From 6dec7c9ee6e949a132ee62aec8134b98f249f48d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Michael Kranzlein <8162250+mkranzlein@users.noreply.github.com>
Date: Mon, 21 Aug 2023 02:09:36 -0400
Subject: [PATCH] Initial dataset reader tests

---
 fixtures/data/curiam_sample.json |  1 +
 tests/curiam_reader_test.py      | 32 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 2 files changed, 33 insertions(+)
 create mode 100644 fixtures/data/curiam_sample.json
 create mode 100644 tests/curiam_reader_test.py

diff --git a/fixtures/data/curiam_sample.json b/fixtures/data/curiam_sample.json
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..3839fef
--- /dev/null
+++ b/fixtures/data/curiam_sample.json
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+[{"name": "12624925_00.tsv", "sentences": [{"id": 0, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Justice"}, {"id": 1, "text": "GORSUCH"}, {"id": 2, "text": "delivered"}, {"id": 3, "text": "the"}, {"id": 4, "text": "opinion"}, {"id": 5, "text": "of"}, {"id": 6, "text": "the"}, {"id": 7, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 8, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 1, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Few"}, {"id": 1, "text": "legal"}, {"id": 2, "text": "principles"}, {"id": 3, "text": "are"}, {"id": 4, "text": "better"}, {"id": 5, "text": "established"}, {"id": 6, "text": "than"}, {"id": 7, "text": "the"}, {"id": 8, "text": "rule"}, {"id": 9, "text": "requiring"}, {"id": 10, "text": "a"}, {"id": 11, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 12, "text": "to"}, {"id": 13, "text": "establish"}, {"id": 14, "text": "causation"}, {"id": 15, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 2, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "In"}, {"id": 1, "text": "the"}, {"id": 2, "text": "law"}, {"id": 3, "text": "of"}, {"id": 4, "text": "torts"}, {"id": 5, "text": ","}, {"id": 6, "text": "this"}, {"id": 7, "text": "usually"}, {"id": 8, "text": "means", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "a", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "plaintiff", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "must", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "first", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "plead", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "then", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "prove", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "that", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "its", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "injury", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "would", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "not", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "have", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "occurred", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "defendant", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "'s", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "unlawful", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "conduct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 3, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "The"}, {"id": 1, "text": "plaintiffs"}, {"id": 2, "text": "before"}, {"id": 3, "text": "us"}, {"id": 4, "text": "suggest"}, {"id": 5, "text": "that"}, {"id": 6, "text": "42", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "U.S.C.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "departs"}, {"id": 11, "text": "from"}, {"id": 12, "text": "this"}, {"id": 13, "text": "traditional"}, {"id": 14, "text": "arrangement"}, {"id": 15, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 4, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "But"}, {"id": 1, "text": "looking"}, {"id": 2, "text": "to"}, {"id": 3, "text": "this"}, {"id": 4, "text": "particular"}, {"id": 5, "text": "statute"}, {"id": 6, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 7, "text": "text", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "and"}, {"id": 9, "text": "history"}, {"id": 10, "text": ","}, {"id": 11, "text": "we"}, {"id": 12, "text": "see"}, {"id": 13, "text": "no"}, {"id": 14, "text": "evidence"}, {"id": 15, "text": "of"}, {"id": 16, "text": "an"}, {"id": 17, "text": "exception"}, {"id": 18, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 5, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "I"}]}, {"id": 6, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "This"}, {"id": 1, "text": "case"}, {"id": 2, "text": "began"}, {"id": 3, "text": "after"}, {"id": 4, "text": "negotiations"}, {"id": 5, "text": "between"}, {"id": 6, "text": "two"}, {"id": 7, "text": "media"}, {"id": 8, "text": "companies"}, {"id": 9, "text": "failed"}, {"id": 10, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 7, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "African"}, {"id": 1, "text": "-"}, {"id": 2, "text": "American"}, {"id": 3, "text": "entrepreneur"}, {"id": 4, "text": "Byron"}, {"id": 5, "text": "Allen"}, {"id": 6, "text": "owns"}, {"id": 7, "text": "Entertainment"}, {"id": 8, "text": "Studios"}, {"id": 9, "text": "Network"}, {"id": 10, "text": "("}, {"id": 11, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 12, "text": ")"}, {"id": 13, "text": ","}, {"id": 14, "text": "the"}, {"id": 15, "text": "operator"}, {"id": 16, "text": "of"}, {"id": 17, "text": "seven"}, {"id": 18, "text": "television"}, {"id": 19, "text": "networks"}, {"id": 20, "text": "-"}, {"id": 21, "text": "Justice"}, {"id": 22, "text": "Central"}, {"id": 23, "text": "."}, {"id": 24, "text": "TV"}, {"id": 25, "text": ","}, {"id": 26, "text": "Comedy"}, {"id": 27, "text": "."}, {"id": 28, "text": "TV"}, {"id": 29, "text": ","}, {"id": 30, "text": "ES.TV"}, {"id": 31, "text": ","}, {"id": 32, "text": "Pets"}, {"id": 33, "text": "."}, {"id": 34, "text": "TV"}, {"id": 35, "text": ","}, {"id": 36, "text": "Recipe"}, {"id": 37, "text": "."}, {"id": 38, "text": "TV"}, {"id": 39, "text": ","}, {"id": 40, "text": "MyDestination"}, {"id": 41, "text": "."}, {"id": 42, "text": "TV"}, {"id": 43, "text": ","}, {"id": 44, "text": "and"}, {"id": 45, "text": "Cars"}, {"id": 46, "text": "."}, {"id": 47, "text": "TV"}, {"id": 48, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 8, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "For"}, {"id": 1, "text": "years"}, {"id": 2, "text": ","}, {"id": 3, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 4, "text": "sought"}, {"id": 5, "text": "to"}, {"id": 6, "text": "have"}, {"id": 7, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 8, "text": ","}, {"id": 9, "text": "one"}, {"id": 10, "text": "of"}, {"id": 11, "text": "the"}, {"id": 12, "text": "nation"}, {"id": 13, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 14, "text": "largest"}, {"id": 15, "text": "cable"}, {"id": 16, "text": "television"}, {"id": 17, "text": "conglomerates"}, {"id": 18, "text": ","}, {"id": 19, "text": "carry"}, {"id": 20, "text": "its"}, {"id": 21, "text": "channels"}, {"id": 22, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 9, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "But"}, {"id": 1, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 2, "text": "refused"}, {"id": 3, "text": ","}, {"id": 4, "text": "citing"}, {"id": 5, "text": "lack"}, {"id": 6, "text": "of"}, {"id": 7, "text": "demand"}, {"id": 8, "text": "for"}, {"id": 9, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 10, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 11, "text": "programming"}, {"id": 12, "text": ","}, {"id": 13, "text": "bandwidth"}, {"id": 14, "text": "constraints"}, {"id": 15, "text": ","}, {"id": 16, "text": "and"}, {"id": 17, "text": "its"}, {"id": 18, "text": "preference"}, {"id": 19, "text": "for"}, {"id": 20, "text": "news"}, {"id": 21, "text": "and"}, {"id": 22, "text": "sports"}, {"id": 23, "text": "programming"}, {"id": 24, "text": "that"}, {"id": 25, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 26, "text": "did"}, {"id": 27, "text": "n't"}, {"id": 28, "text": "offer"}, {"id": 29, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 10, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "With"}, {"id": 1, "text": "bargaining"}, {"id": 2, "text": "at"}, {"id": 3, "text": "an"}, {"id": 4, "text": "impasse"}, {"id": 5, "text": ","}, {"id": 6, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 7, "text": "sued"}, {"id": 8, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 11, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Seeking"}, {"id": 1, "text": "billions"}, {"id": 2, "text": "in"}, {"id": 3, "text": "damages"}, {"id": 4, "text": ","}, {"id": 5, "text": "the"}, {"id": 6, "text": "company"}, {"id": 7, "text": "alleged"}, {"id": 8, "text": "that"}, {"id": 9, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 10, "text": "systematically"}, {"id": 11, "text": "disfavored"}, {"id": 12, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "100", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "%", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "African", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "American", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "owned", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "media", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "companies", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 12, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 1, "text": "did"}, {"id": 2, "text": "n't"}, {"id": 3, "text": "dispute"}, {"id": 4, "text": "that"}, {"id": 5, "text": ","}, {"id": 6, "text": "during"}, {"id": 7, "text": "negotiations"}, {"id": 8, "text": ","}, {"id": 9, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 10, "text": "had"}, {"id": 11, "text": "offered"}, {"id": 12, "text": "legitimate"}, {"id": 13, "text": "business"}, {"id": 14, "text": "reasons"}, {"id": 15, "text": "for"}, {"id": 16, "text": "refusing"}, {"id": 17, "text": "to"}, {"id": 18, "text": "carry"}, {"id": 19, "text": "its"}, {"id": 20, "text": "channels"}, {"id": 21, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 13, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "But"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 3, "text": "contended"}, {"id": 4, "text": ","}, {"id": 5, "text": "these"}, {"id": 6, "text": "reasons"}, {"id": 7, "text": "were"}, {"id": 8, "text": "merely"}, {"id": 9, "text": "pretextual"}, {"id": 10, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 14, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "To"}, {"id": 1, "text": "help"}, {"id": 2, "text": "obscure"}, {"id": 3, "text": "its"}, {"id": 4, "text": "true"}, {"id": 5, "text": "discriminatory"}, {"id": 6, "text": "intentions"}, {"id": 7, "text": "and"}, {"id": 8, "text": "win"}, {"id": 9, "text": "favor"}, {"id": 10, "text": "with"}, {"id": 11, "text": "the"}, {"id": 12, "text": "Federal"}, {"id": 13, "text": "Communications"}, {"id": 14, "text": "Commission"}, {"id": 15, "text": ","}, {"id": 16, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 17, "text": "asserted"}, {"id": 18, "text": ","}, {"id": 19, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 20, "text": "paid"}, {"id": 21, "text": "civil"}, {"id": 22, "text": "rights"}, {"id": 23, "text": "groups"}, {"id": 24, "text": "to"}, {"id": 25, "text": "advocate"}, {"id": 26, "text": "publicly"}, {"id": 27, "text": "on"}, {"id": 28, "text": "its"}, {"id": 29, "text": "behalf"}, {"id": 30, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 15, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "As"}, {"id": 1, "text": "relevant"}, {"id": 2, "text": "here"}, {"id": 3, "text": ","}, {"id": 4, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 5, "text": "alleged"}, {"id": 6, "text": "that"}, {"id": 7, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 8, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 9, "text": "behavior"}, {"id": 10, "text": "violated"}, {"id": 11, "text": "42", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "U.S.C.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "a", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": ","}, {"id": 19, "text": "which"}, {"id": 20, "text": "guarantees"}, {"id": 21, "text": ","}, {"id": 22, "text": "among"}, {"id": 23, "text": "other"}, {"id": 24, "text": "things"}, {"id": 25, "text": ","}, {"id": 26, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "[", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "a]ll", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "persons", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "same", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "right", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "make", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "enforce", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "contracts", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": "as", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": "is", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "enjoyed", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": "by", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": "white", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": "citizens", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 47, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 48, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 16, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Much"}, {"id": 1, "text": "motions"}, {"id": 2, "text": "practice"}, {"id": 3, "text": "followed"}, {"id": 4, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 17, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 1, "text": "sought"}, {"id": 2, "text": "to"}, {"id": 3, "text": "dismiss"}, {"id": 4, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 5, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 6, "text": "complaint"}, {"id": 7, "text": ","}, {"id": 8, "text": "and"}, {"id": 9, "text": "eventually"}, {"id": 10, "text": "the"}, {"id": 11, "text": "district"}, {"id": 12, "text": "court"}, {"id": 13, "text": "agreed"}, {"id": 14, "text": ","}, {"id": 15, "text": "holding"}, {"id": 16, "text": "that"}, {"id": 17, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 18, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 19, "text": "pleading"}, {"id": 20, "text": "failed"}, {"id": 21, "text": "to"}, {"id": 22, "text": "state"}, {"id": 23, "text": "a"}, {"id": 24, "text": "claim"}, {"id": 25, "text": "as"}, {"id": 26, "text": "a"}, {"id": 27, "text": "matter"}, {"id": 28, "text": "of"}, {"id": 29, "text": "law"}, {"id": 30, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 18, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "The"}, {"id": 1, "text": "district"}, {"id": 2, "text": "court"}, {"id": 3, "text": "twice"}, {"id": 4, "text": "allowed"}, {"id": 5, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 6, "text": "a"}, {"id": 7, "text": "chance"}, {"id": 8, "text": "to"}, {"id": 9, "text": "remedy"}, {"id": 10, "text": "its"}, {"id": 11, "text": "complaint"}, {"id": 12, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 13, "text": "deficiencies"}, {"id": 14, "text": "by"}, {"id": 15, "text": "identifying"}, {"id": 16, "text": "additional"}, {"id": 17, "text": "facts"}, {"id": 18, "text": "to"}, {"id": 19, "text": "support"}, {"id": 20, "text": "its"}, {"id": 21, "text": "case"}, {"id": 22, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 19, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "But"}, {"id": 1, "text": "each"}, {"id": 2, "text": "time"}, {"id": 3, "text": ","}, {"id": 4, "text": "the"}, {"id": 5, "text": "court"}, {"id": 6, "text": "concluded"}, {"id": 7, "text": ","}, {"id": 8, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 9, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 10, "text": "efforts"}, {"id": 11, "text": "fell"}, {"id": 12, "text": "short"}, {"id": 13, "text": "of"}, {"id": 14, "text": "plausibly"}, {"id": 15, "text": "showing"}, {"id": 16, "text": "that"}, {"id": 17, "text": ","}, {"id": 18, "text": "but"}, {"id": 19, "text": "for"}, {"id": 20, "text": "racial"}, {"id": 21, "text": "animus"}, {"id": 22, "text": ","}, {"id": 23, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 24, "text": "would"}, {"id": 25, "text": "have"}, {"id": 26, "text": "contracted"}, {"id": 27, "text": "with"}, {"id": 28, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 29, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 20, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "After"}, {"id": 1, "text": "three"}, {"id": 2, "text": "rounds"}, {"id": 3, "text": "of"}, {"id": 4, "text": "pleadings"}, {"id": 5, "text": ","}, {"id": 6, "text": "motions"}, {"id": 7, "text": ","}, {"id": 8, "text": "and"}, {"id": 9, "text": "dismissals"}, {"id": 10, "text": ","}, {"id": 11, "text": "the"}, {"id": 12, "text": "district"}, {"id": 13, "text": "court"}, {"id": 14, "text": "decided"}, {"id": 15, "text": "that"}, {"id": 16, "text": "further"}, {"id": 17, "text": "amendments"}, {"id": 18, "text": "would"}, {"id": 19, "text": "prove"}, {"id": 20, "text": "futile"}, {"id": 21, "text": "and"}, {"id": 22, "text": "entered"}, {"id": 23, "text": "a"}, {"id": 24, "text": "final"}, {"id": 25, "text": "judgment"}, {"id": 26, "text": "for"}, {"id": 27, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 28, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 21, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "The"}, {"id": 1, "text": "Ninth"}, {"id": 2, "text": "Circuit"}, {"id": 3, "text": "reversed"}, {"id": 4, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 22, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "As"}, {"id": 1, "text": "that"}, {"id": 2, "text": "court"}, {"id": 3, "text": "saw"}, {"id": 4, "text": "it"}, {"id": 5, "text": ","}, {"id": 6, "text": "the"}, {"id": 7, "text": "district"}, {"id": 8, "text": "court"}, {"id": 9, "text": "used"}, {"id": 10, "text": "the"}, {"id": 11, "text": "wrong"}, {"id": 12, "text": "causation"}, {"id": 13, "text": "standard"}, {"id": 14, "text": "when"}, {"id": 15, "text": "assessing"}, {"id": 16, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 17, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 18, "text": "pleadings"}, {"id": 19, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 23, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "A"}, {"id": 1, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 4, "text": "does"}, {"id": 5, "text": "n't"}, {"id": 6, "text": "have"}, {"id": 7, "text": "to"}, {"id": 8, "text": "point"}, {"id": 9, "text": "to"}, {"id": 10, "text": "facts"}, {"id": 11, "text": "plausibly"}, {"id": 12, "text": "showing"}, {"id": 13, "text": "that"}, {"id": 14, "text": "racial"}, {"id": 15, "text": "animus"}, {"id": 16, "text": "was"}, {"id": 17, "text": "a"}, {"id": 18, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "cause"}, {"id": 23, "text": "of"}, {"id": 24, "text": "the"}, {"id": 25, "text": "defendant"}, {"id": 26, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 27, "text": "conduct"}, {"id": 28, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 24, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Instead"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "the"}, {"id": 3, "text": "Ninth"}, {"id": 4, "text": "Circuit"}, {"id": 5, "text": "held"}, {"id": 6, "text": ","}, {"id": 7, "text": "a"}, {"id": 8, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 9, "text": "must"}, {"id": 10, "text": "only"}, {"id": 11, "text": "plead"}, {"id": 12, "text": "facts"}, {"id": 13, "text": "plausibly"}, {"id": 14, "text": "showing"}, {"id": 15, "text": "that"}, {"id": 16, "text": "race"}, {"id": 17, "text": "played"}, {"id": 18, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "some", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "role", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "in"}, {"id": 23, "text": "the"}, {"id": 24, "text": "defendant"}, {"id": 25, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 26, "text": "decisionmaking"}, {"id": 27, "text": "process"}, {"id": 28, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 25, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "743", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "Fed", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "Appx", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "106", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "107", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "2018", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": ";"}, {"id": 12, "text": "see"}, {"id": 13, "text": "also"}, {"id": 14, "text": "National", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "Assn", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "African", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "American", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "Owned", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "Media", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "Charter", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "Communications", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "Inc.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "915", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "F.3d", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "617", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "626", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "CA9", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "2019", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "("}, {"id": 39, "text": "describing"}, {"id": 40, "text": "the"}, {"id": 41, "text": "test"}, {"id": 42, "text": "as"}, {"id": 43, "text": "whether"}, {"id": 44, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": "discriminatory", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": "intent", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 47, "text": "play[ed", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 48, "text": "]", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 49, "text": "any", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 50, "text": "role", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 51, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 52, "text": ")"}, {"id": 53, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 26, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "And"}, {"id": 1, "text": "under"}, {"id": 2, "text": "this"}, {"id": 3, "text": "more"}, {"id": 4, "text": "forgiving"}, {"id": 5, "text": "causation"}, {"id": 6, "text": "standard"}, {"id": 7, "text": ","}, {"id": 8, "text": "the"}, {"id": 9, "text": "court"}, {"id": 10, "text": "continued"}, {"id": 11, "text": ","}, {"id": 12, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 13, "text": "had"}, {"id": 14, "text": "pleaded"}, {"id": 15, "text": "a"}, {"id": 16, "text": "viable"}, {"id": 17, "text": "claim"}, {"id": 18, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 27, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Other"}, {"id": 1, "text": "circuits"}, {"id": 2, "text": "dispute"}, {"id": 3, "text": "the"}, {"id": 4, "text": "Ninth"}, {"id": 5, "text": "Circuit"}, {"id": 6, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 7, "text": "understanding"}, {"id": 8, "text": "of"}, {"id": 9, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 28, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Like"}, {"id": 1, "text": "the"}, {"id": 2, "text": "district"}, {"id": 3, "text": "court"}, {"id": 4, "text": "in"}, {"id": 5, "text": "this"}, {"id": 6, "text": "case"}, {"id": 7, "text": ","}, {"id": 8, "text": "for"}, {"id": 9, "text": "example"}, {"id": 10, "text": ","}, {"id": 11, "text": "the"}, {"id": 12, "text": "Seventh"}, {"id": 13, "text": "Circuit"}, {"id": 14, "text": "has"}, {"id": 15, "text": "held"}, {"id": 16, "text": "that"}, {"id": 17, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "be", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "actionable", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "racial", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "prejudice", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "must", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "be", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "a", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "cause", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "refusal", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "transact", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "Bachman", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": "St.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": "Monica", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "'s", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": "Congregation", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": "902", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 47, "text": "F.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 48, "text": "1259", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 49, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 50, "text": "1262", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 51, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 52, "text": "1263", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 53, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 54, "text": "1990", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 55, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 56, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 29, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "To"}, {"id": 1, "text": "resolve"}, {"id": 2, "text": "the"}, {"id": 3, "text": "disagreement"}, {"id": 4, "text": "among"}, {"id": 5, "text": "the"}, {"id": 6, "text": "circuits"}, {"id": 7, "text": "over"}, {"id": 8, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 11, "text": "causation"}, {"id": 12, "text": "requirement"}, {"id": 13, "text": ","}, {"id": 14, "text": "we"}, {"id": 15, "text": "agreed"}, {"id": 16, "text": "to"}, {"id": 17, "text": "hear"}, {"id": 18, "text": "this"}, {"id": 19, "text": "case"}, {"id": 20, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 30, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "587", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "U.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "----", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "139", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "2693", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "204", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "1089", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "2019", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 31, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "II"}]}, {"id": 32, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "It"}, {"id": 1, "text": "is"}, {"id": 2, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "textbook", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "tort", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "law", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "that"}, {"id": 8, "text": "a"}, {"id": 9, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 10, "text": "seeking"}, {"id": 11, "text": "redress"}, {"id": 12, "text": "for"}, {"id": 13, "text": "a"}, {"id": 14, "text": "defendant"}, {"id": 15, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 16, "text": "legal"}, {"id": 17, "text": "wrong"}, {"id": 18, "text": "typically"}, {"id": 19, "text": "must"}, {"id": 20, "text": "prove"}, {"id": 21, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "causation", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 33, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "University", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "Tex", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "Southwestern", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "Medical", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "Center", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "Nassar", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "570", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "338", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "347", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "133", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "2517", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "186", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "503", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "2013", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "("}, {"id": 28, "text": "citing"}, {"id": 29, "text": "W.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "Keeton", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "D.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "Dobbs", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "R.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "Keeton", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "&", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "D.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "Owen", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": "Prosser", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": "Keeton", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": "on", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": "Law", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 47, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 48, "text": "Torts", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 49, "text": "265", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 50, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 51, "text": "5th", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 52, "text": "ed", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 53, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 54, "text": "1984", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 55, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 56, "text": ")"}, {"id": 57, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 34, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Under"}, {"id": 1, "text": "this"}, {"id": 2, "text": "standard"}, {"id": 3, "text": ","}, {"id": 4, "text": "a", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "plaintiff", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "must", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "demonstrate", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "that", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "defendant", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "'s", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "unlawful", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "conduct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "its", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "alleged", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "injury", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "would", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "not", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "have", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "occurred", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 35, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "This"}, {"id": 1, "text": "ancient"}, {"id": 2, "text": "and"}, {"id": 3, "text": "simple"}, {"id": 4, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "common"}, {"id": 9, "text": "law"}, {"id": 10, "text": "causation"}, {"id": 11, "text": "test"}, {"id": 12, "text": ","}, {"id": 13, "text": "we"}, {"id": 14, "text": "have"}, {"id": 15, "text": "held"}, {"id": 16, "text": ","}, {"id": 17, "text": "supplies"}, {"id": 18, "text": "the"}, {"id": 19, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "default", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "or"}, {"id": 23, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "background", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "rule"}, {"id": 27, "text": "against"}, {"id": 28, "text": "which"}, {"id": 29, "text": "Congress"}, {"id": 30, "text": "is"}, {"id": 31, "text": "normally"}, {"id": 32, "text": "presumed"}, {"id": 33, "text": "to"}, {"id": 34, "text": "have"}, {"id": 35, "text": "legislated"}, {"id": 36, "text": "when"}, {"id": 37, "text": "creating"}, {"id": 38, "text": "its"}, {"id": 39, "text": "own"}, {"id": 40, "text": "new"}, {"id": 41, "text": "causes"}, {"id": 42, "text": "of"}, {"id": 43, "text": "action"}, {"id": 44, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 36, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "570", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "346", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "347", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "133", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "2517", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "("}, {"id": 12, "text": "citing"}, {"id": 13, "text": "Los", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "Angeles", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "Dept", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "Water", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "Power", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "Manhart", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "435", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "702", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "711", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "98", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "1370", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "55", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "657", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "1978", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": ")"}, {"id": 42, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 37, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "That"}, {"id": 1, "text": "includes"}, {"id": 2, "text": "when"}, {"id": 3, "text": "it"}, {"id": 4, "text": "comes"}, {"id": 5, "text": "to"}, {"id": 6, "text": "federal"}, {"id": 7, "text": "antidiscrimination"}, {"id": 8, "text": "laws"}, {"id": 9, "text": "like"}, {"id": 10, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 38, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "See"}, {"id": 1, "text": "570", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "346", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "347", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "133", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "2517", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "("}, {"id": 13, "text": "Title"}, {"id": 14, "text": "VII"}, {"id": 15, "text": "retaliation"}, {"id": 16, "text": ")"}, {"id": 17, "text": ";"}, {"id": 18, "text": "Gross", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "FBL", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "Financial", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "Services", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "Inc.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "557", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "167", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "176", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "177", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "129", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "2343", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "174", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": "119", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "2009", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": "("}, {"id": 46, "text": "Age"}, {"id": 47, "text": "Discrimination"}, {"id": 48, "text": "in"}, {"id": 49, "text": "Employment"}, {"id": 50, "text": "Act"}, {"id": 51, "text": "of"}, {"id": 52, "text": "1967"}, {"id": 53, "text": ")"}, {"id": 54, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 39, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Normally"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "too"}, {"id": 3, "text": ","}, {"id": 4, "text": "the"}, {"id": 5, "text": "essential"}, {"id": 6, "text": "elements"}, {"id": 7, "text": "of"}, {"id": 8, "text": "a"}, {"id": 9, "text": "claim"}, {"id": 10, "text": "remain"}, {"id": 11, "text": "constant"}, {"id": 12, "text": "through"}, {"id": 13, "text": "the"}, {"id": 14, "text": "life"}, {"id": 15, "text": "of"}, {"id": 16, "text": "a"}, {"id": 17, "text": "lawsuit"}, {"id": 18, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 40, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "What"}, {"id": 1, "text": "a"}, {"id": 2, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 3, "text": "must"}, {"id": 4, "text": "do"}, {"id": 5, "text": "to"}, {"id": 6, "text": "satisfy"}, {"id": 7, "text": "those"}, {"id": 8, "text": "elements"}, {"id": 9, "text": "may"}, {"id": 10, "text": "increase"}, {"id": 11, "text": "as"}, {"id": 12, "text": "a"}, {"id": 13, "text": "case"}, {"id": 14, "text": "progresses"}, {"id": 15, "text": "from"}, {"id": 16, "text": "complaint"}, {"id": 17, "text": "to"}, {"id": 18, "text": "trial"}, {"id": 19, "text": ","}, {"id": 20, "text": "but"}, {"id": 21, "text": "the"}, {"id": 22, "text": "legal"}, {"id": 23, "text": "elements"}, {"id": 24, "text": "themselves"}, {"id": 25, "text": "do"}, {"id": 26, "text": "not"}, {"id": 27, "text": "change"}, {"id": 28, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 41, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "So"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "to"}, {"id": 3, "text": "determine"}, {"id": 4, "text": "what"}, {"id": 5, "text": "the"}, {"id": 6, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 7, "text": "must"}, {"id": 8, "text": "plausibly"}, {"id": 9, "text": "allege"}, {"id": 10, "text": "at"}, {"id": 11, "text": "the"}, {"id": 12, "text": "outset"}, {"id": 13, "text": "of"}, {"id": 14, "text": "a"}, {"id": 15, "text": "lawsuit"}, {"id": 16, "text": ","}, {"id": 17, "text": "we"}, {"id": 18, "text": "usually"}, {"id": 19, "text": "ask"}, {"id": 20, "text": "what"}, {"id": 21, "text": "the"}, {"id": 22, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 23, "text": "must"}, {"id": 24, "text": "prove"}, {"id": 25, "text": "in"}, {"id": 26, "text": "the"}, {"id": 27, "text": "trial"}, {"id": 28, "text": "at"}, {"id": 29, "text": "its"}, {"id": 30, "text": "end"}, {"id": 31, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 42, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "See"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "e.g."}, {"id": 3, "text": ","}, {"id": 4, "text": "Lujan", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "Defenders", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "Wildlife", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "504", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "555", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "561", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "112", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "2130", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "119", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "351", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "1992", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": ";"}, {"id": 28, "text": "Dura", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "Pharmaceuticals", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "Inc.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "Broudo", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "544", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "336", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "346", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": "347", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "125", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": "1627", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 47, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 48, "text": "161", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 49, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 50, "text": "577", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 51, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 52, "text": "2005", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 53, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 54, "text": ";"}, {"id": 55, "text": "Ashcroft", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 56, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 57, "text": "Iqbal", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 58, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 59, "text": "556", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 60, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 61, "text": "662", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 62, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 63, "text": "678", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 64, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 65, "text": "679", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 66, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 67, "text": "129", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 68, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 69, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 70, "text": "1937", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 71, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 72, "text": "173", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 73, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 74, "text": "868", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 75, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 76, "text": "2009", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 77, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 78, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 43, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 1, "text": "does"}, {"id": 2, "text": "n't"}, {"id": 3, "text": "seriously"}, {"id": 4, "text": "dispute"}, {"id": 5, "text": "these"}, {"id": 6, "text": "general"}, {"id": 7, "text": "principles"}, {"id": 8, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 44, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Instead"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "it"}, {"id": 3, "text": "suggests"}, {"id": 4, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "creates"}, {"id": 7, "text": "an"}, {"id": 8, "text": "exception"}, {"id": 9, "text": "to"}, {"id": 10, "text": "one"}, {"id": 11, "text": "or"}, {"id": 12, "text": "both"}, {"id": 13, "text": "of"}, {"id": 14, "text": "them"}, {"id": 15, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 45, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "At"}, {"id": 1, "text": "times"}, {"id": 2, "text": ","}, {"id": 3, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 4, "text": "seems"}, {"id": 5, "text": "to"}, {"id": 6, "text": "argue"}, {"id": 7, "text": "that"}, {"id": 8, "text": "a"}, {"id": 9, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 12, "text": "only"}, {"id": 13, "text": "bears"}, {"id": 14, "text": "the"}, {"id": 15, "text": "burden"}, {"id": 16, "text": "of"}, {"id": 17, "text": "showing"}, {"id": 18, "text": "that"}, {"id": 19, "text": "race"}, {"id": 20, "text": "was"}, {"id": 21, "text": "a"}, {"id": 22, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "motivating", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "factor", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "in"}, {"id": 27, "text": "the"}, {"id": 28, "text": "defendant"}, {"id": 29, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 30, "text": "challenged"}, {"id": 31, "text": "decision"}, {"id": 32, "text": ","}, {"id": 33, "text": "not"}, {"id": 34, "text": "a"}, {"id": 35, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "cause", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "of"}, {"id": 40, "text": "its"}, {"id": 41, "text": "injury"}, {"id": 42, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 46, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "At"}, {"id": 1, "text": "others"}, {"id": 2, "text": ","}, {"id": 3, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 4, "text": "appears"}, {"id": 5, "text": "to"}, {"id": 6, "text": "concede"}, {"id": 7, "text": "that"}, {"id": 8, "text": "a"}, {"id": 9, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 12, "text": "does"}, {"id": 13, "text": "have"}, {"id": 14, "text": "to"}, {"id": 15, "text": "prove"}, {"id": 16, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "causation", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "at"}, {"id": 21, "text": "trial"}, {"id": 22, "text": ","}, {"id": 23, "text": "but"}, {"id": 24, "text": "contends"}, {"id": 25, "text": "the"}, {"id": 26, "text": "rules"}, {"id": 27, "text": "should"}, {"id": 28, "text": "be"}, {"id": 29, "text": "different"}, {"id": 30, "text": "at"}, {"id": 31, "text": "the"}, {"id": 32, "text": "pleading"}, {"id": 33, "text": "stage"}, {"id": 34, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 47, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "According"}, {"id": 1, "text": "to"}, {"id": 2, "text": "this"}, {"id": 3, "text": "version"}, {"id": 4, "text": "of"}, {"id": 5, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 6, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 7, "text": "argument"}, {"id": 8, "text": ","}, {"id": 9, "text": "a"}, {"id": 10, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 11, "text": "should"}, {"id": 12, "text": "be"}, {"id": 13, "text": "able"}, {"id": 14, "text": "to"}, {"id": 15, "text": "overcome"}, {"id": 16, "text": "at"}, {"id": 17, "text": "least"}, {"id": 18, "text": "a"}, {"id": 19, "text": "motion"}, {"id": 20, "text": "to"}, {"id": 21, "text": "dismiss"}, {"id": 22, "text": "if"}, {"id": 23, "text": "it"}, {"id": 24, "text": "can"}, {"id": 25, "text": "allege"}, {"id": 26, "text": "facts"}, {"id": 27, "text": "plausibly"}, {"id": 28, "text": "showing"}, {"id": 29, "text": "that"}, {"id": 30, "text": "race"}, {"id": 31, "text": "was"}, {"id": 32, "text": "a"}, {"id": 33, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "motivating", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "factor", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "in"}, {"id": 38, "text": "the"}, {"id": 39, "text": "defendant"}, {"id": 40, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 41, "text": "decision"}, {"id": 42, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 48, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 1, "text": "admits"}, {"id": 2, "text": "this"}, {"id": 3, "text": "arrangement"}, {"id": 4, "text": "would"}, {"id": 5, "text": "allow"}, {"id": 6, "text": "some"}, {"id": 7, "text": "claims"}, {"id": 8, "text": "to"}, {"id": 9, "text": "proceed"}, {"id": 10, "text": "past"}, {"id": 11, "text": "the"}, {"id": 12, "text": "pleading"}, {"id": 13, "text": "stage"}, {"id": 14, "text": "that"}, {"id": 15, "text": "are"}, {"id": 16, "text": "destined"}, {"id": 17, "text": "to"}, {"id": 18, "text": "fail"}, {"id": 19, "text": "later"}, {"id": 20, "text": "as"}, {"id": 21, "text": "a"}, {"id": 22, "text": "matter"}, {"id": 23, "text": "of"}, {"id": 24, "text": "law"}, {"id": 25, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 49, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Still"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "the"}, {"id": 3, "text": "company"}, {"id": 4, "text": "insists"}, {"id": 5, "text": ","}, {"id": 6, "text": "that"}, {"id": 7, "text": "is"}, {"id": 8, "text": "what"}, {"id": 9, "text": "the"}, {"id": 10, "text": "statute"}, {"id": 11, "text": "demands"}, {"id": 12, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 50, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "A"}]}, {"id": 51, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "We"}, {"id": 1, "text": "do"}, {"id": 2, "text": "n't"}, {"id": 3, "text": "doubt"}, {"id": 4, "text": "that"}, {"id": 5, "text": "most"}, {"id": 6, "text": "rules"}, {"id": 7, "text": "bear"}, {"id": 8, "text": "their"}, {"id": 9, "text": "exceptions"}, {"id": 10, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 52, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "But"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "taken"}, {"id": 3, "text": "collectively"}, {"id": 4, "text": ","}, {"id": 5, "text": "clues"}, {"id": 6, "text": "from"}, {"id": 7, "text": "the"}, {"id": 8, "text": "statute"}, {"id": 9, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 10, "text": "text", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": ","}, {"id": 12, "text": "its"}, {"id": 13, "text": "history"}, {"id": 14, "text": ","}, {"id": 15, "text": "and"}, {"id": 16, "text": "our"}, {"id": 17, "text": "precedent"}, {"id": 18, "text": "persuade"}, {"id": 19, "text": "us"}, {"id": 20, "text": "that"}, {"id": 21, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "follows"}, {"id": 24, "text": "the"}, {"id": 25, "text": "general"}, {"id": 26, "text": "rule"}, {"id": 27, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 53, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Here"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "a"}, {"id": 3, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 4, "text": "bears"}, {"id": 5, "text": "the"}, {"id": 6, "text": "burden"}, {"id": 7, "text": "of"}, {"id": 8, "text": "showing"}, {"id": 9, "text": "that"}, {"id": 10, "text": "race"}, {"id": 11, "text": "was"}, {"id": 12, "text": "a"}, {"id": 13, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "cause", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "of"}, {"id": 18, "text": "its"}, {"id": 19, "text": "injury"}, {"id": 20, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 54, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "And"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "while"}, {"id": 3, "text": "the"}, {"id": 4, "text": "materials"}, {"id": 5, "text": "the"}, {"id": 6, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 7, "text": "can"}, {"id": 8, "text": "rely"}, {"id": 9, "text": "on"}, {"id": 10, "text": "to"}, {"id": 11, "text": "show"}, {"id": 12, "text": "causation"}, {"id": 13, "text": "may"}, {"id": 14, "text": "change"}, {"id": 15, "text": "as"}, {"id": 16, "text": "a"}, {"id": 17, "text": "lawsuit"}, {"id": 18, "text": "progresses"}, {"id": 19, "text": "from"}, {"id": 20, "text": "filing"}, {"id": 21, "text": "to"}, {"id": 22, "text": "judgment"}, {"id": 23, "text": ","}, {"id": 24, "text": "the"}, {"id": 25, "text": "burden"}, {"id": 26, "text": "itself"}, {"id": 27, "text": "remains"}, {"id": 28, "text": "constant"}, {"id": 29, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 55, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Congress"}, {"id": 1, "text": "passed"}, {"id": 2, "text": "the"}, {"id": 3, "text": "Civil", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "Rights", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "Act", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "1866", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "in"}, {"id": 9, "text": "the"}, {"id": 10, "text": "aftermath"}, {"id": 11, "text": "of"}, {"id": 12, "text": "the"}, {"id": 13, "text": "Civil"}, {"id": 14, "text": "War"}, {"id": 15, "text": "to"}, {"id": 16, "text": "vindicate"}, {"id": 17, "text": "the"}, {"id": 18, "text": "rights"}, {"id": 19, "text": "of"}, {"id": 20, "text": "former"}, {"id": 21, "text": "slaves"}, {"id": 22, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 56, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Section", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "1", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "of"}, {"id": 3, "text": "that"}, {"id": 4, "text": "statute"}, {"id": 5, "text": "included"}, {"id": 6, "text": "the"}, {"id": 7, "text": "language", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "found"}, {"id": 9, "text": "codified", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "today"}, {"id": 11, "text": "in"}, {"id": 12, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "1981(a", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": ","}, {"id": 16, "text": "promising"}, {"id": 17, "text": "that"}, {"id": 18, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "[", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "a]ll", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "persons", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "shall", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "have", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "same", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "right", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "make", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "enforce", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "contracts", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "sue", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "be", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "parties", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": "[", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "]", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": "give", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": "evidence", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 47, "text": "as", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 48, "text": "is", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 49, "text": "enjoyed", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 50, "text": "by", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 51, "text": "white", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 52, "text": "citizens", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 53, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 54, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 57, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "42", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "U.S.C.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": ";", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "Civil", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "Rights", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "Act", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "1866", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "14", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "Stat", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "27", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 58, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "While"}, {"id": 1, "text": "the"}, {"id": 2, "text": "statute"}, {"id": 3, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 4, "text": "text", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "does"}, {"id": 6, "text": "not"}, {"id": 7, "text": "expressly", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "discuss", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "causation"}, {"id": 10, "text": ","}, {"id": 11, "text": "it"}, {"id": 12, "text": "is"}, {"id": 13, "text": "suggestive", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 59, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "The"}, {"id": 1, "text": "guarantee"}, {"id": 2, "text": "that"}, {"id": 3, "text": "each"}, {"id": 4, "text": "person"}, {"id": 5, "text": "is"}, {"id": 6, "text": "entitled"}, {"id": 7, "text": "to"}, {"id": 8, "text": "the"}, {"id": 9, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "same", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "right", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "as", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "is", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "enjoyed", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "by", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "white", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "citizens", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "directs"}, {"id": 21, "text": "our"}, {"id": 22, "text": "attention"}, {"id": 23, "text": "to"}, {"id": 24, "text": "the"}, {"id": 25, "text": "counterfactual"}, {"id": 26, "text": "-"}, {"id": 27, "text": "what"}, {"id": 28, "text": "would"}, {"id": 29, "text": "have"}, {"id": 30, "text": "happened"}, {"id": 31, "text": "if"}, {"id": 32, "text": "the"}, {"id": 33, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 34, "text": "had"}, {"id": 35, "text": "been"}, {"id": 36, "text": "white"}, {"id": 37, "text": "?"}]}, {"id": 60, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "This"}, {"id": 1, "text": "focus"}, {"id": 2, "text": "fits"}, {"id": 3, "text": "naturally"}, {"id": 4, "text": "with"}, {"id": 5, "text": "the"}, {"id": 6, "text": "ordinary"}, {"id": 7, "text": "rule"}, {"id": 8, "text": "that"}, {"id": 9, "text": "a"}, {"id": 10, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 11, "text": "must"}, {"id": 12, "text": "prove"}, {"id": 13, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "causation", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 61, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "If", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "defendant", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "would", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "have", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "responded", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "same", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "way", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "plaintiff", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "even", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "if", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "he", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "had", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "been", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "white", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "an", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "ordinary", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "speaker", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "English", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "would", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "say", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "that", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "plaintiff", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "received", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "same", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "legally", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "protected", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "right", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "as", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "a", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "white", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "person", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}]}, {"id": 62, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Conversely", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "if", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "defendant", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "would", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "have", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "responded", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "differently", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "plaintiff", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "'s", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "race", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "it", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "follows", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "that", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "plaintiff", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "has", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "not", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "received", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "same", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "right", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "as", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "a", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "white", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "person", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Example Use"}]}]}, {"id": 63, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Nor"}, {"id": 1, "text": "does"}, {"id": 2, "text": "anything"}, {"id": 3, "text": "in"}, {"id": 4, "text": "the"}, {"id": 5, "text": "statute"}, {"id": 6, "text": "signal"}, {"id": 7, "text": "that"}, {"id": 8, "text": "this"}, {"id": 9, "text": "test"}, {"id": 10, "text": "should"}, {"id": 11, "text": "change"}, {"id": 12, "text": "its"}, {"id": 13, "text": "stripes"}, {"id": 14, "text": "("}, {"id": 15, "text": "only"}, {"id": 16, "text": ")"}, {"id": 17, "text": "in"}, {"id": 18, "text": "the"}, {"id": 19, "text": "face"}, {"id": 20, "text": "of"}, {"id": 21, "text": "a"}, {"id": 22, "text": "motion"}, {"id": 23, "text": "to"}, {"id": 24, "text": "dismiss"}, {"id": 25, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 64, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "The"}, {"id": 1, "text": "larger"}, {"id": 2, "text": "structure"}, {"id": 3, "text": "and"}, {"id": 4, "text": "history"}, {"id": 5, "text": "of"}, {"id": 6, "text": "the"}, {"id": 7, "text": "Civil", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "Rights", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "Act", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "1866", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "provide"}, {"id": 13, "text": "further"}, {"id": 14, "text": "clues"}, {"id": 15, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 65, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Nothing"}, {"id": 1, "text": "in"}, {"id": 2, "text": "the"}, {"id": 3, "text": "Act", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "specifically"}, {"id": 5, "text": "authorizes"}, {"id": 6, "text": "private"}, {"id": 7, "text": "lawsuits"}, {"id": 8, "text": "to"}, {"id": 9, "text": "enforce"}, {"id": 10, "text": "the"}, {"id": 11, "text": "right"}, {"id": 12, "text": "to"}, {"id": 13, "text": "contract"}, {"id": 14, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 66, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Instead"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "this"}, {"id": 3, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 4, "text": "created"}, {"id": 5, "text": "a"}, {"id": 6, "text": "judicially"}, {"id": 7, "text": "implied"}, {"id": 8, "text": "private"}, {"id": 9, "text": "right"}, {"id": 10, "text": "of"}, {"id": 11, "text": "action"}, {"id": 12, "text": ","}, {"id": 13, "text": "definitively"}, {"id": 14, "text": "doing"}, {"id": 15, "text": "so"}, {"id": 16, "text": "for"}, {"id": 17, "text": "the"}, {"id": 18, "text": "first"}, {"id": 19, "text": "time"}, {"id": 20, "text": "in"}, {"id": 21, "text": "1975"}, {"id": 22, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 67, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "See", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "Johnson", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "Railway", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "Express", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "Agency", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "Inc.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "421", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "454", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "459", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "95", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "1716", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "44", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "295", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "1975", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": ";"}, {"id": 27, "text": "see"}, {"id": 28, "text": "also"}, {"id": 29, "text": "Jett", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "Dallas", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "Independent", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "School", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "Dist", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "491", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "701", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": "720", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "109", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": "2702", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 47, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 48, "text": "105", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 49, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 50, "text": "598", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 51, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 52, "text": "1989", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 53, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 54, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 68, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "That"}, {"id": 1, "text": "was"}, {"id": 2, "text": "during"}, {"id": 3, "text": "a"}, {"id": 4, "text": "period"}, {"id": 5, "text": "when"}, {"id": 6, "text": "the"}, {"id": 7, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 8, "text": "often"}, {"id": 9, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "assumed", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "it", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "be", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "a", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "proper", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "judicial", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "function", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "provide", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "such", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "remedies", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "as", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "are", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "necessary", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "make", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "effective", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "a", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "statute", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "'s", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "purpose", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "Ziglar", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "Abbasi", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "582", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "U.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "S.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": "----", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "----", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": "137", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 47, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 48, "text": "1843", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 49, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 50, "text": "1855", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 51, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 52, "text": "198", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 53, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 54, "text": "290", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 55, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 56, "text": "2017", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 57, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 58, "text": "("}, {"id": 59, "text": "internal"}, {"id": 60, "text": "quotation"}, {"id": 61, "text": "marks"}, {"id": 62, "text": "omitted"}, {"id": 63, "text": ")"}, {"id": 64, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 69, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "With"}, {"id": 1, "text": "the"}, {"id": 2, "text": "passage"}, {"id": 3, "text": "of"}, {"id": 4, "text": "time"}, {"id": 5, "text": ","}, {"id": 6, "text": "of"}, {"id": 7, "text": "course"}, {"id": 8, "text": ","}, {"id": 9, "text": "we"}, {"id": 10, "text": "have"}, {"id": 11, "text": "come"}, {"id": 12, "text": "to"}, {"id": 13, "text": "appreciate"}, {"id": 14, "text": "that"}, {"id": 15, "text": ","}, {"id": 16, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "[", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "l]ike", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "substantive", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "federal", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "law", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "itself", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "private", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "rights", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "action", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "enforce", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "federal", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "law", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "must", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "be", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "created", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "by", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "Congress", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "and"}, {"id": 39, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "[", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": "r]aising", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": "up", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "causes", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": "action", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": "where", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 47, "text": "a", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 48, "text": "statute", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 49, "text": "has", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 50, "text": "not", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 51, "text": "created", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 52, "text": "them", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 53, "text": "may", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 54, "text": "be", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 55, "text": "a", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 56, "text": "proper", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 57, "text": "function", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 58, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 59, "text": "common", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 60, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 61, "text": "law", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 62, "text": "courts", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 63, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 64, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 65, "text": "not", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 66, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 67, "text": "federal", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 68, "text": "tribunals", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 69, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 70, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 70, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Alexander", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "Sandoval", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "532", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "275", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "286", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "287", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "121", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "1511", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "149", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "517", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "2001", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "("}, {"id": 24, "text": "internal"}, {"id": 25, "text": "quotation"}, {"id": 26, "text": "marks"}, {"id": 27, "text": "omitted"}, {"id": 28, "text": ")"}, {"id": 29, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 71, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Yet"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "even"}, {"id": 3, "text": "in"}, {"id": 4, "text": "the"}, {"id": 5, "text": "era"}, {"id": 6, "text": "when"}, {"id": 7, "text": "this"}, {"id": 8, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 9, "text": "routinely"}, {"id": 10, "text": "implied"}, {"id": 11, "text": "causes"}, {"id": 12, "text": "of"}, {"id": 13, "text": "action"}, {"id": 14, "text": ","}, {"id": 15, "text": "it"}, {"id": 16, "text": "usually"}, {"id": 17, "text": "insisted"}, {"id": 18, "text": "on"}, {"id": 19, "text": "legal"}, {"id": 20, "text": "elements"}, {"id": 21, "text": "at"}, {"id": 22, "text": "least"}, {"id": 23, "text": "as"}, {"id": 24, "text": "demanding"}, {"id": 25, "text": "as"}, {"id": 26, "text": "those"}, {"id": 27, "text": "Congress"}, {"id": 28, "text": "specified"}, {"id": 29, "text": "for"}, {"id": 30, "text": "analogous"}, {"id": 31, "text": "causes"}, {"id": 32, "text": "of"}, {"id": 33, "text": "action"}, {"id": 34, "text": "actually"}, {"id": 35, "text": "found"}, {"id": 36, "text": "in"}, {"id": 37, "text": "the"}, {"id": 38, "text": "statutory"}, {"id": 39, "text": "text", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 72, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "See"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "e.g."}, {"id": 3, "text": ","}, {"id": 4, "text": "Blue", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "Chip", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "Stamps", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "Manor", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "Drug", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "Stores", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "421", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "723", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "736", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "95", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "1917", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "44", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "539", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "1975", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 73, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "That"}, {"id": 1, "text": "rule"}, {"id": 2, "text": "supplies"}, {"id": 3, "text": "useful"}, {"id": 4, "text": "guidance"}, {"id": 5, "text": "here"}, {"id": 6, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 74, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Though"}, {"id": 1, "text": "Congress"}, {"id": 2, "text": "did"}, {"id": 3, "text": "not"}, {"id": 4, "text": "adopt"}, {"id": 5, "text": "a"}, {"id": 6, "text": "private"}, {"id": 7, "text": "enforcement"}, {"id": 8, "text": "mechanism"}, {"id": 9, "text": "for"}, {"id": 10, "text": "violations"}, {"id": 11, "text": "of"}, {"id": 12, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": ","}, {"id": 15, "text": "it"}, {"id": 16, "text": "did"}, {"id": 17, "text": "establish"}, {"id": 18, "text": "criminal"}, {"id": 19, "text": "sanctions"}, {"id": 20, "text": "in"}, {"id": 21, "text": "a"}, {"id": 22, "text": "neighboring"}, {"id": 23, "text": "section"}, {"id": 24, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 75, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "That"}, {"id": 1, "text": "provision"}, {"id": 2, "text": "permitted"}, {"id": 3, "text": "the"}, {"id": 4, "text": "prosecution"}, {"id": 5, "text": "of"}, {"id": 6, "text": "anyone"}, {"id": 7, "text": "who"}, {"id": 8, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "depriv[es", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "]", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "a"}, {"id": 13, "text": "person"}, {"id": 14, "text": "of"}, {"id": 15, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "any", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "right", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "protected"}, {"id": 20, "text": "by"}, {"id": 21, "text": "the"}, {"id": 22, "text": "substantive"}, {"id": 23, "text": "provisions"}, {"id": 24, "text": "of"}, {"id": 25, "text": "the"}, {"id": 26, "text": "Civil", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "Rights", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "Act", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "1866", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "on", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "account", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "that"}, {"id": 37, "text": "person"}, {"id": 38, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 39, "text": "prior"}, {"id": 40, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": "condition", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "slavery", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": "or"}, {"id": 46, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 5, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 47, "text": "by", "annotations": [{"id": 5, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 48, "text": "reason", "annotations": [{"id": 5, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 49, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 5, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 50, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 5, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 51, "text": "that"}, {"id": 52, "text": "person"}, {"id": 53, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 54, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 6, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 55, "text": "color", "annotations": [{"id": 6, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 56, "text": "or", "annotations": [{"id": 6, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 57, "text": "race", "annotations": [{"id": 6, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 58, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 6, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 59, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 6, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 76, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "2", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "14", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "Stat", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "27", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 77, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "To"}, {"id": 1, "text": "prove"}, {"id": 2, "text": "a"}, {"id": 3, "text": "violation"}, {"id": 4, "text": ","}, {"id": 5, "text": "then"}, {"id": 6, "text": ","}, {"id": 7, "text": "the"}, {"id": 8, "text": "government"}, {"id": 9, "text": "had"}, {"id": 10, "text": "to"}, {"id": 11, "text": "show"}, {"id": 12, "text": "that"}, {"id": 13, "text": "the"}, {"id": 14, "text": "defendant"}, {"id": 15, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 16, "text": "challenged"}, {"id": 17, "text": "actions"}, {"id": 18, "text": "were"}, {"id": 19, "text": "taken"}, {"id": 20, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "'", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "on", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "account", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "'", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "or"}, {"id": 28, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "'", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "by", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "reason", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "'", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "race"}, {"id": 36, "text": "-"}, {"id": 37, "text": "terms", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "we"}, {"id": 39, "text": "have"}, {"id": 40, "text": "often"}, {"id": 41, "text": "held"}, {"id": 42, "text": "indicate"}, {"id": 43, "text": "a"}, {"id": 44, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 47, "text": "causation", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 48, "text": "requirement"}, {"id": 49, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 78, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Gross", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "557", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "176", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "177", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "129", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "2343", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 79, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Nor"}, {"id": 1, "text": "did"}, {"id": 2, "text": "anything"}, {"id": 3, "text": "in"}, {"id": 4, "text": "the"}, {"id": 5, "text": "statute"}, {"id": 6, "text": "hint", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "that"}, {"id": 8, "text": "a"}, {"id": 9, "text": "different"}, {"id": 10, "text": "and"}, {"id": 11, "text": "more"}, {"id": 12, "text": "forgiving"}, {"id": 13, "text": "rule"}, {"id": 14, "text": "might"}, {"id": 15, "text": "apply"}, {"id": 16, "text": "at"}, {"id": 17, "text": "one"}, {"id": 18, "text": "particular"}, {"id": 19, "text": "stage"}, {"id": 20, "text": "in"}, {"id": 21, "text": "the"}, {"id": 22, "text": "litigation"}, {"id": 23, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 80, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "In"}, {"id": 1, "text": "light"}, {"id": 2, "text": "of"}, {"id": 3, "text": "the"}, {"id": 4, "text": "causation"}, {"id": 5, "text": "standard"}, {"id": 6, "text": "Congress"}, {"id": 7, "text": "specified"}, {"id": 8, "text": "for"}, {"id": 9, "text": "the"}, {"id": 10, "text": "cause"}, {"id": 11, "text": "of"}, {"id": 12, "text": "action"}, {"id": 13, "text": "it"}, {"id": 14, "text": "expressly"}, {"id": 15, "text": "endorsed"}, {"id": 16, "text": ","}, {"id": 17, "text": "it"}, {"id": 18, "text": "would"}, {"id": 19, "text": "be"}, {"id": 20, "text": "more"}, {"id": 21, "text": "than"}, {"id": 22, "text": "a"}, {"id": 23, "text": "little"}, {"id": 24, "text": "incongruous"}, {"id": 25, "text": "for"}, {"id": 26, "text": "us"}, {"id": 27, "text": "to"}, {"id": 28, "text": "employ"}, {"id": 29, "text": "the"}, {"id": 30, "text": "laxer"}, {"id": 31, "text": "rules"}, {"id": 32, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 33, "text": "proposes"}, {"id": 34, "text": "for"}, {"id": 35, "text": "this"}, {"id": 36, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 37, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 38, "text": "judicially"}, {"id": 39, "text": "implied"}, {"id": 40, "text": "cause"}, {"id": 41, "text": "of"}, {"id": 42, "text": "action"}, {"id": 43, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 81, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Other"}, {"id": 1, "text": "provisions"}, {"id": 2, "text": "of"}, {"id": 3, "text": "the"}, {"id": 4, "text": "1866"}, {"id": 5, "text": "statute"}, {"id": 6, "text": "offer"}, {"id": 7, "text": "further"}, {"id": 8, "text": "guidance"}, {"id": 9, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 82, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Not"}, {"id": 1, "text": "only"}, {"id": 2, "text": "do"}, {"id": 3, "text": "we"}, {"id": 4, "text": "generally"}, {"id": 5, "text": "presume"}, {"id": 6, "text": "that"}, {"id": 7, "text": "Congress"}, {"id": 8, "text": "legislates"}, {"id": 9, "text": "against"}, {"id": 10, "text": "the"}, {"id": 11, "text": "backdrop"}, {"id": 12, "text": "of"}, {"id": 13, "text": "the"}, {"id": 14, "text": "common"}, {"id": 15, "text": "law"}, {"id": 16, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 83, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Nassar", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "570", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "347", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "133", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "2517", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 84, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "The", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "Civil", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "Rights", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "Act", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "1866", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "made"}, {"id": 7, "text": "this"}, {"id": 8, "text": "background"}, {"id": 9, "text": "presumption"}, {"id": 10, "text": "explicit"}, {"id": 11, "text": ","}, {"id": 12, "text": "providing"}, {"id": 13, "text": "that"}, {"id": 14, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "in", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "all", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "cases", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "where", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "[", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "laws", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "United", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "States", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "]", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "are", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "not", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "adapted", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "object", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "[", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "carrying", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "statute", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "into", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "effect", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "]", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": "common", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "law", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": "shall", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 47, "text": "govern", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 48, "text": "said", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 49, "text": "courts", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 50, "text": "in", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 51, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 52, "text": "trial", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 53, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 54, "text": "disposition", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 55, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 56, "text": "such", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 57, "text": "cause", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 58, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 59, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 85, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "3", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "14", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "Stat", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "27", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 86, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "And"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "while"}, {"id": 3, "text": "there"}, {"id": 4, "text": "were"}, {"id": 5, "text": "exceptions"}, {"id": 6, "text": ","}, {"id": 7, "text": "the"}, {"id": 8, "text": "common"}, {"id": 9, "text": "law"}, {"id": 10, "text": "in"}, {"id": 11, "text": "1866"}, {"id": 12, "text": "often"}, {"id": 13, "text": "treated"}, {"id": 14, "text": "a"}, {"id": 15, "text": "showing"}, {"id": 16, "text": "of"}, {"id": 17, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "causation", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "as"}, {"id": 22, "text": "a"}, {"id": 23, "text": "prerequisite"}, {"id": 24, "text": "to"}, {"id": 25, "text": "a"}, {"id": 26, "text": "tort"}, {"id": 27, "text": "suit"}, {"id": 28, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 87, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "See"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "e.g."}, {"id": 3, "text": ","}, {"id": 4, "text": "Hayes", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "Michigan", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "Central", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "R.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "Co.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "111", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "228", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "241", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "4", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "369", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "28", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "L.Ed", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "410", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "1884", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": ";"}, {"id": 30, "text": "Smith", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "Legal", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "Cause", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "in", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "Actions", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "Tort", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "25", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "Harv", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": "L.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "Rev.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": "103", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": "108", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 47, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 48, "text": "109", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 49, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 50, "text": "1911", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 51, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 52, "text": ";"}, {"id": 53, "text": "White", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 54, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 55, "text": "The", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 56, "text": "Emergence", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 57, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 58, "text": "Doctrinal", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 59, "text": "Development", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 60, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 61, "text": "Tort", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 62, "text": "Law", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 63, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 64, "text": "1870", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 65, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 66, "text": "1930", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 67, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 68, "text": "11", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 69, "text": "U.", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 70, "text": "St.", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 71, "text": "Thomas", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 72, "text": "L.", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 73, "text": "J.", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 74, "text": "463", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 75, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 76, "text": "464", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 77, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 78, "text": "465", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 79, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 80, "text": "2014", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 81, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 82, "text": ";"}, {"id": 83, "text": "1", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 84, "text": "F.", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 85, "text": "Hilliard", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 86, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 87, "text": "Law", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 88, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 89, "text": "Torts", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 90, "text": "78", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 91, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 92, "text": "79", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 93, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 94, "text": "1866", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 95, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 96, "text": ";"}, {"id": 97, "text": "1", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 98, "text": "T.", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 99, "text": "Sedgwick", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 100, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 101, "text": "Measure", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 102, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 103, "text": "Damages", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 104, "text": "199", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 105, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 106, "text": "9th", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 107, "text": "ed", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 108, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 109, "text": "1912", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 110, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 111, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 88, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Nor"}, {"id": 1, "text": "did"}, {"id": 2, "text": "this"}, {"id": 3, "text": "prerequisite"}, {"id": 4, "text": "normally"}, {"id": 5, "text": "wait"}, {"id": 6, "text": "long"}, {"id": 7, "text": "to"}, {"id": 8, "text": "make"}, {"id": 9, "text": "its"}, {"id": 10, "text": "appearance"}, {"id": 11, "text": ";"}, {"id": 12, "text": "if"}, {"id": 13, "text": "anything"}, {"id": 14, "text": ","}, {"id": 15, "text": "pleadings"}, {"id": 16, "text": "standards"}, {"id": 17, "text": "back"}, {"id": 18, "text": "then"}, {"id": 19, "text": "were"}, {"id": 20, "text": "generally"}, {"id": 21, "text": "even"}, {"id": 22, "text": "stricter"}, {"id": 23, "text": "than"}, {"id": 24, "text": "they"}, {"id": 25, "text": "are"}, {"id": 26, "text": "in"}, {"id": 27, "text": "federal"}, {"id": 28, "text": "practice"}, {"id": 29, "text": "today"}, {"id": 30, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 89, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "See"}, {"id": 1, "text": "generally"}, {"id": 2, "text": ","}, {"id": 3, "text": "e.g."}, {"id": 4, "text": ","}, {"id": 5, "text": "Lugar", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "Common", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "Law", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "Pleading", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "Modified", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "versus", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "Federal", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "Rules", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "52", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "W.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "Va.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "L.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "Rev.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "137", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "1950", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 90, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "This"}, {"id": 1, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 2, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 3, "text": "precedents"}, {"id": 4, "text": "confirm"}, {"id": 5, "text": "all"}, {"id": 6, "text": "that"}, {"id": 7, "text": "the"}, {"id": 8, "text": "statute"}, {"id": 9, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 10, "text": "language", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "and"}, {"id": 12, "text": "history"}, {"id": 13, "text": "indicate"}, {"id": 14, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 91, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "When"}, {"id": 1, "text": "it"}, {"id": 2, "text": "first"}, {"id": 3, "text": "inferred"}, {"id": 4, "text": "a"}, {"id": 5, "text": "private"}, {"id": 6, "text": "cause"}, {"id": 7, "text": "of"}, {"id": 8, "text": "action"}, {"id": 9, "text": "under"}, {"id": 10, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": ","}, {"id": 13, "text": "this"}, {"id": 14, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 15, "text": "described"}, {"id": 16, "text": "it"}, {"id": 17, "text": "as"}, {"id": 18, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "afford[ing", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "]", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "a", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "federal", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "remedy", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "against", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "discrimination", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "on", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "basis", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "race", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "language", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "("}, {"id": 36, "text": "again"}, {"id": 37, "text": ")"}, {"id": 38, "text": "strongly"}, {"id": 39, "text": "suggestive", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "of"}, {"id": 41, "text": "a"}, {"id": 42, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": "causation", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": "standard"}, {"id": 47, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 92, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Johnson", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "421", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "459", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "460", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "95", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "1716", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "("}, {"id": 14, "text": "emphasis"}, {"id": 15, "text": "added"}, {"id": 16, "text": ")"}, {"id": 17, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 93, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Later"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "in"}, {"id": 3, "text": "General", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "Building", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "Contractors", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "Assn", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "Inc.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "Pennsylvania", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "458", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "375", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "102", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": ".3141", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "73", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "835", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "1982", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": ","}, {"id": 28, "text": "the"}, {"id": 29, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 30, "text": "explained"}, {"id": 31, "text": "that"}, {"id": 32, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "was"}, {"id": 35, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "designed", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "eradicate", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "blatant", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "deprivations", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": "civil", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "rights", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": "such"}, {"id": 47, "text": "as"}, {"id": 48, "text": "where"}, {"id": 49, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 50, "text": "a", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 51, "text": "private", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 52, "text": "offeror", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 53, "text": "refuse[d", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 54, "text": "]", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 55, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 56, "text": "extend", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 57, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 58, "text": "[", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 59, "text": "an", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 60, "text": "African", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 61, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 62, "text": "American", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 63, "text": "]", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 64, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 65, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 66, "text": "because", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 67, "text": "he", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 68, "text": "is", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 69, "text": "[", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 70, "text": "an", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 71, "text": "African", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 72, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 73, "text": "American", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 74, "text": "]", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 75, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 76, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 77, "text": "same", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 78, "text": "opportunity", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 79, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 80, "text": "enter", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 81, "text": "into", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 82, "text": "contracts", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 83, "text": "as", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 84, "text": "he", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 85, "text": "extends", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 86, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 87, "text": "white", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 88, "text": "offerees", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 89, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 90, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 94, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Id.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "388", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "102", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "3141", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "("}, {"id": 10, "text": "emphasis"}, {"id": 11, "text": "deleted"}, {"id": 12, "text": ";"}, {"id": 13, "text": "internal"}, {"id": 14, "text": "quotation"}, {"id": 15, "text": "marks"}, {"id": 16, "text": "omitted"}, {"id": 17, "text": ")"}, {"id": 18, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 95, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Once"}, {"id": 1, "text": "more"}, {"id": 2, "text": ","}, {"id": 3, "text": "the"}, {"id": 4, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 5, "text": "spoke"}, {"id": 6, "text": "of"}, {"id": 7, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "using"}, {"id": 10, "text": "language", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "-"}, {"id": 12, "text": "because"}, {"id": 13, "text": "of"}, {"id": 14, "text": "-"}, {"id": 15, "text": "often"}, {"id": 16, "text": "associated"}, {"id": 17, "text": "with"}, {"id": 18, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "causation", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 96, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Nassar", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "570", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "350", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "133", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "2517", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 97, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Nor"}, {"id": 1, "text": "did"}, {"id": 2, "text": "anything"}, {"id": 3, "text": "in"}, {"id": 4, "text": "these"}, {"id": 5, "text": "decisions"}, {"id": 6, "text": "even"}, {"id": 7, "text": "gesture"}, {"id": 8, "text": "toward"}, {"id": 9, "text": "the"}, {"id": 10, "text": "possibility"}, {"id": 11, "text": "that"}, {"id": 12, "text": "this"}, {"id": 13, "text": "rule"}, {"id": 14, "text": "of"}, {"id": 15, "text": "causation"}, {"id": 16, "text": "sometimes"}, {"id": 17, "text": "might"}, {"id": 18, "text": "be"}, {"id": 19, "text": "overlooked"}, {"id": 20, "text": "or"}, {"id": 21, "text": "modified"}, {"id": 22, "text": "in"}, {"id": 23, "text": "the"}, {"id": 24, "text": "early"}, {"id": 25, "text": "stages"}, {"id": 26, "text": "of"}, {"id": 27, "text": "a"}, {"id": 28, "text": "case"}, {"id": 29, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 98, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "This"}, {"id": 1, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 2, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 3, "text": "treatment"}, {"id": 4, "text": "of"}, {"id": 5, "text": "a"}, {"id": 6, "text": "neighboring"}, {"id": 7, "text": "provision"}, {"id": 8, "text": ","}, {"id": 9, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "1982", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": ","}, {"id": 12, "text": "supplies"}, {"id": 13, "text": "a"}, {"id": 14, "text": "final"}, {"id": 15, "text": "telling"}, {"id": 16, "text": "piece"}, {"id": 17, "text": "of"}, {"id": 18, "text": "evidence"}, {"id": 19, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 99, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Because"}, {"id": 1, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "1982", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "was"}, {"id": 4, "text": "also"}, {"id": 5, "text": "first"}, {"id": 6, "text": "enacted"}, {"id": 7, "text": "as"}, {"id": 8, "text": "part"}, {"id": 9, "text": "of"}, {"id": 10, "text": "the"}, {"id": 11, "text": "Civil", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "Rights", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "Act", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "1866", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "and"}, {"id": 17, "text": "uses"}, {"id": 18, "text": "nearly"}, {"id": 19, "text": "identical"}, {"id": 20, "text": "language", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "as"}, {"id": 22, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": ","}, {"id": 25, "text": "the"}, {"id": 26, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 27, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 28, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "precedents", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "have", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "construed", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 5, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 5, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 5, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 5, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "1982", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 5, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "similarly", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 100, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "CBOCS", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "West", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "Inc.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "Humphries", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "553", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "442", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "447", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "128", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "1951", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "170", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "864", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "2008", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 101, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Section", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "1982", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "guarantees"}, {"id": 3, "text": "all"}, {"id": 4, "text": "citizens"}, {"id": 5, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "same", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "right", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "as", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "is", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "enjoyed", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "by", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "white", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "citizens", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "inherit", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "purchase", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "lease", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "sell", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "hold", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "convey", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "real", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "personal", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "property", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 102, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "And"}, {"id": 1, "text": "this"}, {"id": 2, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 3, "text": "has"}, {"id": 4, "text": "repeatedly"}, {"id": 5, "text": "held"}, {"id": 6, "text": "that"}, {"id": 7, "text": "a"}, {"id": 8, "text": "claim"}, {"id": 9, "text": "arises"}, {"id": 10, "text": "under"}, {"id": 11, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "1982", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "when"}, {"id": 14, "text": "a"}, {"id": 15, "text": "citizen"}, {"id": 16, "text": "is"}, {"id": 17, "text": "not"}, {"id": 18, "text": "allowed"}, {"id": 19, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "acquire", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "property", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "because", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "color", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 103, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Buchanan", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "Warley", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "245", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "60", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "78", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "79", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "38", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "16", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "62", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "L.Ed", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "149", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "1917", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "("}, {"id": 25, "text": "emphasis"}, {"id": 26, "text": "added"}, {"id": 27, "text": ")"}, {"id": 28, "text": ";"}, {"id": 29, "text": "see"}, {"id": 30, "text": "also"}, {"id": 31, "text": "Jones", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "Alfred", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "H.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "Mayer", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "Co.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "392", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "409", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": "419", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": "88", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 47, "text": "2186", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 48, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 49, "text": "20", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 50, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 51, "text": "1189", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 52, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 53, "text": "1968", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 54, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 55, "text": ";"}, {"id": 56, "text": "Runyon", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 57, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 58, "text": "McCrary", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 59, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 60, "text": "427", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 61, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 62, "text": "160", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 63, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 64, "text": "170", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 65, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 66, "text": "171", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 67, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 68, "text": "96", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 69, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 70, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 71, "text": "2586", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 72, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 73, "text": "49", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 74, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 75, "text": "415", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 76, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 77, "text": "1976", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 78, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 79, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 104, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "If"}, {"id": 1, "text": "a"}, {"id": 2, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "1982", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 5, "text": "must"}, {"id": 6, "text": "show"}, {"id": 7, "text": "the"}, {"id": 8, "text": "defendant"}, {"id": 9, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 10, "text": "challenged"}, {"id": 11, "text": "conduct"}, {"id": 12, "text": "was"}, {"id": 13, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "because", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "race"}, {"id": 18, "text": ","}, {"id": 19, "text": "it"}, {"id": 20, "text": "is"}, {"id": 21, "text": "unclear"}, {"id": 22, "text": "how"}, {"id": 23, "text": "we"}, {"id": 24, "text": "might"}, {"id": 25, "text": "demand"}, {"id": 26, "text": "less"}, {"id": 27, "text": "from"}, {"id": 28, "text": "a"}, {"id": 29, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 32, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 105, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Certainly"}, {"id": 1, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 2, "text": "offers"}, {"id": 3, "text": "no"}, {"id": 4, "text": "compelling"}, {"id": 5, "text": "reason"}, {"id": 6, "text": "to"}, {"id": 7, "text": "read", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "two"}, {"id": 9, "text": "such"}, {"id": 10, "text": "similar"}, {"id": 11, "text": "statutes"}, {"id": 12, "text": "so"}, {"id": 13, "text": "differently"}, {"id": 14, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 106, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "B"}]}, {"id": 107, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "What"}, {"id": 1, "text": "does"}, {"id": 2, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 3, "text": "offer"}, {"id": 4, "text": "in"}, {"id": 5, "text": "reply"}, {"id": 6, "text": "?"}]}, {"id": 108, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "The"}, {"id": 1, "text": "company"}, {"id": 2, "text": "asks"}, {"id": 3, "text": "us"}, {"id": 4, "text": "to"}, {"id": 5, "text": "draw"}, {"id": 6, "text": "on"}, {"id": 7, "text": ","}, {"id": 8, "text": "and"}, {"id": 9, "text": "then"}, {"id": 10, "text": "innovate"}, {"id": 11, "text": "with"}, {"id": 12, "text": ","}, {"id": 13, "text": "the"}, {"id": 14, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "motivating", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "factor", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "causation"}, {"id": 19, "text": "test"}, {"id": 20, "text": "found"}, {"id": 21, "text": "in"}, {"id": 22, "text": "Title", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "VII", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "of"}, {"id": 25, "text": "the"}, {"id": 26, "text": "Civil", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "Rights", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "Act", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "1964", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 109, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "But"}, {"id": 1, "text": "a"}, {"id": 2, "text": "critical"}, {"id": 3, "text": "examination"}, {"id": 4, "text": "of"}, {"id": 5, "text": "Title", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "VII", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 8, "text": "history"}, {"id": 9, "text": "reveals"}, {"id": 10, "text": "more"}, {"id": 11, "text": "than"}, {"id": 12, "text": "a"}, {"id": 13, "text": "few"}, {"id": 14, "text": "reasons"}, {"id": 15, "text": "to"}, {"id": 16, "text": "be"}, {"id": 17, "text": "wary"}, {"id": 18, "text": "of"}, {"id": 19, "text": "any"}, {"id": 20, "text": "invitation"}, {"id": 21, "text": "to"}, {"id": 22, "text": "import"}, {"id": 23, "text": "its"}, {"id": 24, "text": "motivating", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "factor", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "test"}, {"id": 27, "text": "into"}, {"id": 28, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 110, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "This"}, {"id": 1, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 2, "text": "first"}, {"id": 3, "text": "adopted"}, {"id": 4, "text": "Title", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "VII", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 7, "text": "motivating", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "factor", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "test"}, {"id": 10, "text": "in"}, {"id": 11, "text": "Price", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "Waterhouse", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "Hopkins", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "490", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "228", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "109", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "1775", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "104", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "268", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "1989", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 111, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "There"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "a"}, {"id": 3, "text": "plurality"}, {"id": 4, "text": "and"}, {"id": 5, "text": "two"}, {"id": 6, "text": "Justices"}, {"id": 7, "text": "concurring"}, {"id": 8, "text": "in"}, {"id": 9, "text": "the"}, {"id": 10, "text": "judgment"}, {"id": 11, "text": "held"}, {"id": 12, "text": "that"}, {"id": 13, "text": "a"}, {"id": 14, "text": "Title"}, {"id": 15, "text": "VII"}, {"id": 16, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 17, "text": "does"}, {"id": 18, "text": "n't"}, {"id": 19, "text": "have"}, {"id": 20, "text": "to"}, {"id": 21, "text": "prove"}, {"id": 22, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "causation", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": ";"}, {"id": 27, "text": "instead"}, {"id": 28, "text": ","}, {"id": 29, "text": "it"}, {"id": 30, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 31, "text": "enough"}, {"id": 32, "text": "to"}, {"id": 33, "text": "show"}, {"id": 34, "text": "that"}, {"id": 35, "text": "discrimination"}, {"id": 36, "text": "was"}, {"id": 37, "text": "a"}, {"id": 38, "text": "motivating", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "factor", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "in"}, {"id": 41, "text": "the"}, {"id": 42, "text": "defendant"}, {"id": 43, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 44, "text": "decision"}, {"id": 45, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 112, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Id.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "249", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "250", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "109", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "1775", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "("}, {"id": 12, "text": "plurality"}, {"id": 13, "text": "opinion"}, {"id": 14, "text": ")"}, {"id": 15, "text": ";"}, {"id": 16, "text": "see"}, {"id": 17, "text": "also"}, {"id": 18, "text": "i", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "d.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "258", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "259", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "109", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "1775", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "("}, {"id": 31, "text": "White"}, {"id": 32, "text": ","}, {"id": 33, "text": "J."}, {"id": 34, "text": ","}, {"id": 35, "text": "concurring"}, {"id": 36, "text": "in"}, {"id": 37, "text": "judgment"}, {"id": 38, "text": ")"}, {"id": 39, "text": ";"}, {"id": 40, "text": "i", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": "d.", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": "268", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": "269", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 47, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 48, "text": "109", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 49, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 50, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 51, "text": "1775", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 52, "text": "("}, {"id": 53, "text": "O'Connor"}, {"id": 54, "text": ","}, {"id": 55, "text": "J."}, {"id": 56, "text": ","}, {"id": 57, "text": "concurring"}, {"id": 58, "text": "in"}, {"id": 59, "text": "judgment"}, {"id": 60, "text": ")"}, {"id": 61, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 113, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Once"}, {"id": 1, "text": "a"}, {"id": 2, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 3, "text": "meets"}, {"id": 4, "text": "this"}, {"id": 5, "text": "lesser"}, {"id": 6, "text": "standard"}, {"id": 7, "text": ","}, {"id": 8, "text": "the"}, {"id": 9, "text": "plurality"}, {"id": 10, "text": "continued"}, {"id": 11, "text": ","}, {"id": 12, "text": "the"}, {"id": 13, "text": "defendant"}, {"id": 14, "text": "may"}, {"id": 15, "text": "defeat"}, {"id": 16, "text": "liability"}, {"id": 17, "text": "by"}, {"id": 18, "text": "establishing"}, {"id": 19, "text": "that"}, {"id": 20, "text": "it"}, {"id": 21, "text": "would"}, {"id": 22, "text": "have"}, {"id": 23, "text": "made"}, {"id": 24, "text": "the"}, {"id": 25, "text": "same"}, {"id": 26, "text": "decision"}, {"id": 27, "text": "even"}, {"id": 28, "text": "if"}, {"id": 29, "text": "it"}, {"id": 30, "text": "had"}, {"id": 31, "text": "not"}, {"id": 32, "text": "taken"}, {"id": 33, "text": "the"}, {"id": 34, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 35, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 36, "text": "race"}, {"id": 37, "text": "("}, {"id": 38, "text": "or"}, {"id": 39, "text": "other"}, {"id": 40, "text": "protected"}, {"id": 41, "text": "trait"}, {"id": 42, "text": ")"}, {"id": 43, "text": "into"}, {"id": 44, "text": "account"}, {"id": 45, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 114, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "In"}, {"id": 1, "text": "essence"}, {"id": 2, "text": ","}, {"id": 3, "text": "Price"}, {"id": 4, "text": "Waterhouse"}, {"id": 5, "text": "took"}, {"id": 6, "text": "the"}, {"id": 7, "text": "burden"}, {"id": 8, "text": "of"}, {"id": 9, "text": "proving"}, {"id": 10, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "causation", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "from"}, {"id": 15, "text": "the"}, {"id": 16, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 17, "text": "and"}, {"id": 18, "text": "handed"}, {"id": 19, "text": "it"}, {"id": 20, "text": "to"}, {"id": 21, "text": "the"}, {"id": 22, "text": "defendant"}, {"id": 23, "text": "as"}, {"id": 24, "text": "an"}, {"id": 25, "text": "affirmative"}, {"id": 26, "text": "defense"}, {"id": 27, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 115, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Id.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "246", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "109", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "1775", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 116, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "But"}, {"id": 1, "text": "this"}, {"id": 2, "text": "arrangement"}, {"id": 3, "text": "did"}, {"id": 4, "text": "n't"}, {"id": 5, "text": "last"}, {"id": 6, "text": "long"}, {"id": 7, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 117, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Congress"}, {"id": 1, "text": "soon"}, {"id": 2, "text": "displaced"}, {"id": 3, "text": "Price"}, {"id": 4, "text": "Waterhouse"}, {"id": 5, "text": "in"}, {"id": 6, "text": "favor"}, {"id": 7, "text": "of"}, {"id": 8, "text": "its"}, {"id": 9, "text": "own"}, {"id": 10, "text": "version"}, {"id": 11, "text": "of"}, {"id": 12, "text": "the"}, {"id": 13, "text": "motivating", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "factor", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "test"}, {"id": 16, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 118, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "In"}, {"id": 1, "text": "the"}, {"id": 2, "text": "Civil", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "Rights", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "Act", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "1991", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": ","}, {"id": 8, "text": "Congress"}, {"id": 9, "text": "provided"}, {"id": 10, "text": "that"}, {"id": 11, "text": "a"}, {"id": 12, "text": "Title", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "VII", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 15, "text": "who"}, {"id": 16, "text": "shows"}, {"id": 17, "text": "that"}, {"id": 18, "text": "discrimination"}, {"id": 19, "text": "was"}, {"id": 20, "text": "even"}, {"id": 21, "text": "a"}, {"id": 22, "text": "motivating"}, {"id": 23, "text": "factor"}, {"id": 24, "text": "in"}, {"id": 25, "text": "the"}, {"id": 26, "text": "defendant"}, {"id": 27, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 28, "text": "challenged"}, {"id": 29, "text": "employment"}, {"id": 30, "text": "decision"}, {"id": 31, "text": "is"}, {"id": 32, "text": "entitled"}, {"id": 33, "text": "to"}, {"id": 34, "text": "declaratory"}, {"id": 35, "text": "and"}, {"id": 36, "text": "injunctive"}, {"id": 37, "text": "relief"}, {"id": 38, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 119, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "107", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "105", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "Stat", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "1075", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 120, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "A"}, {"id": 1, "text": "defendant"}, {"id": 2, "text": "may"}, {"id": 3, "text": "still"}, {"id": 4, "text": "invoke"}, {"id": 5, "text": "lack"}, {"id": 6, "text": "of"}, {"id": 7, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "causation", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "as"}, {"id": 12, "text": "an"}, {"id": 13, "text": "affirmative"}, {"id": 14, "text": "defense"}, {"id": 15, "text": ","}, {"id": 16, "text": "but"}, {"id": 17, "text": "only"}, {"id": 18, "text": "to"}, {"id": 19, "text": "stave"}, {"id": 20, "text": "off"}, {"id": 21, "text": "damages"}, {"id": 22, "text": "and"}, {"id": 23, "text": "reinstatement"}, {"id": 24, "text": ","}, {"id": 25, "text": "not"}, {"id": 26, "text": "liability"}, {"id": 27, "text": "in"}, {"id": 28, "text": "general"}, {"id": 29, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 121, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "42", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "U.S.C.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "2000e-2(m", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "2000e-5(g)(2)(B", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": ";"}, {"id": 10, "text": "see"}, {"id": 11, "text": "also"}, {"id": 12, "text": "Desert", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "Palace", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "Inc.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "Costa", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "539", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "90", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "94", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "95", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "123", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "2148", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "156", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "84", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "2003", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 122, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "While"}, {"id": 1, "text": "this"}, {"id": 2, "text": "is"}, {"id": 3, "text": "all"}, {"id": 4, "text": "well"}, {"id": 5, "text": "and"}, {"id": 6, "text": "good"}, {"id": 7, "text": "for"}, {"id": 8, "text": "understanding"}, {"id": 9, "text": "Title", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "VII", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": ","}, {"id": 12, "text": "it"}, {"id": 13, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 14, "text": "hard"}, {"id": 15, "text": "to"}, {"id": 16, "text": "see"}, {"id": 17, "text": "what"}, {"id": 18, "text": "any"}, {"id": 19, "text": "of"}, {"id": 20, "text": "it"}, {"id": 21, "text": "might"}, {"id": 22, "text": "tell"}, {"id": 23, "text": "us"}, {"id": 24, "text": "about"}, {"id": 25, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 123, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Title", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "VII", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "was"}, {"id": 3, "text": "enacted"}, {"id": 4, "text": "in"}, {"id": 5, "text": "1964"}, {"id": 6, "text": ";"}, {"id": 7, "text": "this"}, {"id": 8, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 9, "text": "recognized"}, {"id": 10, "text": "its"}, {"id": 11, "text": "motivating", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "factor", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "test"}, {"id": 14, "text": "in"}, {"id": 15, "text": "1989"}, {"id": 16, "text": ";"}, {"id": 17, "text": "and"}, {"id": 18, "text": "Congress"}, {"id": 19, "text": "replaced"}, {"id": 20, "text": "that"}, {"id": 21, "text": "rule"}, {"id": 22, "text": "with"}, {"id": 23, "text": "its"}, {"id": 24, "text": "own"}, {"id": 25, "text": "version"}, {"id": 26, "text": "two"}, {"id": 27, "text": "years"}, {"id": 28, "text": "later"}, {"id": 29, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 124, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Meanwhile"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "dates"}, {"id": 5, "text": "back"}, {"id": 6, "text": "to"}, {"id": 7, "text": "1866"}, {"id": 8, "text": "and"}, {"id": 9, "text": "has"}, {"id": 10, "text": "never"}, {"id": 11, "text": "said"}, {"id": 12, "text": "a"}, {"id": 13, "text": "word"}, {"id": 14, "text": "about"}, {"id": 15, "text": "motivating", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "factors", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 125, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "So"}, {"id": 1, "text": "we"}, {"id": 2, "text": "have"}, {"id": 3, "text": "two"}, {"id": 4, "text": "statutes"}, {"id": 5, "text": "with"}, {"id": 6, "text": "two"}, {"id": 7, "text": "distinct"}, {"id": 8, "text": "histories"}, {"id": 9, "text": ","}, {"id": 10, "text": "and"}, {"id": 11, "text": "not"}, {"id": 12, "text": "a"}, {"id": 13, "text": "shred"}, {"id": 14, "text": "of"}, {"id": 15, "text": "evidence"}, {"id": 16, "text": "that"}, {"id": 17, "text": "Congress"}, {"id": 18, "text": "meant", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "them"}, {"id": 20, "text": "to"}, {"id": 21, "text": "incorporate"}, {"id": 22, "text": "the"}, {"id": 23, "text": "same"}, {"id": 24, "text": "causation"}, {"id": 25, "text": "standard"}, {"id": 26, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 126, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Worse"}, {"id": 1, "text": "yet"}, {"id": 2, "text": ","}, {"id": 3, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 4, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 5, "text": "fallback"}, {"id": 6, "text": "position"}, {"id": 7, "text": "-"}, {"id": 8, "text": "that"}, {"id": 9, "text": "we"}, {"id": 10, "text": "should"}, {"id": 11, "text": "borrow"}, {"id": 12, "text": "the"}, {"id": 13, "text": "motivating", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "factor", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "concept"}, {"id": 16, "text": "only"}, {"id": 17, "text": "at"}, {"id": 18, "text": "the"}, {"id": 19, "text": "pleadings"}, {"id": 20, "text": "stage"}, {"id": 21, "text": "-"}, {"id": 22, "text": "is"}, {"id": 23, "text": "foreign"}, {"id": 24, "text": "even"}, {"id": 25, "text": "to"}, {"id": 26, "text": "Title", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "VII", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "practice"}, {"id": 29, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 127, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "To"}, {"id": 1, "text": "accept"}, {"id": 2, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 3, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 4, "text": "invitation"}, {"id": 5, "text": "to"}, {"id": 6, "text": "consult"}, {"id": 7, "text": ","}, {"id": 8, "text": "tinker"}, {"id": 9, "text": "with"}, {"id": 10, "text": ","}, {"id": 11, "text": "and"}, {"id": 12, "text": "then"}, {"id": 13, "text": "engraft"}, {"id": 14, "text": "a"}, {"id": 15, "text": "test"}, {"id": 16, "text": "from"}, {"id": 17, "text": "a"}, {"id": 18, "text": "modern"}, {"id": 19, "text": "statute"}, {"id": 20, "text": "onto"}, {"id": 21, "text": "an"}, {"id": 22, "text": "old"}, {"id": 23, "text": "one"}, {"id": 24, "text": "would"}, {"id": 25, "text": "thus"}, {"id": 26, "text": "require"}, {"id": 27, "text": "more"}, {"id": 28, "text": "than"}, {"id": 29, "text": "a"}, {"id": 30, "text": "little"}, {"id": 31, "text": "judicial"}, {"id": 32, "text": "adventurism"}, {"id": 33, "text": ","}, {"id": 34, "text": "and"}, {"id": 35, "text": "look"}, {"id": 36, "text": "a"}, {"id": 37, "text": "good"}, {"id": 38, "text": "deal"}, {"id": 39, "text": "more"}, {"id": 40, "text": "like"}, {"id": 41, "text": "amending"}, {"id": 42, "text": "a"}, {"id": 43, "text": "law"}, {"id": 44, "text": "than"}, {"id": 45, "text": "interpreting"}, {"id": 46, "text": "one"}, {"id": 47, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 128, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "What"}, {"id": 1, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 2, "text": "more"}, {"id": 3, "text": ","}, {"id": 4, "text": "it"}, {"id": 5, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 6, "text": "not"}, {"id": 7, "text": "as"}, {"id": 8, "text": "if"}, {"id": 9, "text": "Congress"}, {"id": 10, "text": "forgot"}, {"id": 11, "text": "about"}, {"id": 12, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "when"}, {"id": 15, "text": "it"}, {"id": 16, "text": "adopted"}, {"id": 17, "text": "the"}, {"id": 18, "text": "Civil", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "Rights", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "Act", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "1991", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 129, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "At"}, {"id": 1, "text": "the"}, {"id": 2, "text": "same"}, {"id": 3, "text": "time"}, {"id": 4, "text": "that"}, {"id": 5, "text": "it"}, {"id": 6, "text": "added"}, {"id": 7, "text": "the"}, {"id": 8, "text": "motivating"}, {"id": 9, "text": "factor"}, {"id": 10, "text": "test"}, {"id": 11, "text": "to"}, {"id": 12, "text": "Title", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "VII", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": ","}, {"id": 15, "text": "Congress"}, {"id": 16, "text": "also"}, {"id": 17, "text": "amended"}, {"id": 18, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 130, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "See"}, {"id": 1, "text": "Civil", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "Rights", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "Act", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "1991", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "101", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "105", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "Stat", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "1072", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "("}, {"id": 15, "text": "adding"}, {"id": 16, "text": "new"}, {"id": 17, "text": "subsections", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "b", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "c", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "to"}, {"id": 26, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": ")"}, {"id": 29, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 131, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "But"}, {"id": 1, "text": "nowhere"}, {"id": 2, "text": "in"}, {"id": 3, "text": "its"}, {"id": 4, "text": "amendments"}, {"id": 5, "text": "to"}, {"id": 6, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "did"}, {"id": 9, "text": "Congress"}, {"id": 10, "text": "so"}, {"id": 11, "text": "much"}, {"id": 12, "text": "as"}, {"id": 13, "text": "whisper"}, {"id": 14, "text": "about"}, {"id": 15, "text": "motivating", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "factors", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 132, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "And", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "where", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "as", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "here", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "Congress", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "has", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "simultaneously", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "chosen", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "amend", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "one", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "statute", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "in", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "one", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "way", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "a", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "second", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "statute", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "in", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "another", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "way", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "we", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "normally", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "assume", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "differences", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "in", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "language", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "imply", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "differences", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "in", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "meaning", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}]}, {"id": 133, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Gross", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "557", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "174", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "175", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "129", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "2343", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": ";"}, {"id": 14, "text": "see"}, {"id": 15, "text": "also"}, {"id": 16, "text": "Russello", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "United", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "States", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "464", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "16", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "23", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "104", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "296", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "78", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "17", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "1983", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 134, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Still"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 3, "text": "tries"}, {"id": 4, "text": "to"}, {"id": 5, "text": "salvage"}, {"id": 6, "text": "something"}, {"id": 7, "text": "from"}, {"id": 8, "text": "the"}, {"id": 9, "text": "1991"}, {"id": 10, "text": "law"}, {"id": 11, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 135, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "It"}, {"id": 1, "text": "reminds"}, {"id": 2, "text": "us"}, {"id": 3, "text": "that"}, {"id": 4, "text": "one"}, {"id": 5, "text": "of"}, {"id": 6, "text": "the"}, {"id": 7, "text": "amendments"}, {"id": 8, "text": "to"}, {"id": 9, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "defined", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "the"}, {"id": 13, "text": "term", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "make", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "enforce", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "contracts", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "include", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "making", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "performance", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "modification", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "termination", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "contracts", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "enjoyment", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "all", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "benefits", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": "privileges", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "terms", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": "conditions", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 47, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 48, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 49, "text": "contractual", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 50, "text": "relationship", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 51, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 52, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 136, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "42", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "U.S.C.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "b", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 137, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "In"}, {"id": 1, "text": "all"}, {"id": 2, "text": "this"}, {"id": 3, "text": ","}, {"id": 4, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 5, "text": "asks"}, {"id": 6, "text": "us"}, {"id": 7, "text": "to"}, {"id": 8, "text": "home"}, {"id": 9, "text": "in"}, {"id": 10, "text": "on"}, {"id": 11, "text": "one"}, {"id": 12, "text": "word", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": ","}, {"id": 14, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "making", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 138, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "By"}, {"id": 1, "text": "using"}, {"id": 2, "text": "this"}, {"id": 3, "text": "particular"}, {"id": 4, "text": "word", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": ","}, {"id": 6, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 7, "text": "says"}, {"id": 8, "text": ","}, {"id": 9, "text": "Congress"}, {"id": 10, "text": "clarified"}, {"id": 11, "text": "that"}, {"id": 12, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "1981(a", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "guarantees"}, {"id": 16, "text": "not"}, {"id": 17, "text": "only"}, {"id": 18, "text": "the"}, {"id": 19, "text": "right"}, {"id": 20, "text": "to"}, {"id": 21, "text": "equivalent"}, {"id": 22, "text": "contractual"}, {"id": 23, "text": "outcomes"}, {"id": 24, "text": "("}, {"id": 25, "text": "a"}, {"id": 26, "text": "contract"}, {"id": 27, "text": "with"}, {"id": 28, "text": "the"}, {"id": 29, "text": "same"}, {"id": 30, "text": "final"}, {"id": 31, "text": "terms"}, {"id": 32, "text": ")"}, {"id": 33, "text": ","}, {"id": 34, "text": "but"}, {"id": 35, "text": "also"}, {"id": 36, "text": "the"}, {"id": 37, "text": "right"}, {"id": 38, "text": "to"}, {"id": 39, "text": "an"}, {"id": 40, "text": "equivalent"}, {"id": 41, "text": "contracting"}, {"id": 42, "text": "process"}, {"id": 43, "text": "("}, {"id": 44, "text": "no"}, {"id": 45, "text": "extra"}, {"id": 46, "text": "hurdles"}, {"id": 47, "text": "on"}, {"id": 48, "text": "the"}, {"id": 49, "text": "road"}, {"id": 50, "text": "to"}, {"id": 51, "text": "securing"}, {"id": 52, "text": "that"}, {"id": 53, "text": "contract"}, {"id": 54, "text": ")"}, {"id": 55, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 139, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "And"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 3, "text": "continues"}, {"id": 4, "text": ","}, {"id": 5, "text": "if"}, {"id": 6, "text": "the"}, {"id": 7, "text": "statute", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "addresses"}, {"id": 9, "text": "the"}, {"id": 10, "text": "whole"}, {"id": 11, "text": "contracting"}, {"id": 12, "text": "process"}, {"id": 13, "text": ","}, {"id": 14, "text": "not"}, {"id": 15, "text": "just"}, {"id": 16, "text": "its"}, {"id": 17, "text": "outcome"}, {"id": 18, "text": ","}, {"id": 19, "text": "a"}, {"id": 20, "text": "motivating", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "factor", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "causation"}, {"id": 23, "text": "test"}, {"id": 24, "text": "fits"}, {"id": 25, "text": "more"}, {"id": 26, "text": "logically"}, {"id": 27, "text": "than"}, {"id": 28, "text": "the"}, {"id": 29, "text": "traditional"}, {"id": 30, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "test"}, {"id": 34, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 140, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 1, "text": "and"}, {"id": 2, "text": "the"}, {"id": 3, "text": "government"}, {"id": 4, "text": "disagree"}, {"id": 5, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 141, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "As"}, {"id": 1, "text": "they"}, {"id": 2, "text": "see"}, {"id": 3, "text": "it"}, {"id": 4, "text": ","}, {"id": 5, "text": "the"}, {"id": 6, "text": "Civil", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "Rights", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "Act", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "1866", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "unambiguously", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "protected"}, {"id": 13, "text": "only"}, {"id": 14, "text": "outcomes"}, {"id": 15, "text": "-"}, {"id": 16, "text": "the"}, {"id": 17, "text": "right"}, {"id": 18, "text": "to"}, {"id": 19, "text": "contract"}, {"id": 20, "text": ","}, {"id": 21, "text": "sue"}, {"id": 22, "text": ","}, {"id": 23, "text": "be"}, {"id": 24, "text": "a"}, {"id": 25, "text": "party"}, {"id": 26, "text": ","}, {"id": 27, "text": "and"}, {"id": 28, "text": "give"}, {"id": 29, "text": "evidence"}, {"id": 30, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 142, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "When"}, {"id": 1, "text": "Congress"}, {"id": 2, "text": "sought"}, {"id": 3, "text": "to"}, {"id": 4, "text": "define", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "some"}, {"id": 6, "text": "of"}, {"id": 7, "text": "these"}, {"id": 8, "text": "terms", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "in"}, {"id": 10, "text": "1991"}, {"id": 11, "text": ","}, {"id": 12, "text": "it"}, {"id": 13, "text": "merely"}, {"id": 14, "text": "repeated"}, {"id": 15, "text": "one"}, {"id": 16, "text": "word", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "from"}, {"id": 18, "text": "the"}, {"id": 19, "text": "original"}, {"id": 20, "text": "1866"}, {"id": 21, "text": "Act"}, {"id": 22, "text": "("}, {"id": 23, "text": "make"}, {"id": 24, "text": ")"}, {"id": 25, "text": "in"}, {"id": 26, "text": "a"}, {"id": 27, "text": "different"}, {"id": 28, "text": "form"}, {"id": 29, "text": "("}, {"id": 30, "text": "making"}, {"id": 31, "text": ")"}, {"id": 32, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 143, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "No", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "reasonable", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "reader", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "Comcast", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "government", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "contend", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "would", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "think", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "that", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "addition", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "present", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "participle", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "form", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "a", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "verb", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "already", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "in", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "statute", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "carries", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "such", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "a", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "radically", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "different", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "meaning", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "so", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "extends", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "liability", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "in", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": "new", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": "directions", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "ESN", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": "suggests", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}]}, {"id": 144, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "And"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "we"}, {"id": 3, "text": "are"}, {"id": 4, "text": "told"}, {"id": 5, "text": ","}, {"id": 6, "text": "the"}, {"id": 7, "text": "statute"}, {"id": 8, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 9, "text": "original"}, {"id": 10, "text": "and"}, {"id": 11, "text": "continuing"}, {"id": 12, "text": "focus"}, {"id": 13, "text": "on"}, {"id": 14, "text": "contractual"}, {"id": 15, "text": "outcomes"}, {"id": 16, "text": "("}, {"id": 17, "text": "not"}, {"id": 18, "text": "processes"}, {"id": 19, "text": ")"}, {"id": 20, "text": "is"}, {"id": 21, "text": "more"}, {"id": 22, "text": "consistent"}, {"id": 23, "text": "with"}, {"id": 24, "text": "the"}, {"id": 25, "text": "traditional"}, {"id": 26, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "test"}, {"id": 30, "text": "of"}, {"id": 31, "text": "causation"}, {"id": 32, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 145, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "This"}, {"id": 1, "text": "debate"}, {"id": 2, "text": ","}, {"id": 3, "text": "we"}, {"id": 4, "text": "think"}, {"id": 5, "text": ","}, {"id": 6, "text": "misses"}, {"id": 7, "text": "the"}, {"id": 8, "text": "point"}, {"id": 9, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 146, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Of"}, {"id": 1, "text": "course"}, {"id": 2, "text": ","}, {"id": 3, "text": "Congress"}, {"id": 4, "text": "could"}, {"id": 5, "text": "write"}, {"id": 6, "text": "an"}, {"id": 7, "text": "employment"}, {"id": 8, "text": "discrimination"}, {"id": 9, "text": "statute"}, {"id": 10, "text": "to"}, {"id": 11, "text": "protect"}, {"id": 12, "text": "only"}, {"id": 13, "text": "outcomes"}, {"id": 14, "text": "or"}, {"id": 15, "text": "to"}, {"id": 16, "text": "provide"}, {"id": 17, "text": "broader"}, {"id": 18, "text": "protection"}, {"id": 19, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 147, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "But"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "for"}, {"id": 3, "text": "our"}, {"id": 4, "text": "purposes"}, {"id": 5, "text": "today"}, {"id": 6, "text": ","}, {"id": 7, "text": "none"}, {"id": 8, "text": "of"}, {"id": 9, "text": "this"}, {"id": 10, "text": "matters"}, {"id": 11, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 148, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "The"}, {"id": 1, "text": "difficulty"}, {"id": 2, "text": "with"}, {"id": 3, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 4, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 5, "text": "argument"}, {"id": 6, "text": "lies"}, {"id": 7, "text": "in"}, {"id": 8, "text": "its"}, {"id": 9, "text": "mistaken"}, {"id": 10, "text": "premise"}, {"id": 11, "text": "that"}, {"id": 12, "text": "a"}, {"id": 13, "text": "process"}, {"id": 14, "text": "-"}, {"id": 15, "text": "oriented"}, {"id": 16, "text": "right"}, {"id": 17, "text": "necessarily"}, {"id": 18, "text": "pairs"}, {"id": 19, "text": "with"}, {"id": 20, "text": "a"}, {"id": 21, "text": "motivating", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "factor", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "causal"}, {"id": 24, "text": "standard"}, {"id": 25, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 149, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "The"}, {"id": 1, "text": "inverse"}, {"id": 2, "text": "argument"}, {"id": 3, "text": "-"}, {"id": 4, "text": "that"}, {"id": 5, "text": "an"}, {"id": 6, "text": "outcome"}, {"id": 7, "text": "-"}, {"id": 8, "text": "oriented"}, {"id": 9, "text": "right"}, {"id": 10, "text": "implies"}, {"id": 11, "text": "a"}, {"id": 12, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "causation"}, {"id": 16, "text": "standard"}, {"id": 17, "text": "-"}, {"id": 18, "text": "is"}, {"id": 19, "text": "just"}, {"id": 20, "text": "as"}, {"id": 21, "text": "flawed"}, {"id": 22, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 150, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Either"}, {"id": 1, "text": "causal"}, {"id": 2, "text": "standard"}, {"id": 3, "text": "could"}, {"id": 4, "text": "conceivably"}, {"id": 5, "text": "apply"}, {"id": 6, "text": "regardless"}, {"id": 7, "text": "of"}, {"id": 8, "text": "the"}, {"id": 9, "text": "legal"}, {"id": 10, "text": "right"}, {"id": 11, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "protects"}, {"id": 14, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 151, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "We"}, {"id": 1, "text": "need"}, {"id": 2, "text": "not"}, {"id": 3, "text": "and"}, {"id": 4, "text": "do"}, {"id": 5, "text": "not"}, {"id": 6, "text": "take"}, {"id": 7, "text": "any"}, {"id": 8, "text": "position"}, {"id": 9, "text": "on"}, {"id": 10, "text": "whether"}, {"id": 11, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "as"}, {"id": 14, "text": "amended"}, {"id": 15, "text": "protects"}, {"id": 16, "text": "only"}, {"id": 17, "text": "outcomes"}, {"id": 18, "text": "or"}, {"id": 19, "text": "protects"}, {"id": 20, "text": "processes"}, {"id": 21, "text": "too"}, {"id": 22, "text": ","}, {"id": 23, "text": "a"}, {"id": 24, "text": "question"}, {"id": 25, "text": "not"}, {"id": 26, "text": "passed"}, {"id": 27, "text": "on"}, {"id": 28, "text": "below"}, {"id": 29, "text": "or"}, {"id": 30, "text": "raised"}, {"id": 31, "text": "in"}, {"id": 32, "text": "the"}, {"id": 33, "text": "petition"}, {"id": 34, "text": "for"}, {"id": 35, "text": "certiorari"}, {"id": 36, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 152, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Our"}, {"id": 1, "text": "point"}, {"id": 2, "text": "is"}, {"id": 3, "text": "simply"}, {"id": 4, "text": "that"}, {"id": 5, "text": "a"}, {"id": 6, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 9, "text": "first"}, {"id": 10, "text": "must"}, {"id": 11, "text": "show"}, {"id": 12, "text": "that"}, {"id": 13, "text": "he"}, {"id": 14, "text": "was"}, {"id": 15, "text": "deprived"}, {"id": 16, "text": "of"}, {"id": 17, "text": "the"}, {"id": 18, "text": "protected"}, {"id": 19, "text": "right"}, {"id": 20, "text": "and"}, {"id": 21, "text": "then"}, {"id": 22, "text": "establish"}, {"id": 23, "text": "causation"}, {"id": 24, "text": "-"}, {"id": 25, "text": "and"}, {"id": 26, "text": "that"}, {"id": 27, "text": "these"}, {"id": 28, "text": "two"}, {"id": 29, "text": "steps"}, {"id": 30, "text": "are"}, {"id": 31, "text": "analytically"}, {"id": 32, "text": "distinct"}, {"id": 33, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 153, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Unable"}, {"id": 1, "text": "to"}, {"id": 2, "text": "latch"}, {"id": 3, "text": "onto"}, {"id": 4, "text": "either"}, {"id": 5, "text": "Price"}, {"id": 6, "text": "Waterhouse"}, {"id": 7, "text": "or"}, {"id": 8, "text": "the"}, {"id": 9, "text": "Civil", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "Rights", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "Act", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "1991", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": ","}, {"id": 15, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 16, "text": "is"}, {"id": 17, "text": "left"}, {"id": 18, "text": "to"}, {"id": 19, "text": "cast"}, {"id": 20, "text": "about"}, {"id": 21, "text": "for"}, {"id": 22, "text": "some"}, {"id": 23, "text": "other"}, {"id": 24, "text": "hook"}, {"id": 25, "text": "to"}, {"id": 26, "text": "support"}, {"id": 27, "text": "its"}, {"id": 28, "text": "arguments"}, {"id": 29, "text": "about"}, {"id": 30, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 33, "text": "operation"}, {"id": 34, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 154, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "In"}, {"id": 1, "text": "a"}, {"id": 2, "text": "final"}, {"id": 3, "text": "effort"}, {"id": 4, "text": ","}, {"id": 5, "text": "it"}, {"id": 6, "text": "asks"}, {"id": 7, "text": "us"}, {"id": 8, "text": "to"}, {"id": 9, "text": "consider"}, {"id": 10, "text": "the"}, {"id": 11, "text": "burden"}, {"id": 12, "text": "-"}, {"id": 13, "text": "shifting"}, {"id": 14, "text": "framework"}, {"id": 15, "text": "of"}, {"id": 16, "text": "McDonnell", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "Douglas", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "Corp.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "Green", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "411", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "792", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "802", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "804", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "93", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "1817", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "36", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "668", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "1973", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 155, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Like"}, {"id": 1, "text": "the"}, {"id": 2, "text": "motivating", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "factor", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "test"}, {"id": 5, "text": ","}, {"id": 6, "text": "McDonnell"}, {"id": 7, "text": "Douglas"}, {"id": 8, "text": "is"}, {"id": 9, "text": "a"}, {"id": 10, "text": "product"}, {"id": 11, "text": "of"}, {"id": 12, "text": "Title", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "VII", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "practice"}, {"id": 15, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 156, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Under"}, {"id": 1, "text": "its"}, {"id": 2, "text": "terms"}, {"id": 3, "text": ","}, {"id": 4, "text": "once"}, {"id": 5, "text": "a"}, {"id": 6, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 7, "text": "establishes"}, {"id": 8, "text": "a"}, {"id": 9, "text": "prima"}, {"id": 10, "text": "facie"}, {"id": 11, "text": "case"}, {"id": 12, "text": "of"}, {"id": 13, "text": "race"}, {"id": 14, "text": "discrimination"}, {"id": 15, "text": "through"}, {"id": 16, "text": "indirect"}, {"id": 17, "text": "proof"}, {"id": 18, "text": ","}, {"id": 19, "text": "the"}, {"id": 20, "text": "defendant"}, {"id": 21, "text": "bears"}, {"id": 22, "text": "the"}, {"id": 23, "text": "burden"}, {"id": 24, "text": "of"}, {"id": 25, "text": "producing"}, {"id": 26, "text": "a"}, {"id": 27, "text": "race"}, {"id": 28, "text": "-"}, {"id": 29, "text": "neutral"}, {"id": 30, "text": "explanation"}, {"id": 31, "text": "for"}, {"id": 32, "text": "its"}, {"id": 33, "text": "action"}, {"id": 34, "text": ","}, {"id": 35, "text": "after"}, {"id": 36, "text": "which"}, {"id": 37, "text": "the"}, {"id": 38, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 39, "text": "may"}, {"id": 40, "text": "challenge"}, {"id": 41, "text": "that"}, {"id": 42, "text": "explanation"}, {"id": 43, "text": "as"}, {"id": 44, "text": "pretextual"}, {"id": 45, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 157, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Texas", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "Dept", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "Community", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "Affairs", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "Burdine", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "450", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "248", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "257", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "258", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "101", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "1089", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "67", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "207", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 158, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "This"}, {"id": 1, "text": "burden"}, {"id": 2, "text": "shifting"}, {"id": 3, "text": ","}, {"id": 4, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 5, "text": "contends"}, {"id": 6, "text": ","}, {"id": 7, "text": "is"}, {"id": 8, "text": "comparable"}, {"id": 9, "text": "to"}, {"id": 10, "text": "the"}, {"id": 11, "text": "regime"}, {"id": 12, "text": "it"}, {"id": 13, "text": "proposes"}, {"id": 14, "text": "for"}, {"id": 15, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 159, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "It"}, {"id": 1, "text": "is"}, {"id": 2, "text": "nothing"}, {"id": 3, "text": "of"}, {"id": 4, "text": "the"}, {"id": 5, "text": "kind"}, {"id": 6, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 160, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Whether"}, {"id": 1, "text": "or"}, {"id": 2, "text": "not"}, {"id": 3, "text": "McDonnell"}, {"id": 4, "text": "Douglas"}, {"id": 5, "text": "has"}, {"id": 6, "text": "some"}, {"id": 7, "text": "useful"}, {"id": 8, "text": "role"}, {"id": 9, "text": "to"}, {"id": 10, "text": "play"}, {"id": 11, "text": "in"}, {"id": 12, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "cases"}, {"id": 15, "text": ","}, {"id": 16, "text": "it"}, {"id": 17, "text": "does"}, {"id": 18, "text": "not"}, {"id": 19, "text": "mention"}, {"id": 20, "text": "the"}, {"id": 21, "text": "motivating"}, {"id": 22, "text": "factor"}, {"id": 23, "text": "test"}, {"id": 24, "text": ","}, {"id": 25, "text": "let"}, {"id": 26, "text": "alone"}, {"id": 27, "text": "endorse"}, {"id": 28, "text": "its"}, {"id": 29, "text": "use"}, {"id": 30, "text": "only"}, {"id": 31, "text": "at"}, {"id": 32, "text": "the"}, {"id": 33, "text": "pleadings"}, {"id": 34, "text": "stage"}, {"id": 35, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 161, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Nor"}, {"id": 1, "text": "can"}, {"id": 2, "text": "this"}, {"id": 3, "text": "come"}, {"id": 4, "text": "as"}, {"id": 5, "text": "a"}, {"id": 6, "text": "surprise"}, {"id": 7, "text": ":"}, {"id": 8, "text": "This"}, {"id": 9, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 10, "text": "did"}, {"id": 11, "text": "n't"}, {"id": 12, "text": "introduce"}, {"id": 13, "text": "the"}, {"id": 14, "text": "motivating", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "factor", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "test"}, {"id": 17, "text": "into"}, {"id": 18, "text": "Title", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "VII", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "practice"}, {"id": 21, "text": "until"}, {"id": 22, "text": "years"}, {"id": 23, "text": "after"}, {"id": 24, "text": "McDonnell"}, {"id": 25, "text": "Douglas"}, {"id": 26, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 162, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "For"}, {"id": 1, "text": "its"}, {"id": 2, "text": "part"}, {"id": 3, "text": ","}, {"id": 4, "text": "McDonnell"}, {"id": 5, "text": "Douglas"}, {"id": 6, "text": "sought"}, {"id": 7, "text": "only"}, {"id": 8, "text": "to"}, {"id": 9, "text": "supply"}, {"id": 10, "text": "a"}, {"id": 11, "text": "tool"}, {"id": 12, "text": "for"}, {"id": 13, "text": "assessing"}, {"id": 14, "text": "claims"}, {"id": 15, "text": ","}, {"id": 16, "text": "typically"}, {"id": 17, "text": "at"}, {"id": 18, "text": "summary"}, {"id": 19, "text": "judgment"}, {"id": 20, "text": ","}, {"id": 21, "text": "when"}, {"id": 22, "text": "the"}, {"id": 23, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 24, "text": "relies"}, {"id": 25, "text": "on"}, {"id": 26, "text": "indirect"}, {"id": 27, "text": "proof"}, {"id": 28, "text": "of"}, {"id": 29, "text": "discrimination"}, {"id": 30, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 163, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "See"}, {"id": 1, "text": "411", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "802", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "805", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "93", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "1817", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": ";"}, {"id": 13, "text": "see"}, {"id": 14, "text": "also"}, {"id": 15, "text": "Furnco", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "Constr", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "Corp.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "Waters", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "438", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "567", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "577", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "98", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "2943", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "57", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "957", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "1978", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": ";"}, {"id": 40, "text": "Malamud", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": "The", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "Last", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": "Minuet", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": ":", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": "Disparate", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 47, "text": "Treatment", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 48, "text": "After", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 49, "text": "Hicks", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 50, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 51, "text": "93", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 52, "text": "Mich.", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 53, "text": "L.", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 54, "text": "Rev.", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 55, "text": "2229", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 56, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 57, "text": "2259", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 58, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 59, "text": "1995", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 60, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 61, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 164, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Because"}, {"id": 1, "text": "McDonnell"}, {"id": 2, "text": "Douglas"}, {"id": 3, "text": "arose"}, {"id": 4, "text": "in"}, {"id": 5, "text": "a"}, {"id": 6, "text": "context"}, {"id": 7, "text": "where"}, {"id": 8, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "causation", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "was"}, {"id": 13, "text": "the"}, {"id": 14, "text": "undisputed"}, {"id": 15, "text": "test"}, {"id": 16, "text": ","}, {"id": 17, "text": "it"}, {"id": 18, "text": "did"}, {"id": 19, "text": "not"}, {"id": 20, "text": "address"}, {"id": 21, "text": "causation"}, {"id": 22, "text": "standards"}, {"id": 23, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 165, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "So"}, {"id": 1, "text": "nothing"}, {"id": 2, "text": "in"}, {"id": 3, "text": "the"}, {"id": 4, "text": "opinion"}, {"id": 5, "text": "involves"}, {"id": 6, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 7, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 8, "text": "preferred"}, {"id": 9, "text": "standard"}, {"id": 10, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 166, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Under"}, {"id": 1, "text": "McDonnell"}, {"id": 2, "text": "Douglas"}, {"id": 3, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 4, "text": "terms"}, {"id": 5, "text": ","}, {"id": 6, "text": "too"}, {"id": 7, "text": ","}, {"id": 8, "text": "only"}, {"id": 9, "text": "the"}, {"id": 10, "text": "burden"}, {"id": 11, "text": "of"}, {"id": 12, "text": "production"}, {"id": 13, "text": "ever"}, {"id": 14, "text": "shifts"}, {"id": 15, "text": "to"}, {"id": 16, "text": "the"}, {"id": 17, "text": "defendant"}, {"id": 18, "text": ","}, {"id": 19, "text": "never"}, {"id": 20, "text": "the"}, {"id": 21, "text": "burden"}, {"id": 22, "text": "of"}, {"id": 23, "text": "persuasion"}, {"id": 24, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 167, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "See"}, {"id": 1, "text": "Burdine"}, {"id": 2, "text": ","}, {"id": 3, "text": "450", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "254", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "255", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "101", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "1089", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": ";", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "Postal", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "Service", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "Bd", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "Governors", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "Aikens", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "460", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "711", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "715", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "716", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "103", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "1478", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "75", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "403", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": "1983", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 168, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "So"}, {"id": 1, "text": "McDonnell"}, {"id": 2, "text": "Douglas"}, {"id": 3, "text": "can"}, {"id": 4, "text": "provide"}, {"id": 5, "text": "no"}, {"id": 6, "text": "basis"}, {"id": 7, "text": "for"}, {"id": 8, "text": "allowing"}, {"id": 9, "text": "a"}, {"id": 10, "text": "complaint"}, {"id": 11, "text": "to"}, {"id": 12, "text": "survive"}, {"id": 13, "text": "a"}, {"id": 14, "text": "motion"}, {"id": 15, "text": "to"}, {"id": 16, "text": "dismiss"}, {"id": 17, "text": "when"}, {"id": 18, "text": "it"}, {"id": 19, "text": "fails"}, {"id": 20, "text": "to"}, {"id": 21, "text": "allege"}, {"id": 22, "text": "essential"}, {"id": 23, "text": "elements"}, {"id": 24, "text": "of"}, {"id": 25, "text": "a"}, {"id": 26, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 27, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 28, "text": "claim"}, {"id": 29, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 169, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "III"}]}, {"id": 170, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "All"}, {"id": 1, "text": "the"}, {"id": 2, "text": "traditional"}, {"id": 3, "text": "tools"}, {"id": 4, "text": "of"}, {"id": 5, "text": "statutory"}, {"id": 6, "text": "interpretation"}, {"id": 7, "text": "persuade"}, {"id": 8, "text": "us"}, {"id": 9, "text": "that"}, {"id": 10, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "follows"}, {"id": 13, "text": "the"}, {"id": 14, "text": "usual"}, {"id": 15, "text": "rules"}, {"id": 16, "text": ","}, {"id": 17, "text": "not"}, {"id": 18, "text": "any"}, {"id": 19, "text": "exception"}, {"id": 20, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 171, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "To"}, {"id": 1, "text": "prevail"}, {"id": 2, "text": ","}, {"id": 3, "text": "a"}, {"id": 4, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 5, "text": "must"}, {"id": 6, "text": "initially"}, {"id": 7, "text": "plead"}, {"id": 8, "text": "and"}, {"id": 9, "text": "ultimately"}, {"id": 10, "text": "prove"}, {"id": 11, "text": "that"}, {"id": 12, "text": ","}, {"id": 13, "text": "but"}, {"id": 14, "text": "for"}, {"id": 15, "text": "race"}, {"id": 16, "text": ","}, {"id": 17, "text": "it"}, {"id": 18, "text": "would"}, {"id": 19, "text": "not"}, {"id": 20, "text": "have"}, {"id": 21, "text": "suffered"}, {"id": 22, "text": "the"}, {"id": 23, "text": "loss"}, {"id": 24, "text": "of"}, {"id": 25, "text": "a"}, {"id": 26, "text": "legally"}, {"id": 27, "text": "protected"}, {"id": 28, "text": "right"}, {"id": 29, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 172, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "We"}, {"id": 1, "text": "do"}, {"id": 2, "text": "not"}, {"id": 3, "text": ","}, {"id": 4, "text": "however"}, {"id": 5, "text": ","}, {"id": 6, "text": "pass"}, {"id": 7, "text": "on"}, {"id": 8, "text": "whether"}, {"id": 9, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 10, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 11, "text": "operative"}, {"id": 12, "text": "amended"}, {"id": 13, "text": "complaint"}, {"id": 14, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "contain[s", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "]", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "sufficient", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "factual", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "matter", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "accepted", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "as", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "true", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "'", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "state", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "a", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "claim", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "relief", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "that", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "is", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "plausible", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "on", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "its", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "face", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "'", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "under"}, {"id": 41, "text": "the"}, {"id": 42, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 44, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 45, "text": "causation", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 46, "text": "standard"}, {"id": 47, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 173, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Iqbal", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "556", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "678", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "679", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "129", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "1937", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 174, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "The"}, {"id": 1, "text": "Ninth"}, {"id": 2, "text": "Circuit"}, {"id": 3, "text": "has"}, {"id": 4, "text": "yet"}, {"id": 5, "text": "to"}, {"id": 6, "text": "consider"}, {"id": 7, "text": "that"}, {"id": 8, "text": "question"}, {"id": 9, "text": "because"}, {"id": 10, "text": "it"}, {"id": 11, "text": "assessed"}, {"id": 12, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 13, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 14, "text": "pleadings"}, {"id": 15, "text": "under"}, {"id": 16, "text": "a"}, {"id": 17, "text": "different"}, {"id": 18, "text": "and"}, {"id": 19, "text": "mistaken"}, {"id": 20, "text": "test"}, {"id": 21, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 175, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "To"}, {"id": 1, "text": "allow"}, {"id": 2, "text": "that"}, {"id": 3, "text": "court"}, {"id": 4, "text": "the"}, {"id": 5, "text": "chance"}, {"id": 6, "text": "to"}, {"id": 7, "text": "determine"}, {"id": 8, "text": "the"}, {"id": 9, "text": "sufficiency"}, {"id": 10, "text": "of"}, {"id": 11, "text": "ESN"}, {"id": 12, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 13, "text": "pleadings"}, {"id": 14, "text": "under"}, {"id": 15, "text": "the"}, {"id": 16, "text": "correct"}, {"id": 17, "text": "legal"}, {"id": 18, "text": "rule"}, {"id": 19, "text": "in"}, {"id": 20, "text": "the"}, {"id": 21, "text": "first"}, {"id": 22, "text": "instance"}, {"id": 23, "text": ","}, {"id": 24, "text": "we"}, {"id": 25, "text": "vacate"}, {"id": 26, "text": "the"}, {"id": 27, "text": "judgment"}, {"id": 28, "text": "of"}, {"id": 29, "text": "the"}, {"id": 30, "text": "court"}, {"id": 31, "text": "of"}, {"id": 32, "text": "appeals"}, {"id": 33, "text": "and"}, {"id": 34, "text": "remand"}, {"id": 35, "text": "the"}, {"id": 36, "text": "case"}, {"id": 37, "text": "for"}, {"id": 38, "text": "further"}, {"id": 39, "text": "proceedings"}, {"id": 40, "text": "consistent"}, {"id": 41, "text": "with"}, {"id": 42, "text": "this"}, {"id": 43, "text": "opinion"}, {"id": 44, "text": "."}]}]}, {"name": "12624925_01.tsv", "sentences": [{"id": 0, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Justice"}, {"id": 1, "text": "GINSBURG"}, {"id": 2, "text": ","}, {"id": 3, "text": "concurring"}, {"id": 4, "text": "in"}, {"id": 5, "text": "part"}, {"id": 6, "text": "and"}, {"id": 7, "text": "concurring"}, {"id": 8, "text": "in"}, {"id": 9, "text": "the"}, {"id": 10, "text": "judgment"}, {"id": 11, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 1, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "I"}, {"id": 1, "text": "join"}, {"id": 2, "text": "the"}, {"id": 3, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 4, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 5, "text": "opinion"}, {"id": 6, "text": "requiring"}, {"id": 7, "text": "a"}, {"id": 8, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 9, "text": "who"}, {"id": 10, "text": "sues"}, {"id": 11, "text": "under"}, {"id": 12, "text": "42", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "U.S.C.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "to"}, {"id": 17, "text": "plead"}, {"id": 18, "text": "and"}, {"id": 19, "text": "prove"}, {"id": 20, "text": "race"}, {"id": 21, "text": "was"}, {"id": 22, "text": "a"}, {"id": 23, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "cause", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "of"}, {"id": 28, "text": "her"}, {"id": 29, "text": "injury"}, {"id": 30, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 2, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "In"}, {"id": 1, "text": "support"}, {"id": 2, "text": "of"}, {"id": 3, "text": "that"}, {"id": 4, "text": "holding"}, {"id": 5, "text": ","}, {"id": 6, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 7, "text": "advances"}, {"id": 8, "text": "a"}, {"id": 9, "text": "narrow"}, {"id": 10, "text": "view"}, {"id": 11, "text": "of"}, {"id": 12, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 15, "text": "scope"}, {"id": 16, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 3, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Section", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 3, "text": "guarantee"}, {"id": 4, "text": "of"}, {"id": 5, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "same", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "right", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "make", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "contracts", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 17, "text": "urges"}, {"id": 18, "text": ","}, {"id": 19, "text": "covers"}, {"id": 20, "text": "only"}, {"id": 21, "text": "the"}, {"id": 22, "text": "final"}, {"id": 23, "text": "decision"}, {"id": 24, "text": "whether"}, {"id": 25, "text": "to"}, {"id": 26, "text": "enter"}, {"id": 27, "text": "a"}, {"id": 28, "text": "contract"}, {"id": 29, "text": ","}, {"id": 30, "text": "not"}, {"id": 31, "text": "earlier"}, {"id": 32, "text": "stages"}, {"id": 33, "text": "of"}, {"id": 34, "text": "the"}, {"id": 35, "text": "contract"}, {"id": 36, "text": "-"}, {"id": 37, "text": "formation"}, {"id": 38, "text": "process"}, {"id": 39, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 4, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "The"}, {"id": 1, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 2, "text": "devotes"}, {"id": 3, "text": "a"}, {"id": 4, "text": "page"}, {"id": 5, "text": "and"}, {"id": 6, "text": "a"}, {"id": 7, "text": "half"}, {"id": 8, "text": "to"}, {"id": 9, "text": "this"}, {"id": 10, "text": "important"}, {"id": 11, "text": "issue"}, {"id": 12, "text": "but"}, {"id": 13, "text": "declines"}, {"id": 14, "text": "to"}, {"id": 15, "text": "resolve"}, {"id": 16, "text": "it"}, {"id": 17, "text": ","}, {"id": 18, "text": "as"}, {"id": 19, "text": "it"}, {"id": 20, "text": "does"}, {"id": 21, "text": "not"}, {"id": 22, "text": "bear"}, {"id": 23, "text": "on"}, {"id": 24, "text": "the"}, {"id": 25, "text": "choice"}, {"id": 26, "text": "of"}, {"id": 27, "text": "causation"}, {"id": 28, "text": "standards"}, {"id": 29, "text": "before"}, {"id": 30, "text": "us"}, {"id": 31, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 5, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Ante", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "1017", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "1018", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 6, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "I"}, {"id": 1, "text": "write"}, {"id": 2, "text": "separately"}, {"id": 3, "text": "to"}, {"id": 4, "text": "resist"}, {"id": 5, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 6, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 7, "text": "attempt"}, {"id": 8, "text": "to"}, {"id": 9, "text": "cabin"}, {"id": 10, "text": "a"}, {"id": 11, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "sweeping", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "law"}, {"id": 15, "text": "designed"}, {"id": 16, "text": "to"}, {"id": 17, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "break", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "down", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "all", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "discrimination", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "between", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "black", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "men", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "white", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "men", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "regarding"}, {"id": 30, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "basic", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "civil", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "rights", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 7, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Jones", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "Alfred", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "H.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "Mayer", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "Co.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "392", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "409", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "432", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "433", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "88", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "2186", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "20", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "1189", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "1968", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "("}, {"id": 27, "text": "internal"}, {"id": 28, "text": "quotation"}, {"id": 29, "text": "marks"}, {"id": 30, "text": "omitted"}, {"id": 31, "text": ";"}, {"id": 32, "text": "emphasis"}, {"id": 33, "text": "in"}, {"id": 34, "text": "original"}, {"id": 35, "text": ")"}, {"id": 36, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 8, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Under"}, {"id": 1, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 2, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 3, "text": "view"}, {"id": 4, "text": ","}, {"id": 5, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "countenances"}, {"id": 8, "text": "racial"}, {"id": 9, "text": "discrimination"}, {"id": 10, "text": "so"}, {"id": 11, "text": "long"}, {"id": 12, "text": "as"}, {"id": 13, "text": "it"}, {"id": 14, "text": "occurs"}, {"id": 15, "text": "in"}, {"id": 16, "text": "advance"}, {"id": 17, "text": "of"}, {"id": 18, "text": "the"}, {"id": 19, "text": "final"}, {"id": 20, "text": "contract"}, {"id": 21, "text": "-"}, {"id": 22, "text": "formation"}, {"id": 23, "text": "decision"}, {"id": 24, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 9, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Thus"}, {"id": 1, "text": ","}, {"id": 2, "text": "a"}, {"id": 3, "text": "lender"}, {"id": 4, "text": "would"}, {"id": 5, "text": "not"}, {"id": 6, "text": "violate"}, {"id": 7, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "by"}, {"id": 10, "text": "requiring"}, {"id": 11, "text": "prospective"}, {"id": 12, "text": "borrowers"}, {"id": 13, "text": "to"}, {"id": 14, "text": "provide"}, {"id": 15, "text": "one"}, {"id": 16, "text": "reference"}, {"id": 17, "text": "letter"}, {"id": 18, "text": "if"}, {"id": 19, "text": "they"}, {"id": 20, "text": "are"}, {"id": 21, "text": "white"}, {"id": 22, "text": "and"}, {"id": 23, "text": "five"}, {"id": 24, "text": "if"}, {"id": 25, "text": "they"}, {"id": 26, "text": "are"}, {"id": 27, "text": "black"}, {"id": 28, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 10, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Nor"}, {"id": 1, "text": "would"}, {"id": 2, "text": "an"}, {"id": 3, "text": "employer"}, {"id": 4, "text": "violate"}, {"id": 5, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "by"}, {"id": 8, "text": "reimbursing"}, {"id": 9, "text": "expenses"}, {"id": 10, "text": "for"}, {"id": 11, "text": "white"}, {"id": 12, "text": "interviewees"}, {"id": 13, "text": "but"}, {"id": 14, "text": "requiring"}, {"id": 15, "text": "black"}, {"id": 16, "text": "applicants"}, {"id": 17, "text": "to"}, {"id": 18, "text": "pay"}, {"id": 19, "text": "their"}, {"id": 20, "text": "own"}, {"id": 21, "text": "way"}, {"id": 22, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 11, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "The"}, {"id": 1, "text": "employer"}, {"id": 2, "text": "could"}, {"id": 3, "text": "even"}, {"id": 4, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "refus[e", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "]", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "consider", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "applications", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "from"}, {"id": 12, "text": "black"}, {"id": 13, "text": "applicants"}, {"id": 14, "text": "at"}, {"id": 15, "text": "all"}, {"id": 16, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 12, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Brief", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "United", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "States", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "as", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "Amicus", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "Curiae", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "21", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 13, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "That"}, {"id": 1, "text": "view"}, {"id": 2, "text": "can"}, {"id": 3, "text": "not"}, {"id": 4, "text": "be"}, {"id": 5, "text": "squared"}, {"id": 6, "text": "with"}, {"id": 7, "text": "the"}, {"id": 8, "text": "statute"}, {"id": 9, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 14, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "An"}, {"id": 1, "text": "equal"}, {"id": 2, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "right", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "make", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "contracts", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "1981(a", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": ","}, {"id": 15, "text": "is"}, {"id": 16, "text": "an"}, {"id": 17, "text": "empty"}, {"id": 18, "text": "promise"}, {"id": 19, "text": "without"}, {"id": 20, "text": "equal"}, {"id": 21, "text": "opportunities"}, {"id": 22, "text": "to"}, {"id": 23, "text": "present"}, {"id": 24, "text": "or"}, {"id": 25, "text": "receive"}, {"id": 26, "text": "offers"}, {"id": 27, "text": "and"}, {"id": 28, "text": "negotiate"}, {"id": 29, "text": "over"}, {"id": 30, "text": "terms"}, {"id": 31, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 15, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "A"}, {"id": 1, "text": "plaintiff"}, {"id": 2, "text": "hindered"}, {"id": 3, "text": "from"}, {"id": 4, "text": "enjoying"}, {"id": 5, "text": "those"}, {"id": 6, "text": "opportunities"}, {"id": 7, "text": "may"}, {"id": 8, "text": "be"}, {"id": 9, "text": "unable"}, {"id": 10, "text": "effectively"}, {"id": 11, "text": "to"}, {"id": 12, "text": "form"}, {"id": 13, "text": "a"}, {"id": 14, "text": "contract"}, {"id": 15, "text": ","}, {"id": 16, "text": "and"}, {"id": 17, "text": "a"}, {"id": 18, "text": "defendant"}, {"id": 19, "text": "able"}, {"id": 20, "text": "to"}, {"id": 21, "text": "impair"}, {"id": 22, "text": "those"}, {"id": 23, "text": "opportunities"}, {"id": 24, "text": "can"}, {"id": 25, "text": "avoid"}, {"id": 26, "text": "contracting"}, {"id": 27, "text": "without"}, {"id": 28, "text": "refusing"}, {"id": 29, "text": "a"}, {"id": 30, "text": "contract"}, {"id": 31, "text": "outright"}, {"id": 32, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 16, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "It"}, {"id": 1, "text": "is"}, {"id": 2, "text": "implausible"}, {"id": 3, "text": "that"}, {"id": 4, "text": "a"}, {"id": 5, "text": "law"}, {"id": 6, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "intended", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "secure", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "...", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "practical", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "freedom", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 17, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Jones", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "392", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "431", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "88", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "2186", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "("}, {"id": 12, "text": "quoting"}, {"id": 13, "text": "Cong", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "Globe", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "39th", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "Cong", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "1st", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "Sess", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "474", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "1866", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": ")"}, {"id": 30, "text": ","}, {"id": 31, "text": "would"}, {"id": 32, "text": "condone"}, {"id": 33, "text": "discriminatory"}, {"id": 34, "text": "barriers"}, {"id": 35, "text": "to"}, {"id": 36, "text": "contract"}, {"id": 37, "text": "formation"}, {"id": 38, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 18, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Far"}, {"id": 1, "text": "from"}, {"id": 2, "text": "confining"}, {"id": 3, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 6, "text": "guarantee"}, {"id": 7, "text": "to"}, {"id": 8, "text": "discrete"}, {"id": 9, "text": "moments"}, {"id": 10, "text": ","}, {"id": 11, "text": "the"}, {"id": 12, "text": "language", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "of"}, {"id": 14, "text": "the"}, {"id": 15, "text": "statute"}, {"id": 16, "text": "covers"}, {"id": 17, "text": "the"}, {"id": 18, "text": "entirety"}, {"id": 19, "text": "of"}, {"id": 20, "text": "the"}, {"id": 21, "text": "contracting"}, {"id": 22, "text": "process"}, {"id": 23, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 19, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "The"}, {"id": 1, "text": "statute"}, {"id": 2, "text": "defines", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "make", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "enforce", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "contracts", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "to"}, {"id": 10, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "includ[e", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "]", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "making", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "performance", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "modification", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "termination", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "contracts", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "enjoyment", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "all", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "benefits", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "privileges", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "terms", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "conditions", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "contractual", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 41, "text": "relationship", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 42, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 43, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 20, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "1981(b", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 21, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "That"}, {"id": 1, "text": "encompassing"}, {"id": 2, "text": "definition", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "ensures"}, {"id": 4, "text": "that"}, {"id": 5, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "applies", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "all", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "phases", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "incidents", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "contractual", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "relationship", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 22, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Rivers", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "Roadway", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "Express", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "Inc.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "511", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "298", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "302", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "114", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "1510", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "128", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "274", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "1994", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 23, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "See"}, {"id": 1, "text": "also"}, {"id": 2, "text": "H.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "R.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "Rep.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "No", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "102", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "40", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "pt", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "2", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "p.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "37", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "1991", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "("}, {"id": 21, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "The", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "Committee", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "intends", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "this", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "provision", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "bar", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "all", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "racial", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "discrimination", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "in", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "contracts", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 24, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "This", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "list", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "is", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "intended", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "be", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "illustrative", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "not", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "exhaustive", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": ")"}, {"id": 13, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 25, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "In", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "line", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "with", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "rest", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "definition", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "word", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "making", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 4, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "is", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "most", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "sensibly", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "read", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}, {"id": 5, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "capture", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "entire", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "process", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "by", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "which", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "contract", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "is", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "formed", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Appeal to Meaning"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 26, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "American", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "Heritage", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "Dictionary", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "1086", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "3d", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "ed", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "1992", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "("}, {"id": 11, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "The", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "process", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "coming", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "into", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "being", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": ")"}, {"id": 20, "text": ";"}, {"id": 21, "text": "9", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "Oxford", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "English", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "Dictionary", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "250", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "2d", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "ed", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "1989", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Language Source"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "("}, {"id": 33, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 5, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "process", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 5, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 5, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "being", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 5, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "made", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 5, "category": "Definition"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": ")"}, {"id": 41, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 27, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 1, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 2, "text": "freeze"}, {"id": 3, "text": "-"}, {"id": 4, "text": "frame"}, {"id": 5, "text": "approach"}, {"id": 6, "text": "to"}, {"id": 7, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "invites"}, {"id": 10, "text": "the"}, {"id": 11, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 12, "text": "to"}, {"id": 13, "text": "repeat"}, {"id": 14, "text": "an"}, {"id": 15, "text": "error"}, {"id": 16, "text": "it"}, {"id": 17, "text": "has"}, {"id": 18, "text": "committed"}, {"id": 19, "text": "before"}, {"id": 20, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 28, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "In"}, {"id": 1, "text": "1989"}, {"id": 2, "text": ","}, {"id": 3, "text": "the"}, {"id": 4, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 5, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "rea[d", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "]", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "not", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "as", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "a", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "general", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "proscription", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "racial", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "discrimination", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "in", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "all", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "aspects", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "contract", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "relations", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 25, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 26, "text": "as", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "limited", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "certain"}, {"id": 31, "text": "narrow"}, {"id": 32, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "enumerated", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": "rights", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 29, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Patterson", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "McLean", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "Credit", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "Union", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "491", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "164", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "181", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "109", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "2363", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "105", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "132", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "1989", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 30, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "According"}, {"id": 1, "text": "to"}, {"id": 2, "text": "Patterson"}, {"id": 3, "text": ","}, {"id": 4, "text": "the"}, {"id": 5, "text": "right"}, {"id": 6, "text": "to"}, {"id": 7, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "make", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "a"}, {"id": 11, "text": "contract"}, {"id": 12, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "extend[ed", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "]", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": "only", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "formation", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "a", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "contract", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "and"}, {"id": 25, "text": "the"}, {"id": 26, "text": "right"}, {"id": 27, "text": "to"}, {"id": 28, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "enforce", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 3, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "it"}, {"id": 32, "text": "encompassed"}, {"id": 33, "text": "only"}, {"id": 34, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "access", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 36, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 37, "text": "legal", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 38, "text": "process", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 39, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 4, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 40, "text": "\""}]}, {"id": 31, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Id.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "176", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "178", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "109", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "2363", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 32, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "The"}, {"id": 1, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 2, "text": "thus"}, {"id": 3, "text": "declined"}, {"id": 4, "text": "to"}, {"id": 5, "text": "apply"}, {"id": 6, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "to"}, {"id": 9, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "postformation", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "conduct", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "concluding"}, {"id": 15, "text": "that"}, {"id": 16, "text": "an"}, {"id": 17, "text": "employee"}, {"id": 18, "text": "had"}, {"id": 19, "text": "no"}, {"id": 20, "text": "recourse"}, {"id": 21, "text": "to"}, {"id": 22, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "1981", "annotations": [{"id": 2, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "for"}, {"id": 25, "text": "racial"}, {"id": 26, "text": "harassment"}, {"id": 27, "text": "occurring"}, {"id": 28, "text": "after"}, {"id": 29, "text": "the"}, {"id": 30, "text": "employment"}, {"id": 31, "text": "contract"}, {"id": 32, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 33, "text": "formation"}, {"id": 34, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 33, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Id.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "at", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "178", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "179", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "109", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": "2363", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 34, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Congress"}, {"id": 1, "text": "promptly"}, {"id": 2, "text": "repudiated"}, {"id": 3, "text": "that"}, {"id": 4, "text": "interpretation", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 35, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "In"}, {"id": 1, "text": "1991"}, {"id": 2, "text": ","}, {"id": 3, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "with", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "the", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "design", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "supersede", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "Patterson", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": "Congress"}, {"id": 13, "text": "enacted"}, {"id": 14, "text": "the"}, {"id": 15, "text": "expansive"}, {"id": 16, "text": "definition", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "of"}, {"id": 18, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "make", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "enforce", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "contracts", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 2, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 1, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "now"}, {"id": 25, "text": "contained"}, {"id": 26, "text": "in"}, {"id": 27, "text": "\u00a7", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "1981(b", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 3, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 36, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "CBOCS", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": "West", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "Inc.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": "v.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "Humphries", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": "553", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "U.S.", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "442", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 11, "text": "450", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 12, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 13, "text": "128", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 14, "text": "S.Ct", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 15, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "1951", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": ",", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "170", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "L.Ed.2d", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "864", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 21, "text": "(", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 22, "text": "2008", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 23, "text": ")", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 24, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 37, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "Postformation"}, {"id": 1, "text": "racial"}, {"id": 2, "text": "harassment"}, {"id": 3, "text": "violates"}, {"id": 4, "text": "\u00a7"}, {"id": 5, "text": "1981"}, {"id": 6, "text": ","}, {"id": 7, "text": "the"}, {"id": 8, "text": "amendment"}, {"id": 9, "text": "clarifies", "annotations": [{"id": -1, "category": "Metalinguistic Cue"}]}, {"id": 10, "text": ","}, {"id": 11, "text": "because"}, {"id": 12, "text": "the"}, {"id": 13, "text": "right"}, {"id": 14, "text": "to"}, {"id": 15, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "make", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "and", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "enforce", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}, {"id": 1, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 20, "text": "a"}, {"id": 21, "text": "contract"}, {"id": 22, "text": "includes"}, {"id": 23, "text": "the"}, {"id": 24, "text": "manner"}, {"id": 25, "text": "in"}, {"id": 26, "text": "which"}, {"id": 27, "text": "the"}, {"id": 28, "text": "contract"}, {"id": 29, "text": "is"}, {"id": 30, "text": "carried"}, {"id": 31, "text": "out"}, {"id": 32, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 38, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "So"}, {"id": 1, "text": "too"}, {"id": 2, "text": "the"}, {"id": 3, "text": "manner"}, {"id": 4, "text": "in"}, {"id": 5, "text": "which"}, {"id": 6, "text": "the"}, {"id": 7, "text": "contract"}, {"id": 8, "text": "is"}, {"id": 9, "text": "made"}, {"id": 10, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 39, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "The"}, {"id": 1, "text": "complaint"}, {"id": 2, "text": "before"}, {"id": 3, "text": "us"}, {"id": 4, "text": "contains"}, {"id": 5, "text": "allegations"}, {"id": 6, "text": "of"}, {"id": 7, "text": "racial"}, {"id": 8, "text": "harassment"}, {"id": 9, "text": "during"}, {"id": 10, "text": "contract"}, {"id": 11, "text": "formation"}, {"id": 12, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 40, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "In"}, {"id": 1, "text": "their"}, {"id": 2, "text": "negotiations"}, {"id": 3, "text": ","}, {"id": 4, "text": "Entertainment"}, {"id": 5, "text": "Studios"}, {"id": 6, "text": "alleges"}, {"id": 7, "text": ","}, {"id": 8, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 9, "text": "required"}, {"id": 10, "text": "of"}, {"id": 11, "text": "Entertainment"}, {"id": 12, "text": "Studios"}, {"id": 13, "text": "a"}, {"id": 14, "text": "series"}, {"id": 15, "text": "of"}, {"id": 16, "text": "tasks"}, {"id": 17, "text": "that"}, {"id": 18, "text": "served"}, {"id": 19, "text": "no"}, {"id": 20, "text": "purpose"}, {"id": 21, "text": "and"}, {"id": 22, "text": "on"}, {"id": 23, "text": "which"}, {"id": 24, "text": "Entertainment"}, {"id": 25, "text": "Studios"}, {"id": 26, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 27, "text": "waste[d", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 28, "text": "]", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 29, "text": "hundreds", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 30, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 31, "text": "thousands", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 32, "text": "of", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 33, "text": "dollars", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 34, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}, {"id": 35, "text": "\"", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Direct Quote"}]}]}, {"id": 41, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "App", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 1, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 2, "text": "to", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 3, "text": "Pet", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 4, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 5, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 6, "text": "Cert", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 7, "text": ".", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 8, "text": "49a-50a", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Legal Source"}]}, {"id": 9, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 42, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "The"}, {"id": 1, "text": "Court"}, {"id": 2, "text": "holds"}, {"id": 3, "text": "today"}, {"id": 4, "text": "that"}, {"id": 5, "text": "Entertainment"}, {"id": 6, "text": "Studios"}, {"id": 7, "text": "must"}, {"id": 8, "text": "plead"}, {"id": 9, "text": "and"}, {"id": 10, "text": "prove"}, {"id": 11, "text": "that"}, {"id": 12, "text": "race"}, {"id": 13, "text": "was"}, {"id": 14, "text": "the"}, {"id": 15, "text": "but", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 16, "text": "-", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 17, "text": "for", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 18, "text": "cause", "annotations": [{"id": 0, "category": "Focal Term"}]}, {"id": 19, "text": "of"}, {"id": 20, "text": "its"}, {"id": 21, "text": "injury"}, {"id": 22, "text": "-"}, {"id": 23, "text": "in"}, {"id": 24, "text": "other"}, {"id": 25, "text": "words"}, {"id": 26, "text": ","}, {"id": 27, "text": "that"}, {"id": 28, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 29, "text": "would"}, {"id": 30, "text": "have"}, {"id": 31, "text": "acted"}, {"id": 32, "text": "differently"}, {"id": 33, "text": "if"}, {"id": 34, "text": "Entertainment"}, {"id": 35, "text": "Studios"}, {"id": 36, "text": "were"}, {"id": 37, "text": "not"}, {"id": 38, "text": "African"}, {"id": 39, "text": "-"}, {"id": 40, "text": "American"}, {"id": 41, "text": "owned"}, {"id": 42, "text": "."}]}, {"id": 43, "tokens": [{"id": 0, "text": "But"}, {"id": 1, "text": "if"}, {"id": 2, "text": "race"}, {"id": 3, "text": "indeed"}, {"id": 4, "text": "accounts"}, {"id": 5, "text": "for"}, {"id": 6, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 7, "text": "'s"}, {"id": 8, "text": "conduct"}, {"id": 9, "text": ","}, {"id": 10, "text": "Comcast"}, {"id": 11, "text": "should"}, {"id": 12, "text": "not"}, {"id": 13, "text": "escape"}, {"id": 14, "text": "liability"}, {"id": 15, "text": "for"}, {"id": 16, "text": "injuries"}, {"id": 17, "text": "inflicted"}, {"id": 18, "text": "during"}, {"id": 19, "text": "the"}, {"id": 20, "text": "contract"}, {"id": 21, "text": "-"}, {"id": 22, "text": "formation"}, {"id": 23, "text": "process"}, {"id": 24, "text": "."}]}]}]
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/tests/curiam_reader_test.py b/tests/curiam_reader_test.py
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..62228e5
--- /dev/null
+++ b/tests/curiam_reader_test.py
@@ -0,0 +1,32 @@
+import pytest
+import torch
+from transformers import BertTokenizer
+
+from hipool import curiam_reader
+
+
+@pytest.fixture
+def curiam_sample():
+    bert_tokenizer = BertTokenizer.from_pretrained('bert-base-uncased', do_lower_case=True)
+    dataset = curiam_reader.CuriamDataset(
+        json_file_path="fixtures/data/curiam_sample.json",
+        tokenizer=bert_tokenizer,
+        chunk_len=50,
+        overlap_len=10)
+    return dataset
+
+
+def test_read_json_len(curiam_sample):
+    assert len(curiam_sample.documents) == 2
+    assert len(curiam_sample.labels) == 2
+
+
+def test_read_json_tokens(curiam_sample):
+    assert curiam_sample.documents[0][0] == "Justice"
+    assert curiam_sample.documents[0][1] == "GORSUCH"
+
+
+def test_getitem_labels(curiam_sample):
+    first_chunk_labels = curiam_sample[0]["targets"][0]
+    first_token_labels = first_chunk_labels[0]
+    assert torch.equal(first_token_labels, torch.zeros((9)))