 60.9 million internal displacements, 60 per cent more than in 2021 and the highest figure on record.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Migration and Migrants: A Global Overview Displacements in 2022 By the end of 2022, there had been a total of 60.9 million internal displacements, 60 per cent more than in 2021 and the highest figure on record." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 66", + "public_claim_text": "Of these displacements, 53 per cent (32.6 million) were triggered by disasters and 47 per cent (28.3 million) were caused by conflict and violence.45 In 2022, Ukraine (over 16 million) and the Democratic Republic of the Congo (4 million) topped the list with the highest numbers of displacements caused by conflict and violence, considerably influencing global numbers as a result.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Of these displacements, 53 per cent (32.6 million) were triggered by disasters and 47 per cent (28.3 million) were caused by conflict and violence.45 In 2022, Ukraine (over 16 million) and the Democratic Republic of the Congo (4 million) topped the list with the highest numbers of displacements caused by conflict and violence, considerably influencing global numbers as a result." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 67", + "public_claim_text": "DTM has been operating since 2004 and by June 2022, operating in more than 120 countries, the DTM had tracked/identified nearly 45 million IDPs, 40.4 million returnees and 6.2 million migrants.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "DTM has been operating since 2004 and by June 2022, operating in more than 120 countries, the DTM had tracked/identified nearly 45 million IDPs, 40.4 million returnees and 6.2 million migrants." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 71", + "public_claim_text": "Chapter 3 is focused primarily at the regional level in order to provide a more detailed picture of migration, which sets out a different but complementary perspective on migrants and movements in different parts of the world.1 Our starting point is geographic, rather than thematic, given that geography is one of the fundamentals underpinning migration today, just as it was in the past.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Chapter 3 is focused primarily at the regional level in order to provide a more detailed picture of migration, which sets out a different but complementary perspective on migrants and movements in different parts of the world.1 Our starting point is geographic, rather than thematic, given that geography is one of the fundamentals underpinning migration today, just as it was in the past." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 72", + "public_claim_text": "Thematic chapters in this volume may also be of interest, including those on migration and human security, gender and migration, COVID-19 impacts, and recent developments in the global governance of migration.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Thematic chapters in this volume may also be of interest, including those on migration and human security, gender and migration, COVID-19 impacts, and recent developments in the global governance of migration." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 72", + "public_claim_text": "Since 1990, the number of African migrants living outside of the region has more than doubled, with the growth in Europe most pronounced.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Since 1990, the number of African migrants living outside of the region has more than doubled, with the growth in Europe most pronounced." + } + ] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..aa9966b72 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 73", + "public_claim_text": "From 2015 to 2020, the number of migrants born outside the region remained virtually unchanged (around 2 million), most of whom were from Asia and Europe.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "From 2015 to 2020, the number of migrants born outside the region remained virtually unchanged (around 2 million), most of whom were from Asia and Europe." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 74", + "public_claim_text": "This dynamic is broadly similar in the top 10 origin countries in Africa, apart from Egypt – the top country of origin in the region – which has a far greater share of male emigrants compared to females.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "This dynamic is broadly similar in the top 10 origin countries in Africa, apart from Egypt – the top country of origin in the region – which has a far greater share of male emigrants compared to females." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 75", + "public_claim_text": "South Sudan continued to be the country of origin of the largest number of refugees in Africa (around 2.3 million) and ranked fourth globally, after the Syrian Arab Republic, Ukraine and Afghanistan.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "South Sudan continued to be the country of origin of the largest number of refugees in Africa (around 2.3 million) and ranked fourth globally, after the Syrian Arab Republic, Ukraine and Afghanistan." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 75", + "public_claim_text": "The Democratic Republic of the Congo and the Sudan were the origin of the second and third largest number of refugees on the continent (more than 900,000 and over 800,000, respectively).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The Democratic Republic of the Congo and the Sudan were the origin of the second and third largest number of refugees on the continent (more than 900,000 and over 800,000, respectively)." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 76", + "public_claim_text": "The Democratic Republic of the Congo (over 4 million) and Ethiopia (more than 2 million) had the largest internal displacements due to conflict and violence.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The Democratic Republic of the Congo (over 4 million) and Ethiopia (more than 2 million) had the largest internal displacements due to conflict and violence." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 76", + "public_claim_text": "The largest disaster displacements were recorded in Nigeria (around 2.4 million), followed by Somalia (1.2 million), Ethiopia (873,000) and South Sudan (596,000).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The largest disaster displacements were recorded in Nigeria (around 2.4 million), followed by Somalia (1.2 million), Ethiopia (873,000) and South Sudan (596,000)." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 77", + "public_claim_text": "Remittances became even more important following the onset of COVID-19, as revenues from tourism – which had long been vital for countries such as Egypt – dried up due to mobility restrictions.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Remittances became even more important following the onset of COVID-19, as revenues from tourism – which had long been vital for countries such as Egypt – dried up due to mobility restrictions." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 80", + "public_claim_text": "The armed conflict that broke out in the Sudan in April 2023 (see North Africa section) has resulted in significant internal and cross-border displacement, forcing many Sudanese to seek refuge in Eastern African countries such as South Sudan and Ethiopia.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The armed conflict that broke out in the Sudan in April 2023 (see North Africa section) has resulted in significant internal and cross-border displacement, forcing many Sudanese to seek refuge in Eastern African countries such as South Sudan and Ethiopia." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 81", + "public_claim_text": "The region faces ongoing crises including climate and environmental degradation, desertification, political and institutional instability, a lack of basic services, intercommunity conflicts between nomadic herders and farmers and the rapid rise of violent extremism.68 The Sahel has long been affected by insecurity, characterized by armed conflict, military clashes and recurrent violence instigated by Islamist groups.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The region faces ongoing crises including climate and environmental degradation, desertification, political and institutional instability, a lack of basic services, intercommunity conflicts between nomadic herders and farmers and the rapid rise of violent extremism.68 The Sahel has long been affected by insecurity, characterized by armed conflict, military clashes and recurrent violence instigated by Islamist groups." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 84", + "public_claim_text": "Migration and migrants: Regional dimensions and developments In Asia, the distribution of female and male migrants in the top 10 countries of destination and origin is much more variable compared to Africa.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Migration and migrants: Regional dimensions and developments In Asia, the distribution of female and male migrants in the top 10 countries of destination and origin is much more variable compared to Africa." + } + ] +} diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G01-2026-07-23.json index 29597f8ca..fdde9e385 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433263531&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 4. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q121831837$ddafce4a-2dc0-411c-a995-d96c5497c73a in revision 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes owned by (P127) with value FANUC (Q212116).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P127\",\"hash\":\"aeb590ac2a711a205dac89882c4068ea024fa1c0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":212116,\"id\":\"Q212116\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q121831837$ddafce4a-2dc0-411c-a995-d96c5497c73a\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433263531&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q121831837; claims.P127; statement Q121831837$ddafce4a-2dc0-411c-a995-d96c5497c73a", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T09:02:52Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "59bf156001d8c5074f63682a284ee5577e18c37f8f9206072fe7685eb3993f4b", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The World Migration Report 2024 project commenced in May 2022 and culminated in the launch of the report in May 2024 by the Director General.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The World Migration Report 2024 project commenced in May 2022 and culminated in the launch of the report in May 2024 by the Director General.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 4", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "9d2600b4d23b287c45f4885189a5a98e90d0527ef7a12b0ed35c6ed0973833a0", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433263531; entity Q121831837; source SHA-256 59bf156001d8c5074f63682a284ee5577e18c37f8f9206072fe7685eb3993f4b; statement SHA-256 2ca6fb4e7f1ee52286eb70be3a465af2546ef480d803927459baf753c2479283; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 9d2600b4d23b287c45f4885189a5a98e90d0527ef7a12b0ed35c6ed0973833a0; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3434, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "bca85380d113f45bce75383cc87c7e94b42c060ae3d1973889a6890fb40cf038", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q121831837$ddafce4a-2dc0-411c-a995-d96c5497c73a in revision 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes owned by (P127) with value FANUC (Q212116).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q121831837$ddafce4a-2dc0-411c-a995-d96c5497c73a", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) / P127", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433263531 at 2025-11-24T09:02:52Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The World Migration Report 2024 project commenced in May 2022 and culminated in the launch of the report in May 2024 by the Director General.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 4", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G01-2026-07-23.svg index 2e58307d9..9acdccbd5 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q121831837$ddafce4a-2dc0-411c-a995-d96c5497c73a in revision - 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes + The World Migration Report 2024 project commenced in May 2022 and culminated in the + launch of the report in May 2024 by the Director General. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T01-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) / P127 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433263531 at 2025-11-24T09:02:52Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q121831837$ddafce4a-2dc0-411c-a995-d96c5497c73a - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 4 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G02-2026-07-23.json index 1821e7979..9f5fad4e6 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433263531&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 8. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q121831837$26696cb9-173a-46e3-a7c8-fd199faec42a in revision 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes title (P1476) with value Processing time monitoring device.", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1476\",\"hash\":\"267daecd84081835d5c46dfc50b5de1319e45cbe\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"text\":\"Processing time monitoring device\",\"language\":\"en\"},\"type\":\"monolingualtext\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q121831837$26696cb9-173a-46e3-a7c8-fd199faec42a\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433263531&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q121831837; claims.P1476; statement Q121831837$26696cb9-173a-46e3-a7c8-fd199faec42a", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T09:02:52Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "59bf156001d8c5074f63682a284ee5577e18c37f8f9206072fe7685eb3993f4b", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "With a combined landmass of a little over half a square kilometre, these islands are home to 2,000 islanders who live a simplified rural lifestyle where they fish, grow food, build their homes, and rely on the resources available to them on the miniature islands.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "With a combined landmass of a little over half a square kilometre, these islands are home to 2,000 islanders who live a simplified rural lifestyle where they fish, grow food, build their homes, and rely on the resources available to them on the miniature islands.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 8", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "d8a97416a5f005d1a2e11a419b3dec04ee2196bade35cb549d0c48252a21a9d5", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433263531; entity Q121831837; source SHA-256 59bf156001d8c5074f63682a284ee5577e18c37f8f9206072fe7685eb3993f4b; statement SHA-256 44e18d9f789311db8d588b640e326ee5a891edd191fa3de9ee9d73391be0b4f8; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 d8a97416a5f005d1a2e11a419b3dec04ee2196bade35cb549d0c48252a21a9d5; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3435, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "bca85380d113f45bce75383cc87c7e94b42c060ae3d1973889a6890fb40cf038", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q121831837$26696cb9-173a-46e3-a7c8-fd199faec42a in revision 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes title (P1476) with value Processing time monitoring device.", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q121831837$26696cb9-173a-46e3-a7c8-fd199faec42a", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) / P1476", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433263531 at 2025-11-24T09:02:52Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "With a combined landmass of a little over half a square kilometre, these islands are home to 2,000 islanders who live a simplified rural lifestyle where they fish, grow food, build their homes, and rely on the resources available to them on the miniature islands.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 8", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G02-2026-07-23.svg index b8eb40faa..15ed1a6fb 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q121831837$26696cb9-173a-46e3-a7c8-fd199faec42a in revision - 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes + With a combined landmass of a little over half a square kilometre, these islands are + home to 2,000 islanders who live a simplified rural lifestyle where they fish, grow Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T01-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) / P1476 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433263531 at 2025-11-24T09:02:52Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q121831837$26696cb9-173a-46e3-a7c8-fd199faec42a - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 8 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G03-2026-07-23.json index 49e244775..f91b36f62 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433263531&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 14. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q121831837$25c63e34-4fb1-4fab-88ef-ff4dab4d4520 in revision 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes country (P17) with value United States (Q30).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P17\",\"hash\":\"be4c6eafa2984964f04be85667263f5642ba1a72\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":30,\"id\":\"Q30\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q121831837$25c63e34-4fb1-4fab-88ef-ff4dab4d4520\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433263531&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q121831837; claims.P17; statement Q121831837$25c63e34-4fb1-4fab-88ef-ff4dab4d4520", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T09:02:52Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "59bf156001d8c5074f63682a284ee5577e18c37f8f9206072fe7685eb3993f4b", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "This is particularly critical in the three areas in which IOM places high priority outlined in IOM’s new Strategic Plan 2024–2028: Saving lives and protecting people on the move; Driving solutions to displacement; and Facilitating pathways for regular migration.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "This is particularly critical in the three areas in which IOM places high priority outlined in IOM’s new Strategic Plan 2024–2028: Saving lives and protecting people on the move; Driving solutions to displacement; and Facilitating pathways for regular migration.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 14", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "f442eec2bd5ee11de7ea074205217a79734a476982a6146c0f86b309276af182", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433263531; entity Q121831837; source SHA-256 59bf156001d8c5074f63682a284ee5577e18c37f8f9206072fe7685eb3993f4b; statement SHA-256 794b4bac4c1b38dc9aa34c31a0302d166d6865283583fcb2de8e8ae4e9978268; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 f442eec2bd5ee11de7ea074205217a79734a476982a6146c0f86b309276af182; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3436, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "bca85380d113f45bce75383cc87c7e94b42c060ae3d1973889a6890fb40cf038", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q121831837$25c63e34-4fb1-4fab-88ef-ff4dab4d4520 in revision 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes country (P17) with value United States (Q30).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q121831837$25c63e34-4fb1-4fab-88ef-ff4dab4d4520", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) / P17", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433263531 at 2025-11-24T09:02:52Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "This is particularly critical in the three areas in which IOM places high priority outlined in IOM’s new Strategic Plan 2024–2028: Saving lives and protecting people on the move; Driving solutions to displacement; and Facilitating pathways for regular migration.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 14", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G03-2026-07-23.svg index e99cf23f9..04c9571d8 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q121831837$25c63e34-4fb1-4fab-88ef-ff4dab4d4520 in revision - 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes + This is particularly critical in the three areas in which IOM places high priority + outlined in IOM’s new Strategic Plan 2024–2028: Saving lives and protecting people Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T01-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) / P17 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433263531 at 2025-11-24T09:02:52Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q121831837$25c63e34-4fb1-4fab-88ef-ff4dab4d4520 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 14 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G04-2026-07-23.json index ae5d5f6be..14334aa40 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433263531&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 14. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q121831837$58f9dfc9-6864-48c4-8e18-b8162cdc1cb3 in revision 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Nobuhiro Hara (Yamanashi)\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2093\",\"hash\":\"ad4de1147b243515a6a3df6ce9de6fe3b8cdbe39\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"Nobuhiro Hara (Yamanashi)\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q121831837$58f9dfc9-6864-48c4-8e18-b8162cdc1cb3\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433263531&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q121831837; claims.P2093; statement Q121831837$58f9dfc9-6864-48c4-8e18-b8162cdc1cb3", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T09:02:52Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "59bf156001d8c5074f63682a284ee5577e18c37f8f9206072fe7685eb3993f4b", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The current United Nations estimate is that there are about 281 million international migrants in the world, which equates to 3.6 per cent of the global population.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The current United Nations estimate is that there are about 281 million international migrants in the world, which equates to 3.6 per cent of the global population.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 14", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "4c5c11a4db2aa6893a400b71225b97bbd004aa768acc7be4ffb5ac26936b91f0", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433263531; entity Q121831837; source SHA-256 59bf156001d8c5074f63682a284ee5577e18c37f8f9206072fe7685eb3993f4b; statement SHA-256 c241e2c6ffe8e276ef86060635cde3eb29375372b2a5f4e69d0106e81a45f1b3; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 4c5c11a4db2aa6893a400b71225b97bbd004aa768acc7be4ffb5ac26936b91f0; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3437, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "bca85380d113f45bce75383cc87c7e94b42c060ae3d1973889a6890fb40cf038", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q121831837$58f9dfc9-6864-48c4-8e18-b8162cdc1cb3 in revision 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Nobuhiro Hara (Yamanashi)\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q121831837$58f9dfc9-6864-48c4-8e18-b8162cdc1cb3", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) / P2093", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433263531 at 2025-11-24T09:02:52Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The current United Nations estimate is that there are about 281 million international migrants in the world, which equates to 3.6 per cent of the global population.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 14", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G04-2026-07-23.svg index b64e9488e..ba509e7c3 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q121831837$58f9dfc9-6864-48c4-8e18-b8162cdc1cb3 in revision - 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes + The current United Nations estimate is that there are about 281 million + international migrants in the world, which equates to 3.6 per cent of the global Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T01-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) / P2093 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433263531 at 2025-11-24T09:02:52Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q121831837$58f9dfc9-6864-48c4-8e18-b8162cdc1cb3 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 14 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G05-2026-07-23.json index 1233e6af9..56bd81ef9 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433263531&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 17. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q121831837$cf4c2194-a131-49be-b531-5bea4b5e7a6d in revision 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Yukio Kaniwa (Yamanashi)\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2093\",\"hash\":\"d6e1a6d7e63a7ed7a17de33232ea54eb26e2f21a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"Yukio Kaniwa (Yamanashi)\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q121831837$cf4c2194-a131-49be-b531-5bea4b5e7a6d\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433263531&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q121831837; claims.P2093; statement Q121831837$cf4c2194-a131-49be-b531-5bea4b5e7a6d", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T09:02:52Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "59bf156001d8c5074f63682a284ee5577e18c37f8f9206072fe7685eb3993f4b", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Introduction It has been more than two years since the release of the World Migration Report 2022, which provided an overview of the global transformations intensely affecting migration and displacement around the world.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Introduction It has been more than two years since the release of the World Migration Report 2022, which provided an overview of the global transformations intensely affecting migration and displacement around the world.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 17", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "be524b6beddfb962914ecd9135ece5d35e518d5e2bda9f7775d1a5e90dfbbfaa", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433263531; entity Q121831837; source SHA-256 59bf156001d8c5074f63682a284ee5577e18c37f8f9206072fe7685eb3993f4b; statement SHA-256 27c79ee4548b0d028e5c6401101af7b656129391915288fdb908deabbc3f9e32; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 be524b6beddfb962914ecd9135ece5d35e518d5e2bda9f7775d1a5e90dfbbfaa; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3438, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "bca85380d113f45bce75383cc87c7e94b42c060ae3d1973889a6890fb40cf038", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q121831837$cf4c2194-a131-49be-b531-5bea4b5e7a6d in revision 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Yukio Kaniwa (Yamanashi)\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q121831837$cf4c2194-a131-49be-b531-5bea4b5e7a6d", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) / P2093", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433263531 at 2025-11-24T09:02:52Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Introduction It has been more than two years since the release of the World Migration Report 2022, which provided an overview of the global transformations intensely affecting migration and displacement around the world.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 17", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G05-2026-07-23.svg index b1da426cc..927622d14 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q121831837$cf4c2194-a131-49be-b531-5bea4b5e7a6d in revision - 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes + Introduction It has been more than two years since the release of the World + Migration Report 2022, which provided an overview of the global transformations Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T01-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) / P2093 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433263531 at 2025-11-24T09:02:52Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q121831837$cf4c2194-a131-49be-b531-5bea4b5e7a6d - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 17 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G06-2026-07-23.json index 2c9e5177c..80b6bb45f 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433263531&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 18. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q121831837$130b16bd-29a3-41e7-8686-afb5e8929e80 in revision 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes instance of (P31) with value United States patent (Q43305660).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P31\",\"hash\":\"3ab9f42da2fd442cd7c0d6a5e4efa75204bdc1c2\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":43305660,\"id\":\"Q43305660\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q121831837$130b16bd-29a3-41e7-8686-afb5e8929e80\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433263531&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q121831837; claims.P31; statement Q121831837$130b16bd-29a3-41e7-8686-afb5e8929e80", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T09:02:52Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "59bf156001d8c5074f63682a284ee5577e18c37f8f9206072fe7685eb3993f4b", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The “asymmetry of power” in AI for migration globally is an ongoing problem, likely to be exacerbated with every new advance.14 However, it is not just inequality between States that will impact migrants.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The “asymmetry of power” in AI for migration globally is an ongoing problem, likely to be exacerbated with every new advance.14 However, it is not just inequality between States that will impact migrants.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 18", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "9681bcc52b712787e9b8d53fa0defa4e8adc561a531b9cd3f8e804e88f427acc", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433263531; entity Q121831837; source SHA-256 59bf156001d8c5074f63682a284ee5577e18c37f8f9206072fe7685eb3993f4b; statement SHA-256 05915fdf4baf09a9fc61267163c730590b620ab8f2b2e55031558cb45285048e; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 9681bcc52b712787e9b8d53fa0defa4e8adc561a531b9cd3f8e804e88f427acc; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3439, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "bca85380d113f45bce75383cc87c7e94b42c060ae3d1973889a6890fb40cf038", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q121831837$130b16bd-29a3-41e7-8686-afb5e8929e80 in revision 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes instance of (P31) with value United States patent (Q43305660).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q121831837$130b16bd-29a3-41e7-8686-afb5e8929e80", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) / P31", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433263531 at 2025-11-24T09:02:52Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The “asymmetry of power” in AI for migration globally is an ongoing problem, likely to be exacerbated with every new advance.14 However, it is not just inequality between States that will impact migrants.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 18", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G06-2026-07-23.svg index 1cce5cc54..187dc4929 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q121831837$130b16bd-29a3-41e7-8686-afb5e8929e80 in revision - 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes + The “asymmetry of power” in AI for migration globally is an ongoing problem, likely + to be exacerbated with every new advance.14 However, it is not just inequality Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T01-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) / P31 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433263531 at 2025-11-24T09:02:52Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q121831837$130b16bd-29a3-41e7-8686-afb5e8929e80 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 18 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G07-2026-07-23.json index 0c58a1b3d..87272f1fe 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433263531&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 19. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q121831837$fcc93e8f-b8a3-4bb2-9e52-5b0afae51a31 in revision 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes significant event (P793) with value filing (Q17146064).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P793\",\"hash\":\"395cd6d011a9505ee39cc56e33358fa6f553bdf3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17146064,\"id\":\"Q17146064\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"ddb4f1da7c6a17790fab2cfab3e8a4c10ebaf4b2\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2019-12-03T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q121831837$fcc93e8f-b8a3-4bb2-9e52-5b0afae51a31\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433263531&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q121831837; claims.P793; statement Q121831837$fcc93e8f-b8a3-4bb2-9e52-5b0afae51a31", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T09:02:52Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "59bf156001d8c5074f63682a284ee5577e18c37f8f9206072fe7685eb3993f4b", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "A great deal has happened in migration in the last two years since the release of the last World Migration Report in late 2021.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "A great deal has happened in migration in the last two years since the release of the last World Migration Report in late 2021.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 19", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "4e146e659bdc8b886dc7df5c6486e73b030cf680ee88c1d37211cdb1ee1e0f0d", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433263531; entity Q121831837; source SHA-256 59bf156001d8c5074f63682a284ee5577e18c37f8f9206072fe7685eb3993f4b; statement SHA-256 a931fad5f3dfaf20b747fde31940b0c97f893c7325e80843319c103bbfdbeba4; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 4e146e659bdc8b886dc7df5c6486e73b030cf680ee88c1d37211cdb1ee1e0f0d; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3440, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "bca85380d113f45bce75383cc87c7e94b42c060ae3d1973889a6890fb40cf038", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q121831837$fcc93e8f-b8a3-4bb2-9e52-5b0afae51a31 in revision 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes significant event (P793) with value filing (Q17146064).