Help understanding how node_file.cc handles toLocal() errors

[uurixx]

Hi, I'm using Node v22.5.1 for our internal infrastructure, and one of our cilents recently crashed with FATAL ERROR: v8::ToLocalChecked Empty MaybeLocal in node::fs::ReadFileUtf8() on src/node_file.cc#L2581.

I applied this commit and the error is gone, but I wonder if I have just silenced the error instead of solving the root cause.

Here are some questions I have on the commit:
src/node_file.cc#L848-L853

    if (link.IsEmpty()) {
      req_wrap->Reject(error);
    } else {
      Local<Value> val;
      if (link.ToLocal(&val)) req_wrap->Resolve(val);
    }
  }
}

If we already check IsEmpty(), then how could ToLocal() fail?

src/node_file.cc#L2586-L2589

  FS_SYNC_TRACE_END(read);

  Local<Value> val;
  if (!ToV8Value(env->context(), result, isolate).ToLocal(&val)) {
    return;
  }

  args.GetReturnValue().Set(val);
}

It looks like ReadFileUtf8() now silently returns undefined if ToLocal() fails. Should it fail instead or will the error be propagated or captured somewhere else?

Appreciate any insight on this.

Side note: v22.5.1 is the highest we can go due to internal requirements, and there's no minimal reproduction for that crash externally.

[hernandemonteiro]

The crash you're encountering is related to how MaybeLocal values are handled in V8 and Node.js. I'll break down the situation and address your questions.

Background

MaybeLocal<T> is a construct in V8 to represent a value that might not exist (e.g., due to an error). Accessing a MaybeLocal directly requires caution, as doing so without checking its validity can lead to fatal crashes, as seen in your error.

The two critical points in your questions are:

1. Why can ToLocal() fail after checking IsEmpty()?
2. Should ReadFileUtf8() fail if ToLocal() fails?

---

1. Why can ToLocal() fail after checking IsEmpty()?

The check for IsEmpty() and the subsequent use of ToLocal() might seem redundant at first glance, but they serve slightly different purposes:

• IsEmpty():

  • Checks whether the MaybeLocal is initialized or holds a value at all. If it's empty, it means there's nothing to convert.

• ToLocal():

  • Converts the MaybeLocal into a Local<Value>. This operation can still fail, even if IsEmpty() is false, due to runtime issues like memory constraints, GC interference, or unexpected exceptions.

Thus, while checking IsEmpty() guards against completely uninitialized states, it's not a guarantee that ToLocal() will succeed. V8 may fail during the conversion process for reasons unrelated to initialization.

---

2. Should ReadFileUtf8() fail if ToLocal() fails?

Currently, the code you provided seems to handle ToLocal() failure by returning undefined:

if (!ToV8Value(env->context(), result, isolate).ToLocal(&val)) {
    return;
}

This behavior avoids crashing the process, which is generally preferable for production environments. However, it might mask the root cause of the failure. Ideally, the failure should be propagated or logged to help diagnose issues.

Here are some possible strategies to handle ToLocal() failures:

1. Log the error:

   • Add logging to record that the ToLocal() conversion failed. This gives visibility into the issue without crashing the process.

2. Reject with an error:

   • Instead of returning silently, propagate the failure as a rejected promise (or equivalent error) to inform the caller.

3. Crash intentionally (optional):

   • In scenarios where silent failures are unacceptable, you can assert or throw to force an investigation.

---

Addressing the Code in Question

Code snippet 1: src/node_file.cc#L848-L853

if (link.IsEmpty()) {
  req_wrap->Reject(error);
} else {
  Local<Value> val;
  if (link.ToLocal(&val)) req_wrap->Resolve(val);
}

• IsEmpty() followed by ToLocal(): As explained, this is not redundant but a cautious approach to handle both uninitialized and runtime failure cases.
• Possible improvement: Log or handle the failure of ToLocal() explicitly. If ToLocal() fails, link is non-empty but invalid, which can happen in certain edge cases.

---

Code snippet 2: src/node_file.cc#L2586-L2589

Local<Value> val;
if (!ToV8Value(env->context(), result, isolate).ToLocal(&val)) {
  return;
}
args.GetReturnValue().Set(val);

• Current behavior: Returning silently when ToLocal() fails avoids crashes but also hides potential bugs or issues in the code path.
• Should it fail instead?:
  • If ReadFileUtf8() returning undefined is acceptable to the caller, this approach is fine.
  • Otherwise, consider logging the failure or throwing an error to ensure it doesn't go unnoticed.

---

Recommendations

Given your constraints and the current implementation:

1. Logging: Add detailed logging at both points where ToLocal() might fail. This will help identify the underlying cause without crashing the process.

2. Error Propagation:

   • For snippet 1, you could add a fallback to reject the request wrap with a meaningful error if ToLocal() fails.
   • For snippet 2, ensure that silent failures won't lead to undefined behavior in downstream code.

3. Testing:

   • Since you can't reproduce the issue externally, consider stress testing the affected code paths under various memory and concurrency conditions to simulate potential edge cases.

By addressing these points, you'll ensure that you're not just "silencing" the issue but also preparing for any similar failures in the future.

[uurixx]

Thank you for such a detailed response! I'll give it try.