Usage reviews and feedback

[GCHQDeveloper36]

Problem

There is no way for consumers to provide feedback on their use of a model.

Proposed Solution

Support a new type of ‘review’ which isn’t approval-based, but instead from a consumer. This can optionally be restricted to users with a valid access request.

Users can complete a schema-based form providing some level of feedback or review about the model, such as the suitability for the task they were applying it to.

The marketplace can be enhanced to support finding models that have been ‘verified’ as suitable for a particular task - I.e. those with a tag, and a ‘positive’ rating.

Alternatives

Comments on releases, but feedback may usually be broader than a specific release. It may be useful to offer a selection as to which release the feedback applies.

What is the priority of your issue?

Low

[ARADDCC002]

Like how we have comments on releases and access requests it might be that we can include comments on the "Overview" tab of a model. Unfortunately, it would be quite basic in that I don't know if we can then query it to get a rating for the marketplace, but it does allow for discussions at least.

Alternatively, we could have a "Discussions" tab on models where people can put their responses. In either case it's possible we could add a "rating" property (whether this is a thumbs up/down, or star rating I'm not sure), and then we could possibly collect all the ratings across an array of model responses and finally display the average rating?

Either way I like this idea in principle.