Track upstream agent CLI versions#1187
Conversation
Live-stack QAResult: failed for adversarial QA on PR #1187. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/28767919468 Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true},
{"agent":"claude","model":"anthropic-sonnet46","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]
Overall verdict: failed. All selected live-stack scenario jobs failed; inspect the linked workflow logs for the specific failure causes. |
Live-stack QAResult: failed for adversarial QA on Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/28767906428 Matrix tested
Job summary
Failure notesAll failed scenario logs show the genty startup check cannot find |
Live-stack QAResult: failed for adversarial QA review. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/28767930022 Selected matrix:
Job results: Notes:
|
Live-stack QAResult: failed. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/28767921172 Scope: QA for adversarial review of Atlas AgentVersion/evidence graph updates and generated tracker artifacts. Tested matrix:
Job results:
Verdict: not passing. All selected live-stack scenario jobs failed; see the Actions run for logs. |
Adversarial Review DecisionDecision: not approved / not merged. GitHub would not allow this actor to submit a formal request-changes review on its own PR, so this comment records the blocking decision. Changed-file review found no security/correctness blockers in the Atlas graph update itself. The new AgentVersion records are additive, the evidence IDs line up with their Blocking evidence:
Required next step: get the live-stack QA and required PR checks green, or document why the failing QA scenarios are unrelated and rerun the appropriate validation. Risk AssessmentRisk level: risk:low for the changed graph data itself, but merge readiness is blocked by failed validation. Risks and mitigations:
|
Live-stack QAResult: failed. Build/index setup passed, but all selected live-stack scenarios failed. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/28767946744
Tested matrix: [
{
"agent": "amp",
"model": "foundry-gpt55",
"mode": "ni",
"install": "vanilla",
"live": true
},
{
"agent": "omp",
"model": "foundry-gpt55",
"mode": "ni",
"install": "vanilla",
"live": true
},
{
"agent": "claude",
"model": "foundry-gpt55",
"mode": "ni",
"install": "vanilla",
"live": true
},
{
"agent": "claude",
"model": "anthropic-sonnet46",
"mode": "ni",
"install": "vanilla",
"live": true
},
{
"agent": "claude",
"model": "foundry-gpt55",
"mode": "interactive",
"install": "bp",
"live": true,
"process_mode": "predefined"
},
{
"agent": "claude",
"model": "foundry-gpt55",
"mode": "interactive",
"install": "bp",
"live": true,
"process_mode": "create"
}
]Notes:
|
Adversarial review decision: changes requestedGitHub would not allow this actor to submit a formal I reviewed the four changed files:
I did not find a changed-line security issue or a concrete schema inconsistency in the new AgentVersion/EvidenceSource records. The records follow the recent dated Blockers
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: failed. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/28767978499 Tested matrix:
Workflow jobs:
Overall verdict: the focused adversarial live-stack QA matrix did not pass. The shared build succeeded, but every live-stack execution job failed. |
Live-stack QAResult: failed. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/28767957118 Matrix tested
Job results
Overall verdict: failed because all four selected live-stack scenario jobs failed. |
Live-stack QAResult: failed Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/28767971589 Focused adversarial matrix for Atlas graph/catalog agent-version metadata changes:
Supporting jobs:
Overall verdict: failed. All selected live-stack scenario jobs failed; setup/build/report completed successfully. |
Adversarial Review Decision: Changes RequestedI could not submit this as a formal request-changes review because GitHub rejects request-changes reviews from the PR author identity. Treating this as the review decision for the predefined adversarial process. Blocking condition
Code review findingsI did not find a code/data correctness blocker in the four changed files. Local checks after installing dependencies:
Minor/debt notes:
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Review decisionRequesting changes because the predefined adversarial review process has a strict reject rule for failed QA. I did not find code/data blockers in the PR diff itself. The Atlas graph changes are additive, the new exact AgentVersion records are indexed with matching EvidenceSource references, and local verification passed:
However, dispatched QA did not pass. The QA dispatch wrapper completed, but the live-stack run it launched failed:
Required follow-up before approval: repair or account for the live-stack QA launch/package issue and rerun QA to a passing or explicitly waived result. Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: failed for adversarial QA review. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/28841181971 Matrix tested
Job results
Overall verdict: failed. Build/matrix/report completed successfully, but every selected live-stack execution scenario failed. Notes:
|
Adversarial Review Decision: Changes RequestedI reviewed PR #1187 using the predefined adversarial review process. I do not see a changed-line security issue or a concrete AgentVersion/EvidenceSource schema mismatch in the four changed files. The new graph records are additive, the new IDs were not already present on However, the strict review rules require rejection because validation is not green. Blockers
Non-blocking findings
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: failed for adversarial QA review. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/28841175591 Matrix tested
Job results
Overall verdict: failed. Build/matrix/report jobs passed, but every selected live-stack scenario failed. |
Adversarial Review Decision: Changes RequestedI reviewed PR #1187 using the predefined adversarial review process. I do not see a changed-line security issue or a concrete AgentVersion/EvidenceSource schema mismatch in the four changed files. The graph records are additive, the new EvidenceSource IDs match the AgentVersion However, the strict process rules require rejection because validation is not green. Blockers
Non-blocking Findings
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: failed for adversarial QA review. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/28841226409 Matrix tested
Job results
Overall verdict: failed. Build/setup/report completed, but all selected live-stack scenario jobs failed. |
Adversarial Review Decision: Changes RequestedDecision: not approved / not merged. I reviewed the PR metadata, full diff, the four changed files, linked issues, existing PR comments/reviews, current checks, and dispatched a fresh I did not find a changed-line security issue, duplicate new graph ID, or obvious evidence-reference mismatch in the added Atlas AgentVersion/EvidenceSource records. Blockers
Major Finding
DebtThe live-stack QA failure pattern appears to be shared workflow/package setup drift rather than a changed-line graph issue. The repeated missing adapter CLI artifact should be tracked and fixed separately if it is not already covered. Risk AssessmentRisk level:
Required next step: get required checks green and rerun QA to a passing or explicitly waived result before approval. |
Live-stack QAResult: failed for adversarial QA review. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/28841202265 Tested matrix
Job results
Overall verdict: failed. Build, matrix computation, and report generation passed, but every selected live-stack scenario failed. Notes:
|
Live-stack QAResult: failed for adversarial QA review. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/28841258932 Matrix tested
Job results
Overall verdict: failed. Build, matrix generation, and report completed, but all selected live-stack execution scenarios failed. Notes:
|
Live-stack QAResult: failed for adversarial QA review. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/28841265155 Matrix tested
Job results
Overall verdict: failed. The workflow setup/report jobs passed, but all selected live-stack scenario jobs failed. Notes:
|
Live-stack QAResult: failed for adversarial QA review. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/28841282249 Focused matrix:
Job results:
Overall verdict: failed. Build/setup/report jobs passed, but all selected live-stack scenario jobs failed. Notes:
|
Adversarial Review Decision: Changes RequestedDecision: not approved / not merged. I reviewed PR #1187 through the predefined adversarial review process. I did not find a changed-line security issue or a concrete AgentVersion/EvidenceSource schema mismatch in the four changed files. The graph records are additive and the new EvidenceSource IDs match the AgentVersion Blockers
Non-blocking Finding
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: failed for adversarial QA review. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/28841294525 Focused matrix:
Job results:
Overall verdict: failed. Build/setup and report jobs passed, but every selected live-stack execution scenario failed. Notes:
|
1 participant
Updates Atlas AgentVersion records from the daily upstream host agent release check.
Artifacts:
Verification:
Note: