Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Include OPeNDAP URLs in download options #344

Open
ocehugo opened this issue Jul 10, 2018 · 6 comments
Open

Include OPeNDAP URLs in download options #344

ocehugo opened this issue Jul 10, 2018 · 6 comments
Assignees
Labels
>= 12 months old task that has been put aside in the past 12 months because of other priorities

Comments

@ocehugo
Copy link

ocehugo commented Jul 10, 2018

For some cases, I think It would be more straight-forward to provide the THREDDS endpoint of the file(s) at step 3.

User case:
user Joe wants to download all the SST for his region in WA. He knows how opendap works and that files are individually stored. He just wants an example opendap address for a typical file, so he can loop through the address with a regex to cut the region/time window with his favourite software (say nco).

Current behaviour:
At the moment, the fastest way to know the address is several clicks away.
Select SST in step1, click next in step 2, click "view metadata record" in step 3, search for opendap in metadata page (which is quite dense), click in the "opendap link" in the Online Resources header, and click towards a year and get the file address.

Suggested behaviour:
Click SST in step1, click next in step2, show opendap end-point after the "Time period" information. In any case of date/product selection, I believe the opendap addresses should pop-up straight below, maybe in a hyperlink called "opendap start-point".

After the first time, some users will know that everything can be found in thredds.aodn.org.au/thredds/catalog.html. However, the portal will still make data discovery much easier.

@ggalibert
Copy link

For most collections that involve NetCDF files, the THREDDS catalog URL for this collection is already provided in step 2, info tab, in Supplementary resources. You don't need to go through the metadata record.

If it's not the case this should be fixed.

@ocehugo
Copy link
Author

ocehugo commented Jul 10, 2018

You are correct, there is a faster way to obtain it. I just expected the dap address to be within the "download" step.

@ggalibert
Copy link

ggalibert commented Jul 10, 2018

What we could easily do is rename "List of URLs" to "List of HTTP URLs" and similarly add a new download option "List of OPeNDAP URLs".

@ocehugo
Copy link
Author

ocehugo commented Jul 12, 2018

@gg, good option, so people can avoid generating expressions or ping/ponging the server with invalid requests/filepaths.

Speaking about it, can we request a catalog/sitemap of aodn thredds files this days?

@ggalibert
Copy link

aodn/aodn-portal#2670 is updating the label in step 3 download to make it clear that we get HTTP URLs.

@ggalibert ggalibert assigned smancini and unassigned ocehugo and ggalibert Aug 7, 2018
@ggalibert ggalibert changed the title Include THREDDS server address for datasets Include OPeNDAP URLs in download options Aug 7, 2018
@ggalibert
Copy link

Retrieving OPeNDAP URLs in download options will require changes in aodn/aodn-portal, this is not just a content issue. @pblain can we have a backlog item for that? Happy to write it for you.

@ggalibert ggalibert added the >= 12 months old task that has been put aside in the past 12 months because of other priorities label Apr 20, 2020
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
>= 12 months old task that has been put aside in the past 12 months because of other priorities
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants