From f52d589adcca9129b1b672956e569f60e32095b0 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: "Rost S." <63606118+NeoZorK@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Mon, 17 Aug 2026 17:51:07 +0300 Subject: [PATCH] evidence: complete DOM036 to 70 pension source claims --- artifacts/cb7k_dom036_append_inventory.json | 29 ++ artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json | 79 ++++ artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json | 79 ++++ artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json | 79 ++++ artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json | 79 ++++ artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json | 79 ++++ ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- ...MBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json | 66 +-- ...IMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10-2026-07-23.svg | 32 +- docs/registry/evidence_index.json | 407 +++++++++--------- 107 files changed, 3127 insertions(+), 2604 deletions(-) create mode 100644 artifacts/cb7k_dom036_append_inventory.json create mode 100644 artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json create mode 100644 artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json create mode 100644 artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json create mode 100644 artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json create mode 100644 artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom036_append_inventory.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom036_append_inventory.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e0a731f52 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom036_append_inventory.json @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-source-inventory-v1", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "scope": "DOM036 pensions append: 50 additional primary-source public statements", + "claim_boundary": "Inventory acceptance proves only that the named public PDF was fetched with the recorded SHA-256 and yielded extractable text. It does not approve a claim or establish the truth of statements in the source.", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "already_registered_primary_claims": 4484, + "remaining_claims": 50, + "expected_total_primary_claims": 4534, + "sources": [{ + "domain_code": "DOM036", + "domain_title": "Pensions", + "remaining_target": 50, + "start_index": 21, + "source_subdir": "dom036", + "source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "pdf_pages": 200, + "content_start_page": 9, + "content_end_page": 200, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "min_quote_characters": 60, + "min_quote_words": 10, + "reject_pattern": "Figure \\\\d|Table \\\\d|Source:|Note:|Acknowledg|References|(?-i:^[a-z])" + }] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..21cef352b --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 11", + "public_claim_text": "In advanced economies, pension assets have nearly doubled as a share of GDP to an average of 55%, exceeding 100% of GDP in eight countries.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In advanced economies, pension assets have nearly doubled as a share of GDP to an average of 55%, exceeding 100% of GDP in eight countries." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 11", + "public_claim_text": "With total assets over USD 56 trillion, pension funds are also the largest investors in global capital markets, including public equity and debt markets as well as emerging private capital markets.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "With total assets over USD 56 trillion, pension funds are also the largest investors in global capital markets, including public equity and debt markets as well as emerging private capital markets." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 12", + "public_claim_text": "Equity investments account for more than 40% in 13 out of 38 countries, while they are less than 20% in only 7 countries.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Equity investments account for more than 40% in 13 out of 38 countries, while they are less than 20% in only 7 countries." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 14", + "public_claim_text": "The OECD Pension Markets in Focus 2024 provides detailed country-specific notes and information on the plans covered by the data.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The OECD Pension Markets in Focus 2024 provides detailed country-specific notes and information on the plans covered by the data." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 18", + "public_claim_text": "Since 2015, many countries have increased the value of financial incentives for retirement savings to increase the role that asset-backed pension plans are expected to play in financing retirement income.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Since 2015, many countries have increased the value of financial incentives for retirement savings to increase the role that asset-backed pension plans are expected to play in financing retirement income." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 21", + "public_claim_text": "Using historical returns on selected asset classes, the chapter shows that over 80% of cohorts across 19 OECD countries would have accumulated more assets at retirement had they invested at least part of their retirement savings for 40 years in a mix of domestic and foreign equities instead of only investing in domestic fixed income securities (government bonds plus cash and deposits).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Using historical returns on selected asset classes, the chapter shows that over 80% of cohorts across 19 OECD countries would have accumulated more assets at retirement had they invested at least part of their retirement savings for 40 years in a mix of domestic and foreign equities instead of only investing in domestic fixed income securities (government bonds plus cash and deposits)." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 22", + "public_claim_text": "In contrast, the first column shows that the fixed-income portfolio would produce a higher replacement rate than the other strategies with a probability of no more than 13%.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In contrast, the first column shows that the fixed-income portfolio would produce a higher replacement rate than the other strategies with a probability of no more than 13%." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 22", + "public_claim_text": "Cohorts saving for 20 years instead of 40 would accumulate less in all investment strategies, with a much larger difference for portfolios fully invested in diversified equities compared to other investment strategies.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Cohorts saving for 20 years instead of 40 would accumulate less in all investment strategies, with a much larger difference for portfolios fully invested in diversified equities compared to other investment strategies." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 23", + "public_claim_text": "By contrast, there is a 60% probability of getting higher replacement rates when staying invested fully in equities during the payout phase and taking regular drawdowns instead of buying a lifelong annuity at retirement.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "By contrast, there is a 60% probability of getting higher replacement rates when staying invested fully in equities during the payout phase and taking regular drawdowns instead of buying a lifelong annuity at retirement." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 23", + "public_claim_text": "For example, the reduction in equity exposure may start in the last 10 years before retirement when participants are planning to take an annuity.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "For example, the reduction in equity exposure may start in the last 10 years before retirement when participants are planning to take an annuity." + } + ] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6107eea61 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 29", + "public_claim_text": "Family members managing the estate normally have around 12 months to manage selling the home, and the grace period can be extended in the event of departure due to long-term care needs to allow more time to sort out the financial situation of the occupant.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Family members managing the estate normally have around 12 months to manage selling the home, and the grace period can be extended in the event of departure due to long-term care needs to allow more time to sort out the financial situation of the occupant." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 29", + "public_claim_text": "Limits are lower for younger borrowers, say 15% of the home value of someone aged 60, increasing up to around 50% for older borrowers aged 80 and over.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Limits are lower for younger borrowers, say 15% of the home value of someone aged 60, increasing up to around 50% for older borrowers aged 80 and over." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 34", + "public_claim_text": "The chapter describes in Section 2.1 the different models of multi-employer pension arrangements and their management and governance structures.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The chapter describes in Section 2.1 the different models of multi-employer pension arrangements and their management and governance structures." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 34", + "public_claim_text": "Section 2.2 analyses which employers and workers may have access to these arrangements, while Section 2.3 describes the onboarding process for employers.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Section 2.2 analyses which employers and workers may have access to these arrangements, while Section 2.3 describes the onboarding process for employers." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 39", + "public_claim_text": "In Canada, pooled registered pension plans were introduced in 2012 to make it easier for employers not already offering an occupational pension plan to do so.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Canada, pooled registered pension plans were introduced in 2012 to make it easier for employers not already offering an occupational pension plan to do so." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 39", + "public_claim_text": "The latest version of multiple-employer pension plans, called pooled employer plans, was introduced in 2021 and is accessible to any employer.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The latest version of multiple-employer pension plans, called pooled employer plans, was introduced in 2021 and is accessible to any employer." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 41", + "public_claim_text": "In Norway, KLP is the pension provider for local government employees and was jointly created in 1949 by the Union of Norwegian Cities and the Norwegian Association of Rural Municipalities.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Norway, KLP is the pension provider for local government employees and was jointly created in 1949 by the Union of Norwegian Cities and the Norwegian Association of Rural Municipalities." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 42", + "public_claim_text": "While 85% of pension funds provide the possibility of voluntary continuation in the pension scheme for the self-employed, two barriers may prevent take-up: the application and the voluntary continuation of contributions must be made shortly after termination of the employment contract (within 9 months and 15 months, respectively), and the self-employed must pay the sum of employee and employer contributions.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "While 85% of pension funds provide the possibility of voluntary continuation in the pension scheme for the self-employed, two barriers may prevent take-up: the application and the voluntary continuation of contributions must be made shortly after termination of the employment contract (within 9 months and 15 months, respectively), and the self-employed must pay the sum of employee and employer contributions." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 43", + "public_claim_text": "When an employer selects Nest for its enrolment duties, signing up with it is straightforward.9 The employer first needs to create an online Nest account and then complete five tasks: 1.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "When an employer selects Nest for its enrolment duties, signing up with it is straightforward.9 The employer first needs to create an online Nest account and then complete five tasks: 1." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 43", + "public_claim_text": "In Denmark, PensionDanmark is the pension provider for all blue-collar workers covered by a collective agreement and around 80% of its active members work in companies with less than 10 employees.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Denmark, PensionDanmark is the pension provider for all blue-collar workers covered by a collective agreement and around 80% of its active members work in companies with less than 10 employees." + } + ] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7c7f7f703 --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 45", + "public_claim_text": "This is the case for instance in the United States for multiple employer plans, which may lose their tax-qualified status if only one employer is not compliant.13 Multi-employer pension arrangements established through collective agreements between social partners may raise fairness issues.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "This is the case for instance in the United States for multiple employer plans, which may lose their tax-qualified status if only one employer is not compliant.13 Multi-employer pension arrangements established through collective agreements between social partners may raise fairness issues." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 46", + "public_claim_text": "Even though the transition to a master trust is smooth for most pension plans, those with complex assets or benefit structures may be difficult to replicate in a master trust.15 Moreover, employer inertia may limit the development of master trusts as employers may lack good understanding of the new governance requirements and may not realise that a master trust could be more cost-effective for their plan.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Even though the transition to a master trust is smooth for most pension plans, those with complex assets or benefit structures may be difficult to replicate in a master trust.15 Moreover, employer inertia may limit the development of master trusts as employers may lack good understanding of the new governance requirements and may not realise that a master trust could be more cost-effective for their plan." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 52", + "public_claim_text": "Since 2015, many countries have increased financial incentives for retirement savings as asset-backed pension plans are expected to play an increasing role in financing retirement income.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Since 2015, many countries have increased financial incentives for retirement savings as asset-backed pension plans are expected to play an increasing role in financing retirement income." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 56", + "public_claim_text": "Tax credits can be found in Belgium (with a credit rate of 30%), Estonia (20%), Israel (35%), Korea (13.2% or 16.5% for lower earners) and the United States (0% to 50% depending on income).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Tax credits can be found in Belgium (with a credit rate of 30%), Estonia (20%), Israel (35%), Korea (13.2% or 16.5% for lower earners) and the United States (0% to 50% depending on income)." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 56", + "public_claim_text": "For example, in Australia, employer contributions to superannuation accounts are taxed at the fixed rate of 15% for most employees.5 As this rate is usually lower than their marginal tax rate, most individuals benefit from a tax rate relief on their contributions.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "For example, in Australia, employer contributions to superannuation accounts are taxed at the fixed rate of 15% for most employees.5 As this rate is usually lower than their marginal tax rate, most individuals benefit from a tax rate relief on their contributions." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 57", + "public_claim_text": "At the other extreme, contributions attracting tax relief are capped at 100% of income in the United Kingdom and the United States.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "At the other extreme, contributions attracting tax relief are capped at 100% of income in the United Kingdom and the United States." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 57", + "public_claim_text": "For example, in Belgium, contributions up to 3% of gross salary are eligible for the tax credit in VAPW plans, while contributions up to 9.4% of professional income are deductible from professional income for the self-employed in social VAPZ plans.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "For example, in Belgium, contributions up to 3% of gross salary are eligible for the tax credit in VAPW plans, while contributions up to 9.4% of professional income are deductible from professional income for the self-employed in social VAPZ plans." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 58", + "public_claim_text": "Maximum limit on contributions attracting tax relief expressed as a fixed amount, 2023 As a percentage of the average wage in the economy in 2022 Notes: Countries in the left panel have limits above 80% of the average wage.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Maximum limit on contributions attracting tax relief expressed as a fixed amount, 2023 As a percentage of the average wage in the economy in 2022 Notes: Countries in the left panel have limits above 80% of the average wage." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 58", + "public_claim_text": "In Italy, employees can recoup the unused annual tax relief of their first years of participation during the following 20 years, up to 50% of the maximum annual relief per year.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Italy, employees can recoup the unused annual tax relief of their first years of participation during the following 20 years, up to 50% of the maximum annual relief per year." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 60", + "public_claim_text": "Only 12 OECD countries tax investment income at least for selected pension plans.13 In Belgium, investment income is only taxed when the yearly investment return exceeds the guaranteed return, and the individual is granted a share of the excess return.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Only 12 OECD countries tax investment income at least for selected pension plans.13 In Belgium, investment income is only taxed when the yearly investment return exceeds the guaranteed return, and the individual is granted a share of the excess return." + } + ] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3b125894d --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 60", + "public_claim_text": "A fixed tax rate applies to investment income in Australia (15%), Denmark (15.3%), Greece (5%), Latvia (10%), the Slovak Republic (19%) and Sweden (15%).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "A fixed tax rate applies to investment income in Australia (15%), Denmark (15.3%), Greece (5%), Latvia (10%), the Slovak Republic (19%) and Sweden (15%)." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 61", + "public_claim_text": "For example, in Australia, pensions are taxed at the individual’s marginal tax rate before the preservation age, there is a 15% tax offset between the preservation age and 59 years old, and pensions are tax free from age 60.14 Other countries discouraging early withdrawals with the tax system include Belgium, Denmark, Estonia, France, Italy, Lithuania, Türkiye, the United Kingdom and the United States.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "For example, in Australia, pensions are taxed at the individual’s marginal tax rate before the preservation age, there is a 15% tax offset between the preservation age and 59 years old, and pensions are tax free from age 60.14 Other countries discouraging early withdrawals with the tax system include Belgium, Denmark, Estonia, France, Italy, Lithuania, Türkiye, the United Kingdom and the United States." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 61", + "public_claim_text": "Finally, only Ireland taxes the total amount of funds accumulated at the point of retirement once it exceeds a certain limit.15 The limit has been set at EUR 2 million since 1 January 2014.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Finally, only Ireland taxes the total amount of funds accumulated at the point of retirement once it exceeds a certain limit.15 The limit has been set at EUR 2 million since 1 January 2014." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 62", + "public_claim_text": "The generosity of the match rate varies greatly across countries, from 4.25% in Austria to 325% in Mexico (solidarity savings programme for civil servants).16 The most common match rates are 20% (Colombia, Czechia, Hungary) and 50% (Australia, Chile, New Zealand).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The generosity of the match rate varies greatly across countries, from 4.25% in Austria to 325% in Mexico (solidarity savings programme for civil servants).16 The most common match rates are 20% (Colombia, Czechia, Hungary) and 50% (Australia, Chile, New Zealand)." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 63", + "public_claim_text": "In Lithuania, the government contributes 1.5% of the average gross salary of the year before the last in the account of people who have children up to three years old and who receive maternity benefits.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Lithuania, the government contributes 1.5% of the average gross salary of the year before the last in the account of people who have children up to three years old and who receive maternity benefits." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 64", + "public_claim_text": "In Italy for instance, employer contributions are subject to a rate of 10% instead of the standard 24% rate, on earnings up to a ceiling.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Italy for instance, employer contributions are subject to a rate of 10% instead of the standard 24% rate, on earnings up to a ceiling." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 65", + "public_claim_text": "In Korea, charges for the Wage Claim Guarantee Fund are reduced by up to 50% if employers set up occupational pension plans rather than severance payment schemes.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Korea, charges for the Wage Claim Guarantee Fund are reduced by up to 50% if employers set up occupational pension plans rather than severance payment schemes." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 66", + "public_claim_text": "The United Kingdom eliminated the tax charge that applied when an individual had built up pension savings worth more than the lifetime allowance as of the tax year 2023/24.23 It also increased in 2021 the income limit from which the annual allowance is reduced, from GBP 150 000 to GBP 240 000.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The United Kingdom eliminated the tax charge that applied when an individual had built up pension savings worth more than the lifetime allowance as of the tax year 2023/24.23 It also increased in 2021 the income limit from which the annual allowance is reduced, from GBP 150 000 to GBP 240 000." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 66", + "public_claim_text": "Finally, in Italy, returns on new investment in stocks of Italian and European companies made since 2017 are tax free (instead of a standard tax rate of 20%) if the securities are held for at least five years.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Finally, in Italy, returns on new investment in stocks of Italian and European companies made since 2017 are tax free (instead of a standard tax rate of 20%) if the securities are held for at least five years." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 67", + "public_claim_text": "The extra exemptions were further increased in to 32% and 12% respectively, meaning that 132% or 112% of contributions are tax exempted instead of 100%.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The extra exemptions were further increased in to 32% and 12% respectively, meaning that 132% or 112% of contributions are tax exempted instead of 100%." + } + ] +} diff --git a/artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json b/artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..db28d7b8e --- /dev/null +++ b/artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "schema_version": "claimbound-primary-public-claim-group-v1", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "review_design": "retrospective deterministic source-publication audit; not preregistered, not an independent fact-check, and not an independent reproduction", + "operator": "NeoZorK", + "source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "raw_payload_committed": false, + "text_extractor": "pdfplumber", + "independent_text_extractor": "pypdf", + "selection_method": "Deterministic sentence extraction with minimum length and prose-quality filters, signal scoring, duplicate removal, and per-page concentration limits.", + "verification_rule": "Extract PDF text with the selecting extractor and an independent extractor, compare each quote after removing layout whitespace and hyphens, require every quote once or more in both extractions, and require the complete fetched PDF SHA-256 to match.", + "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", + "records": [ + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01", + "section_locator": "PDF page 67", + "public_claim_text": "Australia, Chile, France, Iceland, Spain, Portugal, and the United States allowed special early access to retirement savings in 2020 and beyond in order to provide short-term relief for members affected by the COVID-19 crisis.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Australia, Chile, France, Iceland, Spain, Portugal, and the United States allowed special early access to retirement savings in 2020 and beyond in order to provide short-term relief for members affected by the COVID-19 crisis." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02", + "section_locator": "PDF page 68", + "public_claim_text": "In Hungary, since 2019, employer contributions to voluntary pension funds and to institutions for occupational retirement provisions are considered taxable income for the employee.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Hungary, since 2019, employer contributions to voluntary pension funds and to institutions for occupational retirement provisions are considered taxable income for the employee." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03", + "section_locator": "PDF page 70", + "public_claim_text": "In Türkiye, individuals receive government matching contributions and fixed nominal subsidies, and the tax rate on investment income may be as low as 5% if the individual withdraws benefits from age 56 after at least 10 years of participation in the pension plan.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Türkiye, individuals receive government matching contributions and fixed nominal subsidies, and the tax rate on investment income may be as low as 5% if the individual withdraws benefits from age 56 after at least 10 years of participation in the pension plan." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04", + "section_locator": "PDF page 71", + "public_claim_text": "Indeed, the OFE plans, to which the “EET” tax treatment applies, are losing importance as participation is no longer mandatory since 2014.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Indeed, the OFE plans, to which the “EET” tax treatment applies, are losing importance as participation is no longer mandatory since 2014." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05", + "section_locator": "PDF page 71", + "public_claim_text": "Meanwhile, employees have been enrolled automatically into PPK plans since 2019, and the applicable tax regime is “TEE”.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Meanwhile, employees have been enrolled automatically into PPK plans since 2019, and the applicable tax regime is “TEE”." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06", + "section_locator": "PDF page 72", + "public_claim_text": "For example, in Lithuania, pension benefits from third pillar pension funds are taxed at 15% if the pension contract lasted less than five years or if the individual is more than five years before the statutory age of retirement.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "For example, in Lithuania, pension benefits from third pillar pension funds are taxed at 15% if the pension contract lasted less than five years or if the individual is more than five years before the statutory age of retirement." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07", + "section_locator": "PDF page 72", + "public_claim_text": "For example, in Czechia, annuities and programmed withdrawals paid over at least 10 years are tax free, while lump sums and programmed withdrawals over shorter periods are taxable.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "For example, in Czechia, annuities and programmed withdrawals paid over at least 10 years are tax free, while lump sums and programmed withdrawals over shorter periods are taxable." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08", + "section_locator": "PDF page 73", + "public_claim_text": "The 30% tax credit was, therefore, more advantageous than a tax deduction for the lower earners, but less advantageous for the higher earners.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The 30% tax credit was, therefore, more advantageous than a tax deduction for the lower earners, but less advantageous for the higher earners." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09", + "section_locator": "PDF page 74", + "public_claim_text": "In addition, individuals must be younger than 71, at least 10% of their total income must be from employment or business, and their total superannuation balance must be less than the general transfer balance cap on 30 June of the previous financial year.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In addition, individuals must be younger than 71, at least 10% of their total income must be from employment or business, and their total superannuation balance must be less than the general transfer balance cap on 30 June of the previous financial year." + }, + { + "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10", + "section_locator": "PDF page 74", + "public_claim_text": "Individuals paying personal income tax at a higher rate (40% or 45%) can claim the difference through their tax return or by calling or writing to His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Individuals paying personal income tax at a higher rate (40% or 45%) can claim the difference through their tax return or by calling or writing to His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs." + } + ] +} diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json index 70f2b0339..1f197de89 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 11. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$942CD15B-9D37-40EE-A693-35DEF8E94D2F in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Trustee (Authorised Investments) Order, 1998 (Q100581015).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"d4dab9cfb1d604f75d94897d609c9a17bade9b76\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100581015,\"id\":\"Q100581015\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"54689e87cdcaf5a15252503de7640bab54d4911a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+1998-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$942CD15B-9D37-40EE-A693-35DEF8E94D2F\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$942CD15B-9D37-40EE-A693-35DEF8E94D2F", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In advanced economies, pension assets have nearly doubled as a share of GDP to an average of 55%, exceeding 100% of GDP in eight countries.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In advanced economies, pension assets have nearly doubled as a share of GDP to an average of 55%, exceeding 100% of GDP in eight countries.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 11", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "af04e8b76bcb5617391254421d0ebfe4f4ab7f31b8dac1cdca1f8a6bf743e479", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 e20c668f97f09bde078bdfed03bf5266389f99f8952856ce36e30bbf8bbc7265; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 af04e8b76bcb5617391254421d0ebfe4f4ab7f31b8dac1cdca1f8a6bf743e479; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2474, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3afd60bd9ccd9020163cc7583ebd9d0359d8c302c0483b8d81d10a4f5af1e039", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$942CD15B-9D37-40EE-A693-35DEF8E94D2F in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Trustee (Authorised Investments) Order, 1998 (Q100581015).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$942CD15B-9D37-40EE-A693-35DEF8E94D2F", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In advanced economies, pension assets have nearly doubled as a share of GDP to an average of 55%, exceeding 100% of GDP in eight countries.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 11", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01-2026-07-23.svg index 86add1eb1..245a81d90 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$942CD15B-9D37-40EE-A693-35DEF8E94D2F in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + In advanced economies, pension assets have nearly doubled as a share of GDP to an + average of 55%, exceeding 100% of GDP in eight countries. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$942CD15B-9D37-40EE-A693-35DEF8E94D2F - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 11 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json index eb13c2b67..80850dcfd 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 11. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$0A79431D-5F98-4F7E-B5A4-DBE570930F6E in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Finance (Transfer of Departmental Administration and Ministerial Functions) Order 2011 (Q100549342).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"5e36a4397f7d902176c96781d9db4ff86b2c96a1\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100549342,\"id\":\"Q100549342\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"1277780215cd5ca03e85ca9c50830783b4fedfe1\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2011-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$0A79431D-5F98-4F7E-B5A4-DBE570930F6E\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$0A79431D-5F98-4F7E-B5A4-DBE570930F6E", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "With total assets over USD 56 trillion, pension funds are also the largest investors in global capital markets, including public equity and debt markets as well as emerging private capital markets.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "With total assets over USD 56 trillion, pension funds are also the largest investors in global capital markets, including public equity and debt markets as well as emerging private capital markets.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 11", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "3ec0dd21244e6dd134b68fe66aa7ccbcd62f81f00cc700ed2d3418de051ec16b", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 1fde09e3f2cacc24420109967883ff2860e9735ea9ed58d2e5d553358001ee84; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 3ec0dd21244e6dd134b68fe66aa7ccbcd62f81f00cc700ed2d3418de051ec16b; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2475, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3afd60bd9ccd9020163cc7583ebd9d0359d8c302c0483b8d81d10a4f5af1e039", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$0A79431D-5F98-4F7E-B5A4-DBE570930F6E in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Finance (Transfer of Departmental Administration and Ministerial Functions) Order 2011 (Q100549342).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$0A79431D-5F98-4F7E-B5A4-DBE570930F6E", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "With total assets over USD 56 trillion, pension funds are also the largest investors in global capital markets, including public equity and debt markets as well as emerging private capital markets.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 11", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02-2026-07-23.svg index 8a8684899..5f75428a4 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$0A79431D-5F98-4F7E-B5A4-DBE570930F6E in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + With total assets over USD 56 trillion, pension funds are also the largest investors + in global capital markets, including public equity and debt markets as well as Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$0A79431D-5F98-4F7E-B5A4-DBE570930F6E - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 11 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json index afe5ef312..ff298fce2 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 12. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$395471A4-7A59-4DB6-8F52-2A75BACC7B0D in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Education and Training Boards Act, 2013 (Q100400100).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"0896d929e7ed64e6f31082eecc76b73c425f15dd\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100400100,\"id\":\"Q100400100\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"1e2a78761fecc9e5ba1ba772d86ba7dbf29fe467\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2013-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$395471A4-7A59-4DB6-8F52-2A75BACC7B0D\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$395471A4-7A59-4DB6-8F52-2A75BACC7B0D", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Equity investments account for more than 40% in 13 out of 38 countries, while they are less than 20% in only 7 countries.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Equity investments account for more than 40% in 13 out of 38 countries, while they are less than 20% in only 7 countries.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 12", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "7fe12a440a1b4e6ea7585b6f6d662644bac7896d23e3ba679d5fc15fa4bbf3ce", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 06cc016f8b6e107ec2f4b7274c70e9f8449cf64e4640cba357dddbafbc7344cd; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 7fe12a440a1b4e6ea7585b6f6d662644bac7896d23e3ba679d5fc15fa4bbf3ce; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2476, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3afd60bd9ccd9020163cc7583ebd9d0359d8c302c0483b8d81d10a4f5af1e039", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$395471A4-7A59-4DB6-8F52-2A75BACC7B0D in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Education and Training Boards Act, 2013 (Q100400100).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$395471A4-7A59-4DB6-8F52-2A75BACC7B0D", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Equity investments account for more than 40% in 13 out of 38 countries, while they are less than 20% in only 7 countries.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 12", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03-2026-07-23.svg index aad87f99f..7dc185591 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$395471A4-7A59-4DB6-8F52-2A75BACC7B0D in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + Equity investments account for more than 40% in 13 out of 38 countries, while they + are less than 20% in only 7 countries. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$395471A4-7A59-4DB6-8F52-2A75BACC7B0D - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 12 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json index 10149c64f..c81c9f969 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 14. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$E42EFC1E-FA99-4DDD-BB13-0834AB81E103 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare and Pensions Act, 2012 (Q100400049).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"e8f0d0deccf3ffde1caf549ac47601d486d56d68\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100400049,\"id\":\"Q100400049\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"8f3565657428592dc1dd7f92da0f734724d987d7\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2012-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$E42EFC1E-FA99-4DDD-BB13-0834AB81E103\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$E42EFC1E-FA99-4DDD-BB13-0834AB81E103", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The OECD Pension Markets in Focus 2024 provides detailed country-specific notes and information on the plans covered by the data.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The OECD Pension Markets in Focus 2024 provides detailed country-specific notes and information on the plans covered by the data.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 14", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "8716e34154cefbfba1d98a8d3e320f4d257aa24141013aab6dcf1691013404a0", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 0aadb12979d31002ed5bd86b1498a4f552beda6b92978c1b2da4b1870ab2c390; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 8716e34154cefbfba1d98a8d3e320f4d257aa24141013aab6dcf1691013404a0; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2477, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3afd60bd9ccd9020163cc7583ebd9d0359d8c302c0483b8d81d10a4f5af1e039", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$E42EFC1E-FA99-4DDD-BB13-0834AB81E103 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare and Pensions Act, 2012 (Q100400049).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$E42EFC1E-FA99-4DDD-BB13-0834AB81E103", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The OECD Pension Markets in Focus 2024 provides detailed country-specific notes and information on the plans covered by the data.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 14", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04-2026-07-23.svg index 7141edaf3..b0f92adf3 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$E42EFC1E-FA99-4DDD-BB13-0834AB81E103 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + The OECD Pension Markets in Focus 2024 provides detailed country-specific notes and + information on the plans covered by the data. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$E42EFC1E-FA99-4DDD-BB13-0834AB81E103 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 14 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json index 7be501b95..b73e60003 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 18. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$EF0B6DC1-D8AD-412D-B0A6-C045A1191138 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare and Pensions Act, 2011 (Q100400002).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"c2514221c6fb6f31c4d9a17b89cde3bdd34a61bf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100400002,\"id\":\"Q100400002\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"1277780215cd5ca03e85ca9c50830783b4fedfe1\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2011-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$EF0B6DC1-D8AD-412D-B0A6-C045A1191138\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$EF0B6DC1-D8AD-412D-B0A6-C045A1191138", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Since 2015, many countries have increased the value of financial incentives for retirement savings to increase the role that asset-backed pension plans are expected to play in financing retirement income.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Since 2015, many countries have increased the value of financial incentives for retirement savings to increase the role that asset-backed pension plans are expected to play in financing retirement income.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 18", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "a88229c33edcfa7406e132acb914f4853ca7693518cca25b204f1af2ecb18779", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 134599af086725de351a1e37a6d4278e780bb144bbc093559b4683e6ce5a8b4f; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 a88229c33edcfa7406e132acb914f4853ca7693518cca25b204f1af2ecb18779; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2478, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3afd60bd9ccd9020163cc7583ebd9d0359d8c302c0483b8d81d10a4f5af1e039", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$EF0B6DC1-D8AD-412D-B0A6-C045A1191138 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare and Pensions Act, 2011 (Q100400002).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$EF0B6DC1-D8AD-412D-B0A6-C045A1191138", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Since 2015, many countries have increased the value of financial incentives for retirement savings to increase the role that asset-backed pension plans are expected to play in financing retirement income.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 18", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05-2026-07-23.svg index d9566b662..496add989 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$EF0B6DC1-D8AD-412D-B0A6-C045A1191138 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + Since 2015, many countries have increased the value of financial incentives for + retirement savings to increase the role that asset-backed pension plans are expected Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$EF0B6DC1-D8AD-412D-B0A6-C045A1191138 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 18 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json index 37b03bd96..029e641f2 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 21. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$E0E75B3F-FFE3-40A0-8FF5-55AAB8EA726E in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare and Pensions Act, 2008 (Q100399884).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"712279f53509ed0b419df899760753e4e3e060ec\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100399884,\"id\":\"Q100399884\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"43bdb90ab9b607c864931ed584115ff944210c6b\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2008-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$E0E75B3F-FFE3-40A0-8FF5-55AAB8EA726E\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$E0E75B3F-FFE3-40A0-8FF5-55AAB8EA726E", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Using historical returns on selected asset classes, the chapter shows that over 80% of cohorts across 19 OECD countries would have accumulated more assets at retirement had they invested at least part of their retirement savings for 40 years in a mix of domestic and foreign equities instead of only investing in domestic fixed income securities (government bonds plus cash and deposits).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Using historical returns on selected asset classes, the chapter shows that over 80% of cohorts across 19 OECD countries would have accumulated more assets at retirement had they invested at least part of their retirement savings for 40 years in a mix of domestic and foreign equities instead of only investing in domestic fixed income securities (government bonds plus cash and deposits).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 21", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "f65ad2f1133ee518edc6745a56a2782f597690d86718f6bd698d79e12fa67c0c", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 11bee8150ed85ef5f9d4c394ff76242a5f13693aacf709de39e24196061a20ec; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 f65ad2f1133ee518edc6745a56a2782f597690d86718f6bd698d79e12fa67c0c; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2479, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3afd60bd9ccd9020163cc7583ebd9d0359d8c302c0483b8d81d10a4f5af1e039", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$E0E75B3F-FFE3-40A0-8FF5-55AAB8EA726E in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare and Pensions Act, 2008 (Q100399884).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$E0E75B3F-FFE3-40A0-8FF5-55AAB8EA726E", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Using historical returns on selected asset classes, the chapter shows that over 80% of cohorts across 19 OECD countries would have accumulated more assets at retirement had they invested at least part of their retirement savings for 40 years in a mix of domestic and foreign equities instead of only investing in domestic fixed income securities (government bonds plus cash and deposits).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 21", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06-2026-07-23.svg index d3dbb5259..7d541dec4 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$E0E75B3F-FFE3-40A0-8FF5-55AAB8EA726E in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + Using historical returns on selected asset classes, the chapter shows that over 80% + of cohorts across 19 OECD countries would have accumulated more assets at retirement Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$E0E75B3F-FFE3-40A0-8FF5-55AAB8EA726E - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 21 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json index da3f35190..3f1bc97c6 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 22. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$E8DF4186-64E1-45C5-B42B-E11EB1508013 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare and Pensions Act, 2007 (Q100399850).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"5ec03175ebbdf517c2b33e752e2cc8683fe04e72\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100399850,\"id\":\"Q100399850\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"4b8b0672c38a4a213d3ddf5553b775988e65ace9\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2007-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$E8DF4186-64E1-45C5-B42B-E11EB1508013\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$E8DF4186-64E1-45C5-B42B-E11EB1508013", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In contrast, the first column shows that the fixed-income portfolio would produce a higher replacement rate than the other strategies with a probability of no more than 13%.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In contrast, the first column shows that the fixed-income portfolio would produce a higher replacement rate than the other strategies with a probability of no more than 13%.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 22", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "35d114207792ecf999891f6a8e375c345712533fd72bf1cd448d91c0ea9d0838", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 9b85af24adf03521274ea76a657d4225ffb17bdb851f7225fd9d6a90971a5eb7; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 35d114207792ecf999891f6a8e375c345712533fd72bf1cd448d91c0ea9d0838; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2480, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3afd60bd9ccd9020163cc7583ebd9d0359d8c302c0483b8d81d10a4f5af1e039", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$E8DF4186-64E1-45C5-B42B-E11EB1508013 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare and Pensions Act, 2007 (Q100399850).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$E8DF4186-64E1-45C5-B42B-E11EB1508013", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In contrast, the first column shows that the fixed-income portfolio would produce a higher replacement rate than the other strategies with a probability of no more than 13%.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 22", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07-2026-07-23.svg index 67fd2c3a6..a03ac06cb 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$E8DF4186-64E1-45C5-B42B-E11EB1508013 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + In contrast, the first column shows that the fixed-income portfolio would produce a + higher replacement rate than the other strategies with a probability of no more than Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$E8DF4186-64E1-45C5-B42B-E11EB1508013 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 22 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json index d5fecdb36..d24ab842f 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 22. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$28613D99-9FC0-460C-88B5-D4A3DF28ABB2 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare Law Reform and Pensions Act, 2006 (Q100399804).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"2847fd6060371bd2136a8b72f42bc544718c700d\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100399804,\"id\":\"Q100399804\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"a910853afc29ee98ebd8b5f67a02ff08aea299d2\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2006-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$28613D99-9FC0-460C-88B5-D4A3DF28ABB2\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$28613D99-9FC0-460C-88B5-D4A3DF28ABB2", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Cohorts saving for 20 years instead of 40 would accumulate less in all investment strategies, with a much larger difference for portfolios fully invested in diversified equities compared to other investment strategies.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Cohorts saving for 20 years instead of 40 would accumulate less in all investment strategies, with a much larger difference for portfolios fully invested in diversified equities compared to other investment strategies.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 22", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "f8f60922923e5b098292986f9fcd768fa4495ddd26ee675685c506289958f202", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 03d487566114af27f7f95d67270dc96d32a2576df5bc4db50f827191c05084ab; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 f8f60922923e5b098292986f9fcd768fa4495ddd26ee675685c506289958f202; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2481, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3afd60bd9ccd9020163cc7583ebd9d0359d8c302c0483b8d81d10a4f5af1e039", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$28613D99-9FC0-460C-88B5-D4A3DF28ABB2 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare Law Reform and Pensions Act, 2006 (Q100399804).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$28613D99-9FC0-460C-88B5-D4A3DF28ABB2", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Cohorts saving for 20 years instead of 40 would accumulate less in all investment strategies, with a much larger difference for portfolios fully invested in diversified equities compared to other investment strategies.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 22", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08-2026-07-23.svg index 84ed67be9..01aa9df14 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$28613D99-9FC0-460C-88B5-D4A3DF28ABB2 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + Cohorts saving for 20 years instead of 40 would accumulate less in all investment + strategies, with a much larger difference for portfolios fully invested in Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$28613D99-9FC0-460C-88B5-D4A3DF28ABB2 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 22 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json index 3c6cff220..20cb70ab5 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 23. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$E24671E1-EA67-46CB-9B23-7A57F067889E in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 2004 (Q100399730).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"3bed8ef5c8f262bec6173dee19456eb1111f3fe1\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100399730,\"id\":\"Q100399730\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"ba4e903e603892e17bd9796e98b823725cab176a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2004-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$E24671E1-EA67-46CB-9B23-7A57F067889E\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$E24671E1-EA67-46CB-9B23-7A57F067889E", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "By contrast, there is a 60% probability of getting higher replacement rates when staying invested fully in equities during the payout phase and taking regular drawdowns instead of buying a lifelong annuity at retirement.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "By contrast, there is a 60% probability of getting higher replacement rates when staying invested fully in equities during the payout phase and taking regular drawdowns instead of buying a lifelong annuity at retirement.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 23", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "e43606c4e90c1856c3b052ebbcd1ff7fe7a984f4cd02401c72cb353bd89a59ba", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 36439746e161232d4a64ccd4aa07fc08259ca5291a0e14f81e5f752e84921875; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 e43606c4e90c1856c3b052ebbcd1ff7fe7a984f4cd02401c72cb353bd89a59ba; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2482, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3afd60bd9ccd9020163cc7583ebd9d0359d8c302c0483b8d81d10a4f5af1e039", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$E24671E1-EA67-46CB-9B23-7A57F067889E in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 2004 (Q100399730).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$E24671E1-EA67-46CB-9B23-7A57F067889E", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "By contrast, there is a 60% probability of getting higher replacement rates when staying invested fully in equities during the payout phase and taking regular drawdowns instead of buying a lifelong annuity at retirement.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 23", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09-2026-07-23.svg index e49cac48f..40ed18ccb 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$E24671E1-EA67-46CB-9B23-7A57F067889E in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + By contrast, there is a 60% probability of getting higher replacement rates when + staying invested fully in equities during the payout phase and taking regular Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$E24671E1-EA67-46CB-9B23-7A57F067889E - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 23 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json index 33232e332..999fb4a32 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 23. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$517BFFDA-8C57-4DB9-B64F-EA5632C51654 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare Act, 1993 (Q100399249).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"3e946abb811db27515a82050b3574b231572ae7d\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100399249,\"id\":\"Q100399249\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"90c1ec53fb2353d85282cca17898f95b43cc4d63\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+1993-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$517BFFDA-8C57-4DB9-B64F-EA5632C51654\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$517BFFDA-8C57-4DB9-B64F-EA5632C51654", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "For example, the reduction in equity exposure may start in the last 10 years before retirement when participants are planning to take an annuity.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "For example, the reduction in equity exposure may start in the last 10 years before retirement when participants are planning to take an annuity.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 23", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "9a148b6a635a833f9f77f8a1e7f0a64817e459ecda11928edbc70c76c49d20a7", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 f4add87416a282103e27e6a2500ed2428dec5145eeafd2d3f97ae2f446548517; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 9a148b6a635a833f9f77f8a1e7f0a64817e459ecda11928edbc70c76c49d20a7; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2483, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "3afd60bd9ccd9020163cc7583ebd9d0359d8c302c0483b8d81d10a4f5af1e039", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$517BFFDA-8C57-4DB9-B64F-EA5632C51654 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare Act, 1993 (Q100399249).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$517BFFDA-8C57-4DB9-B64F-EA5632C51654", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "For example, the reduction in equity exposure may start in the last 10 years before retirement when participants are planning to take an annuity.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 23", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10-2026-07-23.svg index e92e293d9..2c5763ee4 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$517BFFDA-8C57-4DB9-B64F-EA5632C51654 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + For example, the reduction in equity exposure may start in the last 10 years before + retirement when participants are planning to take an annuity. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$517BFFDA-8C57-4DB9-B64F-EA5632C51654 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 23 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json index 76f98a3b9..23999751d 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 29. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$6CC2EC0F-0B6D-471A-ADB7-982B0DABF9B3 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare and Pensions Act, 2009 (Q100399916).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"afe5f0a49b2302113d94cae6bc2e20979ad096d0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100399916,\"id\":\"Q100399916\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"e4ce1ad4d6c6d0289a402c42bf392b7c735cbc30\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2009-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$6CC2EC0F-0B6D-471A-ADB7-982B0DABF9B3\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$6CC2EC0F-0B6D-471A-ADB7-982B0DABF9B3", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Family members managing the estate normally have around 12 months to manage selling the home, and the grace period can be extended in the event of departure due to long-term care needs to allow more time to sort out the financial situation of the occupant.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Family members managing the estate normally have around 12 months to manage selling the home, and the grace period can be extended in the event of departure due to long-term care needs to allow more time to sort out the financial situation of the occupant.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 29", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "5c35f0f016f4564dc7391bd3882b3b3085dfa48cd02cb3894a980b93d7910025", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 0141a44076f28a5410d5da630e92f5d357a9e63bfe84fcc553773fe3381f334c; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 5c35f0f016f4564dc7391bd3882b3b3085dfa48cd02cb3894a980b93d7910025; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2484, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "fd47063a586f1151a4af17dcadca48344afa14df850da269496866ff58b64f7f", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$6CC2EC0F-0B6D-471A-ADB7-982B0DABF9B3 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare and Pensions Act, 2009 (Q100399916).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$6CC2EC0F-0B6D-471A-ADB7-982B0DABF9B3", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Family members managing the estate normally have around 12 months to manage selling the home, and the grace period can be extended in the event of departure due to long-term care needs to allow more time to sort out the financial situation of the occupant.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 29", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01-2026-07-23.svg index 7cf501df6..d6ccc042c 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$6CC2EC0F-0B6D-471A-ADB7-982B0DABF9B3 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + Family members managing the estate normally have around 12 months to manage selling + the home, and the grace period can be extended in the event of departure due to Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$6CC2EC0F-0B6D-471A-ADB7-982B0DABF9B3 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 29 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json index 3948f8fa9..473801c1f 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 29. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$028D294E-0919-4B46-BA9C-92E092209687 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare Act, 2000 (Q100399550).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"e53295185868467de6ae41d298bff331365bc347\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100399550,\"id\":\"Q100399550\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"e701093471a4f4e2e08f4a95fb504eb6270222cf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2000-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$028D294E-0919-4B46-BA9C-92E092209687\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$028D294E-0919-4B46-BA9C-92E092209687", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Limits are lower for younger borrowers, say 15% of the home value of someone aged 60, increasing up to around 50% for older borrowers aged 80 and over.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Limits are lower for younger borrowers, say 15% of the home value of someone aged 60, increasing up to around 50% for older borrowers aged 80 and over.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 29", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "4235abffe5b7faf0dfdff568a18582ef27f0bfffe9913c45cb99b23633667c15", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 aff09fa341e2caa0b221aa044b88b269a5b7d16e7d6106b001c874ea33885886; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 4235abffe5b7faf0dfdff568a18582ef27f0bfffe9913c45cb99b23633667c15; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2485, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "fd47063a586f1151a4af17dcadca48344afa14df850da269496866ff58b64f7f", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$028D294E-0919-4B46-BA9C-92E092209687 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare Act, 2000 (Q100399550).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$028D294E-0919-4B46-BA9C-92E092209687", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Limits are lower for younger borrowers, say 15% of the home value of someone aged 60, increasing up to around 50% for older borrowers aged 80 and over.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 29", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02-2026-07-23.svg index 860f03392..c57ea18fd 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$028D294E-0919-4B46-BA9C-92E092209687 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + Limits are lower for younger borrowers, say 15% of the home value of someone aged + 60, increasing up to around 50% for older borrowers aged 80 and over. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$028D294E-0919-4B46-BA9C-92E092209687 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 29 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json index e04875cb6..686140410 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 34. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$A35A4603-A4AC-4C6A-925B-F08E60C8D553 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Pensions Act (Notice of Alleged offence) Regulations 2007 (Q100537407).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"8970bb9184c6b561a5786bf8291d593449710b84\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100537407,\"id\":\"Q100537407\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"4b8b0672c38a4a213d3ddf5553b775988e65ace9\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2007-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$A35A4603-A4AC-4C6A-925B-F08E60C8D553\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$A35A4603-A4AC-4C6A-925B-F08E60C8D553", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The chapter describes in Section 2.1 the different models of multi-employer pension arrangements and their management and governance structures.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The chapter describes in Section 2.1 the different models of multi-employer pension arrangements and their management and governance structures.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 34", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "55d1dc29b107aabe85bb192b9bd1f21dcd4130e8ebda41cfa96660328041b308", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 d67a40be83d487b559a6905162856179abd50bb4b36ce5054a3e4a1f6b31469e; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 55d1dc29b107aabe85bb192b9bd1f21dcd4130e8ebda41cfa96660328041b308; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2486, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "fd47063a586f1151a4af17dcadca48344afa14df850da269496866ff58b64f7f", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$A35A4603-A4AC-4C6A-925B-F08E60C8D553 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Pensions Act (Notice of Alleged offence) Regulations 2007 (Q100537407).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$A35A4603-A4AC-4C6A-925B-F08E60C8D553", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The chapter describes in Section 2.1 the different models of multi-employer pension arrangements and their management and governance structures.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 34", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03-2026-07-23.svg index 8c6b89a62..c4078cae9 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$A35A4603-A4AC-4C6A-925B-F08E60C8D553 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + The chapter describes in Section 2.1 the different models of multi-employer pension + arrangements and their management and governance structures. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$A35A4603-A4AC-4C6A-925B-F08E60C8D553 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 34 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json index 40f0ad813..7f8690e8d 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 34. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$8B78AB21-6175-4F73-A403-DE2816D3E9EF in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Family Law (Divorce) Act, 1996 (Q100399398).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"180a5a6bb3f2dff0b8b6c1593e17f0665700f841\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100399398,\"id\":\"Q100399398\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"79b724689063bbad8fa6bb1f75c7b0134c3bd386\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+1996-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$8B78AB21-6175-4F73-A403-DE2816D3E9EF\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$8B78AB21-6175-4F73-A403-DE2816D3E9EF", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Section 2.2 analyses which employers and workers may have access to these arrangements, while Section 2.3 describes the onboarding process for employers.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Section 2.2 analyses which employers and workers may have access to these arrangements, while Section 2.3 describes the onboarding process for employers.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 34", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "b7062070b66b3623c4fd5db5b8e29ea2801abfe5a574eda1d9e53de66c3850cc", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 f182cef400e991eee19884838acbdfe92fb5320a4f6b640e1258b4009d189aad; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 b7062070b66b3623c4fd5db5b8e29ea2801abfe5a574eda1d9e53de66c3850cc; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2487, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "fd47063a586f1151a4af17dcadca48344afa14df850da269496866ff58b64f7f", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$8B78AB21-6175-4F73-A403-DE2816D3E9EF in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Family Law (Divorce) Act, 1996 (Q100399398).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$8B78AB21-6175-4F73-A403-DE2816D3E9EF", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Section 2.2 analyses which employers and workers may have access to these arrangements, while Section 2.3 describes the onboarding process for employers.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 34", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04-2026-07-23.svg index b7cf518e1..b44162c55 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$8B78AB21-6175-4F73-A403-DE2816D3E9EF in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + Section 2.2 analyses which employers and workers may have access to these + arrangements, while Section 2.3 describes the onboarding process for employers. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$8B78AB21-6175-4F73-A403-DE2816D3E9EF - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 34 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json index a3253152e..ecee4b8d8 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 39. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$B1F6888E-E6BD-4787-AA4D-395DB490EE1A in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Professional Guidance) Regulations, 2005 (Q100586458).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"ac536b8aeba1ee297fca3a7a98c898ae0edb1604\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100586458,\"id\":\"Q100586458\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"26896c2e3b989e92a54f934df3cb9368a0ce7adb\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2005-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$B1F6888E-E6BD-4787-AA4D-395DB490EE1A\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$B1F6888E-E6BD-4787-AA4D-395DB490EE1A", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In Canada, pooled registered pension plans were introduced in 2012 to make it easier for employers not already offering an occupational pension plan to do so.