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q121831837$fcc93e8f-b8a3-4bb2-9e52-5b0afae51a31", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) / P793", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433263531 at 2025-11-24T09:02:52Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "A great deal has happened in migration in the last two years since the release of the last World Migration Report in late 2021.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 19", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G07-2026-07-23.svg index f3a389440..ccf644a0b 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q121831837$fcc93e8f-b8a3-4bb2-9e52-5b0afae51a31 in revision - 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes + A great deal has happened in migration in the last two years since the release of + the last World Migration Report in late 2021. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T01-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) / P793 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433263531 at 2025-11-24T09:02:52Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q121831837$fcc93e8f-b8a3-4bb2-9e52-5b0afae51a31 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 19 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G08-2026-07-23.json index 3719e086f..f5c3e7ed2 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433263531&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 22. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q121831837$a9c968fb-af24-4b93-9700-440fabb1c28a in revision 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes significant event (P793) with value consent (Q231043).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P793\",\"hash\":\"51996560f67812a20a350749b6f493eec7207c79\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":231043,\"id\":\"Q231043\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"90365f7e40d754359eb872ded8ec801cf85e2303\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2022-09-27T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q121831837$a9c968fb-af24-4b93-9700-440fabb1c28a\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433263531&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q121831837; claims.P793; statement Q121831837$a9c968fb-af24-4b93-9700-440fabb1c28a", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T09:02:52Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "59bf156001d8c5074f63682a284ee5577e18c37f8f9206072fe7685eb3993f4b", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In the face of negatively skewed discussions, it can be easy to lose sight of the fact that international migration remains relatively uncommon, with a mere 3.6 per cent (or 281 million) of the world being international migrants (see discussion in Chapter 2 of this report).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In the face of negatively skewed discussions, it can be easy to lose sight of the fact that international migration remains relatively uncommon, with a mere 3.6 per cent (or 281 million) of the world being international migrants (see discussion in Chapter 2 of this report).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 22", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "dc56200a1ce9da0a23f391a0e641efe286cd93a82d766ca218f9ddde50ff3523", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433263531; entity Q121831837; source SHA-256 59bf156001d8c5074f63682a284ee5577e18c37f8f9206072fe7685eb3993f4b; statement SHA-256 0f2c16d1662a6378712cf68a0a975cf48d8a1797d5954f81111ee2afdebb3624; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 dc56200a1ce9da0a23f391a0e641efe286cd93a82d766ca218f9ddde50ff3523; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3441, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "bca85380d113f45bce75383cc87c7e94b42c060ae3d1973889a6890fb40cf038", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q121831837$a9c968fb-af24-4b93-9700-440fabb1c28a in revision 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes significant event (P793) with value consent (Q231043).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q121831837$a9c968fb-af24-4b93-9700-440fabb1c28a", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) / P793", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433263531 at 2025-11-24T09:02:52Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In the face of negatively skewed discussions, it can be easy to lose sight of the fact that international migration remains relatively uncommon, with a mere 3.6 per cent (or 281 million) of the world being international migrants (see discussion in Chapter 2 of this report).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 22", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G08-2026-07-23.svg index 515b7b625..88928b254 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q121831837$a9c968fb-af24-4b93-9700-440fabb1c28a in revision - 2433263531 asserts that Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) publishes + In the face of negatively skewed discussions, it can be easy to lose sight of the + fact that international migration remains relatively uncommon, with a mere 3.6 per Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T01-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time monitoring device (Q121831837) / P793 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433263531 at 2025-11-24T09:02:52Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q121831837$a9c968fb-af24-4b93-9700-440fabb1c28a - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 22 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G09-2026-07-23.json index 5fdd60a18..e1c7e8de8 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 22. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$475b54ce-7a91-4214-b8f7-c7e8a2567aeb in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes owned by (P127) with value Salesforce (Q941127).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P127\",\"hash\":\"6b88c7e074147608bf680fed42e0e1aae6b1c4ff\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":941127,\"id\":\"Q941127\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q117348262$475b54ce-7a91-4214-b8f7-c7e8a2567aeb\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q117348262; claims.P127; statement Q117348262$475b54ce-7a91-4214-b8f7-c7e8a2567aeb", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "We also know that most international migration is safe, orderly and regular.23 Long-term research and analysis also tells us unequivocally that migration is a driver of human development and can generate significant benefits for migrants, their families and countries of origin.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "We also know that most international migration is safe, orderly and regular.23 Long-term research and analysis also tells us unequivocally that migration is a driver of human development and can generate significant benefits for migrants, their families and countries of origin.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 22", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "045485bce9fe7dcbab82c19946498503b912bd1b813f0bd4c61730bcbab53504", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433564944; entity Q117348262; source SHA-256 7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e; statement SHA-256 dbf900ee2aee58877ab80c36b9b78e877f9e586c84c8fda4969d8617064eb997; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 045485bce9fe7dcbab82c19946498503b912bd1b813f0bd4c61730bcbab53504; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3442, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "bca85380d113f45bce75383cc87c7e94b42c060ae3d1973889a6890fb40cf038", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$475b54ce-7a91-4214-b8f7-c7e8a2567aeb in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes owned by (P127) with value Salesforce (Q941127).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q117348262$475b54ce-7a91-4214-b8f7-c7e8a2567aeb", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P127", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "We also know that most international migration is safe, orderly and regular.23 Long-term research and analysis also tells us unequivocally that migration is a driver of human development and can generate significant benefits for migrants, their families and countries of origin.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 22", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G09-2026-07-23.svg index 71bb001c8..afd032432 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q117348262$475b54ce-7a91-4214-b8f7-c7e8a2567aeb in revision - 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes + We also know that most international migration is safe, orderly and regular.23 + Long-term research and analysis also tells us unequivocally that migration is a Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T01-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P127 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q117348262$475b54ce-7a91-4214-b8f7-c7e8a2567aeb - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 22 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G10-2026-07-23.json index 7acb55740..36dbea0cc 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 23. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$7cb82278-b9af-47a7-829d-465fd186b457 in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes title (P1476) with value Processing time series metrics data.", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1476\",\"hash\":\"aa344e88b97a3fe4f0b720ae279457a3e6ed3959\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"text\":\"Processing time series metrics data\",\"language\":\"en\"},\"type\":\"monolingualtext\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q117348262$7cb82278-b9af-47a7-829d-465fd186b457\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q117348262; claims.P1476; statement Q117348262$7cb82278-b9af-47a7-829d-465fd186b457", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Analysis of 25 years of international migrant stock data clearly shows that the regular pathways for migrants from developing countries have narrowed considerably, while pathways for those from developed countries have expanded (see Chapter 4 of this report).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Analysis of 25 years of international migrant stock data clearly shows that the regular pathways for migrants from developing countries have narrowed considerably, while pathways for those from developed countries have expanded (see Chapter 4 of this report).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 23", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "d5c6c20d948a04a3db2d3f9542f134bd9d2b1ea352fb07ab491704b2201c8ce6", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433564944; entity Q117348262; source SHA-256 7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e; statement SHA-256 4a635b2f1430f8a0ae4844ec67737d44f07318d154e77b94322cf03450d29fe7; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 d5c6c20d948a04a3db2d3f9542f134bd9d2b1ea352fb07ab491704b2201c8ce6; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3443, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "bca85380d113f45bce75383cc87c7e94b42c060ae3d1973889a6890fb40cf038", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$7cb82278-b9af-47a7-829d-465fd186b457 in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes title (P1476) with value Processing time series metrics data.", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q117348262$7cb82278-b9af-47a7-829d-465fd186b457", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P1476", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Analysis of 25 years of international migrant stock data clearly shows that the regular pathways for migrants from developing countries have narrowed considerably, while pathways for those from developed countries have expanded (see Chapter 4 of this report).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 23", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G10-2026-07-23.svg index 142bdd899..16ee45b90 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q117348262$7cb82278-b9af-47a7-829d-465fd186b457 in revision - 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes + Analysis of 25 years of international migrant stock data clearly shows that the + regular pathways for migrants from developing countries have narrowed considerably, Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T01-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P1476 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q117348262$7cb82278-b9af-47a7-829d-465fd186b457 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 23 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G01-2026-07-23.json index ebb0c3073..a8ef84c0a 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 23. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$7acb09dc-c518-48b2-b0d7-bcc37e91cd08 in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes country (P17) with value United States (Q30).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P17\",\"hash\":\"be4c6eafa2984964f04be85667263f5642ba1a72\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":30,\"id\":\"Q30\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q117348262$7acb09dc-c518-48b2-b0d7-bcc37e91cd08\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q117348262; claims.P17; statement Q117348262$7acb09dc-c518-48b2-b0d7-bcc37e91cd08", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "For increasing numbers of people around the world, therefore, irregular migration – including use of the asylum pathway – is the only option available to them.25 Humanitarian crises due to displacement remain the exception, but they are also on the rise.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "For increasing numbers of people around the world, therefore, irregular migration – including use of the asylum pathway – is the only option available to them.25 Humanitarian crises due to displacement remain the exception, but they are also on the rise.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 23", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "05fd0ce03670117bf4942416f694fe812fc4fdb08d24e07f94558f759e8d16d1", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433564944; entity Q117348262; source SHA-256 7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e; statement SHA-256 40ffe0dd1b7ce8d97ff39a6c0d333c4d9b6ef79d77989dd36594b96561699c84; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 05fd0ce03670117bf4942416f694fe812fc4fdb08d24e07f94558f759e8d16d1; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3444, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "8e105298b1b923a6bd041e40a6d1ec54207e65391eea2c012c6175f219073cfd", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$7acb09dc-c518-48b2-b0d7-bcc37e91cd08 in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes country (P17) with value United States (Q30).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q117348262$7acb09dc-c518-48b2-b0d7-bcc37e91cd08", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P17", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "For increasing numbers of people around the world, therefore, irregular migration – including use of the asylum pathway – is the only option available to them.25 Humanitarian crises due to displacement remain the exception, but they are also on the rise.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 23", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G01-2026-07-23.svg index 66f4a09c4..3de630a36 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q117348262$7acb09dc-c518-48b2-b0d7-bcc37e91cd08 in revision - 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes + For increasing numbers of people around the world, therefore, irregular migration – + including use of the asylum pathway – is the only option available to them.25 Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T02-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P17 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q117348262$7acb09dc-c518-48b2-b0d7-bcc37e91cd08 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 23 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G02-2026-07-23.json index 61e276e61..c96feefb4 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 24. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$5ffb09b1-a730-4b50-a787-51ba387acf2b in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Christian Bayer (Cambridge, MA)\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2093\",\"hash\":\"0f5c0977a7eb6ef307670bf86e1128a122700a56\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"Christian Bayer (Cambridge, MA)\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q117348262$5ffb09b1-a730-4b50-a787-51ba387acf2b\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q117348262; claims.P2093; statement Q117348262$5ffb09b1-a730-4b50-a787-51ba387acf2b", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "International remittances, for example, have grown from an estimated USD 128 billion to USD 831 billion (up by around 650%), underscoring the salience of international migration as a driver of development.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "International remittances, for example, have grown from an estimated USD 128 billion to USD 831 billion (up by around 650%), underscoring the salience of international migration as a driver of development.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 24", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "4681030ac3cb3a3b74860a73dec0da3943cb382489e4c4c4493b3f823455b1f4", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433564944; entity Q117348262; source SHA-256 7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e; statement SHA-256 14fec39f9c04655f2ca598de6e4c0681395a8fda42559ab63f1e5e5403a98fa2; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 4681030ac3cb3a3b74860a73dec0da3943cb382489e4c4c4493b3f823455b1f4; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3445, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "8e105298b1b923a6bd041e40a6d1ec54207e65391eea2c012c6175f219073cfd", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$5ffb09b1-a730-4b50-a787-51ba387acf2b in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Christian Bayer (Cambridge, MA)\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q117348262$5ffb09b1-a730-4b50-a787-51ba387acf2b", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P2093", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "International remittances, for example, have grown from an estimated USD 128 billion to USD 831 billion (up by around 650%), underscoring the salience of international migration as a driver of development.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 24", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G02-2026-07-23.svg index 7722b71f9..bc3cf1eef 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q117348262$5ffb09b1-a730-4b50-a787-51ba387acf2b in revision - 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes + International remittances, for example, have grown from an estimated USD 128 billion + to USD 831 billion (up by around 650%), underscoring the salience of international Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T02-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P2093 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q117348262$5ffb09b1-a730-4b50-a787-51ba387acf2b - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 24 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G03-2026-07-23.json index be67076bc..e561e3941 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 24. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$2ab69b43-de71-47d5-aa62-937ad146b0bd in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Sergei Babovich (Arlington, MA)\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2093\",\"hash\":\"6419d9e1f8b801eecddca8daf1d87b4c67d1f0ec\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"Sergei Babovich (Arlington, MA)\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q117348262$2ab69b43-de71-47d5-aa62-937ad146b0bd\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q117348262; claims.P2093; statement Q117348262$2ab69b43-de71-47d5-aa62-937ad146b0bd", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The World Migration Report 2000’s contribution to migration policy as well as migration studies was timely, and its success heralded the World Migration Report series.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The World Migration Report 2000’s contribution to migration policy as well as migration studies was timely, and its success heralded the World Migration Report series.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 24", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "f935ac73a64dbbb4273e006693f876962d0263355b05627cc6c7b9b3a6dffd0e", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433564944; entity Q117348262; source SHA-256 7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e; statement SHA-256 f7793702b66a311421cf7d024bbb517d851f03414d7b00685c30b66b25943ab9; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 f935ac73a64dbbb4273e006693f876962d0263355b05627cc6c7b9b3a6dffd0e; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3446, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "8e105298b1b923a6bd041e40a6d1ec54207e65391eea2c012c6175f219073cfd", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$2ab69b43-de71-47d5-aa62-937ad146b0bd in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Sergei Babovich (Arlington, MA)\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q117348262$2ab69b43-de71-47d5-aa62-937ad146b0bd", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P2093", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The World Migration Report 2000’s contribution to migration policy as well as migration studies was timely, and its success heralded the World Migration Report series.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 24", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G03-2026-07-23.svg index 3be33ba66..e91f4e91e 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q117348262$2ab69b43-de71-47d5-aa62-937ad146b0bd in revision - 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes + The World Migration Report 2000’s contribution to migration policy as well as + migration studies was timely, and its success heralded the World Migration Report Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T02-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P2093 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q117348262$2ab69b43-de71-47d5-aa62-937ad146b0bd - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 24 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G04-2026-07-23.json index 725e71f5b..b7da49195 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 25. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$80b2b745-ab1b-4d07-8149-8dee0a2c0c9c in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Dmitry Babenko (Shrewsbury, MA)\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2093\",\"hash\":\"f730ab3cebb76857f99b11c8e0360bf4763fe331\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"Dmitry Babenko (Shrewsbury, MA)\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q117348262$80b2b745-ab1b-4d07-8149-8dee0a2c0c9c\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q117348262; claims.P2093; statement Q117348262$80b2b745-ab1b-4d07-8149-8dee0a2c0c9c", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Launched in May 2021, and updated regularly, the interactive data visualizations allow users to read both the “headline” summaries on long-term trends, while also interacting with data points to explore specific time periods, corridors or countries.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Launched in May 2021, and updated regularly, the interactive data visualizations allow users to read both the “headline” summaries on long-term trends, while also interacting with data points to explore specific time periods, corridors or countries.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 25", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "ba38f4ed4bc02badf69813076cb578299ea88974278fefcad1457098d828acdd", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433564944; entity Q117348262; source SHA-256 7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e; statement SHA-256 9425057c2b4557e4010ea92a7cd76de8c853420279f1c14c8e6fdd96bf219cc1; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 ba38f4ed4bc02badf69813076cb578299ea88974278fefcad1457098d828acdd; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3447, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "8e105298b1b923a6bd041e40a6d1ec54207e65391eea2c012c6175f219073cfd", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$80b2b745-ab1b-4d07-8149-8dee0a2c0c9c in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Dmitry Babenko (Shrewsbury, MA)\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q117348262$80b2b745-ab1b-4d07-8149-8dee0a2c0c9c", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P2093", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Launched in May 2021, and updated regularly, the interactive data visualizations allow users to read both the “headline” summaries on long-term trends, while also interacting with data points to explore specific time periods, corridors or countries.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 25", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G04-2026-07-23.svg index 6c302cbb9..492d8fc0e 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q117348262$80b2b745-ab1b-4d07-8149-8dee0a2c0c9c in revision - 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes + Launched in May 2021, and updated regularly, the interactive data visualizations + allow users to read both the “headline” summaries on long-term trends, while also Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T02-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P2093 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q117348262$80b2b745-ab1b-4d07-8149-8dee0a2c0c9c - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 25 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G05-2026-07-23.json index cefea24ad..dd2ddcdc9 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 27. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$b6e9143c-9fad-441d-ae52-9cdad36ff59b in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Ben Susman (Waltham, MA)\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2093\",\"hash\":\"ea3ed9e8ee450545dd2b48c8cb2187a4400bcf65\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"Ben Susman (Waltham, MA)\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q117348262$b6e9143c-9fad-441d-ae52-9cdad36ff59b\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q117348262; claims.P2093; statement Q117348262$b6e9143c-9fad-441d-ae52-9cdad36ff59b", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Analysis of international migrant stock and human development index data show that between 1995 and 2020, migration from low- and medium-development countries increased, but only slightly, reconfirming existing macroeconomic analyses showing that international migration from low-income countries has historically been limited.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Analysis of international migrant stock and human development index data show that between 1995 and 2020, migration from low- and medium-development countries increased, but only slightly, reconfirming existing macroeconomic analyses showing that international migration from low-income countries has historically been limited.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 27", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "34f71b8a670e5440ea509a6a3e8fafdfb5c18ea9ceae37214014887127ba1678", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433564944; entity Q117348262; source SHA-256 7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e; statement SHA-256 94823c3bf2d8506c181273eb52024745df35158533c81f6d9a608d1ed21b6da9; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 34f71b8a670e5440ea509a6a3e8fafdfb5c18ea9ceae37214014887127ba1678; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3448, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "8e105298b1b923a6bd041e40a6d1ec54207e65391eea2c012c6175f219073cfd", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$b6e9143c-9fad-441d-ae52-9cdad36ff59b in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Ben Susman (Waltham, MA)\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q117348262$b6e9143c-9fad-441d-ae52-9cdad36ff59b", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P2093", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Analysis of international migrant stock and human development index data show that between 1995 and 2020, migration from low- and medium-development countries increased, but only slightly, reconfirming existing macroeconomic analyses showing that international migration from low-income countries has historically been limited.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 27", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G05-2026-07-23.svg index 213c34b92..2764434b6 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q117348262$b6e9143c-9fad-441d-ae52-9cdad36ff59b in revision - 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes + Analysis of international migrant stock and human development index data show that + between 1995 and 2020, migration from low- and medium-development countries Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T02-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P2093 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q117348262$b6e9143c-9fad-441d-ae52-9cdad36ff59b - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 27 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G06-2026-07-23.json index 0c8a70157..0705a32be 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 36. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$fca01f52-a961-40f1-b060-70f95a072aba in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Shanmugavel Ponnusamy (Lexington, MA)\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2093\",\"hash\":\"9fcc3f16f6de66ce4b403b0c0bbd358e5b21504e\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"Shanmugavel Ponnusamy (Lexington, MA)\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q117348262$fca01f52-a961-40f1-b060-70f95a072aba\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q117348262; claims.P2093; statement Q117348262$fca01f52-a961-40f1-b060-70f95a072aba", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "To keep within the scope of this report, statistics utilized in this chapter were current as at 30 June 2023, unless otherwise stated.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "To keep within the scope of this report, statistics utilized in this chapter were current as at 30 June 2023, unless otherwise stated.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 36", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "65e445d326c0f82591cdf6eebb6abf05e02127149e6a679ee98e1971293b64bf", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433564944; entity Q117348262; source SHA-256 7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e; statement SHA-256 99f294a96de78378af56446f5216d9533ef1f188f9797fd88fd635f51a209cae; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 65e445d326c0f82591cdf6eebb6abf05e02127149e6a679ee98e1971293b64bf; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3449, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "8e105298b1b923a6bd041e40a6d1ec54207e65391eea2c012c6175f219073cfd", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$fca01f52-a961-40f1-b060-70f95a072aba in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Shanmugavel Ponnusamy (Lexington, MA)\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q117348262$fca01f52-a961-40f1-b060-70f95a072aba", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P2093", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "To keep within the scope of this report, statistics utilized in this chapter were current as at 30 June 2023, unless otherwise stated.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 36", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G06-2026-07-23.svg index 7d712f39c..52bc57ac3 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q117348262$fca01f52-a961-40f1-b060-70f95a072aba in revision - 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes + To keep within the scope of this report, statistics utilized in this chapter were + current as at 30 June 2023, unless otherwise stated. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T02-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P2093 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q117348262$fca01f52-a961-40f1-b060-70f95a072aba - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 36 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G07-2026-07-23.json index d457b27d0..e17bc9ce8 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 38. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$2badcec5-c9e8-4025-9ffd-ec48a0c2c16c in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes instance of (P31) with value United States patent (Q43305660).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P31\",\"hash\":\"3ab9f42da2fd442cd7c0d6a5e4efa75204bdc1c2\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":43305660,\"id\":\"Q43305660\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q117348262$2badcec5-c9e8-4025-9ffd-ec48a0c2c16c\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q117348262; claims.P31; statement Q117348262$2badcec5-c9e8-4025-9ffd-ec48a0c2c16c", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The latest estimates were released in January 2021, based on mid-2020 data – reasonably early in the COVID-19 pandemic and at the height of international travel restrictions.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The latest estimates were released in January 2021, based on mid-2020 data – reasonably early in the COVID-19 pandemic and at the height of international travel restrictions.