Add Raya 1-5 files #10
Conversation
Add Raya Series puzzles to Repository
| @@ -0,0 +1,66 @@ | |||
| include <puzzlecad2.scad> | |||
|
|
|||
| box_puzzle_scale = 15; | |||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I've been using a scale of 17 for this type of puzzle; I'd suggest we standardize on that for consistency
| far = dimlong - mid; | ||
| far2 = dimwide - mid; | ||
|
|
||
| pieces(); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
This should have a * in front of it as well.
|
|
||
| box_puzzle_scale = 15; | ||
| box_puzzle_border = 6; | ||
| $burr_inset = 0.16; |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Any reason for going with 0.16 mm inset rather than 0.125 (as in other packing puzzles)? Was the smaller inset too tight on your prints?
(I'm not necessarily objecting to a larger inset, but we should be consistent... i.e. use the same value here as in Mushkila and the other packing puzzles, unless there's a good reason they should be different)
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Hi Aaron, on my printer 0.125 seems to be too tight for packing puzzles but I agree it should be standard. I will adjust to standard.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
hmm. I have gotten reports from other users that default tolerances are too tight.. it seems there is a lot of variation in tolerances by printer. I am thinking it might make sense to distribute two versions of every puzzle with different tolerances (as different STLs, built from the same .scad)...
| long = box_puzzle_scale * 4; // voxels long | ||
| wide = box_puzzle_scale * 3; // voxels wide | ||
| high = box_puzzle_scale * 2; // voxels high |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
This nomenclature seems a little confusing (there are two sets of dimensions defined with similar names). My suggestion is to declare like so:
interior_dim = [4, 3, 2] * box_puzzle_scale;
Then you can use interior_dim.x, interior_dim.y, and interior_dim.z to refer to the individual coordinate dimensions, if needed.
| dimlong = long + box_puzzle_border * 2; | ||
| dimwide = wide + box_puzzle_border * 2; | ||
| height = high + box_puzzle_border; |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
If you follow my suggestion above, this can become
dim = interior_dim + [box_puzzle_border * 2, box_puzzle_border * 2, box_puzzle_border];
Then dim.x, dim.y, dim.z will refer to the outer dimensions.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Cool, I did not know dimensions could be done as vectors. This is much better.
| burr_plate([ | ||
| ["xx|xx"], //piece A | ||
| ["x..|xxx"],//piece B | ||
| ], $burr_scale = box_puzzle_scale,$plate_width = 150,$burr_bevel = 1.0); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
code style: add a space after the commas (also applies below)
Aaron, i updated Raya 1 based on your commenets. How does this look?
|
Aaaron I updated Raya1 based on your feedback and removed Raya2-4 until I can update those. I will add them back when complete. |
Removed unneccessary comments.
| box(); | ||
| cap(); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
These should be starred by default
| ["xx|xx"],["xx|xx"],["xx|xx"], //piece A-3 copies | ||
| ["x..|xxx"],["x..|xxx"],["x..|xxx"], //piece B-3 copies | ||
| ], $burr_scale = box_puzzle_scale,$plate_width = 150,$burr_bevel = 1.0); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
code style: best is to put a space after each comma, for readability
|
|
||
| difference() { | ||
| beveled_cube(dim); | ||
| translate([box_puzzle_border - $burr_inset, box_puzzle_border - $burr_inset, box_puzzle_border- $burr_inset]) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
suggestion: add an extra $burr_inset on the z axis here:
translate([box_puzzle_border - $burr_inset, box_puzzle_border - $burr_inset, box_puzzle_border - 2 * $burr_inset])
This will provide a little more freedom of movement under the cap.
| cube([ | ||
| interior_dim.x + $burr_inset * 2, | ||
| interior_dim.y + $burr_inset * 2, | ||
| interior_dim.z + $burr_inset * 2]); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
if you adopt the last suggestion, you'll want to enlarge the z axis here by a tiny amount:
interior_dim.z + $burr_inset * 2 + 0.001
this helps prevent rendering errors that can happen when two faces are exactly coincident in a difference() operation.
| translate([0,0,dim.z]) | ||
| difference() { | ||
| beveled_cube([dim.x, dim.y, box_puzzle_border]); | ||
| //first cutout removal | ||
| translate([box_puzzle_border+.5*box_puzzle_scale-$burr_inset,box_puzzle_border - $burr_inset,0]) | ||
| cube([box_puzzle_scale*3+ $burr_inset * 2,box_puzzle_scale*2 + $burr_inset * 2,,box_puzzle_border]); | ||
| // second cutout removal | ||
| translate([box_puzzle_border+1.5*box_puzzle_scale-$burr_inset,box_puzzle_border-$burr_inset +2*box_puzzle_scale,0]) | ||
| cube([box_puzzle_scale+2*$burr_inset,box_puzzle_scale+2*$burr_inset,box_puzzle_border]); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
code style: for readability, best to put spaces after commas and between arithmetic operators, e.g.
5, x + y
rather than
5,x+y
Add Raya Series puzzles to Repository. I have no idea what I am doing here Aaron but maybe this will work.