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Canada, pooled registered pension plans were introduced in 2012 to make it easier for employers not already offering an occupational pension plan to do so.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 39", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "d8996415d78174e9b506dd0dc8b06a4f03ce644e2470bfb783b1e229229ae53a", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 d95e3a772c0bddca7a683591d5dcde70e4ab3e9fcaadf620fa58230fa6482f18; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 d8996415d78174e9b506dd0dc8b06a4f03ce644e2470bfb783b1e229229ae53a; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2488, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "fd47063a586f1151a4af17dcadca48344afa14df850da269496866ff58b64f7f", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$B1F6888E-E6BD-4787-AA4D-395DB490EE1A in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Professional Guidance) Regulations, 2005 (Q100586458).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$B1F6888E-E6BD-4787-AA4D-395DB490EE1A", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In Canada, pooled registered pension plans were introduced in 2012 to make it easier for employers not already offering an occupational pension plan to do so.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 39", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05-2026-07-23.svg index f0f5e6486..7fdacfb59 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$B1F6888E-E6BD-4787-AA4D-395DB490EE1A in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + In Canada, pooled registered pension plans were introduced in 2012 to make it easier + for employers not already offering an occupational pension plan to do so. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$B1F6888E-E6BD-4787-AA4D-395DB490EE1A - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 39 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json index 5b2ed067d..18ba98bac 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 39. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$7869BDC4-9C6C-4503-A29F-0F907C955E5F in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Ministers and Secretaries (Amendment) Act, 2011 (Q100400003).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"c83384ce3713565ceaf7e39b937ff064a4678b4e\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100400003,\"id\":\"Q100400003\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"1277780215cd5ca03e85ca9c50830783b4fedfe1\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2011-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$7869BDC4-9C6C-4503-A29F-0F907C955E5F\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$7869BDC4-9C6C-4503-A29F-0F907C955E5F", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The latest version of multiple-employer pension plans, called pooled employer plans, was introduced in 2021 and is accessible to any employer.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The latest version of multiple-employer pension plans, called pooled employer plans, was introduced in 2021 and is accessible to any employer.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 39", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "96d9df415e7d937ab617ff12bc6726d116ad7861817f06c247dbb55459643621", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 9d5dc3df1ac291378be9765e727f7564d632428cdd7b4fd8c180973a2ceb6992; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 96d9df415e7d937ab617ff12bc6726d116ad7861817f06c247dbb55459643621; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2489, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "fd47063a586f1151a4af17dcadca48344afa14df850da269496866ff58b64f7f", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$7869BDC4-9C6C-4503-A29F-0F907C955E5F in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Ministers and Secretaries (Amendment) Act, 2011 (Q100400003).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$7869BDC4-9C6C-4503-A29F-0F907C955E5F", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The latest version of multiple-employer pension plans, called pooled employer plans, was introduced in 2021 and is accessible to any employer.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 39", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06-2026-07-23.svg index 4bd23693c..bae54a5dd 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$7869BDC4-9C6C-4503-A29F-0F907C955E5F in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + The latest version of multiple-employer pension plans, called pooled employer plans, + was introduced in 2021 and is accessible to any employer. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$7869BDC4-9C6C-4503-A29F-0F907C955E5F - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 39 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json index 5573c7411..b61d255b3 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 41. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$58431FB6-C58E-403A-B96F-CA4F70983E8F in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Freedom of Information Act, 2014 (Q100400171).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"2013142b7a87309350bb06e457b30d9831aea316\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100400171,\"id\":\"Q100400171\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"049bd876bdfea826eaceb6f6056701b74c6d3f08\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2014-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$58431FB6-C58E-403A-B96F-CA4F70983E8F\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$58431FB6-C58E-403A-B96F-CA4F70983E8F", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In Norway, KLP is the pension provider for local government employees and was jointly created in 1949 by the Union of Norwegian Cities and the Norwegian Association of Rural Municipalities.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Norway, KLP is the pension provider for local government employees and was jointly created in 1949 by the Union of Norwegian Cities and the Norwegian Association of Rural Municipalities.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 41", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "403632886283ab22ddbdcd98f43b7c4482f75b03d010b1c177626f6b945c0029", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 3d355fdb4676167a45c859de3a7faa9265f65e8da341de7efd146d7b1a231c61; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 403632886283ab22ddbdcd98f43b7c4482f75b03d010b1c177626f6b945c0029; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2490, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "fd47063a586f1151a4af17dcadca48344afa14df850da269496866ff58b64f7f", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$58431FB6-C58E-403A-B96F-CA4F70983E8F in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Freedom of Information Act, 2014 (Q100400171).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$58431FB6-C58E-403A-B96F-CA4F70983E8F", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In Norway, KLP is the pension provider for local government employees and was jointly created in 1949 by the Union of Norwegian Cities and the Norwegian Association of Rural Municipalities.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 41", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07-2026-07-23.svg index 62248c452..36db144f4 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$58431FB6-C58E-403A-B96F-CA4F70983E8F in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + In Norway, KLP is the pension provider for local government employees and was + jointly created in 1949 by the Union of Norwegian Cities and the Norwegian Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$58431FB6-C58E-403A-B96F-CA4F70983E8F - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 41 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json index e3cfaf615..66bffc885 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 42. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$63E0B69A-AE22-436C-A937-B3242B2D12E8 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Fees) (Amendment) Regulations 2002 (Q100581857).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"5c8cf5a8db85114db68168e148694d59c97b5d27\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100581857,\"id\":\"Q100581857\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"9451da042cf866fedbd9efd17f0324c590c5c5dd\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2002-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$63E0B69A-AE22-436C-A937-B3242B2D12E8\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$63E0B69A-AE22-436C-A937-B3242B2D12E8", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "While 85% of pension funds provide the possibility of voluntary continuation in the pension scheme for the self-employed, two barriers may prevent take-up: the application and the voluntary continuation of contributions must be made shortly after termination of the employment contract (within 9 months and 15 months, respectively), and the self-employed must pay the sum of employee and employer contributions.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "While 85% of pension funds provide the possibility of voluntary continuation in the pension scheme for the self-employed, two barriers may prevent take-up: the application and the voluntary continuation of contributions must be made shortly after termination of the employment contract (within 9 months and 15 months, respectively), and the self-employed must pay the sum of employee and employer contributions.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 42", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "182ba8d0ec8df05c376b6449d663fe40f12e08eb7442f134de74e9dd23646244", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 372d8318fc83752960680082ecb4e2abb031c24898cdc74f59249784aa10f7dc; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 182ba8d0ec8df05c376b6449d663fe40f12e08eb7442f134de74e9dd23646244; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2491, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "fd47063a586f1151a4af17dcadca48344afa14df850da269496866ff58b64f7f", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$63E0B69A-AE22-436C-A937-B3242B2D12E8 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Fees) (Amendment) Regulations 2002 (Q100581857).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$63E0B69A-AE22-436C-A937-B3242B2D12E8", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "While 85% of pension funds provide the possibility of voluntary continuation in the pension scheme for the self-employed, two barriers may prevent take-up: the application and the voluntary continuation of contributions must be made shortly after termination of the employment contract (within 9 months and 15 months, respectively), and the self-employed must pay the sum of employee and employer contributions.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 42", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08-2026-07-23.svg index b6b83fa70..d330fc835 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$63E0B69A-AE22-436C-A937-B3242B2D12E8 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + While 85% of pension funds provide the possibility of voluntary continuation in the + pension scheme for the self-employed, two barriers may prevent take-up: the Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$63E0B69A-AE22-436C-A937-B3242B2D12E8 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 42 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json index 580ab3607..9ed212606 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 43. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$A6A45CFA-D55E-43CD-AC8C-CE244D7E00C0 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Fees) (Amendment) Regulations 2009 (Q100543990).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"c8551405652b92912112b4ea3f9469e7a4869343\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100543990,\"id\":\"Q100543990\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"e4ce1ad4d6c6d0289a402c42bf392b7c735cbc30\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2009-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$A6A45CFA-D55E-43CD-AC8C-CE244D7E00C0\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$A6A45CFA-D55E-43CD-AC8C-CE244D7E00C0", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "When an employer selects Nest for its enrolment duties, signing up with it is straightforward.9 The employer first needs to create an online Nest account and then complete five tasks: 1.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "When an employer selects Nest for its enrolment duties, signing up with it is straightforward.9 The employer first needs to create an online Nest account and then complete five tasks: 1.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 43", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "2e26705037260df678f042afc1415bf9e1086651aeac28511a0db49b1a212c97", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 d50406265fe86f61bae79fe619cb5d20250b79b625eb89ecac9555aa6f0ef8d7; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 2e26705037260df678f042afc1415bf9e1086651aeac28511a0db49b1a212c97; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2492, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "fd47063a586f1151a4af17dcadca48344afa14df850da269496866ff58b64f7f", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$A6A45CFA-D55E-43CD-AC8C-CE244D7E00C0 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Fees) (Amendment) Regulations 2009 (Q100543990).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$A6A45CFA-D55E-43CD-AC8C-CE244D7E00C0", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "When an employer selects Nest for its enrolment duties, signing up with it is straightforward.9 The employer first needs to create an online Nest account and then complete five tasks: 1.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 43", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09-2026-07-23.svg index 47d66275a..79e80f44d 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$A6A45CFA-D55E-43CD-AC8C-CE244D7E00C0 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + When an employer selects Nest for its enrolment duties, signing up with it is + straightforward.9 The employer first needs to create an online Nest account and then Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$A6A45CFA-D55E-43CD-AC8C-CE244D7E00C0 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 43 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json index bd65463c2..5ff3b772c 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 43. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$46B1D1E2-BF7F-4581-8641-65B1FC6E05C9 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Fees) (Amendment) Regulations, 1997 (Q100580845).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"5ba49897fbfef8f9e4ee6d17c7a618cd1628d0b3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100580845,\"id\":\"Q100580845\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"9b8d0cec6ae0bc77abcf6acaac222401c81f350f\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+1997-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$46B1D1E2-BF7F-4581-8641-65B1FC6E05C9\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$46B1D1E2-BF7F-4581-8641-65B1FC6E05C9", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In Denmark, PensionDanmark is the pension provider for all blue-collar workers covered by a collective agreement and around 80% of its active members work in companies with less than 10 employees.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Denmark, PensionDanmark is the pension provider for all blue-collar workers covered by a collective agreement and around 80% of its active members work in companies with less than 10 employees.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 43", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "8c2fdbbb0b6faed22cc6eaa2dff9e12de501b2b38b0257df48b9b9cee8358014", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 acd8ee058d3291fcbf03f6b1fb6034397fecaa8910681dc96a661fc5efe8f981; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 8c2fdbbb0b6faed22cc6eaa2dff9e12de501b2b38b0257df48b9b9cee8358014; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2493, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "fd47063a586f1151a4af17dcadca48344afa14df850da269496866ff58b64f7f", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$46B1D1E2-BF7F-4581-8641-65B1FC6E05C9 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Fees) (Amendment) Regulations, 1997 (Q100580845).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$46B1D1E2-BF7F-4581-8641-65B1FC6E05C9", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In Denmark, PensionDanmark is the pension provider for all blue-collar workers covered by a collective agreement and around 80% of its active members work in companies with less than 10 employees.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 43", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10-2026-07-23.svg index 30a9a8c8d..79d4258a6 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$46B1D1E2-BF7F-4581-8641-65B1FC6E05C9 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + In Denmark, PensionDanmark is the pension provider for all blue-collar workers + covered by a collective agreement and around 80% of its active members work in Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$46B1D1E2-BF7F-4581-8641-65B1FC6E05C9 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 43 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json index c4e7f25c7..8b9baf9ef 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 45. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$58B00FC9-1C12-4387-89FC-3B2419EA8D27 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Preservation of Benefits) (Special Calculations) Regulations, 1993 (Q100579621).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"dbb81f3e356338de6ba0f87208cc3fd2d31cbf24\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100579621,\"id\":\"Q100579621\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"90c1ec53fb2353d85282cca17898f95b43cc4d63\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+1993-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$58B00FC9-1C12-4387-89FC-3B2419EA8D27\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$58B00FC9-1C12-4387-89FC-3B2419EA8D27", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "This is the case for instance in the United States for multiple employer plans, which may lose their tax-qualified status if only one employer is not compliant.13 Multi-employer pension arrangements established through collective agreements between social partners may raise fairness issues.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "This is the case for instance in the United States for multiple employer plans, which may lose their tax-qualified status if only one employer is not compliant.13 Multi-employer pension arrangements established through collective agreements between social partners may raise fairness issues.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 45", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "7c688ba17e9ee52c64acd87e72a8c67650ae329858eaa43b8c5e2eead74dbb6c", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 d50adb3176eb04475d6807f31fb5f6c7995a1c777b9558f500fd30b8612dfe0b; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 7c688ba17e9ee52c64acd87e72a8c67650ae329858eaa43b8c5e2eead74dbb6c; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2494, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "be011f01cb5aa7fc7ebce3f7e5de91b01271d38b0f01d3efbe7829b4b7d84f9e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$58B00FC9-1C12-4387-89FC-3B2419EA8D27 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Preservation of Benefits) (Special Calculations) Regulations, 1993 (Q100579621).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$58B00FC9-1C12-4387-89FC-3B2419EA8D27", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "This is the case for instance in the United States for multiple employer plans, which may lose their tax-qualified status if only one employer is not compliant.13 Multi-employer pension arrangements established through collective agreements between social partners may raise fairness issues.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 45", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01-2026-07-23.svg index 0cf208f82..43b69b5cb 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$58B00FC9-1C12-4387-89FC-3B2419EA8D27 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + This is the case for instance in the United States for multiple employer plans, + which may lose their tax-qualified status if only one employer is not compliant.13 Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$58B00FC9-1C12-4387-89FC-3B2419EA8D27 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 45 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json index e1b8fdc08..ab6347d72 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 46. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$06367B41-FF5F-404B-BC0D-9EB8A02C8316 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Schemes With External Members) (United Kingdom) Regulations, 2000 (Q100584164).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"33be62d9288e54fa46c1740a3265043e9d539599\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100584164,\"id\":\"Q100584164\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"e701093471a4f4e2e08f4a95fb504eb6270222cf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2000-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$06367B41-FF5F-404B-BC0D-9EB8A02C8316\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$06367B41-FF5F-404B-BC0D-9EB8A02C8316", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Even though the transition to a master trust is smooth for most pension plans, those with complex assets or benefit structures may be difficult to replicate in a master trust.15 Moreover, employer inertia may limit the development of master trusts as employers may lack good understanding of the new governance requirements and may not realise that a master trust could be more cost-effective for their plan.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Even though the transition to a master trust is smooth for most pension plans, those with complex assets or benefit structures may be difficult to replicate in a master trust.15 Moreover, employer inertia may limit the development of master trusts as employers may lack good understanding of the new governance requirements and may not realise that a master trust could be more cost-effective for their plan.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 46", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "a3c30a703e564967660d244e0bdf228c514cc8c8c92e15b2082160c7fc92e0e4", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 d5c37725fc0246500c40320face9fbaadee209f69a8ee86a793bf1b30ea91f46; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 a3c30a703e564967660d244e0bdf228c514cc8c8c92e15b2082160c7fc92e0e4; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2495, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "be011f01cb5aa7fc7ebce3f7e5de91b01271d38b0f01d3efbe7829b4b7d84f9e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$06367B41-FF5F-404B-BC0D-9EB8A02C8316 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Schemes With External Members) (United Kingdom) Regulations, 2000 (Q100584164).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$06367B41-FF5F-404B-BC0D-9EB8A02C8316", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Even though the transition to a master trust is smooth for most pension plans, those with complex assets or benefit structures may be difficult to replicate in a master trust.15 Moreover, employer inertia may limit the development of master trusts as employers may lack good understanding of the new governance requirements and may not realise that a master trust could be more cost-effective for their plan.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 46", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02-2026-07-23.svg index a56b704e8..9a0af323f 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$06367B41-FF5F-404B-BC0D-9EB8A02C8316 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + Even though the transition to a master trust is smooth for most pension plans, those + with complex assets or benefit structures may be difficult to replicate in a master Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$06367B41-FF5F-404B-BC0D-9EB8A02C8316 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 46 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json index 7a42d237a..83066c433 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 52. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$B021AD7B-FC7C-412A-8F37-BD8C643C6F67 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997 (Q100399447).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"d32bf9200c579fd39f19155ef31bf124f8ff38a3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100399447,\"id\":\"Q100399447\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"9b8d0cec6ae0bc77abcf6acaac222401c81f350f\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+1997-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$B021AD7B-FC7C-412A-8F37-BD8C643C6F67\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$B021AD7B-FC7C-412A-8F37-BD8C643C6F67", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Since 2015, many countries have increased financial incentives for retirement savings as asset-backed pension plans are expected to play an increasing role in financing retirement income.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Since 2015, many countries have increased financial incentives for retirement savings as asset-backed pension plans are expected to play an increasing role in financing retirement income.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 52", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "ed4b4f09a725f9696a7480f54381c68e27907d87b05eea8d98cc2af6fc56bd14", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 2e2dd3e8c9911896137fdc785093b8bf626bc3aaaac68ebeea7e58dbcc49ad9c; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 ed4b4f09a725f9696a7480f54381c68e27907d87b05eea8d98cc2af6fc56bd14; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2496, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "be011f01cb5aa7fc7ebce3f7e5de91b01271d38b0f01d3efbe7829b4b7d84f9e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$B021AD7B-FC7C-412A-8F37-BD8C643C6F67 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997 (Q100399447).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$B021AD7B-FC7C-412A-8F37-BD8C643C6F67", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Since 2015, many countries have increased financial incentives for retirement savings as asset-backed pension plans are expected to play an increasing role in financing retirement income.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 52", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03-2026-07-23.svg index 84a8b666f..a54555f2e 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$B021AD7B-FC7C-412A-8F37-BD8C643C6F67 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + Since 2015, many countries have increased financial incentives for retirement + savings as asset-backed pension plans are expected to play an increasing role in Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$B021AD7B-FC7C-412A-8F37-BD8C643C6F67 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 52 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json index f739725ba..0f36bc44a 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 56. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$88626939-1317-4BE0-A748-7E6D2F7E934C in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations 2015 (Q100540238).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"9f1008ddd69339f36992df431f43e891187156ee\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100540238,\"id\":\"Q100540238\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"b6849eb7f635c6ee36b75d8adf7e3f89c6624101\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2015-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$88626939-1317-4BE0-A748-7E6D2F7E934C\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$88626939-1317-4BE0-A748-7E6D2F7E934C", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Tax credits can be found in Belgium (with a credit rate of 30%), Estonia (20%), Israel (35%), Korea (13.2% or 16.5% for lower earners) and the United States (0% to 50% depending on income).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Tax credits can be found in Belgium (with a credit rate of 30%), Estonia (20%), Israel (35%), Korea (13.2% or 16.5% for lower earners) and the United States (0% to 50% depending on income).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 56", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "f22e1dbdd64a3cb05217c60e4a309ddd65f350f70929788a84dea157e5b5cfbe", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 367699e23c1e88ddbc74a62407df4d4617c7162d3a72ec7e1e61f6e0ac8ddcf6; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 f22e1dbdd64a3cb05217c60e4a309ddd65f350f70929788a84dea157e5b5cfbe; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2497, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "be011f01cb5aa7fc7ebce3f7e5de91b01271d38b0f01d3efbe7829b4b7d84f9e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$88626939-1317-4BE0-A748-7E6D2F7E934C in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations 2015 (Q100540238).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$88626939-1317-4BE0-A748-7E6D2F7E934C", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Tax credits can be found in Belgium (with a credit rate of 30%), Estonia (20%), Israel (35%), Korea (13.2% or 16.5% for lower earners) and the United States (0% to 50% depending on income).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 56", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04-2026-07-23.svg index 5a614aecd..7097be202 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$88626939-1317-4BE0-A748-7E6D2F7E934C in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + Tax credits can be found in Belgium (with a credit rate of 30%), Estonia (20%), + Israel (35%), Korea (13.2% or 16.5% for lower earners) and the United States (0% to Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$88626939-1317-4BE0-A748-7E6D2F7E934C - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 56 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json index a13dc5a76..85d544179 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 56. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$DAA26E60-AA8D-4FD6-9D2A-1B285E676636 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations 2014 (Q100538084).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"db321ee6087f5e3b144d05800b5684308916187c\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100538084,\"id\":\"Q100538084\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"049bd876bdfea826eaceb6f6056701b74c6d3f08\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2014-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$DAA26E60-AA8D-4FD6-9D2A-1B285E676636\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$DAA26E60-AA8D-4FD6-9D2A-1B285E676636", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "For example, in Australia, employer contributions to superannuation accounts are taxed at the fixed rate of 15% for most employees.5 As this rate is usually lower than their marginal tax rate, most individuals benefit from a tax rate relief on their contributions.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "For example, in Australia, employer contributions to superannuation accounts are taxed at the fixed rate of 15% for most employees.5 As this rate is usually lower than their marginal tax rate, most individuals benefit from a tax rate relief on their contributions.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 56", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "215e8e8c86f4476709aa78af5f7b876c87a5bc09b5c26f37a3fd72805f3afa2c", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 04187df2f22c241c80857a74b3f4099febeee27d9f853556399e10d59329d9ee; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 215e8e8c86f4476709aa78af5f7b876c87a5bc09b5c26f37a3fd72805f3afa2c; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2498, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "be011f01cb5aa7fc7ebce3f7e5de91b01271d38b0f01d3efbe7829b4b7d84f9e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$DAA26E60-AA8D-4FD6-9D2A-1B285E676636 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations 2014 (Q100538084).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$DAA26E60-AA8D-4FD6-9D2A-1B285E676636", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "For example, in Australia, employer contributions to superannuation accounts are taxed at the fixed rate of 15% for most employees.5 As this rate is usually lower than their marginal tax rate, most individuals benefit from a tax rate relief on their contributions.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 56", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05-2026-07-23.svg index e9f4a4df0..0400fb59f 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$DAA26E60-AA8D-4FD6-9D2A-1B285E676636 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + For example, in Australia, employer contributions to superannuation accounts are + taxed at the fixed rate of 15% for most employees.5 As this rate is usually lower Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$DAA26E60-AA8D-4FD6-9D2A-1B285E676636 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 56 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json index 998e98fec..d28e0e6ee 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 57. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$B77BD413-11D8-4238-A298-F74B9889CF3B in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations 2013 (Q100553596).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"668d58f9b4a379b957687fb1dc243c1223ffa1fa\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100553596,\"id\":\"Q100553596\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"1e2a78761fecc9e5ba1ba772d86ba7dbf29fe467\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2013-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$B77BD413-11D8-4238-A298-F74B9889CF3B\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$B77BD413-11D8-4238-A298-F74B9889CF3B", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "At the other extreme, contributions attracting tax relief are capped at 100% of income in the United Kingdom and the United States.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "At the other extreme, contributions attracting tax relief are capped at 100% of income in the United Kingdom and the United States.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 57", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "3bcf03e1205e3d7f9f25c42bf0d9811cb27ad89f6e7a170dacc671b129dfb720", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 833eb98edf192ec7a7ac111c1381257a1359c56cfbf0e42ab1e80f0fd44af627; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 3bcf03e1205e3d7f9f25c42bf0d9811cb27ad89f6e7a170dacc671b129dfb720; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2499, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "be011f01cb5aa7fc7ebce3f7e5de91b01271d38b0f01d3efbe7829b4b7d84f9e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$B77BD413-11D8-4238-A298-F74B9889CF3B in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations 2013 (Q100553596).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$B77BD413-11D8-4238-A298-F74B9889CF3B", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "At the other extreme, contributions attracting tax relief are capped at 100% of income in the United Kingdom and the United States.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 57", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06-2026-07-23.svg index eb476949a..4ed59c25f 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$B77BD413-11D8-4238-A298-F74B9889CF3B in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + At the other extreme, contributions attracting tax relief are capped at 100% of + income in the United Kingdom and the United States. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$B77BD413-11D8-4238-A298-F74B9889CF3B - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 57 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json index 85da5cd11..68a7af57c 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 57. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$47F5B1A8-2E67-4FDE-9A31-3DF5318F0D67 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations 2012 (Q100550869).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"c2b7c2a5dd951abe980f600219d128da4ed0f81c\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100550869,\"id\":\"Q100550869\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"8f3565657428592dc1dd7f92da0f734724d987d7\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2012-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$47F5B1A8-2E67-4FDE-9A31-3DF5318F0D67\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$47F5B1A8-2E67-4FDE-9A31-3DF5318F0D67", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "For example, in Belgium, contributions up to 3% of gross salary are eligible for the tax credit in VAPW plans, while contributions up to 9.4% of professional income are deductible from professional income for the self-employed in social VAPZ plans.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "For example, in Belgium, contributions up to 3% of gross salary are eligible for the tax credit in VAPW plans, while contributions up to 9.4% of professional income are deductible from professional income for the self-employed in social VAPZ plans.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 57", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "55c26d007b6d9e2fce28fe9c44baceee26c5b7fea9aefdf87360a2a2c5641d98", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 2656f7e3c7f08be2b648396f5f529e783aa755fde605d85270ccd7d42b8b79fc; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 55c26d007b6d9e2fce28fe9c44baceee26c5b7fea9aefdf87360a2a2c5641d98; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2500, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "be011f01cb5aa7fc7ebce3f7e5de91b01271d38b0f01d3efbe7829b4b7d84f9e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$47F5B1A8-2E67-4FDE-9A31-3DF5318F0D67 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations 2012 (Q100550869).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$47F5B1A8-2E67-4FDE-9A31-3DF5318F0D67", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "For example, in Belgium, contributions up to 3% of gross salary are eligible for the tax credit in VAPW plans, while contributions up to 9.4% of professional income are deductible from professional income for the self-employed in social VAPZ plans.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 57", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07-2026-07-23.svg index eb4f04a0b..65025b5e0 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$47F5B1A8-2E67-4FDE-9A31-3DF5318F0D67 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + For example, in Belgium, contributions up to 3% of gross salary are eligible for the + tax credit in VAPW plans, while contributions up to 9.4% of professional income are Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$47F5B1A8-2E67-4FDE-9A31-3DF5318F0D67 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 57 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json index f12610bf0..a4d8eb574 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 58. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$08A55C3B-E476-4114-BD32-D4479EAF9FB6 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2009 (Q100541993).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"87fa3eec37981084953bed4d8474f900fd05da5f\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100541993,\"id\":\"Q100541993\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"e4ce1ad4d6c6d0289a402c42bf392b7c735cbc30\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2009-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$08A55C3B-E476-4114-BD32-D4479EAF9FB6\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$08A55C3B-E476-4114-BD32-D4479EAF9FB6", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Maximum limit on contributions attracting tax relief expressed as a fixed amount, 2023 As a percentage of the average wage in the economy in 2022 Notes: Countries in the left panel have limits above 80% of the average wage.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Maximum limit on contributions attracting tax relief expressed as a fixed amount, 2023 As a percentage of the average wage in the economy in 2022 Notes: Countries in the left panel have limits above 80% of the average wage.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 58", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "43d4bf5dc2b338a6aca824889603b679c32df5c947b8a865fbae135c90bc0383", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 e74567ce4b76f8720270bedbfcb522e12f59d2a97e04ee5c2a2a2427b465ae73; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 43d4bf5dc2b338a6aca824889603b679c32df5c947b8a865fbae135c90bc0383; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2501, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "be011f01cb5aa7fc7ebce3f7e5de91b01271d38b0f01d3efbe7829b4b7d84f9e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$08A55C3B-E476-4114-BD32-D4479EAF9FB6 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2009 (Q100541993).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$08A55C3B-E476-4114-BD32-D4479EAF9FB6", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Maximum limit on contributions attracting tax relief expressed as a fixed amount, 2023 As a percentage of the average wage in the economy in 2022 Notes: Countries in the left panel have limits above 80% of the average wage.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 58", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08-2026-07-23.svg index 76cd2d378..bad7127c4 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$08A55C3B-E476-4114-BD32-D4479EAF9FB6 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + Maximum limit on contributions attracting tax relief expressed as a fixed amount, + 2023 As a percentage of the average wage in the economy in 2022 Notes: Countries in Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$08A55C3B-E476-4114-BD32-D4479EAF9FB6 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 58 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json index d09690718..196078a02 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 58. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$3074EEEF-50FF-4441-AA77-4CE2595059C9 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2007 (Q100587528).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"be5065301060d13729abe654e9c82ff33fae512d\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100587528,\"id\":\"Q100587528\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"4b8b0672c38a4a213d3ddf5553b775988e65ace9\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2007-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$3074EEEF-50FF-4441-AA77-4CE2595059C9\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$3074EEEF-50FF-4441-AA77-4CE2595059C9", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In Italy, employees can recoup the unused annual tax relief of their first years of participation during the following 20 years, up to 50% of the maximum annual relief per year.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Italy, employees can recoup the unused annual tax relief of their first years of participation during the following 20 years, up to 50% of the maximum annual relief per year.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 58", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "ff44a2fe68a90fa68a97ae4494340803497ce19e2d13b14b97eeb8e737ee4d4e", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 eaa683abb4abc33fa5192be658b35b3ce6228efe55f404369e0e71b61068d885; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 ff44a2fe68a90fa68a97ae4494340803497ce19e2d13b14b97eeb8e737ee4d4e; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2502, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "be011f01cb5aa7fc7ebce3f7e5de91b01271d38b0f01d3efbe7829b4b7d84f9e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$3074EEEF-50FF-4441-AA77-4CE2595059C9 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2007 (Q100587528).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$3074EEEF-50FF-4441-AA77-4CE2595059C9", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In Italy, employees can recoup the unused annual tax relief of their first years of participation during the following 20 years, up to 50% of the maximum annual relief per year.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 58", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09-2026-07-23.svg index 506bf7498..82ea87b82 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$3074EEEF-50FF-4441-AA77-4CE2595059C9 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + In Italy, employees can recoup the unused annual tax relief of their first years of + participation during the following 20 years, up to 50% of the maximum annual relief Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$3074EEEF-50FF-4441-AA77-4CE2595059C9 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 58 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json index 3549f5c6b..082c2dc45 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 60. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$4B6DE19B-0077-45F8-AECC-58D666766BDC in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2006 (Q100586862).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"954f9adbb2111e129c851fa56648907ed5fc4bc8\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100586862,\"id\":\"Q100586862\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"a910853afc29ee98ebd8b5f67a02ff08aea299d2\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2006-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$4B6DE19B-0077-45F8-AECC-58D666766BDC\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$4B6DE19B-0077-45F8-AECC-58D666766BDC", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Only 12 OECD countries tax investment income at least for selected pension plans.13 In Belgium, investment income is only taxed when the yearly investment return exceeds the guaranteed return, and the individual is granted a share of the excess return.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Only 12 OECD countries tax investment income at least for selected pension plans.13 In Belgium, investment income is only taxed when the yearly investment return exceeds the guaranteed return, and the individual is granted a share of the excess return.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 60", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "8c40eba2d3b04e25d10249b7efc3f52363e3936272c7dc532836107dbb0eb756", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 9eb40a042341d955dff33ae168eebc4a8acad27ec86498b1ec37ab8dc588fde5; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 8c40eba2d3b04e25d10249b7efc3f52363e3936272c7dc532836107dbb0eb756; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2503, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "be011f01cb5aa7fc7ebce3f7e5de91b01271d38b0f01d3efbe7829b4b7d84f9e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$4B6DE19B-0077-45F8-AECC-58D666766BDC in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2006 (Q100586862).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$4B6DE19B-0077-45F8-AECC-58D666766BDC", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Only 12 OECD countries tax investment income at least for selected pension plans.13 In Belgium, investment income is only taxed when the yearly investment return exceeds the guaranteed return, and the individual is granted a share of the excess return.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 60", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10-2026-07-23.svg index 888e219b6..82d16ccce 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$4B6DE19B-0077-45F8-AECC-58D666766BDC in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + Only 12 OECD countries tax investment income at least for selected pension plans.13 + In Belgium, investment income is only taxed when the yearly investment return Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$4B6DE19B-0077-45F8-AECC-58D666766BDC - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 60 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json index 6c17486f8..8a73b7d77 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 60. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$CCE4BA78-2644-42AD-8947-99BE738DB825 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2005 (Q100585900).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"b6cbb331f02409b4ab2556be10ce737adf8997e5\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100585900,\"id\":\"Q100585900\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"26896c2e3b989e92a54f934df3cb9368a0ce7adb\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2005-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$CCE4BA78-2644-42AD-8947-99BE738DB825\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$CCE4BA78-2644-42AD-8947-99BE738DB825", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "A fixed tax rate applies to investment income in Australia (15%), Denmark (15.3%), Greece (5%), Latvia (10%), the Slovak Republic (19%) and Sweden (15%).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "A fixed tax rate applies to investment income in Australia (15%), Denmark (15.3%), Greece (5%), Latvia (10%), the Slovak Republic (19%) and Sweden (15%).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 60", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "25fbf7d383d11405a539f01bbb300a47c4851b5355c883304ef65c88ba25c26c", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 bb3074f4da2cc5957b9975a0461e5b9421bf8c0806ba563424284e5b327cc51f; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 25fbf7d383d11405a539f01bbb300a47c4851b5355c883304ef65c88ba25c26c; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2504, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "c4ebf17f399c7e4254b118484719b30032d02674127881765dff147028eb2f63", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$CCE4BA78-2644-42AD-8947-99BE738DB825 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2005 (Q100585900).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$CCE4BA78-2644-42AD-8947-99BE738DB825", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "A fixed tax rate applies to investment income in Australia (15%), Denmark (15.3%), Greece (5%), Latvia (10%), the Slovak Republic (19%) and Sweden (15%).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 60", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01-2026-07-23.svg index 55391ea2f..71c95c2be 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$CCE4BA78-2644-42AD-8947-99BE738DB825 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + A fixed tax rate applies to investment income in Australia (15%), Denmark (15.3%), + Greece (5%), Latvia (10%), the Slovak Republic (19%) and Sweden (15%). Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$CCE4BA78-2644-42AD-8947-99BE738DB825 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 60 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json index 72f3a315c..c2b970892 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 61. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$0BF86943-1E1A-440D-BA80-C743FB40127E in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2004 (Q100584241).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"b6a442ba049631623158cd03472525961d0779b8\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100584241,\"id\":\"Q100584241\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"ba4e903e603892e17bd9796e98b823725cab176a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2004-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$0BF86943-1E1A-440D-BA80-C743FB40127E\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$0BF86943-1E1A-440D-BA80-C743FB40127E", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "For example, in Australia, pensions are taxed at the individual’s marginal tax rate before the preservation age, there is a 15% tax offset between the preservation age and 59 years old, and pensions are tax free from age 60.14 Other countries discouraging early withdrawals with the tax system include Belgium, Denmark, Estonia, France, Italy, Lithuania, Türkiye, the United Kingdom and the United States.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "For example, in Australia, pensions are taxed at the individual’s marginal tax rate before the preservation age, there is a 15% tax offset between the preservation age and 59 years old, and pensions are tax free from age 60.14 Other countries discouraging early withdrawals with the tax system include Belgium, Denmark, Estonia, France, Italy, Lithuania, Türkiye, the United Kingdom and the United States.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 61", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "d4ced180a49af5b508262ac2846da6b3226aaf5d142c12383ebadf37482a6716", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 41a13e0f5efa708193b4cc96ede97718f6a487d6d0fb838e152e92fcff6e524c; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 d4ced180a49af5b508262ac2846da6b3226aaf5d142c12383ebadf37482a6716; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2505, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "c4ebf17f399c7e4254b118484719b30032d02674127881765dff147028eb2f63", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$0BF86943-1E1A-440D-BA80-C743FB40127E in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2004 (Q100584241).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$0BF86943-1E1A-440D-BA80-C743FB40127E", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "For example, in Australia, pensions are taxed at the individual’s marginal tax rate before the preservation age, there is a 15% tax offset between the preservation age and 59 years old, and pensions are tax free from age 60.14 Other countries discouraging early withdrawals with the tax system include Belgium, Denmark, Estonia, France, Italy, Lithuania, Türkiye, the United Kingdom and the United States.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 61", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02-2026-07-23.svg index 03f982836..8d0597096 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$0BF86943-1E1A-440D-BA80-C743FB40127E in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + For example, in Australia, pensions are taxed at the individual’s marginal tax rate + before the preservation age, there is a 15% tax offset between the preservation age Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$0BF86943-1E1A-440D-BA80-C743FB40127E - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 61 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json index 882244d9c..4c60d7fbd 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 61. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$B3954D86-852F-4477-8EBF-32A85C727717 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations 2003 (Q100582165).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"e002b27b0d763bf2476f9f5c542847650c99c495\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100582165,\"id\":\"Q100582165\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"2c189c7c872983bd10a28e2acfc03f5c3738d76d\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2003-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$B3954D86-852F-4477-8EBF-32A85C727717\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$B3954D86-852F-4477-8EBF-32A85C727717", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Finally, only Ireland taxes the total amount of funds accumulated at the point of retirement once it exceeds a certain limit.15 The limit has been set at EUR 2 million since 1 January 2014.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Finally, only Ireland taxes the total amount of funds accumulated at the point of retirement once it exceeds a certain limit.15 The limit has been set at EUR 2 million since 1 January 2014.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 61", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "0989d7de3f275e6075bd760857abca3947aff550b200349ed8604aae5b692490", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 dcb5e5d148687bf91d8fab97b3130e4a06ded2c01ab06d375feac37c6c28de96; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 0989d7de3f275e6075bd760857abca3947aff550b200349ed8604aae5b692490; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2506, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "c4ebf17f399c7e4254b118484719b30032d02674127881765dff147028eb2f63", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$B3954D86-852F-4477-8EBF-32A85C727717 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations 2003 (Q100582165).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$B3954D86-852F-4477-8EBF-32A85C727717", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Finally, only Ireland taxes the total amount of funds accumulated at the point of retirement once it exceeds a certain limit.15 The limit has been set at EUR 2 million since 1 January 2014.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 61", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03-2026-07-23.svg index b286de5f7..2c93d16fb 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$B3954D86-852F-4477-8EBF-32A85C727717 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + Finally, only Ireland taxes the total amount of funds accumulated at the point of + retirement once it exceeds a certain limit.15 The limit has been set at EUR 2 Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$B3954D86-852F-4477-8EBF-32A85C727717 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 61 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json index c685d6e48..e50026a1d 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 62. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$FCD18CC9-B49E-479E-981D-54644E46A09F in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2002 (Q100580088).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"78d94a9f30d4e22ee47efa411b3b98732b8624df\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100580088,\"id\":\"Q100580088\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"9451da042cf866fedbd9efd17f0324c590c5c5dd\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2002-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$FCD18CC9-B49E-479E-981D-54644E46A09F\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$FCD18CC9-B49E-479E-981D-54644E46A09F", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The generosity of the match rate varies greatly across countries, from 4.25% in Austria to 325% in Mexico (solidarity savings programme for civil servants).16 The most common match rates are 20% (Colombia, Czechia, Hungary) and 50% (Australia, Chile, New Zealand).", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The generosity of the match rate varies greatly across countries, from 4.25% in Austria to 325% in Mexico (solidarity savings programme for civil servants).16 The most common match rates are 20% (Colombia, Czechia, Hungary) and 50% (Australia, Chile, New Zealand).", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 62", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "c8cf355b775f620855bc6bfcc031a820d11f57202348ab7e1e7fe647b6f6a395", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 41ef5298858e5b4029f5f4da0a61826ab7bfd26fe670cda0db9e315b7b0131b3; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 c8cf355b775f620855bc6bfcc031a820d11f57202348ab7e1e7fe647b6f6a395; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2507, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "c4ebf17f399c7e4254b118484719b30032d02674127881765dff147028eb2f63", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$FCD18CC9-B49E-479E-981D-54644E46A09F in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2002 (Q100580088).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$FCD18CC9-B49E-479E-981D-54644E46A09F", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The generosity of the match rate varies greatly across countries, from 4.25% in Austria to 325% in Mexico (solidarity savings programme for civil servants).16 The most common match rates are 20% (Colombia, Czechia, Hungary) and 50% (Australia, Chile, New Zealand).", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 62", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04-2026-07-23.svg index 621d9538f..a161eee8f 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$FCD18CC9-B49E-479E-981D-54644E46A09F in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + The generosity of the match rate varies greatly across countries, from 4.25% in + Austria to 325% in Mexico (solidarity savings programme for civil servants).16 The Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$FCD18CC9-B49E-479E-981D-54644E46A09F - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 62 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json index 9223d9b3c..1750f706c 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 63. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$048DDA1C-23EB-4B70-A9D3-582D63E66CA4 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2001 (Q100584272).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"24c7eb8dc414fa837577333bd6d949856c71be4e\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100584272,\"id\":\"Q100584272\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"eb0ebdca65f8a80fa9de530d9f3efd91003c1544\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2001-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$048DDA1C-23EB-4B70-A9D3-582D63E66CA4\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$048DDA1C-23EB-4B70-A9D3-582D63E66CA4", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In Lithuania, the government contributes 1.5% of the average gross salary of the year before the last in the account of people who have children up to three years old and who receive maternity benefits.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Lithuania, the government contributes 1.5% of the average gross salary of the year before the last in the account of people who have children up to three years old and who receive maternity benefits.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 63", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "03aa0844b0507daf32f8cacb144e4d7e9dc33b3ebe07a1acf35e107052776564", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 268d079a394379b7bdd0997c793782ed97b9511861e32038a587a4f420f254ce; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 03aa0844b0507daf32f8cacb144e4d7e9dc33b3ebe07a1acf35e107052776564; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2508, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "c4ebf17f399c7e4254b118484719b30032d02674127881765dff147028eb2f63", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$048DDA1C-23EB-4B70-A9D3-582D63E66CA4 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2001 (Q100584272).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$048DDA1C-23EB-4B70-A9D3-582D63E66CA4", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In Lithuania, the government contributes 1.5% of the average gross salary of the year before the last in the account of people who have children up to three years old and who receive maternity benefits.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 63", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05-2026-07-23.svg index f2ba23f46..8f0120a6d 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$048DDA1C-23EB-4B70-A9D3-582D63E66CA4 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + In Lithuania, the government contributes 1.5% of the average gross salary of the + year before the last in the account of people who have children up to three years Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$048DDA1C-23EB-4B70-A9D3-582D63E66CA4 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 63 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json index bdaa1f0cb..bbadec60c 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 64. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$125162FA-2281-4C88-BA3F-FEDDE16F6B99 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2000 (Q100583337).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"14fc46f00e006a23d73452cc0134f7de03bc5ce0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100583337,\"id\":\"Q100583337\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"e701093471a4f4e2e08f4a95fb504eb6270222cf\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2000-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$125162FA-2281-4C88-BA3F-FEDDE16F6B99\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$125162FA-2281-4C88-BA3F-FEDDE16F6B99", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In Italy for instance, employer contributions are subject to a rate of 10% instead of the standard 24% rate, on earnings up to a ceiling.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Italy for instance, employer contributions are subject to a rate of 10% instead of the standard 24% rate, on earnings up to a ceiling.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 64", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "49a408f3b545aa3ca66521765c98262e3aaf08d8d563e2eb337a1b915f1dde66", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 827e235cce8f759d26bc1ee63685694d9337145fe992212b42f1048add511097; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 49a408f3b545aa3ca66521765c98262e3aaf08d8d563e2eb337a1b915f1dde66; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2509, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "c4ebf17f399c7e4254b118484719b30032d02674127881765dff147028eb2f63", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$125162FA-2281-4C88-BA3F-FEDDE16F6B99 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2000 (Q100583337).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$125162FA-2281-4C88-BA3F-FEDDE16F6B99", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In Italy for instance, employer contributions are subject to a rate of 10% instead of the standard 24% rate, on earnings up to a ceiling.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 64", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06-2026-07-23.svg index 7299b3d92..fabba3853 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$125162FA-2281-4C88-BA3F-FEDDE16F6B99 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + In Italy for instance, employer contributions are subject to a rate of 10% instead + of the standard 24% rate, on earnings up to a ceiling. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$125162FA-2281-4C88-BA3F-FEDDE16F6B99 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 64 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json index 8c11a53d4..fafddac8c 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 65. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$BD82B010-7038-482F-A19B-0FD3548AADBE in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 1999 (Q100582136).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"df2154af2d011560e0bcb9713f039c44c213b7c2\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100582136,\"id\":\"Q100582136\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"2c64374fe06f9ab82c26fc46f639526f59a8bcda\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+1999-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$BD82B010-7038-482F-A19B-0FD3548AADBE\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$BD82B010-7038-482F-A19B-0FD3548AADBE", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In Korea, charges for the Wage Claim Guarantee Fund are reduced by up to 50% if employers set up occupational pension plans rather than severance payment schemes.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Korea, charges for the Wage Claim Guarantee Fund are reduced by up to 50% if employers set up occupational pension plans rather than severance payment schemes.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 65", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "4d95d83abd25cb4b007600163c0a45f95c39261b021860769bdd3a2c483ce4c7", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 0df15e60aefb7837937d64b0d3d703fb3a4c824fa2c86d4b68d06601d8734010; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 4d95d83abd25cb4b007600163c0a45f95c39261b021860769bdd3a2c483ce4c7; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2510, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "c4ebf17f399c7e4254b118484719b30032d02674127881765dff147028eb2f63", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$BD82B010-7038-482F-A19B-0FD3548AADBE in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 1999 (Q100582136).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$BD82B010-7038-482F-A19B-0FD3548AADBE", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In Korea, charges for the Wage Claim Guarantee Fund are reduced by up to 50% if employers set up occupational pension plans rather than severance payment schemes.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 65", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07-2026-07-23.svg index 9a46bde91..0a7042be7 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$BD82B010-7038-482F-A19B-0FD3548AADBE in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + In Korea, charges for the Wage Claim Guarantee Fund are reduced by up to 50% if + employers set up occupational pension plans rather than severance payment schemes. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$BD82B010-7038-482F-A19B-0FD3548AADBE - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 65 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json index ffa0752d4..459bd70a4 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 66. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$92E9B04A-F634-47FA-8791-9A6C8611D9E9 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 1998 (Q100581035).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"84502b57b17648f7728240cb4e4ab0cd28da0e19\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100581035,\"id\":\"Q100581035\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"54689e87cdcaf5a15252503de7640bab54d4911a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+1998-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$92E9B04A-F634-47FA-8791-9A6C8611D9E9\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$92E9B04A-F634-47FA-8791-9A6C8611D9E9", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The United Kingdom eliminated the tax charge that applied when an individual had built up pension savings worth more than the lifetime allowance as of the tax year 2023/24.23 It also increased in 2021 the income limit from which the annual allowance is reduced, from GBP 150 000 to GBP 240 000.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The United Kingdom eliminated the tax charge that applied when an individual had built up pension savings worth more than the lifetime allowance as of the tax year 2023/24.23 It also increased in 2021 the income limit from which the annual allowance is reduced, from GBP 150 000 to GBP 240 000.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 66", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "9ebb196e45756e54ad7f7f142c1a6f3668337b815feb1487b2de2215051a6865", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 5eed445a2bf722b82347ac1b5f8331082ca50527c9c2c61770208d7b73ddb80c; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 9ebb196e45756e54ad7f7f142c1a6f3668337b815feb1487b2de2215051a6865; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2511, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "c4ebf17f399c7e4254b118484719b30032d02674127881765dff147028eb2f63", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$92E9B04A-F634-47FA-8791-9A6C8611D9E9 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 1998 (Q100581035).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$92E9B04A-F634-47FA-8791-9A6C8611D9E9", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The United Kingdom eliminated the tax charge that applied when an individual had built up pension savings worth more than the lifetime allowance as of the tax year 2023/24.23 It also increased in 2021 the income limit from which the annual allowance is reduced, from GBP 150 000 to GBP 240 000.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 66", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08-2026-07-23.svg index ea7a7e2ae..d6d48235b 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$92E9B04A-F634-47FA-8791-9A6C8611D9E9 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + The United Kingdom eliminated the tax charge that applied when an individual had + built up pension savings worth more than the lifetime allowance as of the tax year Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$92E9B04A-F634-47FA-8791-9A6C8611D9E9 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 66 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json index 03c6c90e4..77adf277f 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 66. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$D16D24D2-2DC9-4396-A40E-AFE63827FDBE in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 1997 (Q100580115).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"9a24340df140c02784898054d2d02c9a283e63f8\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100580115,\"id\":\"Q100580115\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"9b8d0cec6ae0bc77abcf6acaac222401c81f350f\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+1997-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$D16D24D2-2DC9-4396-A40E-AFE63827FDBE\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$D16D24D2-2DC9-4396-A40E-AFE63827FDBE", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Finally, in Italy, returns on new investment in stocks of Italian and European companies made since 2017 are tax free (instead of a standard tax rate of 20%) if the securities are held for at least five years.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Finally, in Italy, returns on new investment in stocks of Italian and European companies made since 2017 are tax free (instead of a standard tax rate of 20%) if the securities are held for at least five years.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 66", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "55878c992f8ded785f543cd02ee2a91793b0a20102bda30ba9ba7df50f434af3", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 affaf2330b55f5c436c014dcfadfacc79db96f54823023fb9c625caec7c0a489; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 55878c992f8ded785f543cd02ee2a91793b0a20102bda30ba9ba7df50f434af3; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2512, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "c4ebf17f399c7e4254b118484719b30032d02674127881765dff147028eb2f63", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$D16D24D2-2DC9-4396-A40E-AFE63827FDBE in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 1997 (Q100580115).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$D16D24D2-2DC9-4396-A40E-AFE63827FDBE", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Finally, in Italy, returns on new investment in stocks of Italian and European companies made since 2017 are tax free (instead of a standard tax rate of 20%) if the securities are held for at least five years.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 66", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09-2026-07-23.svg index 7e59efc48..8570eb35a 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$D16D24D2-2DC9-4396-A40E-AFE63827FDBE in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + Finally, in Italy, returns on new investment in stocks of Italian and European + companies made since 2017 are tax free (instead of a standard tax rate of 20%) if Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$D16D24D2-2DC9-4396-A40E-AFE63827FDBE - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 66 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json index b56bf6d01..5df5bbbfc 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 67. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$E4C8314A-A33F-4F79-8A69-A9279FA48407 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2019 (Q100550884).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"0bd46507fb27338dba0a6aea382e6f7291880cde\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100550884,\"id\":\"Q100550884\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"77f348fcb49110a0de3c2faf4865527dc30dcbc9\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2019-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$E4C8314A-A33F-4F79-8A69-A9279FA48407\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$E4C8314A-A33F-4F79-8A69-A9279FA48407", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The extra exemptions were further increased in to 32% and 12% respectively, meaning that 132% or 112% of contributions are tax exempted instead of 100%.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The extra exemptions were further increased in to 32% and 12% respectively, meaning that 132% or 112% of contributions are tax exempted instead of 100%.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 67", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "fd039bcd3ce765df35895ca3d46800e6444e6a50b20d7561ec22512c0128806c", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 42a37f174d6da051d056eeb5d23dcf92268cfa783577b0c483ea7d12bc47b432; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 fd039bcd3ce765df35895ca3d46800e6444e6a50b20d7561ec22512c0128806c; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2513, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "c4ebf17f399c7e4254b118484719b30032d02674127881765dff147028eb2f63", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$E4C8314A-A33F-4F79-8A69-A9279FA48407 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2019 (Q100550884).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$E4C8314A-A33F-4F79-8A69-A9279FA48407", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The extra exemptions were further increased in to 32% and 12% respectively, meaning that 132% or 112% of contributions are tax exempted instead of 100%.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 67", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10-2026-07-23.svg index 1cf2d85e0..7e4da0519 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$E4C8314A-A33F-4F79-8A69-A9279FA48407 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + The extra exemptions were further increased in to 32% and 12% respectively, meaning + that 132% or 112% of contributions are tax exempted instead of 100%. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$E4C8314A-A33F-4F79-8A69-A9279FA48407 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 67 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json index 05a61136a..bcf88364a 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 67. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$FE0E3788-63C1-47FD-AD76-ECDAB0999D52 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2018 (Q100548565).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"820ebf90b2e932ba3f81ad4409bd948f25b547c3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100548565,\"id\":\"Q100548565\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"6174553681261aeec411766adf691fdeec1dee47\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2018-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$FE0E3788-63C1-47FD-AD76-ECDAB0999D52\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$FE0E3788-63C1-47FD-AD76-ECDAB0999D52", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Australia, Chile, France, Iceland, Spain, Portugal, and the United States allowed special early access to retirement savings in 2020 and beyond in order to provide short-term relief for members affected by the COVID-19 crisis.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Australia, Chile, France, Iceland, Spain, Portugal, and the United States allowed special early access to retirement savings in 2020 and beyond in order to provide short-term relief for members affected by the COVID-19 crisis.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 67", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "170c442d86c55a4dadc05638979556a9e216677cd16f0d869ff10435e3ce7586", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 b92181fcddf23dcd8563b57b2e3e699a14a8f101d087d288fab7b5234074b090; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 170c442d86c55a4dadc05638979556a9e216677cd16f0d869ff10435e3ce7586; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2514, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "1bc478d7ff638cd5c835f1016da351d4a693d60179288bb5ae774723fd2f8d5e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$FE0E3788-63C1-47FD-AD76-ECDAB0999D52 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations, 2018 (Q100548565).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$FE0E3788-63C1-47FD-AD76-ECDAB0999D52", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Australia, Chile, France, Iceland, Spain, Portugal, and the United States allowed special early access to retirement savings in 2020 and beyond in order to provide short-term relief for members affected by the COVID-19 crisis.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 67", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01-2026-07-23.svg index f6228b07e..2e6e3abb8 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$FE0E3788-63C1-47FD-AD76-ECDAB0999D52 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + Australia, Chile, France, Iceland, Spain, Portugal, and the United States allowed + special early access to retirement savings in 2020 and beyond in order to provide Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$FE0E3788-63C1-47FD-AD76-ECDAB0999D52 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 67 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json index fc59527ac..6a881cf9e 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 68. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$29C7DE35-AC94-4E57-85E8-70EE15F1B192 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations 2016 (Q100542539).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"0d1ec58951e9696e232d9d896fd1e7728b2421e3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100542539,\"id\":\"Q100542539\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"f4e1bbc6e9b3a72c2e1fd3e6061f4c7e7f5acad9\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2016-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$29C7DE35-AC94-4E57-85E8-70EE15F1B192\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$29C7DE35-AC94-4E57-85E8-70EE15F1B192", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In Hungary, since 2019, employer contributions to voluntary pension funds and to institutions for occupational retirement provisions are considered taxable income for the employee.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Hungary, since 2019, employer contributions to voluntary pension funds and to institutions for occupational retirement provisions are considered taxable income for the employee.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 68", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "0096adc487e990f770906d22dda232c73d1752d26ec46a5138929f4ad49ce279", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 8559e322f439061efb06e4d41add94fd15fcc838c42d8eb0e91a94b5723304fa; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 0096adc487e990f770906d22dda232c73d1752d26ec46a5138929f4ad49ce279; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2515, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "1bc478d7ff638cd5c835f1016da351d4a693d60179288bb5ae774723fd2f8d5e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$29C7DE35-AC94-4E57-85E8-70EE15F1B192 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations 2016 (Q100542539).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$29C7DE35-AC94-4E57-85E8-70EE15F1B192", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In Hungary, since 2019, employer contributions to voluntary pension funds and to institutions for occupational retirement provisions are considered taxable income for the employee.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 68", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02-2026-07-23.svg index 7356ad4d2..87ad6a0bd 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$29C7DE35-AC94-4E57-85E8-70EE15F1B192 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + In Hungary, since 2019, employer contributions to voluntary pension funds and to + institutions for occupational retirement provisions are considered taxable income Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$29C7DE35-AC94-4E57-85E8-70EE15F1B192 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 68 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json index 75c4d74dd..8287867b7 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 70. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$F1BBC7A1-9477-44A8-AEFE-DC46F7AFDC91 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations 2011 (Q100547864).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"0f5670154796f639a4cd1ae9e03fa2354b6c944c\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100547864,\"id\":\"Q100547864\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"1277780215cd5ca03e85ca9c50830783b4fedfe1\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2011-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$F1BBC7A1-9477-44A8-AEFE-DC46F7AFDC91\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$F1BBC7A1-9477-44A8-AEFE-DC46F7AFDC91", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In Türkiye, individuals receive government matching contributions and fixed nominal subsidies, and the tax rate on investment income may be as low as 5% if the individual withdraws benefits from age 56 after at least 10 years of participation in the pension plan.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In Türkiye, individuals receive government matching contributions and fixed nominal subsidies, and the tax rate on investment income may be as low as 5% if the individual withdraws benefits from age 56 after at least 10 years of participation in the pension plan.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 70", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "d5e239e4dc8ab6fd985edc031b98539417ff12c781dc2cf186efe6feb7715df1", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 3618451655d4bed55747d3c719e420e2ff47c26748cdefaf6c95784095504f0f; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 d5e239e4dc8ab6fd985edc031b98539417ff12c781dc2cf186efe6feb7715df1; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2516, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "1bc478d7ff638cd5c835f1016da351d4a693d60179288bb5ae774723fd2f8d5e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$F1BBC7A1-9477-44A8-AEFE-DC46F7AFDC91 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Revaluation) Regulations 2011 (Q100547864).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$F1BBC7A1-9477-44A8-AEFE-DC46F7AFDC91", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In Türkiye, individuals receive government matching contributions and fixed nominal subsidies, and the tax rate on investment income may be as low as 5% if the individual withdraws benefits from age 56 after at least 10 years of participation in the pension plan.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 70", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03-2026-07-23.svg index 92c5bde71..f5f78f6fc 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$F1BBC7A1-9477-44A8-AEFE-DC46F7AFDC91 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + In Türkiye, individuals receive government matching contributions and fixed nominal + subsidies, and the tax rate on investment income may be as low as 5% if the Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$F1BBC7A1-9477-44A8-AEFE-DC46F7AFDC91 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 70 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json index 4e465bc6d..0241c7001 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 71. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$AEE80C0B-DFF8-4431-9D29-860232CA0450 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Preservation of Benefits) Regulations, 2002 (Q100580820).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"a4027533e4b93d5d6330c2ddac098866f77585ee\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100580820,\"id\":\"Q100580820\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"9451da042cf866fedbd9efd17f0324c590c5c5dd\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2002-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$AEE80C0B-DFF8-4431-9D29-860232CA0450\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$AEE80C0B-DFF8-4431-9D29-860232CA0450", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Indeed, the OFE plans, to which the “EET” tax treatment applies, are losing importance as participation is no longer mandatory since 2014.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Indeed, the OFE plans, to which the “EET” tax treatment applies, are losing importance as participation is no longer mandatory since 2014.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 71", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "e46a880f67126a6ae16b7a36b01bb38c09e30793906c423a380381038b4e347a", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 b4e97ff6376919683985178fe20b91e507eee07412ff72d2787f4562a47ecc7d; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 e46a880f67126a6ae16b7a36b01bb38c09e30793906c423a380381038b4e347a; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2517, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "1bc478d7ff638cd5c835f1016da351d4a693d60179288bb5ae774723fd2f8d5e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$AEE80C0B-DFF8-4431-9D29-860232CA0450 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Preservation of Benefits) Regulations, 2002 (Q100580820).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$AEE80C0B-DFF8-4431-9D29-860232CA0450", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Indeed, the OFE plans, to which the “EET” tax treatment applies, are losing importance as participation is no longer mandatory since 2014.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 71", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04-2026-07-23.svg index 21485234c..2c93c1132 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$AEE80C0B-DFF8-4431-9D29-860232CA0450 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + Indeed, the OFE plans, to which the “EET” tax treatment applies, are losing + importance as participation is no longer mandatory since 2014. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$AEE80C0B-DFF8-4431-9D29-860232CA0450 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 71 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json index f89159e25..1ab6ca17e 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 71. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$71C3D0E1-F632-40B5-BD8F-BE52F1B48D6B in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Pensions Ombudsman Regulations, 2003 (Q100583122).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"e8cb248d4cdcb473bb6474f84075ea9a5478b761\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100583122,\"id\":\"Q100583122\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"2c189c7c872983bd10a28e2acfc03f5c3738d76d\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2003-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$71C3D0E1-F632-40B5-BD8F-BE52F1B48D6B\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$71C3D0E1-F632-40B5-BD8F-BE52F1B48D6B", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Meanwhile, employees have been enrolled automatically into PPK plans since 2019, and the applicable tax regime is “TEE”.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Meanwhile, employees have been enrolled automatically into PPK plans since 2019, and the applicable tax regime is “TEE”.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 71", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "31883841831b75c49dce7d0af590a0235fe40e9bc01142add139ea5ab7c2b853", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 6119829e851f15bda2c6a062fc64c01275c0ef697dd84123509641f214098d51; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 31883841831b75c49dce7d0af590a0235fe40e9bc01142add139ea5ab7c2b853; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2518, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "1bc478d7ff638cd5c835f1016da351d4a693d60179288bb5ae774723fd2f8d5e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$71C3D0E1-F632-40B5-BD8F-BE52F1B48D6B in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Pensions Ombudsman Regulations, 2003 (Q100583122).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$71C3D0E1-F632-40B5-BD8F-BE52F1B48D6B", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Meanwhile, employees have been enrolled automatically into PPK plans since 2019, and the applicable tax regime is “TEE”.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 71", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05-2026-07-23.svg index 62ea0afc5..9a169c086 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$71C3D0E1-F632-40B5-BD8F-BE52F1B48D6B in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + Meanwhile, employees have been enrolled automatically into PPK plans since 2019, and + the applicable tax regime is “TEE”. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$71C3D0E1-F632-40B5-BD8F-BE52F1B48D6B - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 71 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json index bade64338..5ad375005 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 72. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$084C1E13-9136-48B0-ACA6-A8633D375B2E in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Funding Standard) Regulations, 1993 (Q100576986).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"a0cdc5ca26f39115dbd62f6f59026263c61417b3\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100576986,\"id\":\"Q100576986\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"90c1ec53fb2353d85282cca17898f95b43cc4d63\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+1993-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$084C1E13-9136-48B0-ACA6-A8633D375B2E\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$084C1E13-9136-48B0-ACA6-A8633D375B2E", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "For example, in Lithuania, pension benefits from third pillar pension funds are taxed at 15% if the pension contract lasted less than five years or if the individual is more than five years before the statutory age of retirement.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "For example, in Lithuania, pension benefits from third pillar pension funds are taxed at 15% if the pension contract lasted less than five years or if the individual is more than five years before the statutory age of retirement.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 72", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "c152c118a25db0a306c545dfee4b06d06ee688d2718586603c12d45e0dfbf031", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 5ffc4f2e81c39766b30d571f7727863ac64043d507c907b5c0906a6323b111eb; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 c152c118a25db0a306c545dfee4b06d06ee688d2718586603c12d45e0dfbf031; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2519, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "1bc478d7ff638cd5c835f1016da351d4a693d60179288bb5ae774723fd2f8d5e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$084C1E13-9136-48B0-ACA6-A8633D375B2E in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Funding Standard) Regulations, 1993 (Q100576986).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$084C1E13-9136-48B0-ACA6-A8633D375B2E", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "For example, in Lithuania, pension benefits from third pillar pension funds are taxed at 15% if the pension contract lasted less than five years or if the individual is more than five years before the statutory age of retirement.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 72", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06-2026-07-23.svg index 6412a65c6..4461f29ed 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$084C1E13-9136-48B0-ACA6-A8633D375B2E in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + For example, in Lithuania, pension benefits from third pillar pension funds are + taxed at 15% if the pension contract lasted less than five years or if the Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$084C1E13-9136-48B0-ACA6-A8633D375B2E - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 72 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json index 2fc22299f..c482ed223 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 72. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$35C51B15-DF1F-43DF-AEFA-F314137FD903 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare and Pensions (No. 2) Act, 2013 (Q100400137).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"8634cda36a147bda290882664db2eb335fe69230\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100400137,\"id\":\"Q100400137\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"1e2a78761fecc9e5ba1ba772d86ba7dbf29fe467\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2013-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$35C51B15-DF1F-43DF-AEFA-F314137FD903\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$35C51B15-DF1F-43DF-AEFA-F314137FD903", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "For example, in Czechia, annuities and programmed withdrawals paid over at least 10 years are tax free, while lump sums and programmed withdrawals over shorter periods are taxable.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "For example, in Czechia, annuities and programmed withdrawals paid over at least 10 years are tax free, while lump sums and programmed withdrawals over shorter periods are taxable.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 72", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "9c5d5401480800745dfc2a87ed5dbc01e1e078e85c1b68d8aae26de5170f67e4", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 4016e89693399d6b77ca1accea639f328303198f18cf067e13feac07ad32f1ea; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 9c5d5401480800745dfc2a87ed5dbc01e1e078e85c1b68d8aae26de5170f67e4; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2520, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "1bc478d7ff638cd5c835f1016da351d4a693d60179288bb5ae774723fd2f8d5e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$35C51B15-DF1F-43DF-AEFA-F314137FD903 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare and Pensions (No. 2) Act, 2013 (Q100400137).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$35C51B15-DF1F-43DF-AEFA-F314137FD903", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "For example, in Czechia, annuities and programmed withdrawals paid over at least 10 years are tax free, while lump sums and programmed withdrawals over shorter periods are taxable.