Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Improve discoverability and the ways to join the weekly/fortnightly Google Hangout meetings. #215

Open
klonos opened this issue Mar 30, 2016 · 20 comments

Comments

@klonos
Copy link
Member

klonos commented Mar 30, 2016

I was so disappointed today! ...I made a decision last night to wake up early in the morning in order to finally join the weekly dev meeting (so far, I've been only watching the recording on YouTube). I tried to figure out how to do that (never used Google Hangouts before) and I swear it's hard. ...mind you I consider myself very computer-savvy and I've been around for 17+ years now.

So, I started with our Resources and Tools page. The "Weekly Meetings: Google hangouts" section prompts you to join our Google+ group. So, I did that, but there was no obvious way to see the scheduled meetings or how you go about it. Is there a desktop app I need to download or is it all done on my browser? Is my default browser (firefox) compatible with the Hangouts platform or do I need Google Chrome?

I often hear you guys mention IRC in the meetings, so I thought I might give that a go for pointers. I downloaded mIRC (have not used it since the 1990s BTW) and joined the channel mentioned on our Resources and Tools page. I asked there and was pointed to our Tweeter feed (I do not use it, so I was lucky that it doesn't need registration) that has a link to the Google Doc with the meeting agenda that is supposed to have a link that you can use in order to join. Did that, but the only link available was the one to watch the recorded video on YouTube. Perhaps I was too late and the meeting has ended. Fair enough, but boy what a hustle! I know now for the next time, but I was so excited by the idea of finally joining that the disappointment was huge 😞

Lets recap: website -> IRC -> Tweeter -> Google Docs -> no-go ...to many steps involved even if I finally got to it. So, lets fix this as much as we can and make it easy for people to join the meetings if they wish to:

  • There is a "Meet Up" section in our Ways to Contribute page with links to the iCal feeds of the meetings. I think that these should be copied over to the Resources and Tools page in the "Weekly Meetings: Google hangouts" section. I'll take care of that now that I have permissions to edit those pages.
  • I have imported these on my calendar application, so I now know when the next meeting is held, but the question remains: how do I actually join? I am a Skype user, so I am used to the fact that I need to send an invite to a contact and they need to accept it before I can confer with them. How does it work with Google Hangouts? How is the meeting initiated and will I get some sort of ringing/call the way that Skype works?
  • ...
@klonos
Copy link
Member Author

klonos commented Mar 30, 2016

...the only link available was the one to watch the recorded video on YouTube. Perhaps I was too late and the meeting has ended.

IRC excerpt:

<klonos> I just took a look at the Google doc linked from the twitter feed and
it has only a link to watch the meeting on YouTube...
<klonos> I guess because the meeting mast have ended by now :(
<klonos> ...I'll file an issue in the backdropcms.org queue about this and
perhaps also update the "Resources and Tools" page in
https://backdropcms.org/resources to include some info about how to join.
<klonos> ...the "Weekly Meetings: Google hangouts" section in that page has a
link to join through Google+. I did that, but I did not see any obvious way to
join the meeting from there. Trust me, if it was hard for me to figure things
(17+ years of experience in IT), I bet you it must be hard for newcomers.
<klonos> ...the "Ways to Contribute" page in https://backdropcms.org/contribute
has a "Meet Up" section (at the very bottom of the page though) with links to
iCal files. I think that these should be in the "Resources and Tools" page as
well.
<jackalope> klonos: I think it's because the meeting is tomorrow, not today!
<klonos> jacklope: http://www.timebie.com/timezone/pacificmelbourne.php
<klonos> ...it's **next day**. Silly me.

...no comments please 😄

@klonos
Copy link
Member Author

klonos commented Mar 30, 2016

From the calendar event:

This weekly meeting is a Google Plus hangout for BackdropCMS. Please follow @backdropcms on twitter for the link (it changes weekly due to some technical limitations of Google+)

Can we somehow have it so that soon as we post the link on Tweeter, it is automagically added to the "Weekly Meetings: Google hangouts" section as a "next meeting: [date/time]" thing?

@docwilmot
Copy link
Contributor

Quick Google search for "Static Hnagout Link" brings this: http://behindcompanies.com/2014/01/set-up-a-permanent-google-hangout-for-easy-collaboration/. We should do that, if it works, because as you say hunting the hangout is ridiculous. Only Just accidentally figured out how to join late last year when I downloaded Twitter app for an entirely different purpose.

