Testsuche Alle Felder "Mäser Bach und die drei Temporätsel"

[annekauf]

1st hit ( https://stabikat.de/Record/1438713770 ) remains a review (primary source is No 2), in spite of crass (absurd) discrimination of ALL VuFind fields containing "Besprechungen" or Rezension" that are to be found in 1st hit's metadata in Searchspecs yaml:

- [bq, topic_facet:"Besprechungen"^0.0001]
- [bq, genre:"Rezension"^0.0001]
- [bq, title-sub:"Rezension"^0.0001]
- [bq, (*:* NOT format_details_str_mv:Rezension)^20000]
- [bq, (*:* NOT format_details_str_mv:review)^20000]
- [bq, (*:* NOT genre_facet:Rezension)^20000]
- [bq, (*:* NOT genre_facet:review)^20000]
- [bq, (*:* NOT genre:Rezension)^20000]
- [bq, (*:* NOT genre:review)^20000]
- [bq, (*:* NOT allfields_unstemmed:Rezension)^20000]
- [bq, (*:* NOT allfields_unstemmed:review)^20000]
- [bq, (*:* NOT topic_facet:Besprechungen)^20000]

Conclusion:
(some of these) functions simply CANNOT be working as they should.

Question of adequate means: Search AllFields "Bach und die drei Temporätsel"
gets result list with primary book as 1st hit!!

[JBrechmacher]

Ist das der einzige Rezensionstest der nicht funktioniert? Die Kommentare im Test und Stichproben vermitteln den Eindruck, dass das Suchergebnis wie gewünscht ist. So hat auch eine oberflächliche Suche im Stabikat mit Grupp Biographie Kessler bezüglich der Anordnung von Rezensionen auch zufriedenstellende Ergebnisse gebracht.
Wenn dieses also ein Einzelfall ist, dann kann das Issue aus meiner Sicht geschlossen werden.

[annekauf]

This test is a very helpful example for more work trying to get review tests working due to its specifics. So issue should remain open; plus: it's exemplary for all the failing review tests.
Question needs to be answered by doing more work on it.

[annekauf]

Another answer, after again reading JBrechmacher: no, result list is not as it should be: 1st hit is NOT the primary source. The search strategy needs to be changed to get primary source as first hit. I guess there's been a misunderstanding?