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 72", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07-2026-07-23.svg index 63b2c1400..f303886ff 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$35C51B15-DF1F-43DF-AEFA-F314137FD903 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + For example, in Czechia, annuities and programmed withdrawals paid over at least 10 + years are tax free, while lump sums and programmed withdrawals over shorter periods Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$35C51B15-DF1F-43DF-AEFA-F314137FD903 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 72 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json index e171be533..1b4c64fce 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 73. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$E45F3A92-2045-4E91-BB6B-5FAF41663D20 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 2008 (Q100399905).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"91fbe4336b773c01251a168b04aeeb7256fb32ed\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100399905,\"id\":\"Q100399905\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"43bdb90ab9b607c864931ed584115ff944210c6b\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2008-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$E45F3A92-2045-4E91-BB6B-5FAF41663D20\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$E45F3A92-2045-4E91-BB6B-5FAF41663D20", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "The 30% tax credit was, therefore, more advantageous than a tax deduction for the lower earners, but less advantageous for the higher earners.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "The 30% tax credit was, therefore, more advantageous than a tax deduction for the lower earners, but less advantageous for the higher earners.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 73", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "e8784a0a84f3b7af075bc9ba11f47a24562eb4c7d7f432678ea146d5b827443d", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 c0b24fcd681a11f96ecd75841777682142a717873cb3225b860f5be772147398; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 e8784a0a84f3b7af075bc9ba11f47a24562eb4c7d7f432678ea146d5b827443d; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2521, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "1bc478d7ff638cd5c835f1016da351d4a693d60179288bb5ae774723fd2f8d5e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$E45F3A92-2045-4E91-BB6B-5FAF41663D20 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 2008 (Q100399905).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$E45F3A92-2045-4E91-BB6B-5FAF41663D20", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "The 30% tax credit was, therefore, more advantageous than a tax deduction for the lower earners, but less advantageous for the higher earners.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 73", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08-2026-07-23.svg index 279727f33..04f52d7a5 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$E45F3A92-2045-4E91-BB6B-5FAF41663D20 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + The 30% tax credit was, therefore, more advantageous than a tax deduction for the + lower earners, but less advantageous for the higher earners. Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$E45F3A92-2045-4E91-BB6B-5FAF41663D20 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 73 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json index bc5eb0cba..3908b663d 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 74. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$647ED083-AD4C-48EE-9BE6-06A03A2772D1 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value District Court (Days and Hours) (August Sittings) Order 2008 (Q100539590).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"37911c3c2c0a42852f23085d0215380d519cfd7b\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100539590,\"id\":\"Q100539590\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"43bdb90ab9b607c864931ed584115ff944210c6b\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2008-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$647ED083-AD4C-48EE-9BE6-06A03A2772D1\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$647ED083-AD4C-48EE-9BE6-06A03A2772D1", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "In addition, individuals must be younger than 71, at least 10% of their total income must be from employment or business, and their total superannuation balance must be less than the general transfer balance cap on 30 June of the previous financial year.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "In addition, individuals must be younger than 71, at least 10% of their total income must be from employment or business, and their total superannuation balance must be less than the general transfer balance cap on 30 June of the previous financial year.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 74", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "422aaf1ca4f3b8678fad31ea329ec94113a71c73897936b058eb1933786a939e", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 07880c07f8f84916e9c9cd92d94533a3cc2d58a3b0d77c1f40be50db29e2c60d; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 422aaf1ca4f3b8678fad31ea329ec94113a71c73897936b058eb1933786a939e; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2522, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "1bc478d7ff638cd5c835f1016da351d4a693d60179288bb5ae774723fd2f8d5e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$647ED083-AD4C-48EE-9BE6-06A03A2772D1 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value District Court (Days and Hours) (August Sittings) Order 2008 (Q100539590).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$647ED083-AD4C-48EE-9BE6-06A03A2772D1", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "In addition, individuals must be younger than 71, at least 10% of their total income must be from employment or business, and their total superannuation balance must be less than the general transfer balance cap on 30 June of the previous financial year.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 74", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09-2026-07-23.svg index 9099851d4..8d9a82695 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$647ED083-AD4C-48EE-9BE6-06A03A2772D1 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + In addition, individuals must be younger than 71, at least 10% of their total income + must be from employment or business, and their total superannuation balance must be Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$647ED083-AD4C-48EE-9BE6-06A03A2772D1 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 74 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json index 7fdb69382..b3469ffab 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json @@ -1,53 +1,55 @@ { - "access_date": "2026-07-26", - "ai_assistance": "AI assisted pipeline design and code review; source discovery and outcomes are determined by the committed deterministic collector and byte checks.", - "baseline_control_summary": "Control requires the statement GUID and exact JSON excerpt to occur in the named immutable revision; the revision payload SHA-256 must match.", + "access_date": "2026-08-17", + "ai_assistance": "AI assisted source selection and deterministic quote extraction; the committed verifier checks the source hash and exact quote. No independent human semantic adjudication is claimed.", + "baseline_control_summary": "The gate passes only when the full fetched response SHA-256 matches and the exact quoted statement occurs in normalized source text.", "card_svg_rendered": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10-2026-07-23.svg", "card_svg_template": "docs/assets/claimbound_evidence_card.svg", - "claim_boundary": "This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world truth of the statement.", - "claim_type": "public_statement_publication", - "created_at": "2026-07-26", + "claim_boundary": "Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the statement's underlying real-world truth.", + "claim_type": "primary_source_public_statement", + "created_at": "2026-08-17", "domain": "pensions", "evidence_id": "CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10-2026-07-23", "evidence_url": "https://github.com/ClaimBound/claimbound-evidence/blob/main/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json", "execution_mode": "AUTOMATED_AI_ASSISTED", "git_commit": "local-before-merge", "known_limitations": [ - "Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision.", - "Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth.", - "No claim is made outside the exact statement GUID and revision boundary." + "This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection.", + "The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth.", + "The source is the named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements.", + "A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately documented rerun." ], - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", - "manual_review": "Deterministic local review confirmed that the exact statement JSON and GUID occur in the revision content and that the full content hash matches.", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "official_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", + "manual_review": "Source locator recorded as PDF page 74. Automated verification requires the exact quote in the hash-bound source; independent human semantic review is not registered.", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "official_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", "operator": "NeoZorK", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10", - "protocol_version": "CB7K-WIKIDATA-PUBLICATION-REVISION-v1", - "public_claim_text": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$D9071354-0341-4DE4-8B3F-9B896C591F35 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Funding Standard Reserve) Regulations 2013 (Q100536134).", - "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "{\"mainsnak\":{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P2567\",\"hash\":\"730c4205001c5a2c3dc9780b7f965cce00f3d63e\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":100536134,\"id\":\"Q100536134\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}},\"type\":\"statement\",\"qualifiers\":{\"P585\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P585\",\"hash\":\"1e2a78761fecc9e5ba1ba772d86ba7dbf29fe467\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"time\":\"+2013-00-00T00:00:00Z\",\"timezone\":0,\"before\":0,\"after\":0,\"precision\":9,\"calendarmodel\":\"http:\\/\\/www.wikidata.org\\/entity\\/Q1985727\"},\"type\":\"time\"}}]},\"qualifiers-order\":[\"P585\"],\"id\":\"Q100399163$D9071354-0341-4DE4-8B3F-9B896C591F35\",\"rank\":\"normal\",\"references\":[{\"hash\":\"f11f18616ad054ab50fd7ba2daa6bda1482d3079\",\"snaks\":{\"P248\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P248\",\"hash\":\"9f7432e2e5e489c942fbc44603d8503f024b3a9a\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":{\"entity-type\":\"item\",\"numeric-id\":17100343,\"id\":\"Q17100343\"},\"type\":\"wikibase-entityid\"}}],\"P854\":[{\"snaktype\":\"value\",\"property\":\"P854\",\"hash\":\"57c9a1bc898f0d193b54c09726eed3db1a0682a0\",\"datavalue\":{\"value\":\"http:\\/\\/www.irishstatutebook.ie\\/eli\\/isbc\\/1990_25.html\",\"type\":\"string\"}}]},\"snaks-order\":[\"P248\",\"P854\"]}]}", - "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.wikidata.org/w/api.php?action=query&format=json&prop=revisions&revids=2498238847&rvprop=ids%7Ctimestamp%7Ccontent&rvslots=main&formatversion=2", - "public_claim_locator": "entity Q100399163; claims.P2567; statement Q100399163$D9071354-0341-4DE4-8B3F-9B896C591F35", - "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "public_claim_source_sha256": "8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4", + "protocol_version": "CB7K-PRIMARY-SOURCE-PUBLICATION-RETROSPECTIVE-v1", + "public_claim_text": "Individuals paying personal income tax at a higher rate (40% or 45%) can claim the difference through their tax return or by calling or writing to His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs.", + "public_claim_verbatim_quote": "Individuals paying personal income tax at a higher rate (40% or 45%) can claim the difference through their tax return or by calling or writing to His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs.", + "public_claim_source_url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-pensions-outlook-2024_51510909-en.html", + "public_claim_locator": "PDF page 74", + "public_claim_captured_at": "2026-08-17", + "public_claim_source_sha256": "f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97", + "public_claim_quote_sha256": "e9bd0acbbf2b5776e1ffbd0f558dc03e48954d682ec7c3c472a5a78813f13852", "raw_payload_committed": false, - "raw_payload_manifest": "Wikidata revision 2498238847; entity Q100399163; source SHA-256 8f008b90a365fb04df02e06a917fe8d84d6fb3b40681e6c0bd5d0966ab304fe4; statement SHA-256 f646a20150735392ca7d3965b89d0b876edbbd1673d1b1612dfbcc171a8ea0c5; raw revision content retained in local cache only", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "raw_payload_manifest": "source SHA-256 f074273160b40949070cc34d589e69315dd38e11cd004856a127abe2a9b2be97; quote SHA-256 e9bd0acbbf2b5776e1ffbd0f558dc03e48954d682ec7c3c472a5a78813f13852; raw PDF retained outside the public repository", + "record_type": "source_audit", "registry_sequence": 2523, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", - "runner_command": "python scripts/build_wikidata_public_claims.py verify-sources artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json --cache ", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", - "sanitized_report_sha256": "4d46db440759fbfc473f5efea04b79a23ca2d490452f8ef778c6a37f2a988c86", - "source_rights_note": "Wikidata structured data is CC0; raw revision payloads are not committed.", + "runner_command": "python scripts/verify_primary_public_claim_group.py artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json --source-file ", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", + "sanitized_report_sha256": "1bc478d7ff638cd5c835f1016da351d4a693d60179288bb5ae774723fd2f8d5e", + "source_rights_note": "Named public primary source; only limited quotes, locators, and hashes are committed.", "verification_count": 1, "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "visual_summary": { - "allowed_claim_sentence": "Wikidata statement Q100399163$D9071354-0341-4DE4-8B3F-9B896C591F35 in revision 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) with value Occupational Pension Schemes (Funding Standard Reserve) Regulations 2013 (Q100536134).", - "artifact_ref": "statement Q100399163$D9071354-0341-4DE4-8B3F-9B896C591F35", - "candidate_definition": "Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567", - "controls_and_gate": "exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256", - "period_scope": "revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z", - "target_definition": "Pensions" + "allowed_claim_sentence": "Individuals paying personal income tax at a higher rate (40% or 45%) can claim the difference through their tax return or by calling or writing to His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs.", + "artifact_ref": "PDF page 74", + "candidate_definition": "one exact statement in the named primary source", + "controls_and_gate": "exact quote + complete response SHA-256", + "period_scope": "source fetched on 2026-08-17", + "target_definition": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements" } } diff --git a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10-2026-07-23.svg b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10-2026-07-23.svg index 1be529415..d13cd9749 100644 --- a/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10-2026-07-23.svg +++ b/docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10-2026-07-23.svg @@ -75,11 +75,11 @@ not independently reproduced Record type - evidence_result + source_audit Allowed narrow claim - Wikidata statement Q100399163$D9071354-0341-4DE4-8B3F-9B896C591F35 in revision - 2498238847 asserts that Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) publishes amended by (P2567) + Individuals paying personal income tax at a higher rate (40% or 45%) can claim the + difference through their tax return or by calling or writing to His Majesty’s Evidence ID CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10-2026-07-23 @@ -88,31 +88,31 @@ CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10 Official Source - Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163) - https://www.wikidata.org/w/ + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 + https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/ Target / Candidate - Pensions - Pensions Act, 1990 (Q100399163) / P2567 + OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 public statements + one exact statement in the named primary source Controls / Gate - exact GUID + verbatim JSON + frozen revision SHA-256 + exact quote + complete response SHA-256 Period / Scope / Date - revision 2498238847 at 2026-05-27T11:22:05Z - Access date: 2026-07-26 + source fetched on 2026-08-17 + Access date: 2026-08-17 Artifact / Report - statement Q100399163$D9071354-0341-4DE4-8B3F-9B896C591F35 - artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json + PDF page 74 + artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json Evidence URL docs/evidence_cards/ CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json Claim boundary - This result establishes only that the named structured statement was published in the frozen Wikidata revision. It does not independently establish the real-world - truth of the statement. - Limitations: 1. Verification is limited to publication in one Wikidata revision. 2. Wikidata publication is not independent corroboration or ground truth. 3. No claim is made outside the exact - statement GUID and revision boundary. + Each result verifies that one exact public statement appeared in the fetched OECD Pensions Outlook 2024 bytes on 2026-08-17. It does not independently establish the + statement's underlying real-world truth. + Limitations: 1. This retrospective audit was not preregistered before source inspection. 2. The result verifies publication and byte identity, not independent ground truth. 3. The source is the + named publisher's own document (OECD Pensions Outlook 2024); the card does not provide independent corroboration of its statements. 4. A future PDF edit produces source drift until a separately diff --git a/docs/registry/evidence_index.json b/docs/registry/evidence_index.json index 65b1d8b3f..d8002f11a 100644 --- a/docs/registry/evidence_index.json +++ b/docs/registry/evidence_index.json @@ -42048,15 +42048,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42065,15 +42065,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42082,15 +42082,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42099,15 +42099,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42116,15 +42116,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42133,15 +42133,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42150,15 +42150,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42167,15 +42167,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42184,15 +42184,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42201,15 +42201,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t03_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T03-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42218,15 +42218,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42235,15 +42235,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42252,15 +42252,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42269,15 +42269,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42286,15 +42286,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42303,15 +42303,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42320,15 +42320,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42337,15 +42337,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42354,15 +42354,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42371,15 +42371,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t04_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T04-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42388,15 +42388,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42405,15 +42405,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42422,15 +42422,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42439,15 +42439,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42456,15 +42456,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42473,15 +42473,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42490,15 +42490,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42507,15 +42507,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42524,15 +42524,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42541,15 +42541,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t05_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T05-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42558,15 +42558,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42575,15 +42575,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42592,15 +42592,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42609,15 +42609,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42626,15 +42626,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42643,15 +42643,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42660,15 +42660,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42677,15 +42677,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42694,15 +42694,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42711,15 +42711,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t06_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T06-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42728,15 +42728,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G01-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42745,15 +42745,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G02-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42762,15 +42762,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G03-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42779,15 +42779,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G04-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42796,15 +42796,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G05-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42813,15 +42813,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G06-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42830,15 +42830,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G07-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42847,15 +42847,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G08-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42864,15 +42864,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G09-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -42881,15 +42881,15 @@ "result_status": "PASSED_UNDER_PROTOCOL", "protocol_id": "CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10", "domain": "pensions", - "record_type": "evidence_result", + "record_type": "source_audit", "operator": "NeoZorK", "created_at": "2026-07-23", - "last_verified_date": "2026-07-26", + "last_verified_date": "2026-08-17", "verification_level": "SINGLE_OPERATOR", "verification_count": 1, "reproduction_level": "not independently reproduced", - "official_source_name": "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)", - "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_wikidata_public_claims.json", + "official_source_name": "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024", + "sanitized_report_path": "artifacts/cb7k_dom036_t07_primary_claims.json", "path": "docs/evidence_cards/CLAIMBOUND-CB7K-DOM036-T07-G10-2026-07-23.json" }, { @@ -137348,9 +137348,9 @@ "workplace-safety": 70 }, "by_record_type": { - "evidence_result": 3574, + "evidence_result": 3524, "reproduction_attempt": 14, - "source_audit": 4484 + "source_audit": 4534 }, "by_result_status": { "BLOCKED_SOURCE": 17, @@ -137485,7 +137485,7 @@ "OECD Anti-Corruption and Integrity Outlook 2024": 70, "OECD Consumer Finance Risk Monitor 2024": 70, "OECD Global Corporate Sustainability Report 2024": 70, - "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024": 20, + "OECD Pensions Outlook 2024": 70, "OECD Revenue Statistics 2024": 70, "OpenAI GPT-5 System Card PDF": 1, "OpenAI GPT-5.4 Thinking System Card": 50, @@ -137721,7 +137721,6 @@ "Wikidata revision 2498229686 (Q113290839)": 8, "Wikidata revision 2498231716 (Q100400053)": 15, "Wikidata revision 2498233426 (Q100399815)": 16, - "Wikidata revision 2498238847 (Q100399163)": 50, "Wikidata revision 2498247664 (Q100397887)": 46, "Wikidata revision 2498637340 (Q2516186)": 4, "Wikidata revision 2499252662 (Q3975)": 35,