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 38", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "02293bcd773f6673c7b77184df7ccc733008ce032d19c555b6d1cf52f2205206", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433564944; entity Q117348262; source SHA-256 7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e; statement SHA-256 9a481411e77ea1833cf80e2550f41bfe662b1250e2f60ce931b66798b368f9ce; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 02293bcd773f6673c7b77184df7ccc733008ce032d19c555b6d1cf52f2205206; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3450, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "8e105298b1b923a6bd041e40a6d1ec54207e65391eea2c012c6175f219073cfd", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$2badcec5-c9e8-4025-9ffd-ec48a0c2c16c in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes instance of (P31) with value United States patent (Q43305660).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q117348262$2badcec5-c9e8-4025-9ffd-ec48a0c2c16c", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P31", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The latest estimates were released in January 2021, based on mid-2020 data – reasonably early in the COVID-19 pandemic and at the height of international travel restrictions.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 38", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G07-2026-07-23.svg index d243b190f..b628b2502 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q117348262$2badcec5-c9e8-4025-9ffd-ec48a0c2c16c in revision - 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes + The latest estimates were released in January 2021, based on mid-2020 data – + reasonably early in the COVID-19 pandemic and at the height of international travel Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T02-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P31 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q117348262$2badcec5-c9e8-4025-9ffd-ec48a0c2c16c - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 38 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G08-2026-07-23.json index fe308dfa9..47fe3966c 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 39. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$5b06983a-5c07-4804-8d2a-37e89d9d2fbd in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes significant event (P793) with value filing (Q17146064).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P793\",\"hash\":\"395cd6d011a9505ee39cc56e33358fa6f553bdf3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17146064,\"id\":\"Q17146064\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"f33c4f194f9275e1221b8a13e60a2adf47194ca5\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2019-04-26T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q117348262$5b06983a-5c07-4804-8d2a-37e89d9d2fbd\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q117348262; claims.P793; statement Q117348262$5b06983a-5c07-4804-8d2a-37e89d9d2fbd", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The corridor between the Russian Federation and Ukraine takes up spots three and five among the largest corridors in the world, which is due to a range of underpinning reasons over time (including, for example, displacement from Ukraine following Russian Federation invasions in 2014 and 2022).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The corridor between the Russian Federation and Ukraine takes up spots three and five among the largest corridors in the world, which is due to a range of underpinning reasons over time (including, for example, displacement from Ukraine following Russian Federation invasions in 2014 and 2022).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 39", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "f20041e4e98ef042410be7333a0e19c15c3b9705964b46a3772262d02267d0c3", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433564944; entity Q117348262; source SHA-256 7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e; statement SHA-256 06b2f615cbeea9702d0bd32e6ba30906ad746c7d91a62d010765357ffdc5846c; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 f20041e4e98ef042410be7333a0e19c15c3b9705964b46a3772262d02267d0c3; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3451, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "8e105298b1b923a6bd041e40a6d1ec54207e65391eea2c012c6175f219073cfd", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$5b06983a-5c07-4804-8d2a-37e89d9d2fbd in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes significant event (P793) with value filing (Q17146064).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q117348262$5b06983a-5c07-4804-8d2a-37e89d9d2fbd", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P793", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The corridor between the Russian Federation and Ukraine takes up spots three and five among the largest corridors in the world, which is due to a range of underpinning reasons over time (including, for example, displacement from Ukraine following Russian Federation invasions in 2014 and 2022).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 39", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G08-2026-07-23.svg index f12e9b8ea..663386064 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q117348262$5b06983a-5c07-4804-8d2a-37e89d9d2fbd in revision - 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes + The corridor between the Russian Federation and Ukraine takes up spots three and + five among the largest corridors in the world, which is due to a range of Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T02-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P793 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q117348262$5b06983a-5c07-4804-8d2a-37e89d9d2fbd - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 39 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G09-2026-07-23.json index 8a4853222..a8d1f0927 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 39. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$06167e04-5a31-4fb8-8258-5b659674aa0b in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes significant event (P793) with value consent (Q231043).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P793\",\"hash\":\"51996560f67812a20a350749b6f493eec7207c79\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":231043,\"id\":\"Q231043\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"d85ea85769f978b2954f8ecc772527ca2de4824b\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2022-12-06T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q117348262$06167e04-5a31-4fb8-8258-5b659674aa0b\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2433564944&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q117348262; claims.P793; statement Q117348262$06167e04-5a31-4fb8-8258-5b659674aa0b", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Revisions have been made based on large-scale displacement from Ukraine to neighbouring countries (as at end October 2023).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Revisions have been made based on large-scale displacement from Ukraine to neighbouring countries (as at end October 2023).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 39", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "c0251d88860867f8938df6e43fc0f8d3909017be17645e697c6d6b6e0abd4ec9", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2433564944; entity Q117348262; source SHA-256 7517010e9cde30b19101964b0b3d4133b1abad62deaefbc1e8c7cb6d9e0e8e3e; statement SHA-256 e9fded91981b2817278c621de0a79b1f7386957fc770436ac7191703ec623aad; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 c0251d88860867f8938df6e43fc0f8d3909017be17645e697c6d6b6e0abd4ec9; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3452, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "8e105298b1b923a6bd041e40a6d1ec54207e65391eea2c012c6175f219073cfd", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q117348262$06167e04-5a31-4fb8-8258-5b659674aa0b in revision 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes significant event (P793) with value consent (Q231043).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q117348262$06167e04-5a31-4fb8-8258-5b659674aa0b", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P793", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Revisions have been made based on large-scale displacement from Ukraine to neighbouring countries (as at end October 2023).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 39", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G09-2026-07-23.svg index 3908ddd4a..9039aefff 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q117348262$06167e04-5a31-4fb8-8258-5b659674aa0b in revision - 2433564944 asserts that Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) publishes + Revisions have been made based on large-scale displacement from Ukraine to + neighbouring countries (as at end October 2023). Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T02-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time series metrics data (Q117348262) / P793 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2433564944 at 2025-11-24T23:02:53Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q117348262$06167e04-5a31-4fb8-8258-5b659674aa0b - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 39 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G10-2026-07-23.json index e36b35300..3ee95e1b0 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=1549544926&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 40. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q34398219$524E763B-7E36-458A-BE7D-A5139D73D174 in revision 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) publishes published in (P1433) with value Language and Speech (Q80605).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1433\",\"hash\":\"a14f2fbf783d1560f9edcde15185c16d55cc2b43\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":80605,\"id\":\"Q80605\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q34398219$524E763B-7E36-458A-BE7D-A5139D73D174\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"ca8e05ff451fa45ad3dc44b021e5f2a8a6c8b41b\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"cc0d904327e74c637fb8aa8274ffbab68d6456bd\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8816082\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"7ff45ac6fd9104a058b89c3851c8b1fec5c870f6\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-08-01T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=1549544926&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q34398219; claims.P1433; statement Q34398219$524E763B-7E36-458A-BE7D-A5139D73D174", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2021-12-24T20:38:33Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "5b17c0fce60246bd08c189d112bbfd653610b15e87360571571f7574e77bdd7d", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In 2000, the male to female split was 50.6 to 49.4 per cent (or 88 million male migrants and 86 million female migrants).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2000, the male to female split was 50.6 to 49.4 per cent (or 88 million male migrants and 86 million female migrants).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 40", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "2c5d4feaa47ba29758226090ee706963a50fb5988b3b6bb5c2267c1a0e23386c", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 1549544926; entity Q34398219; source SHA-256 5b17c0fce60246bd08c189d112bbfd653610b15e87360571571f7574e77bdd7d; statement SHA-256 1d4529ac90cac41bdce55a91068a19c71f510ba2b2a7df1530d1ea3ac328db0c; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 2c5d4feaa47ba29758226090ee706963a50fb5988b3b6bb5c2267c1a0e23386c; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3453, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "8e105298b1b923a6bd041e40a6d1ec54207e65391eea2c012c6175f219073cfd", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q34398219$524E763B-7E36-458A-BE7D-A5139D73D174 in revision 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) publishes published in (P1433) with value Language and Speech (Q80605).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q34398219$524E763B-7E36-458A-BE7D-A5139D73D174", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) / P1433", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 1549544926 at 2021-12-24T20:38:33Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In 2000, the male to female split was 50.6 to 49.4 per cent (or 88 million male migrants and 86 million female migrants).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 40", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G10-2026-07-23.svg index 840582276..6181708a3 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q34398219$524E763B-7E36-458A-BE7D-A5139D73D174 in revision - 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the + In 2000, the male to female split was 50.6 to 49.4 per cent (or 88 million male + migrants and 86 million female migrants). Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T02-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 1549544926 at 2021-12-24T20:38:33Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q34398219$524E763B-7E36-458A-BE7D-A5139D73D174 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 40 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json index 330db3e72..6235bbaa6 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=1549544926&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 40. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q34398219$7C086752-4A40-4F44-B08B-EB31B3FD918C in revision 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) publishes title (P1476) with value Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech.", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1476\",\"hash\":\"537414ed59747b398ed062d68502561b3fb94d3d\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"text\":\"Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech\",\"language\":\"en\"},\"type\":\"monolingualtext\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q34398219$7C086752-4A40-4F44-B08B-EB31B3FD918C\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"ca8e05ff451fa45ad3dc44b021e5f2a8a6c8b41b\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"cc0d904327e74c637fb8aa8274ffbab68d6456bd\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8816082\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"7ff45ac6fd9104a058b89c3851c8b1fec5c870f6\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-08-01T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=1549544926&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q34398219; claims.P1476; statement Q34398219$7C086752-4A40-4F44-B08B-EB31B3FD918C", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2021-12-24T20:38:33Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "5b17c0fce60246bd08c189d112bbfd653610b15e87360571571f7574e77bdd7d", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The share of female migrants has been decreasing since 2000, while the share of male migrants has increased by 1.3 percentage points.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The share of female migrants has been decreasing since 2000, while the share of male migrants has increased by 1.3 percentage points.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 40", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "7e1e97a774b1e1517a266b50d0c91dc138caf6128b2050fbbf8c34a2c1dd1287", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 1549544926; entity Q34398219; source SHA-256 5b17c0fce60246bd08c189d112bbfd653610b15e87360571571f7574e77bdd7d; statement SHA-256 020943bd9f6fffae444a4c9d0db52ea2f4dab225aa0c16df384c55062e6c023c; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 7e1e97a774b1e1517a266b50d0c91dc138caf6128b2050fbbf8c34a2c1dd1287; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3454, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "d088d197988e71e764f4675ea764abf91b336cb755c15918bb9082811ef56cd8", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q34398219$7C086752-4A40-4F44-B08B-EB31B3FD918C in revision 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) publishes title (P1476) with value Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech.", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q34398219$7C086752-4A40-4F44-B08B-EB31B3FD918C", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) / P1476", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 1549544926 at 2021-12-24T20:38:33Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The share of female migrants has been decreasing since 2000, while the share of male migrants has increased by 1.3 percentage points.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 40", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G01-2026-07-23.svg index ef9269c69..3a6e43327 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q34398219$7C086752-4A40-4F44-B08B-EB31B3FD918C in revision - 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the + The share of female migrants has been decreasing since 2000, while the share of male + migrants has increased by 1.3 percentage points. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T03-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 1549544926 at 2021-12-24T20:38:33Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q34398219$7C086752-4A40-4F44-B08B-EB31B3FD918C - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 40 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json index 430e619c3..d3133942d 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=1549544926&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 42. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q34398219$B08F3234-E6B7-4EA7-96BC-C6F80975D428 in revision 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"M J Munro\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2093\",\"hash\":\"c2533b84a5dc11884bb1bd2a9b54b251cafd0def\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"M J Munro\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P1545\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1545\",\"hash\":\"2a1ced1dca90648ea7e306acbadd74fc81a10722\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"1\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P1545\"],\"id\":\"Q34398219$B08F3234-E6B7-4EA7-96BC-C6F80975D428\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"ca8e05ff451fa45ad3dc44b021e5f2a8a6c8b41b\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"cc0d904327e74c637fb8aa8274ffbab68d6456bd\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8816082\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"7ff45ac6fd9104a058b89c3851c8b1fec5c870f6\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-08-01T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=1549544926&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q34398219; claims.P2093; statement Q34398219$B08F3234-E6B7-4EA7-96BC-C6F80975D428", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2021-12-24T20:38:33Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "5b17c0fce60246bd08c189d112bbfd653610b15e87360571571f7574e77bdd7d", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "This pattern is broadly similar in top 20 origin countries, with only slight differences between females and males, except in a handful of origin countries such as India, the Syrian Arab Republic, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Myanmar and Egypt, where the share of male migrants as a percentage of total emigrants from these countries is significant and considerably higher than that of female international migrants.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "This pattern is broadly similar in top 20 origin countries, with only slight differences between females and males, except in a handful of origin countries such as India, the Syrian Arab Republic, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Myanmar and Egypt, where the share of male migrants as a percentage of total emigrants from these countries is significant and considerably higher than that of female international migrants.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 42", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "03af648e0cec7ff07f1aef3b1320d419ff5b3d10e8299a2a7e6961642a8ce8e5", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 1549544926; entity Q34398219; source SHA-256 5b17c0fce60246bd08c189d112bbfd653610b15e87360571571f7574e77bdd7d; statement SHA-256 8b9f739278435cd371a4d85a6fe53dfb4d36f6ee742979477046291de99d580e; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 03af648e0cec7ff07f1aef3b1320d419ff5b3d10e8299a2a7e6961642a8ce8e5; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3455, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "d088d197988e71e764f4675ea764abf91b336cb755c15918bb9082811ef56cd8", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q34398219$B08F3234-E6B7-4EA7-96BC-C6F80975D428 in revision 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"M J Munro\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q34398219$B08F3234-E6B7-4EA7-96BC-C6F80975D428", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) / P2093", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 1549544926 at 2021-12-24T20:38:33Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "This pattern is broadly similar in top 20 origin countries, with only slight differences between females and males, except in a handful of origin countries such as India, the Syrian Arab Republic, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Myanmar and Egypt, where the share of male migrants as a percentage of total emigrants from these countries is significant and considerably higher than that of female international migrants.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 42", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G02-2026-07-23.svg index 7ddc403b3..8df93d1b5 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q34398219$B08F3234-E6B7-4EA7-96BC-C6F80975D428 in revision - 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the + This pattern is broadly similar in top 20 origin countries, with only slight + differences between females and males, except in a handful of origin countries such Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T03-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 1549544926 at 2021-12-24T20:38:33Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q34398219$B08F3234-E6B7-4EA7-96BC-C6F80975D428 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 42 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json index 268818bc7..5bcfa4c92 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=1549544926&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 43. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q34398219$05450B29-F88D-4F10-B556-1443F65749D0 in revision 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"T M Derwing\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2093\",\"hash\":\"4e87d3de5de7998535b6b7540c293b8397d02d07\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"T M Derwing\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P1545\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1545\",\"hash\":\"7241753c62a310cf84895620ea82250dcea65835\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"2\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P1545\"],\"id\":\"Q34398219$05450B29-F88D-4F10-B556-1443F65749D0\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"ca8e05ff451fa45ad3dc44b021e5f2a8a6c8b41b\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"cc0d904327e74c637fb8aa8274ffbab68d6456bd\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8816082\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"7ff45ac6fd9104a058b89c3851c8b1fec5c870f6\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-08-01T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=1549544926&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q34398219; claims.P2093; statement Q34398219$05450B29-F88D-4F10-B556-1443F65749D0", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2021-12-24T20:38:33Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "5b17c0fce60246bd08c189d112bbfd653610b15e87360571571f7574e77bdd7d", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The Arab States region is one of the top destinations for international migrant workers, where they comprise 41.4 per cent of the entire working population, often dominating in key sectors.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The Arab States region is one of the top destinations for international migrant workers, where they comprise 41.4 per cent of the entire working population, often dominating in key sectors.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 43", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "3a71b42234581f97d4dcf842379c897fd09cff4b692985d68d2c1ca1235a3fec", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 1549544926; entity Q34398219; source SHA-256 5b17c0fce60246bd08c189d112bbfd653610b15e87360571571f7574e77bdd7d; statement SHA-256 2d3e66a0e27ff2795351258d2c51c69890099ab3db5caa880a0bd035075cd193; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 3a71b42234581f97d4dcf842379c897fd09cff4b692985d68d2c1ca1235a3fec; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3456, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "d088d197988e71e764f4675ea764abf91b336cb755c15918bb9082811ef56cd8", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q34398219$05450B29-F88D-4F10-B556-1443F65749D0 in revision 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"T M Derwing\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q34398219$05450B29-F88D-4F10-B556-1443F65749D0", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) / P2093", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 1549544926 at 2021-12-24T20:38:33Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The Arab States region is one of the top destinations for international migrant workers, where they comprise 41.4 per cent of the entire working population, often dominating in key sectors.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 43", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G03-2026-07-23.svg index c1aefd0d4..5d365aa18 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q34398219$05450B29-F88D-4F10-B556-1443F65749D0 in revision - 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the + The Arab States region is one of the top destinations for international migrant + workers, where they comprise 41.4 per cent of the entire working population, often Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T03-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 1549544926 at 2021-12-24T20:38:33Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q34398219$05450B29-F88D-4F10-B556-1443F65749D0 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 43 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json index e61da516b..17251bd25 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=1549544926&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 44. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q34398219$157AC753-025F-4BFD-868C-2CE4358270EA in revision 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) publishes page(s) (P304) with value \"289-306\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P304\",\"hash\":\"6425f82e06b8b6b3c1e5db608c6318b443972239\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"289-306\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q34398219$157AC753-025F-4BFD-868C-2CE4358270EA\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"ca8e05ff451fa45ad3dc44b021e5f2a8a6c8b41b\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"cc0d904327e74c637fb8aa8274ffbab68d6456bd\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8816082\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"7ff45ac6fd9104a058b89c3851c8b1fec5c870f6\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-08-01T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=1549544926&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q34398219; claims.P304; statement Q34398219$157AC753-025F-4BFD-868C-2CE4358270EA", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2021-12-24T20:38:33Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "5b17c0fce60246bd08c189d112bbfd653610b15e87360571571f7574e77bdd7d", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In many of these countries, the outflows were due to temporary labour movements, such as for Pakistan (net flow of −16.5 million), India (−3.5 million), Bangladesh (−2.9 million), Nepal (−1.6 million) and Sri Lanka (−1.0 million).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In many of these countries, the outflows were due to temporary labour movements, such as for Pakistan (net flow of −16.5 million), India (−3.5 million), Bangladesh (−2.9 million), Nepal (−1.6 million) and Sri Lanka (−1.0 million).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 44", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "275d1230e91c61fd368467073f1e529d34e9a128f31f17eb7210731525ab002c", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 1549544926; entity Q34398219; source SHA-256 5b17c0fce60246bd08c189d112bbfd653610b15e87360571571f7574e77bdd7d; statement SHA-256 237dfb35054d18f1a17a359c37f588c8b7045a33a250c1e82f1e2aebe4af0503; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 275d1230e91c61fd368467073f1e529d34e9a128f31f17eb7210731525ab002c; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3457, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "d088d197988e71e764f4675ea764abf91b336cb755c15918bb9082811ef56cd8", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q34398219$157AC753-025F-4BFD-868C-2CE4358270EA in revision 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) publishes page(s) (P304) with value \"289-306\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q34398219$157AC753-025F-4BFD-868C-2CE4358270EA", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) / P304", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 1549544926 at 2021-12-24T20:38:33Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In many of these countries, the outflows were due to temporary labour movements, such as for Pakistan (net flow of −16.5 million), India (−3.5 million), Bangladesh (−2.9 million), Nepal (−1.6 million) and Sri Lanka (−1.0 million).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 44", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G04-2026-07-23.svg index a581fb183..93003a138 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q34398219$157AC753-025F-4BFD-868C-2CE4358270EA in revision - 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the + In many of these countries, the outflows were due to temporary labour movements, + such as for Pakistan (net flow of −16.5 million), India (−3.5 million), Bangladesh Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T03-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 1549544926 at 2021-12-24T20:38:33Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q34398219$157AC753-025F-4BFD-868C-2CE4358270EA - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 44 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json index b0e50207b..59dff6f1b 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=1549544926&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 44. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q34398219$2C2C70DA-1E72-4A38-AAD3-933EC7F305E3 in revision 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) publishes instance of (P31) with value scholarly article (Q13442814).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P31\",\"hash\":\"29465f78f13add11b617f0de4ade56cd1122c19c\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":13442814,\"id\":\"Q13442814\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q34398219$2C2C70DA-1E72-4A38-AAD3-933EC7F305E3\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"ca8e05ff451fa45ad3dc44b021e5f2a8a6c8b41b\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"cc0d904327e74c637fb8aa8274ffbab68d6456bd\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8816082\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"7ff45ac6fd9104a058b89c3851c8b1fec5c870f6\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-08-01T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=1549544926&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q34398219; claims.P31; statement Q34398219$2C2C70DA-1E72-4A38-AAD3-933EC7F305E3", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2021-12-24T20:38:33Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "5b17c0fce60246bd08c189d112bbfd653610b15e87360571571f7574e77bdd7d", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Furthermore, migratory movements are often hard to separate from non-migratory travel, such as tourism or business.12 Tracking migratory movements also requires considerable resources, infrastructure and ICT/knowledge systems.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Furthermore, migratory movements are often hard to separate from non-migratory travel, such as tourism or business.12 Tracking migratory movements also requires considerable resources, infrastructure and ICT/knowledge systems.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 44", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "6490a79c319e66cf27b068c9dcdf55605a81bb1c7107bec08b26b5521ba72464", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 1549544926; entity Q34398219; source SHA-256 5b17c0fce60246bd08c189d112bbfd653610b15e87360571571f7574e77bdd7d; statement SHA-256 4b677df8e926fbf6e39c5a45f78ec2ce2ea11dce8d168a38d3f646d1bc19a624; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 6490a79c319e66cf27b068c9dcdf55605a81bb1c7107bec08b26b5521ba72464; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3458, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "d088d197988e71e764f4675ea764abf91b336cb755c15918bb9082811ef56cd8", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q34398219$2C2C70DA-1E72-4A38-AAD3-933EC7F305E3 in revision 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) publishes instance of (P31) with value scholarly article (Q13442814).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q34398219$2C2C70DA-1E72-4A38-AAD3-933EC7F305E3", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) / P31", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 1549544926 at 2021-12-24T20:38:33Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Furthermore, migratory movements are often hard to separate from non-migratory travel, such as tourism or business.12 Tracking migratory movements also requires considerable resources, infrastructure and ICT/knowledge systems.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 44", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G05-2026-07-23.svg index d6affb726..26523dfc2 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q34398219$2C2C70DA-1E72-4A38-AAD3-933EC7F305E3 in revision - 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the + Furthermore, migratory movements are often hard to separate from non-migratory + travel, such as tourism or business.12 Tracking migratory movements also requires Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T03-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 1549544926 at 2021-12-24T20:38:33Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q34398219$2C2C70DA-1E72-4A38-AAD3-933EC7F305E3 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 44 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json index 0054c23e3..ad4d7e756 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=1549544926&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 45. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q34398219$285C98C8-4F31-4735-9B56-44C2224A7684 in revision 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) publishes volume (P478) with value \"38 ( Pt 3)\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P478\",\"hash\":\"aa7f39a59e1a035dd5c0dcb1396fabfb30c5af50\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"38 ( Pt 3)\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q34398219$285C98C8-4F31-4735-9B56-44C2224A7684\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"ca8e05ff451fa45ad3dc44b021e5f2a8a6c8b41b\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"cc0d904327e74c637fb8aa8274ffbab68d6456bd\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8816082\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"7ff45ac6fd9104a058b89c3851c8b1fec5c870f6\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-08-01T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=1549544926&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q34398219; claims.P478; statement Q34398219$285C98C8-4F31-4735-9B56-44C2224A7684", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2021-12-24T20:38:33Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "5b17c0fce60246bd08c189d112bbfd653610b15e87360571571f7574e77bdd7d", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Entry and border management, for example, is particularly challenging in some regions because of archipelagic and isolated borders, and is further complicated by traditions of informal migration for work.13 Conflating “migration” and “migrant” In a general sense, migration is the process of moving from one place to another.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Entry and border management, for example, is particularly challenging in some regions because of archipelagic and isolated borders, and is further complicated by traditions of informal migration for work.13 Conflating “migration” and “migrant” In a general sense, migration is the process of moving from one place to another.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 45", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "767cbb1d096e9747231b4752fc11c7445ff0249efe2b14a26d26c6c6124a912d", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 1549544926; entity Q34398219; source SHA-256 5b17c0fce60246bd08c189d112bbfd653610b15e87360571571f7574e77bdd7d; statement SHA-256 65dcf192b08f55b60217817f3942bf5bc0799913ceef488112b204068392e90d; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 767cbb1d096e9747231b4752fc11c7445ff0249efe2b14a26d26c6c6124a912d; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3459, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "d088d197988e71e764f4675ea764abf91b336cb755c15918bb9082811ef56cd8", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q34398219$285C98C8-4F31-4735-9B56-44C2224A7684 in revision 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) publishes volume (P478) with value \"38 ( Pt 3)\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q34398219$285C98C8-4F31-4735-9B56-44C2224A7684", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) / P478", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 1549544926 at 2021-12-24T20:38:33Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Entry and border management, for example, is particularly challenging in some regions because of archipelagic and isolated borders, and is further complicated by traditions of informal migration for work.13 Conflating “migration” and “migrant” In a general sense, migration is the process of moving from one place to another.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 45", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G06-2026-07-23.svg index d98534f32..39e498757 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q34398219$285C98C8-4F31-4735-9B56-44C2224A7684 in revision - 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the + Entry and border management, for example, is particularly challenging in some + regions because of archipelagic and isolated borders, and is further complicated by Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T03-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 1549544926 at 2021-12-24T20:38:33Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q34398219$285C98C8-4F31-4735-9B56-44C2224A7684 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 45 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json index 9e5d78ed4..0976e0ab6 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=1549544926&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 46. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q34398219$8FED3F33-C2FF-4BA6-B4EE-4D671D1BF45E in revision 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) publishes publication date (P577) with value +1995-07-01T00:00:00Z.", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P577\",\"hash\":\"2908f78e4bf89d613ced1833191f66c9ba6c1462\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+1995-07-01T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q34398219$8FED3F33-C2FF-4BA6-B4EE-4D671D1BF45E\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"ca8e05ff451fa45ad3dc44b021e5f2a8a6c8b41b\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"cc0d904327e74c637fb8aa8274ffbab68d6456bd\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8816082\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"7ff45ac6fd9104a058b89c3851c8b1fec5c870f6\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-08-01T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=1549544926&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q34398219; claims.P577; statement Q34398219$8FED3F33-C2FF-4BA6-B4EE-4D671D1BF45E", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2021-12-24T20:38:33Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "5b17c0fce60246bd08c189d112bbfd653610b15e87360571571f7574e77bdd7d", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "They found that the publicly available Facebook Social Connectedness Index is a strong predictor of diaspora populations within 27 European Union Member States, which is itself predictive of displacement trajectories of those uprooted by conflict.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "They found that the publicly available Facebook Social Connectedness Index is a strong predictor of diaspora populations within 27 European Union Member States, which is itself predictive of displacement trajectories of those uprooted by conflict.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 46", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "1044a4443c7ad57305fe03d96a7dd17663a336510708e1fc267c3bdf3bad11b4", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 1549544926; entity Q34398219; source SHA-256 5b17c0fce60246bd08c189d112bbfd653610b15e87360571571f7574e77bdd7d; statement SHA-256 624ccd95f5c9ad6c98cf90e9290ac483813dc2db3c645b7834e331a1afb78172; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 1044a4443c7ad57305fe03d96a7dd17663a336510708e1fc267c3bdf3bad11b4; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3460, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "d088d197988e71e764f4675ea764abf91b336cb755c15918bb9082811ef56cd8", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q34398219$8FED3F33-C2FF-4BA6-B4EE-4D671D1BF45E in revision 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) publishes publication date (P577) with value +1995-07-01T00:00:00Z.", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q34398219$8FED3F33-C2FF-4BA6-B4EE-4D671D1BF45E", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of native and foreign-accented speech (Q34398219) / P577", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 1549544926 at 2021-12-24T20:38:33Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "They found that the publicly available Facebook Social Connectedness Index is a strong predictor of diaspora populations within 27 European Union Member States, which is itself predictive of displacement trajectories of those uprooted by conflict.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 46", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G07-2026-07-23.svg index ef595daae..a09da8077 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q34398219$8FED3F33-C2FF-4BA6-B4EE-4D671D1BF45E in revision - 1549544926 asserts that Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the + They found that the publicly available Facebook Social Connectedness Index is a + strong predictor of diaspora populations within 27 European Union Member States, Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T03-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time, accent, and comprehensibility in the perception of + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 1549544926 at 2021-12-24T20:38:33Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q34398219$8FED3F33-C2FF-4BA6-B4EE-4D671D1BF45E - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 46 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json index baa2e814f..768898cdf 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 47. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$BE309705-94CE-4795-8BDD-E2ED10E90F94 in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes published in (P1433) with value Journal of Experimental Child Psychology (Q15755108).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1433\",\"hash\":\"f57ae51174ce52fe4c385237231a618090b60a20\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":15755108,\"id\":\"Q15755108\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q52058308$BE309705-94CE-4795-8BDD-E2ED10E90F94\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"45b454291c309371b1935c1132faa065adc4a634\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"1f82b44a7e1e22b1bf64e283052da8508d1607d3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8169582\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"ea2027e737b4d6e7ee954c0e844ad1178ab714b3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2018-04-20T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"80e21d24b2449eedb168fdba66664d249a75b976\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/europepmc.org\\/abstract\\/MED\\/8169582\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52058308; claims.P1433; statement Q52058308$BE309705-94CE-4795-8BDD-E2ED10E90F94", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "IOM and other collaborators have helped guide the development of a global dataset estimating international migration flows, forthcoming in 2024, with analysis of country-to-country trends spanning the COVID-19 pandemic years.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "IOM and other collaborators have helped guide the development of a global dataset estimating international migration flows, forthcoming in 2024, with analysis of country-to-country trends spanning the COVID-19 pandemic years.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 47", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "e076fd06dc4b93d6cf4905aa3303daaf65dc89390c4ab4def64615ecdde0dcf4", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325813; entity Q52058308; source SHA-256 dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600; statement SHA-256 4ef9aa4c5a70e492cc854379f069d8c2f9b2fed067fecd033a06004dddb9a080; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 e076fd06dc4b93d6cf4905aa3303daaf65dc89390c4ab4def64615ecdde0dcf4; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3461, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "d088d197988e71e764f4675ea764abf91b336cb755c15918bb9082811ef56cd8", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$BE309705-94CE-4795-8BDD-E2ED10E90F94 in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes published in (P1433) with value Journal of Experimental Child Psychology (Q15755108).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52058308$BE309705-94CE-4795-8BDD-E2ED10E90F94", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P1433", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "IOM and other collaborators have helped guide the development of a global dataset estimating international migration flows, forthcoming in 2024, with analysis of country-to-country trends spanning the COVID-19 pandemic years.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 47", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G08-2026-07-23.svg index cdc7ccc22..78f2ccbca 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52058308$BE309705-94CE-4795-8BDD-E2ED10E90F94 in revision - 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span + IOM and other collaborators have helped guide the development of a global dataset + estimating international migration flows, forthcoming in 2024, with analysis of Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T03-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P1433 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52058308$BE309705-94CE-4795-8BDD-E2ED10E90F94 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 47 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json index 8315e35a6..09b5de06a 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 49. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$AFD5C7B5-7C98-4CFA-B2A2-F47220BA57DA in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes title (P1476) with value Processing time, articulation time, and memory span.", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1476\",\"hash\":\"58744b31664ea338658b259c7aaa798196274578\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"text\":\"Processing time, articulation time, and memory span\",\"language\":\"en\"},\"type\":\"monolingualtext\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q52058308$AFD5C7B5-7C98-4CFA-B2A2-F47220BA57DA\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"45b454291c309371b1935c1132faa065adc4a634\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"1f82b44a7e1e22b1bf64e283052da8508d1607d3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8169582\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"ea2027e737b4d6e7ee954c0e844ad1178ab714b3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2018-04-20T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"80e21d24b2449eedb168fdba66664d249a75b976\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/europepmc.org\\/abstract\\/MED\\/8169582\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52058308; claims.P1476; statement Q52058308$AFD5C7B5-7C98-4CFA-B2A2-F47220BA57DA", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "COVID-19 impacts on mobility COVID-19 has been the most severe pandemic in a century, with its combination of high transmission, virus strains and the severity of the disease forcing policymakers into previously uncharted territory.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "COVID-19 impacts on mobility COVID-19 has been the most severe pandemic in a century, with its combination of high transmission, virus strains and the severity of the disease forcing policymakers into previously uncharted territory.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 49", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "625ef31161166d4ba6e6b0c360694bdf83e79dfbfd2b42aa7a2d062b20ec435f", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325813; entity Q52058308; source SHA-256 dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600; statement SHA-256 a53f1ce4d83e60b378ea6ba6ab6197fbfb93d3bcb893b8bbc0b2291e9f83887f; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 625ef31161166d4ba6e6b0c360694bdf83e79dfbfd2b42aa7a2d062b20ec435f; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3462, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "d088d197988e71e764f4675ea764abf91b336cb755c15918bb9082811ef56cd8", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$AFD5C7B5-7C98-4CFA-B2A2-F47220BA57DA in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes title (P1476) with value Processing time, articulation time, and memory span.", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52058308$AFD5C7B5-7C98-4CFA-B2A2-F47220BA57DA", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P1476", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "COVID-19 impacts on mobility COVID-19 has been the most severe pandemic in a century, with its combination of high transmission, virus strains and the severity of the disease forcing policymakers into previously uncharted territory.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 49", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G09-2026-07-23.svg index 41d8ab8d7..3d538c57d 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52058308$AFD5C7B5-7C98-4CFA-B2A2-F47220BA57DA in revision - 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span + COVID-19 impacts on mobility COVID-19 has been the most severe pandemic in a + century, with its combination of high transmission, virus strains and the severity Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T03-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P1476 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52058308$AFD5C7B5-7C98-4CFA-B2A2-F47220BA57DA - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 49 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json index 972871a2c..337016f02 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 49. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$6443332A-2FEE-4F69-ADDD-35833D7B60BB in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Kail R\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2093\",\"hash\":\"4b50da3b07eaf7f2af3e511d287c9e1b815f8c6e\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"Kail R\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P1545\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1545\",\"hash\":\"2a1ced1dca90648ea7e306acbadd74fc81a10722\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"1\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P1545\"],\"id\":\"Q52058308$6443332A-2FEE-4F69-ADDD-35833D7B60BB\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"45b454291c309371b1935c1132faa065adc4a634\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"1f82b44a7e1e22b1bf64e283052da8508d1607d3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8169582\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"ea2027e737b4d6e7ee954c0e844ad1178ab714b3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2018-04-20T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"80e21d24b2449eedb168fdba66664d249a75b976\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/europepmc.org\\/abstract\\/MED\\/8169582\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52058308; claims.P2093; statement Q52058308$6443332A-2FEE-4F69-ADDD-35833D7B60BB", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "COVID-19-related immobility became the “great disrupter” of migration.20 Governments around the world implemented various measures to limit the spread of the virus and a range of restrictions was introduced from early 2020, evolving over time.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "COVID-19-related immobility became the “great disrupter” of migration.20 Governments around the world implemented various measures to limit the spread of the virus and a range of restrictions was introduced from early 2020, evolving over time.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 49", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "ccb7e116b14ffabec15c555c0a1e4e3093d6ddd29a775cdabfb4f5c1f6ff4868", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325813; entity Q52058308; source SHA-256 dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600; statement SHA-256 a41b191b03dd35a6a0b5fe62de79b09f5b3bf12629e2e8b16d8518b97bb83a99; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 ccb7e116b14ffabec15c555c0a1e4e3093d6ddd29a775cdabfb4f5c1f6ff4868; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3463, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "d088d197988e71e764f4675ea764abf91b336cb755c15918bb9082811ef56cd8", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$6443332A-2FEE-4F69-ADDD-35833D7B60BB in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Kail R\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52058308$6443332A-2FEE-4F69-ADDD-35833D7B60BB", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P2093", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "COVID-19-related immobility became the “great disrupter” of migration.20 Governments around the world implemented various measures to limit the spread of the virus and a range of restrictions was introduced from early 2020, evolving over time.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 49", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G10-2026-07-23.svg index b56c93c7b..548738801 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52058308$6443332A-2FEE-4F69-ADDD-35833D7B60BB in revision - 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span + COVID-19-related immobility became the “great disrupter” of migration.20 Governments + around the world implemented various measures to limit the spread of the virus and a Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T03-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P2093 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52058308$6443332A-2FEE-4F69-ADDD-35833D7B60BB - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 49 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json index 6716ea690..f6046e7bd 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 50. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$6FB56DAA-017E-4E1D-8F7F-0E5489BD3E0F in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Park YS\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2093\",\"hash\":\"3769ecca96f7d23fe64e95cb9b4eb417053ad7e1\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"Park YS\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P1545\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1545\",\"hash\":\"7241753c62a310cf84895620ea82250dcea65835\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"2\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P1545\"],\"id\":\"Q52058308$6FB56DAA-017E-4E1D-8F7F-0E5489BD3E0F\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"45b454291c309371b1935c1132faa065adc4a634\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"1f82b44a7e1e22b1bf64e283052da8508d1607d3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8169582\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"ea2027e737b4d6e7ee954c0e844ad1178ab714b3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2018-04-20T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"80e21d24b2449eedb168fdba66664d249a75b976\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/europepmc.org\\/abstract\\/MED\\/8169582\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52058308; claims.P2093; statement Q52058308$6FB56DAA-017E-4E1D-8F7F-0E5489BD3E0F", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "It is also important to note that categories are COVID-19-related only and do not reflect other travel restrictions that may have already been in place, such as those related to visa restrictions, entry bans based on specific citizens, and departure/ exit restrictions.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "It is also important to note that categories are COVID-19-related only and do not reflect other travel restrictions that may have already been in place, such as those related to visa restrictions, entry bans based on specific citizens, and departure/ exit restrictions.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 50", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "11be2c1e4302b443ab1c123e77130c14913e51bd09548d250d5c9a60a892fa53", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325813; entity Q52058308; source SHA-256 dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600; statement SHA-256 b798e736bdabc5d9d794b8e4243e483c698c7d113dfb34c851c2ef636b0c52b2; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 11be2c1e4302b443ab1c123e77130c14913e51bd09548d250d5c9a60a892fa53; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3464, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "933964f2447fa60ce2acdd9f8e45564c97af138fda120004859ce9628f076afc", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$6FB56DAA-017E-4E1D-8F7F-0E5489BD3E0F in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Park YS\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52058308$6FB56DAA-017E-4E1D-8F7F-0E5489BD3E0F", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P2093", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "It is also important to note that categories are COVID-19-related only and do not reflect other travel restrictions that may have already been in place, such as those related to visa restrictions, entry bans based on specific citizens, and departure/ exit restrictions.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 50", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G01-2026-07-23.svg index 6cb13b8ac..4d10d94aa 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52058308$6FB56DAA-017E-4E1D-8F7F-0E5489BD3E0F in revision - 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span + It is also important to note that categories are COVID-19-related only and do not + reflect other travel restrictions that may have already been in place, such as those Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T04-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P2093 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52058308$6FB56DAA-017E-4E1D-8F7F-0E5489BD3E0F - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 50 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json index 3634f997b..f56082c40 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 50. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$F7BCA479-8988-4C1C-A923-7A353C369999 in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes page(s) (P304) with value \"281-291\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P304\",\"hash\":\"74ab10cd429f3a64687d50bf7b6a0dde2cd8de8d\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"281-291\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q52058308$F7BCA479-8988-4C1C-A923-7A353C369999\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"45b454291c309371b1935c1132faa065adc4a634\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"1f82b44a7e1e22b1bf64e283052da8508d1607d3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8169582\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"ea2027e737b4d6e7ee954c0e844ad1178ab714b3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2018-04-20T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"80e21d24b2449eedb168fdba66664d249a75b976\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/europepmc.org\\/abstract\\/MED\\/8169582\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52058308; claims.P304; statement Q52058308$F7BCA479-8988-4C1C-A923-7A353C369999", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "We can see from long-term air passenger figures that COVID-19 travel restrictions had a major impact on both international and domestic air travel in 2020.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "We can see from long-term air passenger figures that COVID-19 travel restrictions had a major impact on both international and domestic air travel in 2020.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 50", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "8d4125b425c4dbf36988c88b57b63a656a805c0d56c2dac7ff907655d5a27e19", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325813; entity Q52058308; source SHA-256 dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600; statement SHA-256 6a0478a964dbac6755d69994890c0037469ac93b42be28ea7a8cf6642447b2f0; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 8d4125b425c4dbf36988c88b57b63a656a805c0d56c2dac7ff907655d5a27e19; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3465, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "933964f2447fa60ce2acdd9f8e45564c97af138fda120004859ce9628f076afc", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$F7BCA479-8988-4C1C-A923-7A353C369999 in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes page(s) (P304) with value \"281-291\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52058308$F7BCA479-8988-4C1C-A923-7A353C369999", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P304", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "We can see from long-term air passenger figures that COVID-19 travel restrictions had a major impact on both international and domestic air travel in 2020.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 50", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G02-2026-07-23.svg index 5298e53d4..63e0b152a 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52058308$F7BCA479-8988-4C1C-A923-7A353C369999 in revision - 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span + We can see from long-term air passenger figures that COVID-19 travel restrictions + had a major impact on both international and domestic air travel in 2020. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T04-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P304 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52058308$F7BCA479-8988-4C1C-A923-7A353C369999 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 50 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json index 577bb10e5..e5fe5d645 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 51. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$9D4BDD44-B128-4DAE-9D11-287EF1D58E4C in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes instance of (P31) with value scholarly article (Q13442814).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P31\",\"hash\":\"29465f78f13add11b617f0de4ade56cd1122c19c\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":13442814,\"id\":\"Q13442814\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q52058308$9D4BDD44-B128-4DAE-9D11-287EF1D58E4C\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"45b454291c309371b1935c1132faa065adc4a634\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"1f82b44a7e1e22b1bf64e283052da8508d1607d3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8169582\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"ea2027e737b4d6e7ee954c0e844ad1178ab714b3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2018-04-20T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"80e21d24b2449eedb168fdba66664d249a75b976\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/europepmc.org\\/abstract\\/MED\\/8169582\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52058308; claims.P31; statement Q52058308$9D4BDD44-B128-4DAE-9D11-287EF1D58E4C", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "See additional data, research and analysis in the thematic Chapter 9 in this report, which provides an update on COVID-19 impacts on migration and mobility globally.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "See additional data, research and analysis in the thematic Chapter 9 in this report, which provides an update on COVID-19 impacts on migration and mobility globally.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 51", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "c8284b71b3d2096935a6647579237040e641075e294a6f771e2462dfc6a891a8", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325813; entity Q52058308; source SHA-256 dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600; statement SHA-256 8befdb2329a149cb221cc3cafd4a0dccdadfa575d2920f509938530da7fed302; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 c8284b71b3d2096935a6647579237040e641075e294a6f771e2462dfc6a891a8; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3466, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "933964f2447fa60ce2acdd9f8e45564c97af138fda120004859ce9628f076afc", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$9D4BDD44-B128-4DAE-9D11-287EF1D58E4C in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes instance of (P31) with value scholarly article (Q13442814).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52058308$9D4BDD44-B128-4DAE-9D11-287EF1D58E4C", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P31", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "See additional data, research and analysis in the thematic Chapter 9 in this report, which provides an update on COVID-19 impacts on migration and mobility globally.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 51", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G03-2026-07-23.svg index b3137a543..c584e2311 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52058308$9D4BDD44-B128-4DAE-9D11-287EF1D58E4C in revision - 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span + See additional data, research and analysis in the thematic Chapter 9 in this report, + which provides an update on COVID-19 impacts on migration and mobility globally. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T04-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P31 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52058308$9D4BDD44-B128-4DAE-9D11-287EF1D58E4C - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 51 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json index e98417a0f..7a7d05c14 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 51. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$8D936AC7-75D0-47D7-8D75-3853A00B525C in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes language of work or name (P407) with value English (Q1860).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P407\",\"hash\":\"daf1c4fcb58181b02dff9cc89deb084004ddae4b\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":1860,\"id\":\"Q1860\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q52058308$8D936AC7-75D0-47D7-8D75-3853A00B525C\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52058308; claims.P407; statement Q52058308$8D936AC7-75D0-47D7-8D75-3853A00B525C", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In particular, the World Bank’s annual remittances data sets (ibid.), Migration and Development Brief 38 (Ratha et al., 2023), and its 13 June press release (World Bank, 2023b) are key sources of information.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In particular, the World Bank’s annual remittances data sets (ibid.), Migration and Development Brief 38 (Ratha et al., 2023), and its 13 June press release (World Bank, 2023b) are key sources of information.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 51", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "d67cb2b8ea73dd18fcd40482b1b4b8ea094970e03fadfb6e2f40190eda4fb23e", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325813; entity Q52058308; source SHA-256 dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600; statement SHA-256 61f1fc97a122d4b543d55df8b69057015e3782e9708048cb9c1ef38715b43463; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 d67cb2b8ea73dd18fcd40482b1b4b8ea094970e03fadfb6e2f40190eda4fb23e; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3467, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "933964f2447fa60ce2acdd9f8e45564c97af138fda120004859ce9628f076afc", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$8D936AC7-75D0-47D7-8D75-3853A00B525C in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes language of work or name (P407) with value English (Q1860).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52058308$8D936AC7-75D0-47D7-8D75-3853A00B525C", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P407", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In particular, the World Bank’s annual remittances data sets (ibid.), Migration and Development Brief 38 (Ratha et al., 2023), and its 13 June press release (World Bank, 2023b) are key sources of information.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 51", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G04-2026-07-23.svg index 6f50bc0d6..7902aff1e 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52058308$8D936AC7-75D0-47D7-8D75-3853A00B525C in revision - 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span + In particular, the World Bank’s annual remittances data sets (ibid.), Migration and + Development Brief 38 (Ratha et al., 2023), and its 13 June press release (World Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T04-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P407 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52058308$8D936AC7-75D0-47D7-8D75-3853A00B525C - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 51 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json index 3d12c0fe3..e40534d7e 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 52. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$05D1826C-3FB8-498E-B71B-4CA72BE9906C in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes issue (P433) with value \"2\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P433\",\"hash\":\"69d52212d282a400dfd773d3aea95b8e4f7c9e2f\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"2\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q52058308$05D1826C-3FB8-498E-B71B-4CA72BE9906C\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"45b454291c309371b1935c1132faa065adc4a634\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"1f82b44a7e1e22b1bf64e283052da8508d1607d3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8169582\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"ea2027e737b4d6e7ee954c0e844ad1178ab714b3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2018-04-20T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"80e21d24b2449eedb168fdba66664d249a75b976\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/europepmc.org\\/abstract\\/MED\\/8169582\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52058308; claims.P433; statement Q52058308$05D1826C-3FB8-498E-B71B-4CA72BE9906C", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Mexico was the second-largest remittance recipient in 2022, a position it also held in 2021 after overtaking China, which historically had been the second-biggest recipient after India.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Mexico was the second-largest remittance recipient in 2022, a position it also held in 2021 after overtaking China, which historically had been the second-biggest recipient after India.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 52", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "75d929279c9e93efb0bf4f3bef470c53cd1ca7db0c01ce26814fbdd97d20d3d0", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325813; entity Q52058308; source SHA-256 dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600; statement SHA-256 9037a8715ee8c0c03eff46509f7327bcb31dac2fc9989680017596327347ebf0; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 75d929279c9e93efb0bf4f3bef470c53cd1ca7db0c01ce26814fbdd97d20d3d0; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3468, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "933964f2447fa60ce2acdd9f8e45564c97af138fda120004859ce9628f076afc", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$05D1826C-3FB8-498E-B71B-4CA72BE9906C in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes issue (P433) with value \"2\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52058308$05D1826C-3FB8-498E-B71B-4CA72BE9906C", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P433", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Mexico was the second-largest remittance recipient in 2022, a position it also held in 2021 after overtaking China, which historically had been the second-biggest recipient after India.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 52", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G05-2026-07-23.svg index db889ac76..f03135ad0 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52058308$05D1826C-3FB8-498E-B71B-4CA72BE9906C in revision - 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span + Mexico was the second-largest remittance recipient in 2022, a position it also held + in 2021 after overtaking China, which historically had been the second-biggest Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T04-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P433 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52058308$05D1826C-3FB8-498E-B71B-4CA72BE9906C - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 52 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json index 8fd5fcf09..38b1af7f6 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 52. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$159270EF-1944-49D9-B9FE-BE4296E24204 in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes volume (P478) with value \"57\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P478\",\"hash\":\"0cb5acbf8092b652cabb291fc9c83ac64e66264e\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"57\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q52058308$159270EF-1944-49D9-B9FE-BE4296E24204\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"45b454291c309371b1935c1132faa065adc4a634\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"1f82b44a7e1e22b1bf64e283052da8508d1607d3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8169582\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"ea2027e737b4d6e7ee954c0e844ad1178ab714b3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2018-04-20T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"80e21d24b2449eedb168fdba66664d249a75b976\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/europepmc.org\\/abstract\\/MED\\/8169582\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52058308; claims.P478; statement Q52058308$159270EF-1944-49D9-B9FE-BE4296E24204", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "It should be noted, however, that the majority of inflows are not household transfers, but relate to salaries of cross-border workers who work in Switzerland while residing in France or Germany.29 High-income countries are almost always the main source of international remittances.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "It should be noted, however, that the majority of inflows are not household transfers, but relate to salaries of cross-border workers who work in Switzerland while residing in France or Germany.29 High-income countries are almost always the main source of international remittances.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 52", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "8d846a5e85de0863f4d6b044ab9b9dd9ff81d1cff0b01fe3a8b803fdcbee375d", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325813; entity Q52058308; source SHA-256 dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600; statement SHA-256 2fde176fbf8b601b80064fe19d11235ddc98e2099f350f4f0b02138fd7801078; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 8d846a5e85de0863f4d6b044ab9b9dd9ff81d1cff0b01fe3a8b803fdcbee375d; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3469, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "933964f2447fa60ce2acdd9f8e45564c97af138fda120004859ce9628f076afc", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$159270EF-1944-49D9-B9FE-BE4296E24204 in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes volume (P478) with value \"57\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52058308$159270EF-1944-49D9-B9FE-BE4296E24204", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P478", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "It should be noted, however, that the majority of inflows are not household transfers, but relate to salaries of cross-border workers who work in Switzerland while residing in France or Germany.29 High-income countries are almost always the main source of international remittances.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 52", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G06-2026-07-23.svg index 6b2e52659..ae118b160 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52058308$159270EF-1944-49D9-B9FE-BE4296E24204 in revision - 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span + It should be noted, however, that the majority of inflows are not household + transfers, but relate to salaries of cross-border workers who work in Switzerland Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T04-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P478 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52058308$159270EF-1944-49D9-B9FE-BE4296E24204 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 52 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json index 8afaaf5cc..1370769a9 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 55. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$64BB27A4-FC88-46F6-8A2D-A872765D55C8 in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes publication date (P577) with value +1994-04-01T00:00:00Z.", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P577\",\"hash\":\"91cfdde9dfbc294d87991fcb212439a49cc08b84\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+1994-04-01T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q52058308$64BB27A4-FC88-46F6-8A2D-A872765D55C8\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"45b454291c309371b1935c1132faa065adc4a634\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"1f82b44a7e1e22b1bf64e283052da8508d1607d3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8169582\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"ea2027e737b4d6e7ee954c0e844ad1178ab714b3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2018-04-20T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"80e21d24b2449eedb168fdba66664d249a75b976\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/europepmc.org\\/abstract\\/MED\\/8169582\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325813&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52058308; claims.P577; statement Q52058308$64BB27A4-FC88-46F6-8A2D-A872765D55C8", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 10.C commits countries to reducing the transaction costs of migrant remittances to less than 3 per cent.32 The 3 per cent transaction cost is intended as the global average of sending USD 200.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 10.C commits countries to reducing the transaction costs of migrant remittances to less than 3 per cent.32 The 3 per cent transaction cost is intended as the global average of sending USD 200.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 55", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "3bf54e0d8e5d33e5c6fdc086c93d54ef30fe0e990a0a5cae9488b8d467c67dad", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325813; entity Q52058308; source SHA-256 dcb02f0b007c3ee37b4d6389c67d0dfa89a0af2221ca89c46b32e8c4537c6600; statement SHA-256 e58715a60e21c78aa4ed88315a2df3b4f469233f175a15b54857978921794bfe; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 3bf54e0d8e5d33e5c6fdc086c93d54ef30fe0e990a0a5cae9488b8d467c67dad; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3470, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "933964f2447fa60ce2acdd9f8e45564c97af138fda120004859ce9628f076afc", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52058308$64BB27A4-FC88-46F6-8A2D-A872765D55C8 in revision 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) publishes publication date (P577) with value +1994-04-01T00:00:00Z.", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52058308$64BB27A4-FC88-46F6-8A2D-A872765D55C8", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P577", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 10.C commits countries to reducing the transaction costs of migrant remittances to less than 3 per cent.32 The 3 per cent transaction cost is intended as the global average of sending USD 200.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 55", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G07-2026-07-23.svg index 9568c4d6a..f0ab441ec 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52058308$64BB27A4-FC88-46F6-8A2D-A872765D55C8 in revision - 2407325813 asserts that Processing time, articulation time, and memory span + Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 10.C commits countries to reducing the + transaction costs of migrant remittances to less than 3 per cent.32 The 3 per cent Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T04-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time, articulation time, and memory span (Q52058308) / P577 + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325813 at 2025-09-19T11:12:38Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52058308$64BB27A4-FC88-46F6-8A2D-A872765D55C8 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 55 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json index 8637243a7..ecd54febb 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 55. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$0CF47825-B5B0-4316-B8A3-4328F6C13611 in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes published in (P1433) with value Journal of Experimental Child Psychology (Q15755108).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1433\",\"hash\":\"f57ae51174ce52fe4c385237231a618090b60a20\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":15755108,\"id\":\"Q15755108\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q52222645$0CF47825-B5B0-4316-B8A3-4328F6C13611\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"ed4180a7832fcbb6dcea8e10a1663242d99ce434\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"c11b30fe941886af14a8ccdbe394bce5cfecb497\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8245769\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"cadddf2d8a14cfec53d172514de1c69884ba8d5b\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2018-04-27T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57835f412415c40e2e92dd7b6a25dfd8442ee815\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/europepmc.org\\/abstract\\/MED\\/8245769\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52222645; claims.P1433; statement Q52222645$0CF47825-B5B0-4316-B8A3-4328F6C13611", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In 2022, average costs were lowest in South Asia (4.6%), followed by East Asia and Pacific, and Latin America and the Caribbean (both around 5.8%).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2022, average costs were lowest in South Asia (4.6%), followed by East Asia and Pacific, and Latin America and the Caribbean (both around 5.8%).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 55", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "7e299200ef904218ed699030559214024a7a7f25edb4e2debf4a2336949b5db9", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325716; entity Q52222645; source SHA-256 94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b; statement SHA-256 1d1563400aadd78b6218760dd28cd2a20fe8ac6055c6b7dc629fbd376eacaac5; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 7e299200ef904218ed699030559214024a7a7f25edb4e2debf4a2336949b5db9; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3471, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "933964f2447fa60ce2acdd9f8e45564c97af138fda120004859ce9628f076afc", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$0CF47825-B5B0-4316-B8A3-4328F6C13611 in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes published in (P1433) with value Journal of Experimental Child Psychology (Q15755108).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52222645$0CF47825-B5B0-4316-B8A3-4328F6C13611", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) / P1433", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In 2022, average costs were lowest in South Asia (4.6%), followed by East Asia and Pacific, and Latin America and the Caribbean (both around 5.8%).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 55", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G08-2026-07-23.svg index b0059fe2d..6d992887a 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52222645$0CF47825-B5B0-4316-B8A3-4328F6C13611 in revision - 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate + In 2022, average costs were lowest in South Asia (4.6%), followed by East Asia and + Pacific, and Latin America and the Caribbean (both around 5.8%). Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T04-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52222645$0CF47825-B5B0-4316-B8A3-4328F6C13611 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 55 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json index 4cc6d73b1..aa2c17fc4 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 57. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$397FF694-73F3-4161-866A-26B18A719E75 in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes title (P1476) with value Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence.", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1476\",\"hash\":\"16741da375ff506e8af3ab9a750e5b740c156de2\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"text\":\"Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence\",\"language\":\"en\"},\"type\":\"monolingualtext\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q52222645$397FF694-73F3-4161-866A-26B18A719E75\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"ed4180a7832fcbb6dcea8e10a1663242d99ce434\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"c11b30fe941886af14a8ccdbe394bce5cfecb497\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8245769\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"cadddf2d8a14cfec53d172514de1c69884ba8d5b\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2018-04-27T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57835f412415c40e2e92dd7b6a25dfd8442ee815\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/europepmc.org\\/abstract\\/MED\\/8245769\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52222645; claims.P1476; statement Q52222645$397FF694-73F3-4161-866A-26B18A719E75", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In 2001, there were around 1 million internationally mobile female students (45% of the total) and 1.2 million male students (54%).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2001, there were around 1 million internationally mobile female students (45% of the total) and 1.2 million male students (54%).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 57", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "5eb50eb78b88242ec548d327b1cb823572a50e30bc13657460403b67a9a2d1b7", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325716; entity Q52222645; source SHA-256 94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b; statement SHA-256 178155f59b51f8a96c431b2495ae8b4f0168b0ac2628b8c488a674756c4e98d2; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 5eb50eb78b88242ec548d327b1cb823572a50e30bc13657460403b67a9a2d1b7; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3472, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "933964f2447fa60ce2acdd9f8e45564c97af138fda120004859ce9628f076afc", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$397FF694-73F3-4161-866A-26B18A719E75 in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes title (P1476) with value Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence.", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52222645$397FF694-73F3-4161-866A-26B18A719E75", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) / P1476", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In 2001, there were around 1 million internationally mobile female students (45% of the total) and 1.2 million male students (54%).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 57", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G09-2026-07-23.svg index b8955854b..c7f14455f 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52222645$397FF694-73F3-4161-866A-26B18A719E75 in revision - 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate + In 2001, there were around 1 million internationally mobile female students (45% of + the total) and 1.2 million male students (54%). Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T04-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52222645$397FF694-73F3-4161-866A-26B18A719E75 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 57 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json index bf3649308..46a69fa36 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 57. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$E8F3F1E6-0578-46D5-8C98-9247B6A891DD in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Kail R\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2093\",\"hash\":\"4b50da3b07eaf7f2af3e511d287c9e1b815f8c6e\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"Kail R\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P1545\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1545\",\"hash\":\"2a1ced1dca90648ea7e306acbadd74fc81a10722\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"1\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P1545\"],\"id\":\"Q52222645$E8F3F1E6-0578-46D5-8C98-9247B6A891DD\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"ed4180a7832fcbb6dcea8e10a1663242d99ce434\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"c11b30fe941886af14a8ccdbe394bce5cfecb497\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8245769\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"cadddf2d8a14cfec53d172514de1c69884ba8d5b\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2018-04-27T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57835f412415c40e2e92dd7b6a25dfd8442ee815\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/europepmc.org\\/abstract\\/MED\\/8245769\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52222645; claims.P2093; statement Q52222645$E8F3F1E6-0578-46D5-8C98-9247B6A891DD", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In 2021, more than 1 million internationally mobile students were from China, by far the highest number globally and more than double the number of students from India, which ranks second (around 508,000).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2021, more than 1 million internationally mobile students were from China, by far the highest number globally and more than double the number of students from India, which ranks second (around 508,000).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 57", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "40268f7d95651ce9a00ad2bd32aa526933083ab72e4b0a751a5ce657d5c27916", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325716; entity Q52222645; source SHA-256 94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b; statement SHA-256 2cace4323f789aa600245de08bdd361f5625155e3c430123912746f044311535; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 40268f7d95651ce9a00ad2bd32aa526933083ab72e4b0a751a5ce657d5c27916; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3473, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "933964f2447fa60ce2acdd9f8e45564c97af138fda120004859ce9628f076afc", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$E8F3F1E6-0578-46D5-8C98-9247B6A891DD in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Kail R\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52222645$E8F3F1E6-0578-46D5-8C98-9247B6A891DD", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) / P2093", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In 2021, more than 1 million internationally mobile students were from China, by far the highest number globally and more than double the number of students from India, which ranks second (around 508,000).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 57", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G10-2026-07-23.svg index 39a115f01..0f55e2032 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52222645$E8F3F1E6-0578-46D5-8C98-9247B6A891DD in revision - 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate + In 2021, more than 1 million internationally mobile students were from China, by far + the highest number globally and more than double the number of students from India, Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T04-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52222645$E8F3F1E6-0578-46D5-8C98-9247B6A891DD - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 57 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json index de125067f..4ca76d100 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 58. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$E58E68D7-B25C-425E-A2A3-DEDD46447158 in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes page(s) (P304) with value \"254-265\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P304\",\"hash\":\"2f35015ca8dcbb04381e34c99ce0c8e9c0743a42\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"254-265\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q52222645$E58E68D7-B25C-425E-A2A3-DEDD46447158\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"ed4180a7832fcbb6dcea8e10a1663242d99ce434\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"c11b30fe941886af14a8ccdbe394bce5cfecb497\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8245769\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"cadddf2d8a14cfec53d172514de1c69884ba8d5b\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2018-04-27T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57835f412415c40e2e92dd7b6a25dfd8442ee815\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/europepmc.org\\/abstract\\/MED\\/8245769\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52222645; claims.P304; statement Q52222645$E58E68D7-B25C-425E-A2A3-DEDD46447158", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In 2022, over 904,000 migration health assessments were conducted, of which 15 per cent were among refugees and 85 per cent were among immigrants.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2022, over 904,000 migration health assessments were conducted, of which 15 per cent were among refugees and 85 per cent were among immigrants.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 58", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "281abca2d8e1d4bcac25a14a6ba248cff60fd13e1e7cbc6c49e4f9e89853c905", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325716; entity Q52222645; source SHA-256 94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b; statement SHA-256 dd65d8649115757ca676453e2783b8fee07900f9c700f5f01c6effbaaffd46eb; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 281abca2d8e1d4bcac25a14a6ba248cff60fd13e1e7cbc6c49e4f9e89853c905; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3474, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "58d7217cf9d14c5b12484f806e34f97a08e86cca6478efef71bace68084e66d0", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$E58E68D7-B25C-425E-A2A3-DEDD46447158 in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes page(s) (P304) with value \"254-265\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52222645$E58E68D7-B25C-425E-A2A3-DEDD46447158", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) / P304", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In 2022, over 904,000 migration health assessments were conducted, of which 15 per cent were among refugees and 85 per cent were among immigrants.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 58", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G01-2026-07-23.svg index 180b4e51f..5104375d3 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52222645$E58E68D7-B25C-425E-A2A3-DEDD46447158 in revision - 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate + In 2022, over 904,000 migration health assessments were conducted, of which 15 per + cent were among refugees and 85 per cent were among immigrants. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T05-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52222645$E58E68D7-B25C-425E-A2A3-DEDD46447158 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 58 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json index 1fb282cca..441f0ba43 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 58. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$2E837CA4-FED5-43DE-BE83-BD07A72CE6F5 in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes instance of (P31) with value scholarly article (Q13442814).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P31\",\"hash\":\"29465f78f13add11b617f0de4ade56cd1122c19c\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":13442814,\"id\":\"Q13442814\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q52222645$2E837CA4-FED5-43DE-BE83-BD07A72CE6F5\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"ed4180a7832fcbb6dcea8e10a1663242d99ce434\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"c11b30fe941886af14a8ccdbe394bce5cfecb497\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8245769\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"cadddf2d8a14cfec53d172514de1c69884ba8d5b\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2018-04-27T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57835f412415c40e2e92dd7b6a25dfd8442ee815\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/europepmc.org\\/abstract\\/MED\\/8245769\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52222645; claims.P31; statement Q52222645$2E837CA4-FED5-43DE-BE83-BD07A72CE6F5", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In 2022 alone, almost 2.9 million asylum applications were registered in 162 countries, the highest number of individual asylum applications on record.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2022 alone, almost 2.9 million asylum applications were registered in 162 countries, the highest number of individual asylum applications on record.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 58", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "8df0ba3e5434b6afd8bd2e20f78fd2f2f9e3e5e1def274f9388ea3fdf81630a6", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325716; entity Q52222645; source SHA-256 94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b; statement SHA-256 eba5d14b80f8a14c40a77f3708b4be129ccf67fb036bba40677eeca5e21689a7; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 8df0ba3e5434b6afd8bd2e20f78fd2f2f9e3e5e1def274f9388ea3fdf81630a6; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3475, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "58d7217cf9d14c5b12484f806e34f97a08e86cca6478efef71bace68084e66d0", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$2E837CA4-FED5-43DE-BE83-BD07A72CE6F5 in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes instance of (P31) with value scholarly article (Q13442814).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52222645$2E837CA4-FED5-43DE-BE83-BD07A72CE6F5", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) / P31", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In 2022 alone, almost 2.9 million asylum applications were registered in 162 countries, the highest number of individual asylum applications on record.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 58", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G02-2026-07-23.svg index 0e0669447..5fedcbd57 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52222645$2E837CA4-FED5-43DE-BE83-BD07A72CE6F5 in revision - 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate + In 2022 alone, almost 2.9 million asylum applications were registered in 162 + countries, the highest number of individual asylum applications on record. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T05-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52222645$2E837CA4-FED5-43DE-BE83-BD07A72CE6F5 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 58 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json index 372e564d3..0b8c0d138 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 59. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$C7ACE29D-A9D8-4446-BC98-45B4AFE48043 in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes language of work or name (P407) with value English (Q1860).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P407\",\"hash\":\"daf1c4fcb58181b02dff9cc89deb084004ddae4b\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":1860,\"id\":\"Q1860\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q52222645$C7ACE29D-A9D8-4446-BC98-45B4AFE48043\",\"rank\":\"normal\"}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52222645; claims.P407; statement Q52222645$C7ACE29D-A9D8-4446-BC98-45B4AFE48043", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Around 5.7 million Ukrainians had been forced to flee their country by the end of 2022, making Ukraine the second-largest origin country of refugees in the world after the Syrian Arab Republic.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Around 5.7 million Ukrainians had been forced to flee their country by the end of 2022, making Ukraine the second-largest origin country of refugees in the world after the Syrian Arab Republic.