@serundeputy
Copy link
Member

@klonos the meeting is on Thursdays 3/31 tomorrow: https://docs.google.com/document/d/11dPo2w_6jjTt_WXjvpN6ePScafucACLugKOJyTOqz_I/edit?usp=sharing

The easiest way to be informed of the latest and greatest link is: https://gitter.im/backdrop/backdrop-issues which is also tied to our issue queue just visit the gitter link in any browser. Join us tomorrow.

@klonos
Copy link
Member Author

klonos commented Mar 30, 2016

Thanx you guys! @docwilmot Yes, lets do that if it works. Would be easier to have a permanent link in our Google Hangouts section. @serundeputy Will do. See you guys live tomorrow!

@docwilmot
Copy link
Contributor

@klonos this would be one for @jenlampton to do; I dont have access to the Google+ site.

@docwilmot docwilmot reopened this Mar 30, 2016
@jenlampton
Copy link
Member

Unfortunately I don't think that will work, as that post says "Your Hangout link will expire on this day". Let me see if there is a way to set up a recurring event and "attach" a hangout to it. (I tried this before but was unsuccessful... since Backdrop is a G+ "page" and not a person, the calendar doesn't work like it should. Maybe they have fixed that!

@jenlampton
Copy link
Member

I tried scheduling a hangout and creating an event, neither one lets me set the hangout URL. Maybe it's not possible for "hangouts on air"?

@jenlampton
Copy link
Member

if anyone else wants to battle with this G+ page and try to help figure this out, I'd be happy to add you :) the whole thing is a mystery to me!

@biolithic
Copy link

It can be done -- I remember John Albin in Taiwan, many others around the
globe and I in America attending weekly mobile D8 meetings, and that was
kind of a pain for everyone. I have had (non-Drupal) clients in Australia,
we remember the meetings somehow.

I've never attended a scheduled Hangout. "When it is time", somebody just
creates one and then we have the meeting. Sorry for the lack of help on
that account. I just pay attention to some type of real time social
communication around the scheduled time and then click the link in my
browser.

On Wed, Mar 30, 2016 at 9:13 PM, Jen Lampton [email protected]
wrote:

Unfortunately I don't think that will work, as that post says "Your
Hangout link will expire on this day". Let me see if there is a way to set
up a recurring event and "attach" a hangout to it. (I tried this before but
was unsuccessful... since Backdrop is a G+ "page" and not a person, the
calendar doesn't work like it should. Maybe they have fixed that!


You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub
#215 (comment)

@biolithic
Copy link

"real-time communication" could be your pick of irc, twitter, g+, gitter,
any others? Fbook, Myspace, Friendster? Bueller?

On Wed, Mar 30, 2016 at 9:33 PM, Andy Martha [email protected]
wrote:

It can be done -- I remember John Albin in Taiwan, many others around the
globe and I in America attending weekly mobile D8 meetings, and that was
kind of a pain for everyone. I have had (non-Drupal) clients in Australia,
we remember the meetings somehow.

I've never attended a scheduled Hangout. "When it is time", somebody just
creates one and then we have the meeting. Sorry for the lack of help on
that account. I just pay attention to some type of real time social
communication around the scheduled time and then click the link in my
browser.

On Wed, Mar 30, 2016 at 9:13 PM, Jen Lampton [email protected]
wrote:

Unfortunately I don't think that will work, as that post says "Your
Hangout link will expire on this day". Let me see if there is a way to set
up a recurring event and "attach" a hangout to it. (I tried this before but
was unsuccessful... since Backdrop is a G+ "page" and not a person, the
calendar doesn't work like it should. Maybe they have fixed that!


You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub
#215 (comment)

@biolithic
Copy link

I guess the Backdrop community on Friendster is taking a break effective
June 14, 2015, so don't be listening to that :)

On Wed, Mar 30, 2016 at 9:36 PM, Andy Martha [email protected]
wrote:

"real-time communication" could be your pick of irc, twitter, g+, gitter,
any others? Fbook, Myspace, Friendster? Bueller?

On Wed, Mar 30, 2016 at 9:33 PM, Andy Martha [email protected]
wrote:

It can be done -- I remember John Albin in Taiwan, many others around the
globe and I in America attending weekly mobile D8 meetings, and that was
kind of a pain for everyone. I have had (non-Drupal) clients in Australia,
we remember the meetings somehow.

I've never attended a scheduled Hangout. "When it is time", somebody
just creates one and then we have the meeting. Sorry for the lack of help
on that account. I just pay attention to some type of real time social
communication around the scheduled time and then click the link in my
browser.

On Wed, Mar 30, 2016 at 9:13 PM, Jen Lampton [email protected]
wrote:

Unfortunately I don't think that will work, as that post says "Your
Hangout link will expire on this day". Let me see if there is a way to set
up a recurring event and "attach" a hangout to it. (I tried this before but
was unsuccessful... since Backdrop is a G+ "page" and not a person, the
calendar doesn't work like it should. Maybe they have fixed that!


You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub
#215 (comment)

@klonos
Copy link
Member Author

klonos commented Mar 31, 2016

I just find it silly (especially at a time where we are looking to attract more people to b.org) to have them "jump through hoops" in order to find and join the meeting. That's all.

So to understand how this thing works better, @jenlampton do you initiate the hangout meeting a few minutes before the scheduled time and then get a URL for it that you twit through our official Twitter account. Is that how it goes?

If we cannot get a permanent link to a Hangout, and if twitting about the link is our only current option, then may I propose the following change to the workflow:

How about we make the meeting announcements a b.org node or something (so that we publish the link to the hangout on b.org first) and then have the Twitter module auto-twit that node on the Twitter account? That way...

  1. we do not disrupt the way of people currently discovering the URL (because the URL will still be published on Twitter)
  2. at the same time we have it published on the official website
  3. since only publishing a node is all it takes to publish the URL in both places (the module will take care of auto-twitting it), there is no additional steps for the person that starts the hangout. They will simply publish a node on b.org instead of twitting.

What do you think?

@quicksketch
Copy link
Member

So to understand how this thing works better, @jenlampton do you initiate the hangout meeting a few minutes before the scheduled time and then get a URL for it that you twit through our official Twitter account. Is that how it goes?

Yep, currently that is the situation. We have not been able to figure out how to have a regularly scheduled hangout at the same URL. They are always unique and have to be set up at the time it happens.

How about we make the meeting announcements a b.org node or something

This is (sort of) what we do already, though we could adjust. Right now we tweet the meeting agenda, which as you know does NOT contain the link (or should not) until just ~5 minutes before the meeting time. Then we (Jen) updates the agenda with the hangout URL. Right now the best way of finding the link is going to the agenda, waiting until meeting time, and then it will be updated as soon as it is created.

We could expand this to process to create nodes on bdcms.org as well. Right now we only update the Google doc as things are happening, including frequent updating during the meeting itself as discussion takes place.

@klonos
Copy link
Member Author

klonos commented Mar 31, 2016

Fair enough. I understand that there are technical limitations with the way Google Hangouts are created and that they cannot be scheduled and/or have a permanent URL. We'll simply have to live with it and adapt.

Is it ok if I go forward with the things I proposed in the issue summary so we can improve the situation as much as we can?

@jenlampton
Copy link
Member

I agree that it is way too hard to find out how to join a google hangout... one of my biggest gripes with all Hangouts!!!

We could expand this to process to create nodes on bdcms.org as well.

I don't like the idea of having a node for each meeting on the website. It seems not only like too much for work for running the meetings, but also too much clutter on the site, as most people there won't be intending to join the meetings.

How about adding a single block somewhere? Something that says "watch twitter for meeting info" with a link to the twitter feed? Hm... We do already pull in the twitter feed, I don't think a link to it is really necessary, AS LONG AS people know they need to click on the agenda link. Perhaps that is the issue?

Or! we could post a link to gitter.im, since the actual meeting link is posted there.

@quicksketch
Copy link
Member

There is a "Meet Up" section in our Ways to Contribute page with links to the iCal feeds of the meetings. I think that these should be copied over to the Resources and Tools page in the "Weekly Meetings: Google hangouts" section. I'll take care of that now that I have permissions to edit those pages.

Yes that would be great. 😄

@docwilmot
Copy link
Contributor

I just went to my G+ acct and created a Hangouts on Air event with a future date (3 months from now) and got a link to share. Even if it turns out to be not a static link (I dont know, didnt explore that much) at the very least we can prepare the link for the next meeting a lot longer than 5 minutes before, it seems.

@klonos
Copy link
Member Author

klonos commented Mar 31, 2016

@docwilmot maybe the key difference is what @jenlampton said previously:

...Backdrop is a G+ "page" and not a person, the calendar doesn't work like it should.

@ghost
Copy link

ghost commented May 26, 2020

We don't use Google Hangouts, etc. anymore, so is this issue still relevant?

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

6 participants