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 59", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "f0d77b0b1f7224de32c7c90bd829846ced6b547c003ce1b2dedaeb6e2e0798c2", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325716; entity Q52222645; source SHA-256 94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b; statement SHA-256 84ef810c3caa2df54295d122c1617cbb591cd746ee85edefe2641ad207ef2792; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 f0d77b0b1f7224de32c7c90bd829846ced6b547c003ce1b2dedaeb6e2e0798c2; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3476, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "58d7217cf9d14c5b12484f806e34f97a08e86cca6478efef71bace68084e66d0", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$C7ACE29D-A9D8-4446-BC98-45B4AFE48043 in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes language of work or name (P407) with value English (Q1860).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52222645$C7ACE29D-A9D8-4446-BC98-45B4AFE48043", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) / P407", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Around 5.7 million Ukrainians had been forced to flee their country by the end of 2022, making Ukraine the second-largest origin country of refugees in the world after the Syrian Arab Republic.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 59", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G03-2026-07-23.svg index 0b3f569c5..5e9b91d60 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52222645$C7ACE29D-A9D8-4446-BC98-45B4AFE48043 in revision - 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate + Around 5.7 million Ukrainians had been forced to flee their country by the end of + 2022, making Ukraine the second-largest origin country of refugees in the world Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T05-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52222645$C7ACE29D-A9D8-4446-BC98-45B4AFE48043 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 59 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json index fdb18308f..f85dc028f 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 59. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$11E2BC06-04F4-46D5-869D-F0429574B556 in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes issue (P433) with value \"2\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P433\",\"hash\":\"69d52212d282a400dfd773d3aea95b8e4f7c9e2f\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"2\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q52222645$11E2BC06-04F4-46D5-869D-F0429574B556\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"ed4180a7832fcbb6dcea8e10a1663242d99ce434\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"c11b30fe941886af14a8ccdbe394bce5cfecb497\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8245769\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"cadddf2d8a14cfec53d172514de1c69884ba8d5b\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2018-04-27T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57835f412415c40e2e92dd7b6a25dfd8442ee815\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/europepmc.org\\/abstract\\/MED\\/8245769\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52222645; claims.P433; statement Q52222645$11E2BC06-04F4-46D5-869D-F0429574B556", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The protracted conflict in the Syrian Arab Republic meant that the country continued to be the largest origin of refugees in the world at the end of 2022 (6.5 million), although this was a decrease from 6.8 million in 2021.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The protracted conflict in the Syrian Arab Republic meant that the country continued to be the largest origin of refugees in the world at the end of 2022 (6.5 million), although this was a decrease from 6.8 million in 2021.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 59", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "a09d2a10560c8a2a7557c3026c01e042aea23ed7c0b638c2bee6052d1994282b", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325716; entity Q52222645; source SHA-256 94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b; statement SHA-256 2588c716c7020f2ad87ade709b912654d45d517a4a0fbb956df3473e38733488; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 a09d2a10560c8a2a7557c3026c01e042aea23ed7c0b638c2bee6052d1994282b; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3477, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "58d7217cf9d14c5b12484f806e34f97a08e86cca6478efef71bace68084e66d0", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$11E2BC06-04F4-46D5-869D-F0429574B556 in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes issue (P433) with value \"2\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52222645$11E2BC06-04F4-46D5-869D-F0429574B556", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) / P433", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The protracted conflict in the Syrian Arab Republic meant that the country continued to be the largest origin of refugees in the world at the end of 2022 (6.5 million), although this was a decrease from 6.8 million in 2021.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 59", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G04-2026-07-23.svg index ad1c3639b..e79dbdc8b 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52222645$11E2BC06-04F4-46D5-869D-F0429574B556 in revision - 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate + The protracted conflict in the Syrian Arab Republic meant that the country continued + to be the largest origin of refugees in the world at the end of 2022 (6.5 million), Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T05-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52222645$11E2BC06-04F4-46D5-869D-F0429574B556 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 59 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json index a304be654..c10b7c910 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 60. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$5CE50873-612B-4FC9-B832-237E43C80EA2 in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes volume (P478) with value \"56\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P478\",\"hash\":\"c7dba4e4e089e305a972aa5052b868e68e9ec392\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"56\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q52222645$5CE50873-612B-4FC9-B832-237E43C80EA2\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"ed4180a7832fcbb6dcea8e10a1663242d99ce434\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"c11b30fe941886af14a8ccdbe394bce5cfecb497\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8245769\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"cadddf2d8a14cfec53d172514de1c69884ba8d5b\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2018-04-27T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57835f412415c40e2e92dd7b6a25dfd8442ee815\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/europepmc.org\\/abstract\\/MED\\/8245769\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52222645; claims.P478; statement Q52222645$5CE50873-612B-4FC9-B832-237E43C80EA2", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Pakistan and the Islamic Republic of Iran were also among the top 10 refugee-hosting countries, as the two principal hosts of refugees from Afghanistan, the second-largest origin country.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Pakistan and the Islamic Republic of Iran were also among the top 10 refugee-hosting countries, as the two principal hosts of refugees from Afghanistan, the second-largest origin country.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 60", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "3bdf7056fba9de37addda01774b6374fa6341c0379b049a8b266b57b71a070e2", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325716; entity Q52222645; source SHA-256 94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b; statement SHA-256 6ac5e5b4afc5293d80929f804ba4c21fd76d48b5d62c470f1072b1931966d985; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 3bdf7056fba9de37addda01774b6374fa6341c0379b049a8b266b57b71a070e2; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3478, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "58d7217cf9d14c5b12484f806e34f97a08e86cca6478efef71bace68084e66d0", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$5CE50873-612B-4FC9-B832-237E43C80EA2 in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes volume (P478) with value \"56\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52222645$5CE50873-612B-4FC9-B832-237E43C80EA2", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) / P478", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Pakistan and the Islamic Republic of Iran were also among the top 10 refugee-hosting countries, as the two principal hosts of refugees from Afghanistan, the second-largest origin country.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 60", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G05-2026-07-23.svg index 3b739cca9..b5ba6bc15 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52222645$5CE50873-612B-4FC9-B832-237E43C80EA2 in revision - 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate + Pakistan and the Islamic Republic of Iran were also among the top 10 refugee-hosting + countries, as the two principal hosts of refugees from Afghanistan, the Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T05-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52222645$5CE50873-612B-4FC9-B832-237E43C80EA2 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 60 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json index 1b830a977..da1ca125a 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 60. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$10FBF2A7-DFF3-453C-982F-F33CA133DFCF in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes publication date (P577) with value +1993-10-01T00:00:00Z.", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P577\",\"hash\":\"6f8e6efb395ddf5f33a406ef6e09837aa84b6e02\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+1993-10-01T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q52222645$10FBF2A7-DFF3-453C-982F-F33CA133DFCF\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"ed4180a7832fcbb6dcea8e10a1663242d99ce434\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P698\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P698\",\"hash\":\"c11b30fe941886af14a8ccdbe394bce5cfecb497\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"8245769\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"cadddf2d8a14cfec53d172514de1c69884ba8d5b\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2018-04-27T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57835f412415c40e2e92dd7b6a25dfd8442ee815\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/europepmc.org\\/abstract\\/MED\\/8245769\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P698\",\"P813\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52222645; claims.P577; statement Q52222645$10FBF2A7-DFF3-453C-982F-F33CA133DFCF", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The vast majority (70%) of refugees and other people in need of international protection were hosted in countries neighbouring their countries of origin.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The vast majority (70%) of refugees and other people in need of international protection were hosted in countries neighbouring their countries of origin.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 60", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "88dde88f8753ae5ef3542c2045b0935855892e4f13fcc01c7d6002c7eb03abba", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325716; entity Q52222645; source SHA-256 94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b; statement SHA-256 5899eb7f159990f7c4b7c8ebd374422206b10a8eefc86455ace1fb3a0b223010; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 88dde88f8753ae5ef3542c2045b0935855892e4f13fcc01c7d6002c7eb03abba; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3479, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "58d7217cf9d14c5b12484f806e34f97a08e86cca6478efef71bace68084e66d0", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$10FBF2A7-DFF3-453C-982F-F33CA133DFCF in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes publication date (P577) with value +1993-10-01T00:00:00Z.", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52222645$10FBF2A7-DFF3-453C-982F-F33CA133DFCF", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) / P577", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The vast majority (70%) of refugees and other people in need of international protection were hosted in countries neighbouring their countries of origin.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 60", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G06-2026-07-23.svg index 73058efcc..b6b69ef82 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52222645$10FBF2A7-DFF3-453C-982F-F33CA133DFCF in revision - 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate + The vast majority (70%) of refugees and other people in need of international + protection were hosted in countries neighbouring their countries of origin. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T05-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52222645$10FBF2A7-DFF3-453C-982F-F33CA133DFCF - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 60 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json index 5fe5173b6..4cee67294 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 61. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$6FC9BB6F-6905-4DAA-8E57-46424AB34F89 in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes main subject (P921) with value adolescence (Q131774).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P921\",\"hash\":\"c76f2b0d30de10a850cedd16a0c9fb9b134982a1\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":131774,\"id\":\"Q131774\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q52222645$6FC9BB6F-6905-4DAA-8E57-46424AB34F89\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"0723282bb80042897ca697416c050b4bf7fb5428\",\"snaks\":{\"P887\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P887\",\"hash\":\"2009eafb2646ea71bee7372b061e8521ee613fc2\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":69652283,\"id\":\"Q69652283\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P887\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2407325716&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q52222645; claims.P921; statement Q52222645$6FC9BB6F-6905-4DAA-8E57-46424AB34F89", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In 2022, over 114,000 refugees were admitted for resettlement globally, double the number in 2021 (57,500) and a return to pre-COVID-19 pandemic levels.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2022, over 114,000 refugees were admitted for resettlement globally, double the number in 2021 (57,500) and a return to pre-COVID-19 pandemic levels.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 61", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "4259932832d26c4e31b359990b78407f8dafd2484b2a9aad8d1a9b7aa9056b07", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2407325716; entity Q52222645; source SHA-256 94a8788c0db2aca88859b801f6e6a7076289742d9dff48525a3a692365bf2f0b; statement SHA-256 12b44e7d3e0c9c0ddf376b3ccf83b630d783c36feb615511ba6a37c1ab2294c2; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 4259932832d26c4e31b359990b78407f8dafd2484b2a9aad8d1a9b7aa9056b07; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3480, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "58d7217cf9d14c5b12484f806e34f97a08e86cca6478efef71bace68084e66d0", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q52222645$6FC9BB6F-6905-4DAA-8E57-46424AB34F89 in revision 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) publishes main subject (P921) with value adolescence (Q131774).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q52222645$6FC9BB6F-6905-4DAA-8E57-46424AB34F89", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during childhood and adolescence (Q52222645) / P921", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In 2022, over 114,000 refugees were admitted for resettlement globally, double the number in 2021 (57,500) and a return to pre-COVID-19 pandemic levels.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 61", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G07-2026-07-23.svg index f40fe3c84..bd5da4ae7 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q52222645$6FC9BB6F-6905-4DAA-8E57-46424AB34F89 in revision - 2407325716 asserts that Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate + In 2022, over 114,000 refugees were admitted for resettlement globally, double the + number in 2021 (57,500) and a return to pre-COVID-19 pandemic levels. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T05-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time decreases globally at an exponential rate during + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2407325716 at 2025-09-19T11:12:00Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q52222645$6FC9BB6F-6905-4DAA-8E57-46424AB34F89 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 61 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json index 8c96c5246..f2f85a53b 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 62. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$F8367FDD-112E-4849-8A72-0D2529B6E334 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes published in (P1433) with value Brain and Language (Q2474530).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1433\",\"hash\":\"9b8eeca15d42f6984f58d9a17ac4b763065b746a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":2474530,\"id\":\"Q2474530\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$F8367FDD-112E-4849-8A72-0D2529B6E334\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"859a5eed70241e61b7ba753c92f56ce4b2487200\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P932\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P932\",\"hash\":\"dc51e6520521cb4792b0545873c752f33a150350\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"3c27743c3b919fa4c89dc94259769591baa5b1f7\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-15T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P932\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P1433; statement Q39849109$F8367FDD-112E-4849-8A72-0D2529B6E334", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Migration and Migrants: A Global Overview Refugee resettlement has been increasing since 2021 and returned to pre-COVID-19 pandemic levels by the end of 2022.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Migration and Migrants: A Global Overview Refugee resettlement has been increasing since 2021 and returned to pre-COVID-19 pandemic levels by the end of 2022.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 62", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "953f9add012f326d5ba173e47accbf8e03f1c67bf3df61b7ad44fae6e7996043", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 6340530fccf463a31aaa8f4964fcb51c29ce6261c6e6aad5e7ecc78816faa43f; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 953f9add012f326d5ba173e47accbf8e03f1c67bf3df61b7ad44fae6e7996043; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3481, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "58d7217cf9d14c5b12484f806e34f97a08e86cca6478efef71bace68084e66d0", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$F8367FDD-112E-4849-8A72-0D2529B6E334 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes published in (P1433) with value Brain and Language (Q2474530).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$F8367FDD-112E-4849-8A72-0D2529B6E334", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P1433", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Migration and Migrants: A Global Overview Refugee resettlement has been increasing since 2021 and returned to pre-COVID-19 pandemic levels by the end of 2022.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 62", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G08-2026-07-23.svg index 2696bea7c..541995c8b 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$F8367FDD-112E-4849-8A72-0D2529B6E334 in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + Migration and Migrants: A Global Overview Refugee resettlement has been increasing + since 2021 and returned to pre-COVID-19 pandemic levels by the end of 2022. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T05-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$F8367FDD-112E-4849-8A72-0D2529B6E334 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 62 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json index a13b2b42b..569a2660a 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 63. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$4884FE1A-F8B0-4B82-98DF-4202EE46BFF2 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes title (P1476) with value Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses.", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1476\",\"hash\":\"d4bd99e0953f279a981b2f2242e7520823834a73\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"text\":\"Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses\",\"language\":\"en\"},\"type\":\"monolingualtext\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$4884FE1A-F8B0-4B82-98DF-4202EE46BFF2\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"859a5eed70241e61b7ba753c92f56ce4b2487200\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P932\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P932\",\"hash\":\"dc51e6520521cb4792b0545873c752f33a150350\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"3c27743c3b919fa4c89dc94259769591baa5b1f7\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-15T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P932\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P1476; statement Q39849109$4884FE1A-F8B0-4B82-98DF-4202EE46BFF2", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In 2022, more than 120,700 persons travelled under IOM’s auspices through resettlement, humanitarian admissions and relocation programmes, with significant operations out of Türkiye, Lebanon, Jordan, Pakistan and Qatar.a Of the beneficiaries, 49 per cent were female and 51 per cent were male.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2022, more than 120,700 persons travelled under IOM’s auspices through resettlement, humanitarian admissions and relocation programmes, with significant operations out of Türkiye, Lebanon, Jordan, Pakistan and Qatar.a Of the beneficiaries, 49 per cent were female and 51 per cent were male.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 63", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "e0474f2fedb54142c3e192d48e4ce218fd4d1880ea94f80ed3945760cc464108", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 ac2212e74b83159cfa34d21dcf653c1a35a3dfcb0fffa5ebca9b49f54a11bfd7; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 e0474f2fedb54142c3e192d48e4ce218fd4d1880ea94f80ed3945760cc464108; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3482, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "58d7217cf9d14c5b12484f806e34f97a08e86cca6478efef71bace68084e66d0", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$4884FE1A-F8B0-4B82-98DF-4202EE46BFF2 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes title (P1476) with value Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses.", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$4884FE1A-F8B0-4B82-98DF-4202EE46BFF2", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P1476", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In 2022, more than 120,700 persons travelled under IOM’s auspices through resettlement, humanitarian admissions and relocation programmes, with significant operations out of Türkiye, Lebanon, Jordan, Pakistan and Qatar.a Of the beneficiaries, 49 per cent were female and 51 per cent were male.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 63", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G09-2026-07-23.svg index f96643877..cc20625da 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$4884FE1A-F8B0-4B82-98DF-4202EE46BFF2 in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + In 2022, more than 120,700 persons travelled under IOM’s auspices through + resettlement, humanitarian admissions and relocation programmes, with significant Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T05-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$4884FE1A-F8B0-4B82-98DF-4202EE46BFF2 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 63 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json index aa3e96dec..1a1ad09c5 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 63. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$7AD8C061-8617-4F9C-AF79-0E9B8D1DA7DB in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Andrea J Sell\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2093\",\"hash\":\"7424882070989903b71c75fa99375683cca0e2c7\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"Andrea J Sell\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P1545\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1545\",\"hash\":\"2a1ced1dca90648ea7e306acbadd74fc81a10722\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"1\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P1545\"],\"id\":\"Q39849109$7AD8C061-8617-4F9C-AF79-0E9B8D1DA7DB\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"859a5eed70241e61b7ba753c92f56ce4b2487200\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P932\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P932\",\"hash\":\"dc51e6520521cb4792b0545873c752f33a150350\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"3c27743c3b919fa4c89dc94259769591baa5b1f7\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-15T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P932\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2093; statement Q39849109$7AD8C061-8617-4F9C-AF79-0E9B8D1DA7DB", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Of the above-mentioned figure, 710 persons in need of international protection were relocated from Greece, Italy and Cyprus to eight different European Economic Area countries, while 97 movements were conducted through complementary pathways from Eritrea, Afghanistan and the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Of the above-mentioned figure, 710 persons in need of international protection were relocated from Greece, Italy and Cyprus to eight different European Economic Area countries, while 97 movements were conducted through complementary pathways from Eritrea, Afghanistan and the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 63", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "a588043572a05f4d530655e2b76c1139391277efbec794e793fb12d85a15e71e", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 208ff1a9fc0ae2c3fb4e02354b69fe6f12cc93840d2d9e41b23daabd01d58486; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 a588043572a05f4d530655e2b76c1139391277efbec794e793fb12d85a15e71e; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3483, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "58d7217cf9d14c5b12484f806e34f97a08e86cca6478efef71bace68084e66d0", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$7AD8C061-8617-4F9C-AF79-0E9B8D1DA7DB in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Andrea J Sell\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$7AD8C061-8617-4F9C-AF79-0E9B8D1DA7DB", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2093", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Of the above-mentioned figure, 710 persons in need of international protection were relocated from Greece, Italy and Cyprus to eight different European Economic Area countries, while 97 movements were conducted through complementary pathways from Eritrea, Afghanistan and the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 63", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G10-2026-07-23.svg index 3dd5d4949..781e20059 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$7AD8C061-8617-4F9C-AF79-0E9B8D1DA7DB in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + Of the above-mentioned figure, 710 persons in need of international protection were + relocated from Greece, Italy and Cyprus to eight different European Economic Area Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T05-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$7AD8C061-8617-4F9C-AF79-0E9B8D1DA7DB - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 63 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json index bea8d55f9..ba7c1d817 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 64. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$FC1AE792-DCF5-4187-83EF-7A02859E6DED in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Michael P Kaschak\".", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2093\",\"hash\":\"3c62c316985b6e9ec0a01e5b243756fbe575e252\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"Michael P Kaschak\",\"type\":\"string\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P1545\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P1545\",\"hash\":\"7241753c62a310cf84895620ea82250dcea65835\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"2\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P1545\"],\"id\":\"Q39849109$FC1AE792-DCF5-4187-83EF-7A02859E6DED\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"859a5eed70241e61b7ba753c92f56ce4b2487200\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"93747a24d4fc614d1eb34cac855a7d80bbb04057\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":5412157,\"id\":\"Q5412157\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P932\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P932\",\"hash\":\"dc51e6520521cb4792b0545873c752f33a150350\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"3c27743c3b919fa4c89dc94259769591baa5b1f7\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-15T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P932\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2093; statement Q39849109$FC1AE792-DCF5-4187-83EF-7A02859E6DED", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "As with trends for refugees (discussed in the previous section), intractable and new conflicts have meant that the total number of persons internally displaced by conflict and violence has more than doubled since 2012.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "As with trends for refugees (discussed in the previous section), intractable and new conflicts have meant that the total number of persons internally displaced by conflict and violence has more than doubled since 2012.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 64", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "e56e39c31dd079058d7d3e72a84b2714a2b853604d7904e5f215f935b700fba9", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 eb659b58438843028b06f3f9ed8049c637a9dadedcf5274bbfa8501831eb6bd4; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 e56e39c31dd079058d7d3e72a84b2714a2b853604d7904e5f215f935b700fba9; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3484, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "2ff0f17d706403f0ac836437c2e1145eff3da0f2e36ec32fa5ab298c522fe654", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$FC1AE792-DCF5-4187-83EF-7A02859E6DED in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes author name string (P2093) with value \"Michael P Kaschak\".", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$FC1AE792-DCF5-4187-83EF-7A02859E6DED", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2093", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "As with trends for refugees (discussed in the previous section), intractable and new conflicts have meant that the total number of persons internally displaced by conflict and violence has more than doubled since 2012.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 64", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G01-2026-07-23.svg index 432e8caef..17e69bbf4 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$FC1AE792-DCF5-4187-83EF-7A02859E6DED in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + As with trends for refugees (discussed in the previous section), intractable and new + conflicts have meant that the total number of persons internally displaced by Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T06-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$FC1AE792-DCF5-4187-83EF-7A02859E6DED - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 64 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json index 7491ce264..4c0b14a8d 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 64. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$B4936781-CBC6-4EB5-A2F6-6209A39A218D in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value The comprehension of sentences involving quantity information affects responses on the up–down axis (Q30370251).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"f18f9bd57cb9e55d67e19a416ac8264410068f8f\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":30370251,\"id\":\"Q30370251\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$B4936781-CBC6-4EB5-A2F6-6209A39A218D\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$B4936781-CBC6-4EB5-A2F6-6209A39A218D", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The Syrian Arab Republic had the highest number of people displaced due to conflict (nearly 6.9 million) by the end of 2022, followed by Ukraine (5.9 million).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The Syrian Arab Republic had the highest number of people displaced due to conflict (nearly 6.9 million) by the end of 2022, followed by Ukraine (5.9 million).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 64", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "42a794a342d4cdebdb46b14ddd6ad35ef08acfff26ca7685a40a3b23d485b20a", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 dd3297621bbb3070493e06dbb7fa190d8a9515cca538dbf6a47cde79e4749f77; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 42a794a342d4cdebdb46b14ddd6ad35ef08acfff26ca7685a40a3b23d485b20a; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3485, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "2ff0f17d706403f0ac836437c2e1145eff3da0f2e36ec32fa5ab298c522fe654", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$B4936781-CBC6-4EB5-A2F6-6209A39A218D in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value The comprehension of sentences involving quantity information affects responses on the up–down axis (Q30370251).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$B4936781-CBC6-4EB5-A2F6-6209A39A218D", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The Syrian Arab Republic had the highest number of people displaced due to conflict (nearly 6.9 million) by the end of 2022, followed by Ukraine (5.9 million).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 64", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G02-2026-07-23.svg index 19a742004..f111c7cdc 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$B4936781-CBC6-4EB5-A2F6-6209A39A218D in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + The Syrian Arab Republic had the highest number of people displaced due to conflict + (nearly 6.9 million) by the end of 2022, followed by Ukraine (5.9 million). Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T06-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$B4936781-CBC6-4EB5-A2F6-6209A39A218D - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 64 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json index efe263c1d..b36bad68d 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 65. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$3E1C466A-8321-4492-A4E7-2DABF15AE3D4 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Flexible conceptual projection of time onto spatial frames of reference (Q40309816).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"eff2b1d1d23bc424a284d161471640cfe18fb5b5\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":40309816,\"id\":\"Q40309816\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$3E1C466A-8321-4492-A4E7-2DABF15AE3D4\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$3E1C466A-8321-4492-A4E7-2DABF15AE3D4", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The population size used to calculate the percentage of conflict IDPs is based on the total resident population of the country per UN DESA population estimates (2022).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The population size used to calculate the percentage of conflict IDPs is based on the total resident population of the country per UN DESA population estimates (2022).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 65", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "2a662da8fb6aaec9b47653fb26763bb7d46c7ae9dbe418e9f82081339ae6429d", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 85ecba8bc468d17e87164a2b89c80dec5ed2f2be364ed15729ccd2f4831801aa; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 2a662da8fb6aaec9b47653fb26763bb7d46c7ae9dbe418e9f82081339ae6429d; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3486, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "2ff0f17d706403f0ac836437c2e1145eff3da0f2e36ec32fa5ab298c522fe654", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$3E1C466A-8321-4492-A4E7-2DABF15AE3D4 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Flexible conceptual projection of time onto spatial frames of reference (Q40309816).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$3E1C466A-8321-4492-A4E7-2DABF15AE3D4", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The population size used to calculate the percentage of conflict IDPs is based on the total resident population of the country per UN DESA population estimates (2022).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 65", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G03-2026-07-23.svg index b044a4bae..7841b92a6 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$3E1C466A-8321-4492-A4E7-2DABF15AE3D4 in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + The population size used to calculate the percentage of conflict IDPs is based on + the total resident population of the country per UN DESA population estimates Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T06-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$3E1C466A-8321-4492-A4E7-2DABF15AE3D4 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 65 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json index 91d9c8bac..85745f9b4 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 65. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$236CD70F-DEF4-486F-B439-6A3F6D097A9A in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Role of mental imagery in a property verification task: FMRI evidence for perceptual representations of conceptual knowledge (Q38428482).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"a2283a6db5b7ba3008d8e1ba98852b082a610015\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":38428482,\"id\":\"Q38428482\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$236CD70F-DEF4-486F-B439-6A3F6D097A9A\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$236CD70F-DEF4-486F-B439-6A3F6D097A9A", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In 2022, the global total number of persons displaced by disasters was around 8.7 million persons across countries and territories.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In 2022, the global total number of persons displaced by disasters was around 8.7 million persons across countries and territories.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 65", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "52b3cf866b4514a7d0b7a74e18a457ad33bc6fc245acc41e47527db887148c09", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 c5fa10366307ccd7e2c5637d4ea3a63c0ee3e0eda9aba9e6fe1c49309eeb0b6f; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 52b3cf866b4514a7d0b7a74e18a457ad33bc6fc245acc41e47527db887148c09; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3487, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "2ff0f17d706403f0ac836437c2e1145eff3da0f2e36ec32fa5ab298c522fe654", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$236CD70F-DEF4-486F-B439-6A3F6D097A9A in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Role of mental imagery in a property verification task: FMRI evidence for perceptual representations of conceptual knowledge (Q38428482).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$236CD70F-DEF4-486F-B439-6A3F6D097A9A", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In 2022, the global total number of persons displaced by disasters was around 8.7 million persons across countries and territories.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 65", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G04-2026-07-23.svg index 2fb86b990..60edce7d4 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$236CD70F-DEF4-486F-B439-6A3F6D097A9A in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + In 2022, the global total number of persons displaced by disasters was around 8.7 + million persons across countries and territories. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T06-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$236CD70F-DEF4-486F-B439-6A3F6D097A9A - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 65 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json index 43c94a3e5..eeb75a863 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 66. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$0621BB15-D090-4879-92AE-9EF8BA54C07F in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Three parietal circuits for number processing (Q28296068).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"a1c5f9c02c45a61ca755c900b7f3396f8186347c\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":28296068,\"id\":\"Q28296068\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$0621BB15-D090-4879-92AE-9EF8BA54C07F\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$0621BB15-D090-4879-92AE-9EF8BA54C07F", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Migration and Migrants: A Global Overview Displacements in 2022 By the end of 2022, there had been a total of 60.9 million internal displacements, 60 per cent more than in 2021 and the highest figure on record.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Migration and Migrants: A Global Overview Displacements in 2022 By the end of 2022, there had been a total of 60.9 million internal displacements, 60 per cent more than in 2021 and the highest figure on record.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 66", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "0b15c3bfe22071a457ae527b83bb05930350ce74569457dc1374ab0c742cdd47", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 121d9b1a10ca5f84bdf989c2069a4da3cf2e3c0bcc2fd713e48c25679906fc43; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 0b15c3bfe22071a457ae527b83bb05930350ce74569457dc1374ab0c742cdd47; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3488, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "2ff0f17d706403f0ac836437c2e1145eff3da0f2e36ec32fa5ab298c522fe654", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$0621BB15-D090-4879-92AE-9EF8BA54C07F in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Three parietal circuits for number processing (Q28296068).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$0621BB15-D090-4879-92AE-9EF8BA54C07F", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Migration and Migrants: A Global Overview Displacements in 2022 By the end of 2022, there had been a total of 60.9 million internal displacements, 60 per cent more than in 2021 and the highest figure on record.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 66", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G05-2026-07-23.svg index 90ff95546..a8071abf9 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$0621BB15-D090-4879-92AE-9EF8BA54C07F in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + Migration and Migrants: A Global Overview Displacements in 2022 By the end of 2022, + there had been a total of 60.9 million internal displacements, 60 per cent more than Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T06-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$0621BB15-D090-4879-92AE-9EF8BA54C07F - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 66 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json index 647e44c88..7cff14962 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 66. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$360D3CB0-C66A-4B22-A64C-DA3EA4D30451 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Creating number semantics through finger movement perception (Q38376618).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"16ce2846fb78bb62c45ef6f4acd421b99c556ee1\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":38376618,\"id\":\"Q38376618\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$360D3CB0-C66A-4B22-A64C-DA3EA4D30451\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$360D3CB0-C66A-4B22-A64C-DA3EA4D30451", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Of these displacements, 53 per cent (32.6 million) were triggered by disasters and 47 per cent (28.3 million) were caused by conflict and violence.45 In 2022, Ukraine (over 16 million) and the Democratic Republic of the Congo (4 million) topped the list with the highest numbers of displacements caused by conflict and violence, considerably influencing global numbers as a result.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Of these displacements, 53 per cent (32.6 million) were triggered by disasters and 47 per cent (28.3 million) were caused by conflict and violence.45 In 2022, Ukraine (over 16 million) and the Democratic Republic of the Congo (4 million) topped the list with the highest numbers of displacements caused by conflict and violence, considerably influencing global numbers as a result.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 66", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "4801435f1d212846a047ed66d4b271d0c4088304ada2ce72bbe9067ef4a57681", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 f637143dd6bc87e4e250a1fbcaa72c9d92ef42d3d5000a913ba24bac363d64c8; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 4801435f1d212846a047ed66d4b271d0c4088304ada2ce72bbe9067ef4a57681; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3489, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "2ff0f17d706403f0ac836437c2e1145eff3da0f2e36ec32fa5ab298c522fe654", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$360D3CB0-C66A-4B22-A64C-DA3EA4D30451 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Creating number semantics through finger movement perception (Q38376618).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$360D3CB0-C66A-4B22-A64C-DA3EA4D30451", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Of these displacements, 53 per cent (32.6 million) were triggered by disasters and 47 per cent (28.3 million) were caused by conflict and violence.45 In 2022, Ukraine (over 16 million) and the Democratic Republic of the Congo (4 million) topped the list with the highest numbers of displacements caused by conflict and violence, considerably influencing global numbers as a result.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 66", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G06-2026-07-23.svg index 1d8d3dc32..cc66d9505 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$360D3CB0-C66A-4B22-A64C-DA3EA4D30451 in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + Of these displacements, 53 per cent (32.6 million) were triggered by disasters and + 47 per cent (28.3 million) were caused by conflict and violence.45 In 2022, Ukraine Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T06-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$360D3CB0-C66A-4B22-A64C-DA3EA4D30451 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 66 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json index 415d3c137..872c2086f 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 67. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$3D705C20-EC48-41BB-B7CE-DF138A181637 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Embodied cognition and beyond: acting and sensing the body (Q35012834).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"d009bece468ea1a45e3f15dc29580493e9e79f6a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":35012834,\"id\":\"Q35012834\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$3D705C20-EC48-41BB-B7CE-DF138A181637\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$3D705C20-EC48-41BB-B7CE-DF138A181637", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "DTM has been operating since 2004 and by June 2022, operating in more than 120 countries, the DTM had tracked/identified nearly 45 million IDPs, 40.4 million returnees and 6.2 million migrants.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "DTM has been operating since 2004 and by June 2022, operating in more than 120 countries, the DTM had tracked/identified nearly 45 million IDPs, 40.4 million returnees and 6.2 million migrants.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 67", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "3b095ca68d96c9e9d0c2b15f05001c494a15f540afa2717512c4434a8b4bea78", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 92c3894293f40053f953f48ca748c91ee84297cccd273514c93dfe6b247d41ee; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 3b095ca68d96c9e9d0c2b15f05001c494a15f540afa2717512c4434a8b4bea78; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3490, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "2ff0f17d706403f0ac836437c2e1145eff3da0f2e36ec32fa5ab298c522fe654", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$3D705C20-EC48-41BB-B7CE-DF138A181637 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Embodied cognition and beyond: acting and sensing the body (Q35012834).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$3D705C20-EC48-41BB-B7CE-DF138A181637", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "DTM has been operating since 2004 and by June 2022, operating in more than 120 countries, the DTM had tracked/identified nearly 45 million IDPs, 40.4 million returnees and 6.2 million migrants.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 67", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G07-2026-07-23.svg index d6c1406ec..019233690 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$3D705C20-EC48-41BB-B7CE-DF138A181637 in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + DTM has been operating since 2004 and by June 2022, operating in more than 120 + countries, the DTM had tracked/identified nearly 45 million IDPs, 40.4 million Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T06-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$3D705C20-EC48-41BB-B7CE-DF138A181637 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 67 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json index 7e7d47397..e5036face 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 71. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$2DFD3B2C-EC18-45E7-9F62-827411CEDFF5 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Integrating experiential and distributional data to learn semantic representations (Q33484306).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"b5788d9838c0db76b064ddb30aebcdbd0e6e1d32\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":33484306,\"id\":\"Q33484306\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$2DFD3B2C-EC18-45E7-9F62-827411CEDFF5\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$2DFD3B2C-EC18-45E7-9F62-827411CEDFF5", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Chapter 3 is focused primarily at the regional level in order to provide a more detailed picture of migration, which sets out a different but complementary perspective on migrants and movements in different parts of the world.1 Our starting point is geographic, rather than thematic, given that geography is one of the fundamentals underpinning migration today, just as it was in the past.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Chapter 3 is focused primarily at the regional level in order to provide a more detailed picture of migration, which sets out a different but complementary perspective on migrants and movements in different parts of the world.1 Our starting point is geographic, rather than thematic, given that geography is one of the fundamentals underpinning migration today, just as it was in the past.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 71", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "d5cedf745958e839b95e6cade2ebba12d32fbd6eb11273a14233098394e6d228", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 ac907c6aff0f993ac74313e68a41d09b7bfb80a9668c67c2d1e2c25c3e1d3e07; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 d5cedf745958e839b95e6cade2ebba12d32fbd6eb11273a14233098394e6d228; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3491, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "2ff0f17d706403f0ac836437c2e1145eff3da0f2e36ec32fa5ab298c522fe654", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$2DFD3B2C-EC18-45E7-9F62-827411CEDFF5 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Integrating experiential and distributional data to learn semantic representations (Q33484306).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$2DFD3B2C-EC18-45E7-9F62-827411CEDFF5", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Chapter 3 is focused primarily at the regional level in order to provide a more detailed picture of migration, which sets out a different but complementary perspective on migrants and movements in different parts of the world.1 Our starting point is geographic, rather than thematic, given that geography is one of the fundamentals underpinning migration today, just as it was in the past.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 71", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G08-2026-07-23.svg index c6d21f3d3..21475e529 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$2DFD3B2C-EC18-45E7-9F62-827411CEDFF5 in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + Chapter 3 is focused primarily at the regional level in order to provide a more + detailed picture of migration, which sets out a different but complementary Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T06-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$2DFD3B2C-EC18-45E7-9F62-827411CEDFF5 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 71 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json index 04f2cbf28..8d883c43b 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 72. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$BE4A3FEC-9AE5-408C-9464-48D8534DB59C in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Beyond perceptual symbols: a call for representational pluralism. (Q37365995).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"6b979e614e113a3036daa788bcee2836e705162f\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":37365995,\"id\":\"Q37365995\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$BE4A3FEC-9AE5-408C-9464-48D8534DB59C\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$BE4A3FEC-9AE5-408C-9464-48D8534DB59C", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Thematic chapters in this volume may also be of interest, including those on migration and human security, gender and migration, COVID-19 impacts, and recent developments in the global governance of migration.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Thematic chapters in this volume may also be of interest, including those on migration and human security, gender and migration, COVID-19 impacts, and recent developments in the global governance of migration.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 72", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "62873f30643b7256079e8b6137608ae737116a9a2e5be6f95497ad47a3298b92", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 adc6e096eb6a309fb2823cfb73d07440277a71e7057593f6325e6c4b8c3cf675; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 62873f30643b7256079e8b6137608ae737116a9a2e5be6f95497ad47a3298b92; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3492, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "2ff0f17d706403f0ac836437c2e1145eff3da0f2e36ec32fa5ab298c522fe654", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$BE4A3FEC-9AE5-408C-9464-48D8534DB59C in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Beyond perceptual symbols: a call for representational pluralism. (Q37365995).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$BE4A3FEC-9AE5-408C-9464-48D8534DB59C", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Thematic chapters in this volume may also be of interest, including those on migration and human security, gender and migration, COVID-19 impacts, and recent developments in the global governance of migration.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 72", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G09-2026-07-23.svg index 0a7352bec..e367a2688 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$BE4A3FEC-9AE5-408C-9464-48D8534DB59C in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + Thematic chapters in this volume may also be of interest, including those on + migration and human security, gender and migration, COVID-19 impacts, and recent Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T06-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$BE4A3FEC-9AE5-408C-9464-48D8534DB59C - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 72 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json index 06bfb9d22..349ed45b5 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 72. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$10A053A3-4317-4B3E-8793-C20576D3018F in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Processing abstract language modulates motor system activity (Q38390396).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"7d5fdffadfe902bedab63af6ce6b399cbd9ae0b5\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":38390396,\"id\":\"Q38390396\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$10A053A3-4317-4B3E-8793-C20576D3018F\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$10A053A3-4317-4B3E-8793-C20576D3018F", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Since 1990, the number of African migrants living outside of the region has more than doubled, with the growth in Europe most pronounced.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Since 1990, the number of African migrants living outside of the region has more than doubled, with the growth in Europe most pronounced.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 72", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "03a5663820b4adeefa0583ab063748f83a210c4186a1485ac10a6b53e84aaea4", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 9d8b67a8dca953dcf3b046200ef366657f58e179dc81045f8f5eb289fd803dce; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 03a5663820b4adeefa0583ab063748f83a210c4186a1485ac10a6b53e84aaea4; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3493, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "2ff0f17d706403f0ac836437c2e1145eff3da0f2e36ec32fa5ab298c522fe654", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$10A053A3-4317-4B3E-8793-C20576D3018F in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Processing abstract language modulates motor system activity (Q38390396).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$10A053A3-4317-4B3E-8793-C20576D3018F", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Since 1990, the number of African migrants living outside of the region has more than doubled, with the growth in Europe most pronounced.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 72", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G10-2026-07-23.svg index bf2a0cc73..2a2155704 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$10A053A3-4317-4B3E-8793-C20576D3018F in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + Since 1990, the number of African migrants living outside of the region has more + than doubled, with the growth in Europe most pronounced. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T06-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$10A053A3-4317-4B3E-8793-C20576D3018F - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 72 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json index 9281f4ba6..f81cf0415 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 73. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$0A545B0E-FB33-475F-A91C-DBE6C788C03D in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value From grasp to language: embodied concepts and the challenge of abstraction (Q37148792).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"0deb30a914adb09f50cacc43a1a4500abb038be0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":37148792,\"id\":\"Q37148792\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$0A545B0E-FB33-475F-A91C-DBE6C788C03D\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$0A545B0E-FB33-475F-A91C-DBE6C788C03D", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "From 2015 to 2020, the number of migrants born outside the region remained virtually unchanged (around 2 million), most of whom were from Asia and Europe.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "From 2015 to 2020, the number of migrants born outside the region remained virtually unchanged (around 2 million), most of whom were from Asia and Europe.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 73", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "5fda6ef5cc100263d4208664bde1f10e2737a816483b9989cce3cebb5dbb6e9c", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 f2ef66db4b05c1ad159ec1c6b6ec31501c73494fdb5886fa411c761295917b17; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 5fda6ef5cc100263d4208664bde1f10e2737a816483b9989cce3cebb5dbb6e9c; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3494, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "edf060bdfc3b90cef60dc857401c966b333d428ed093f7c6e8fc37b75cb6e366", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$0A545B0E-FB33-475F-A91C-DBE6C788C03D in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value From grasp to language: embodied concepts and the challenge of abstraction (Q37148792).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$0A545B0E-FB33-475F-A91C-DBE6C788C03D", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "From 2015 to 2020, the number of migrants born outside the region remained virtually unchanged (around 2 million), most of whom were from Asia and Europe.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 73", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G01-2026-07-23.svg index cfbb646bc..2e27408ff 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$0A545B0E-FB33-475F-A91C-DBE6C788C03D in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + From 2015 to 2020, the number of migrants born outside the region remained virtually + unchanged (around 2 million), most of whom were from Asia and Europe. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T07-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$0A545B0E-FB33-475F-A91C-DBE6C788C03D - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 73 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json index 75637352f..f69c147f0 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 74. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$CB222FEF-0385-43EC-BB01-02D36420FC1C in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Time (also) flies from left to right (Q40173429).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"f31ccf8d07ca909c66a4a16387732729e96f1b15\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":40173429,\"id\":\"Q40173429\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$CB222FEF-0385-43EC-BB01-02D36420FC1C\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$CB222FEF-0385-43EC-BB01-02D36420FC1C", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "This dynamic is broadly similar in the top 10 origin countries in Africa, apart from Egypt – the top country of origin in the region – which has a far greater share of male emigrants compared to females.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "This dynamic is broadly similar in the top 10 origin countries in Africa, apart from Egypt – the top country of origin in the region – which has a far greater share of male emigrants compared to females.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 74", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "b71fd25089669c55a9852029bb857a3da7592efd2fb3bf2e886c76d9df9ee101", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 e18dcbe25ee73dc0c8a73866b933cd028eb61ab69cfd2a54a121c860a70623ec; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 b71fd25089669c55a9852029bb857a3da7592efd2fb3bf2e886c76d9df9ee101; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3495, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "edf060bdfc3b90cef60dc857401c966b333d428ed093f7c6e8fc37b75cb6e366", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$CB222FEF-0385-43EC-BB01-02D36420FC1C in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Time (also) flies from left to right (Q40173429).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$CB222FEF-0385-43EC-BB01-02D36420FC1C", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "This dynamic is broadly similar in the top 10 origin countries in Africa, apart from Egypt – the top country of origin in the region – which has a far greater share of male emigrants compared to females.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 74", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G02-2026-07-23.svg index abc3693b6..e613b5dc5 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$CB222FEF-0385-43EC-BB01-02D36420FC1C in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + This dynamic is broadly similar in the top 10 origin countries in Africa, apart from + Egypt – the top country of origin in the region – which has a far greater share of Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T07-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$CB222FEF-0385-43EC-BB01-02D36420FC1C - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 74 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json index 5e0e08696..d23af8100 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 75. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$2010A21A-71F8-43A7-BE10-B12BBE3BE08E in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Grounded cognition (Q36913029).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"1aae7a9f3506399e71be8e5240c78432870ece5a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":36913029,\"id\":\"Q36913029\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$2010A21A-71F8-43A7-BE10-B12BBE3BE08E\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$2010A21A-71F8-43A7-BE10-B12BBE3BE08E", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "South Sudan continued to be the country of origin of the largest number of refugees in Africa (around 2.3 million) and ranked fourth globally, after the Syrian Arab Republic, Ukraine and Afghanistan.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "South Sudan continued to be the country of origin of the largest number of refugees in Africa (around 2.3 million) and ranked fourth globally, after the Syrian Arab Republic, Ukraine and Afghanistan.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 75", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "228117b843a4e9110a4a1caa6f1d9ed70bae4ab3e0aa7439dadbc40708eaced2", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 e61c20d7df5b77b351dd955955b0450ac497c44b2fece33ec94dbfb042c7cce2; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 228117b843a4e9110a4a1caa6f1d9ed70bae4ab3e0aa7439dadbc40708eaced2; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3496, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "edf060bdfc3b90cef60dc857401c966b333d428ed093f7c6e8fc37b75cb6e366", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$2010A21A-71F8-43A7-BE10-B12BBE3BE08E in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Grounded cognition (Q36913029).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$2010A21A-71F8-43A7-BE10-B12BBE3BE08E", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "South Sudan continued to be the country of origin of the largest number of refugees in Africa (around 2.3 million) and ranked fourth globally, after the Syrian Arab Republic, Ukraine and Afghanistan.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 75", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G03-2026-07-23.svg index e9510d39d..b962a0190 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$2010A21A-71F8-43A7-BE10-B12BBE3BE08E in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + South Sudan continued to be the country of origin of the largest number of refugees + in Africa (around 2.3 million) and ranked fourth globally, after the Syrian Arab Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T07-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$2010A21A-71F8-43A7-BE10-B12BBE3BE08E - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 75 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json index 49deb0a00..f481a2e5c 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 75. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$F066B2AE-31DE-4F6B-9315-19090851B5AE in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value The future for SNARC could be stark... (Q36702002).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"6fcb042f8d59636d74842fe1ee12e47f733fce2d\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":36702002,\"id\":\"Q36702002\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$F066B2AE-31DE-4F6B-9315-19090851B5AE\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$F066B2AE-31DE-4F6B-9315-19090851B5AE", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The Democratic Republic of the Congo and the Sudan were the origin of the second and third largest number of refugees on the continent (more than 900,000 and over 800,000, respectively).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The Democratic Republic of the Congo and the Sudan were the origin of the second and third largest number of refugees on the continent (more than 900,000 and over 800,000, respectively).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 75", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "b60047d837888eaffe358bb3391f5605baa1f512af0624bb934b2c189681e0a4", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 5e406e40380a9604ce000e7e876be09072c520ace5e5165ff6ed20789c61a7ac; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 b60047d837888eaffe358bb3391f5605baa1f512af0624bb934b2c189681e0a4; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3497, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "edf060bdfc3b90cef60dc857401c966b333d428ed093f7c6e8fc37b75cb6e366", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$F066B2AE-31DE-4F6B-9315-19090851B5AE in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value The future for SNARC could be stark... (Q36702002).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$F066B2AE-31DE-4F6B-9315-19090851B5AE", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The Democratic Republic of the Congo and the Sudan were the origin of the second and third largest number of refugees on the continent (more than 900,000 and over 800,000, respectively).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 75", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G04-2026-07-23.svg index 5978ecc53..823fddd9d 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$F066B2AE-31DE-4F6B-9315-19090851B5AE in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + The Democratic Republic of the Congo and the Sudan were the origin of the second and + third largest number of refugees on the continent (more than 900,000 and over Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T07-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$F066B2AE-31DE-4F6B-9315-19090851B5AE - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 75 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json index b497878e8..b6dade9eb 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 76. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$9FA69FE2-3835-43FE-BF0A-7A11AE0D8A72 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Interactions between number and space in parietal cortex (Q28253939).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"a3f6e9b894564f30da9cd335c48d0185e67a6310\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":28253939,\"id\":\"Q28253939\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$9FA69FE2-3835-43FE-BF0A-7A11AE0D8A72\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$9FA69FE2-3835-43FE-BF0A-7A11AE0D8A72", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The Democratic Republic of the Congo (over 4 million) and Ethiopia (more than 2 million) had the largest internal displacements due to conflict and violence.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The Democratic Republic of the Congo (over 4 million) and Ethiopia (more than 2 million) had the largest internal displacements due to conflict and violence.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 76", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "6dede665e48ddcdb0359730b37cd60ec7632c65e524895bb4d3294419d35a772", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 5f46c14db33c893101003956a4267a1788dce436f4214277350f042184b9e1cd; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 6dede665e48ddcdb0359730b37cd60ec7632c65e524895bb4d3294419d35a772; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3498, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "edf060bdfc3b90cef60dc857401c966b333d428ed093f7c6e8fc37b75cb6e366", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$9FA69FE2-3835-43FE-BF0A-7A11AE0D8A72 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Interactions between number and space in parietal cortex (Q28253939).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$9FA69FE2-3835-43FE-BF0A-7A11AE0D8A72", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The Democratic Republic of the Congo (over 4 million) and Ethiopia (more than 2 million) had the largest internal displacements due to conflict and violence.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 76", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G05-2026-07-23.svg index dbbe46da9..059761c98 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$9FA69FE2-3835-43FE-BF0A-7A11AE0D8A72 in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + The Democratic Republic of the Congo (over 4 million) and Ethiopia (more than 2 + million) had the largest internal displacements due to conflict and violence. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T07-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$9FA69FE2-3835-43FE-BF0A-7A11AE0D8A72 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 76 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json index b11dd2495..7edd66cff 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 76. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$CC890888-973E-4B63-B71A-A19241BEDC33 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value A theory of magnitude: common cortical metrics of time, space and quantity (Q29035915).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"8ad7b43a2ea33e822edf7f47aa165c3cf7085d99\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":29035915,\"id\":\"Q29035915\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$CC890888-973E-4B63-B71A-A19241BEDC33\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$CC890888-973E-4B63-B71A-A19241BEDC33", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The largest disaster displacements were recorded in Nigeria (around 2.4 million), followed by Somalia (1.2 million), Ethiopia (873,000) and South Sudan (596,000).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The largest disaster displacements were recorded in Nigeria (around 2.4 million), followed by Somalia (1.2 million), Ethiopia (873,000) and South Sudan (596,000).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 76", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "aeb86335a554a226bdf2f11d0aa8e28941e632d1b5a6f77b61a71b7d67cc274a", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 5dbadf583f88a2a5a00ded99a02b12618d0784d37a17de488d103a75f0c81aab; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 aeb86335a554a226bdf2f11d0aa8e28941e632d1b5a6f77b61a71b7d67cc274a; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3499, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "edf060bdfc3b90cef60dc857401c966b333d428ed093f7c6e8fc37b75cb6e366", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$CC890888-973E-4B63-B71A-A19241BEDC33 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value A theory of magnitude: common cortical metrics of time, space and quantity (Q29035915).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$CC890888-973E-4B63-B71A-A19241BEDC33", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The largest disaster displacements were recorded in Nigeria (around 2.4 million), followed by Somalia (1.2 million), Ethiopia (873,000) and South Sudan (596,000).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 76", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G06-2026-07-23.svg index eab7b1396..747c6641a 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$CC890888-973E-4B63-B71A-A19241BEDC33 in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + The largest disaster displacements were recorded in Nigeria (around 2.4 million), + followed by Somalia (1.2 million), Ethiopia (873,000) and South Sudan (596,000). Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T07-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$CC890888-973E-4B63-B71A-A19241BEDC33 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 76 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json index bce6d924d..d9c669476 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 77. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$243BA525-62AD-4EFA-A3A3-F7DC2B44153D in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value The roles of body and mind in abstract thought (Q38577105).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"aa833ca460d175e8fc69db169be5b063ce40555f\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":38577105,\"id\":\"Q38577105\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$243BA525-62AD-4EFA-A3A3-F7DC2B44153D\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$243BA525-62AD-4EFA-A3A3-F7DC2B44153D", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Remittances became even more important following the onset of COVID-19, as revenues from tourism – which had long been vital for countries such as Egypt – dried up due to mobility restrictions.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Remittances became even more important following the onset of COVID-19, as revenues from tourism – which had long been vital for countries such as Egypt – dried up due to mobility restrictions.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 77", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "1e75f321934c679c941b77e0d68d7dc300888be9da6b7e1892ec01c0005c46ca", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 2c4770fb440748204ba88b8a20db46d4ccb40638a86aed7276116810783eb43e; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 1e75f321934c679c941b77e0d68d7dc300888be9da6b7e1892ec01c0005c46ca; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3500, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "edf060bdfc3b90cef60dc857401c966b333d428ed093f7c6e8fc37b75cb6e366", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$243BA525-62AD-4EFA-A3A3-F7DC2B44153D in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value The roles of body and mind in abstract thought (Q38577105).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$243BA525-62AD-4EFA-A3A3-F7DC2B44153D", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Remittances became even more important following the onset of COVID-19, as revenues from tourism – which had long been vital for countries such as Egypt – dried up due to mobility restrictions.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 77", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G07-2026-07-23.svg index 0407de524..06e9ed30b 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$243BA525-62AD-4EFA-A3A3-F7DC2B44153D in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + Remittances became even more important following the onset of COVID-19, as revenues + from tourism – which had long been vital for countries such as Egypt – dried up due Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T07-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$243BA525-62AD-4EFA-A3A3-F7DC2B44153D - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 77 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json index 8cafe8aaf..61f721c2e 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 80. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$964921EA-40F0-4637-AD63-49E8DB2CFB92 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Perceptual symbol systems (Q34218379).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"bd7984039b07ca1569d251974ee526761d9d5331\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":34218379,\"id\":\"Q34218379\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$964921EA-40F0-4637-AD63-49E8DB2CFB92\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$964921EA-40F0-4637-AD63-49E8DB2CFB92", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The armed conflict that broke out in the Sudan in April 2023 (see North Africa section) has resulted in significant internal and cross-border displacement, forcing many Sudanese to seek refuge in Eastern African countries such as South Sudan and Ethiopia.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The armed conflict that broke out in the Sudan in April 2023 (see North Africa section) has resulted in significant internal and cross-border displacement, forcing many Sudanese to seek refuge in Eastern African countries such as South Sudan and Ethiopia.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 80", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "851ea7b08a3b1386f0d0ea18af59faf739ab8504c3458b3984ac0c2f6b5ea744", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 b83603ff82ed75a0fd9652d975b3c02c8361acc5246cba2cf45c8d04b0adce32; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 851ea7b08a3b1386f0d0ea18af59faf739ab8504c3458b3984ac0c2f6b5ea744; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3501, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "edf060bdfc3b90cef60dc857401c966b333d428ed093f7c6e8fc37b75cb6e366", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$964921EA-40F0-4637-AD63-49E8DB2CFB92 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Perceptual symbol systems (Q34218379).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$964921EA-40F0-4637-AD63-49E8DB2CFB92", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The armed conflict that broke out in the Sudan in April 2023 (see North Africa section) has resulted in significant internal and cross-border displacement, forcing many Sudanese to seek refuge in Eastern African countries such as South Sudan and Ethiopia.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 80", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G08-2026-07-23.svg index 889a741d7..4f35a9eac 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$964921EA-40F0-4637-AD63-49E8DB2CFB92 in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + The armed conflict that broke out in the Sudan in April 2023 (see North Africa + section) has resulted in significant internal and cross-border displacement, forcing Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T07-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$964921EA-40F0-4637-AD63-49E8DB2CFB92 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 80 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json index ceff8b66b..1ab6c5c71 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 81. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$E43A6941-7B4D-46DB-A425-1C0744E1997F in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Metaphoric structuring: understanding time through spatial metaphors (Q33902167).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"d0d7b401414988c6f7fd7184fb1f270cc623d449\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":33902167,\"id\":\"Q33902167\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$E43A6941-7B4D-46DB-A425-1C0744E1997F\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$E43A6941-7B4D-46DB-A425-1C0744E1997F", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The region faces ongoing crises including climate and environmental degradation, desertification, political and institutional instability, a lack of basic services, intercommunity conflicts between nomadic herders and farmers and the rapid rise of violent extremism.68 The Sahel has long been affected by insecurity, characterized by armed conflict, military clashes and recurrent violence instigated by Islamist groups.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The region faces ongoing crises including climate and environmental degradation, desertification, political and institutional instability, a lack of basic services, intercommunity conflicts between nomadic herders and farmers and the rapid rise of violent extremism.68 The Sahel has long been affected by insecurity, characterized by armed conflict, military clashes and recurrent violence instigated by Islamist groups.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 81", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "e1480fc01d1622139d8fdbbff029d052d850a0970966f97fd58d8cf92447f6f2", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 0e453fa60d6a16048d316914f9718fa8f88cb4f2b91f4da3810ecb995745d5f1; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 e1480fc01d1622139d8fdbbff029d052d850a0970966f97fd58d8cf92447f6f2; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3502, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "edf060bdfc3b90cef60dc857401c966b333d428ed093f7c6e8fc37b75cb6e366", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$E43A6941-7B4D-46DB-A425-1C0744E1997F in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Metaphoric structuring: understanding time through spatial metaphors (Q33902167).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$E43A6941-7B4D-46DB-A425-1C0744E1997F", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The region faces ongoing crises including climate and environmental degradation, desertification, political and institutional instability, a lack of basic services, intercommunity conflicts between nomadic herders and farmers and the rapid rise of violent extremism.68 The Sahel has long been affected by insecurity, characterized by armed conflict, military clashes and recurrent violence instigated by Islamist groups.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 81", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G09-2026-07-23.svg index 7df1d81de..6ee18cf09 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$E43A6941-7B4D-46DB-A425-1C0744E1997F in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + The region faces ongoing crises including climate and environmental degradation, + desertification, political and institutional instability, a lack of basic services, Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T07-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$E43A6941-7B4D-46DB-A425-1C0744E1997F - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 81 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json index 43b54f152..3da97742d 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "migration-services", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 84. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$BCA6BEA0-0E91-48D7-AC4D-298AB96B7E19 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Abstract representations of numbers in the animal and human brain. (Q34751667).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2860\",\"hash\":\"8bae6b443cce2c4172d146a7a2e5fdd3c4359f34\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":34751667,\"id\":\"Q34751667\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"id\":\"Q39849109$BCA6BEA0-0E91-48D7-AC4D-298AB96B7E19\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"21f034bb312d41516f9ea914e41171d2daa7f135\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"420d1d0eee25c4ba44a01f7f6371e8b759e62979\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":229883,\"id\":\"Q229883\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"79219142777a77a0c7573dad60e7b61f3b2e3c1a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"https:\\/\\/eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\\/entrez\\/eutils\\/elink.fcgi?dbfrom=pmc&linkname=pmc_refs_pubmed&retmode=json&id=4606935\",\"type\":\"string\"}}],\"P813\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P813\",\"hash\":\"e69d479a3188566ff91ff915404fb8029fdfefbf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2017-09-22T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":11,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\",\"P813\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2417159511&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q39849109; claims.P2860; statement Q39849109$BCA6BEA0-0E91-48D7-AC4D-298AB96B7E19", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Migration and migrants: Regional dimensions and developments In Asia, the distribution of female and male migrants in the top 10 countries of destination and origin is much more variable compared to Africa.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Migration and migrants: Regional dimensions and developments In Asia, the distribution of female and male migrants in the top 10 countries of destination and origin is much more variable compared to Africa.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 84", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "7fa9daaf66e6c615a54b0e6c42233007cc7ffd33f111d9280c644d80d5d51af8", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2417159511; entity Q39849109; source SHA-256 6e8bab548065713bf059046ba4135fa83542487c697f168c86730fd56f14b32c; statement SHA-256 919bea4b680344638d4eb01cb4932e6ccf9f2c21c5aa48a48f24227a0a916b65; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 81bea6186fe482dd87ebf8950cf4c0fb6149537eb5c520b951744770c463028f; quote SHA-256 7fa9daaf66e6c615a54b0e6c42233007cc7ffd33f111d9280c644d80d5d51af8; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 3503, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "edf060bdfc3b90cef60dc857401c966b333d428ed093f7c6e8fc37b75cb6e366", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q39849109$BCA6BEA0-0E91-48D7-AC4D-298AB96B7E19 in revision 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) publishes cites work (P2860) with value Abstract representations of numbers in the animal and human brain. (Q34751667).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q39849109$BCA6BEA0-0E91-48D7-AC4D-298AB96B7E19", - "candidate_definition": "Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses (Q39849109) / P2860", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z", - "target_definition": "Migration services" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Migration and migrants: Regional dimensions and developments In Asia, the distribution of female and male migrants in the top 10 countries of destination and origin is much more variable compared to Africa.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 84", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G10-2026-07-23.svg index 17b3fb018..6b3c5a00a 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q39849109$BCA6BEA0-0E91-48D7-AC4D-298AB96B7E19 in revision - 2417159511 asserts that Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor + Migration and migrants: Regional dimensions and developments In Asia, the + distribution of female and male migrants in the top 10 countries of destination and Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM050-T07-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + IOM World Migration Report 2024 + https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4046958 Target / Candidate - Migration services - Processing time shifts affects the execution of motor responses + IOM World Migration Report 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2417159511 at 2025-10-16T16:00:18Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q39849109$BCA6BEA0-0E91-48D7-AC4D-298AB96B7E19 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 84 + artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched IOM World Migration Report 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently + establish the statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (IOM World Migration Report 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a diff --git a/docs/registry/evidence_index.json b/docs/registry/evidence_index.json index 3cc05166b..65b1d8b3f 100644 --- a/docs/registry/evidence_index.json +++ b/docs/registry/evidence_index.json @@ -58368,15 +58368,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G01", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58385,15 +58385,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G02", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58402,15 +58402,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G03", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58419,15 +58419,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G04", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58436,15 +58436,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G05", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58453,15 +58453,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G06", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58470,15 +58470,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G07", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58487,15 +58487,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G08", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58504,15 +58504,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G09", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58521,15 +58521,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T01-G10", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t01_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T01-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58538,15 +58538,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G01", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58555,15 +58555,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G02", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58572,15 +58572,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G03", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58589,15 +58589,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G04", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58606,15 +58606,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G05", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58623,15 +58623,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G06", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58640,15 +58640,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G07", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58657,15 +58657,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G08", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58674,15 +58674,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G09", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58691,15 +58691,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T02-G10", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t02_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T02-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58708,15 +58708,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G01", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58725,15 +58725,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G02", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58742,15 +58742,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G03", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58759,15 +58759,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G04", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58776,15 +58776,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G05", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58793,15 +58793,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G06", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58810,15 +58810,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G07", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58827,15 +58827,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G08", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58844,15 +58844,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G09", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58861,15 +58861,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T03-G10", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58878,15 +58878,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G01", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58895,15 +58895,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G02", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58912,15 +58912,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G03", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58929,15 +58929,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G04", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58946,15 +58946,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G05", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58963,15 +58963,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G06", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58980,15 +58980,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G07", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -58997,15 +58997,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G08", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59014,15 +59014,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G09", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59031,15 +59031,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T04-G10", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59048,15 +59048,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G01", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59065,15 +59065,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G02", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59082,15 +59082,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G03", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59099,15 +59099,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G04", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59116,15 +59116,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G05", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59133,15 +59133,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G06", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59150,15 +59150,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G07", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59167,15 +59167,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G08", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59184,15 +59184,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G09", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59201,15 +59201,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T05-G10", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59218,15 +59218,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G01", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59235,15 +59235,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G02", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59252,15 +59252,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G03", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59269,15 +59269,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G04", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59286,15 +59286,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G05", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59303,15 +59303,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G06", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59320,15 +59320,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G07", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59337,15 +59337,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G08", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59354,15 +59354,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G09", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59371,15 +59371,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T06-G10", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59388,15 +59388,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G01", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59405,15 +59405,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G02", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59422,15 +59422,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G03", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59439,15 +59439,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G04", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59456,15 +59456,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G05", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59473,15 +59473,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G06", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59490,15 +59490,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G07", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59507,15 +59507,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G08", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59524,15 +59524,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G09", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -59541,15 +59541,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM050-T07-G10", "domain": "migration-services", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "IOM World Migration Report 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom050_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM050-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -137348,9 +137348,9 @@ "workplace-safety": 70 }, "by_record_type": { - "evidence_result": 3644, + "evidence_result": 3574, "reproduction_attempt": 14, - "source_audit": 4414 + "source_audit": 4484 }, "by_result_status": { "BLOCKED_SOURCE": 17, @@ -137415,6 +137415,7 @@ "IMF Fiscal Monitor, April 2024: Fiscal Policy in the Great Election Year": 70, "IMF Global Financial Stability Report, April 2024: The Last Mile": 70, "IMF Global Financial Stability Report, October 2024: Steadying the Course": 70, + "IOM World Migration Report 2024": 70, "Implementing the OECD Recommendation on Public Procurement in OECD and Partner Countries: 2020-2024 Report": 70, "International IDEA Global State of Democracy 2024": 70, "NASA 2001 Mars Odyssey official page": 10, @@ -137523,7 +137524,6 @@ "Wikidata revision 1363413822 (Q105545706)": 2, "Wikidata revision 1489970417 (Q5327099)": 6, "Wikidata revision 1494865887 (Q108468468)": 9, - "Wikidata revision 1549544926 (Q34398219)": 8, "Wikidata revision 1600777506 (Q8035055)": 1, "Wikidata revision 1618931734 (Q74526403)": 6, "Wikidata revision 1618965769 (Q59355769)": 7, @@ -137634,11 +137634,8 @@ "Wikidata revision 2402855165 (Q1285336)": 7, "Wikidata revision 2404796084 (Q136270441)": 2, "Wikidata revision 2406759491 (Q57112916)": 11, - "Wikidata revision 2407325716 (Q52222645)": 10, - "Wikidata revision 2407325813 (Q52058308)": 10, "Wikidata revision 2411050244 (Q19760149)": 7, "Wikidata revision 2415513399 (Q98089670)": 7, - "Wikidata revision 2417159511 (Q39849109)": 23, "Wikidata revision 2419900028 (Q115460408)": 10, "Wikidata revision 2426845087 (Q126664050)": 19, "Wikidata revision 2427280173 (Q130562079)": 8, @@ -137648,9 +137645,7 @@ "Wikidata revision 2432947582 (Q122764321)": 9, "Wikidata revision 2433083121 (Q121086261)": 14, "Wikidata revision 2433258127 (Q126486653)": 13, - "Wikidata revision 2433263531 (Q121831837)": 8, "Wikidata revision 2433387673 (Q136871851)": 6, - "Wikidata revision 2433564944 (Q117348262)": 11, "Wikidata revision 2433747666 (Q20664888)": 6, "Wikidata revision 2435609886 (Q58244285)": 10, "Wikidata revision 2435843880 (Q28452792)": 4,