Skip to content

Clarify vers representation of Elixir ~> range with pre-release semantics #49

@maennchen

Description

@maennchen

In Elixir, SemVer version requirements may use the ~> operator.

Examples (naive translation):

  • ~> 0.1>= 0.1.0, < 1.0.0
  • ~> 0.1.5>= 0.1.5, < 0.2.0

Ref: https://hexdocs.pm/elixir/Version.html#module-requirements

However, because pre-release versions (e.g. -alpha, -beta, etc.) are ordered before their corresponding release version, these translations are not accurate.

Example:

iex> Version.match?("0.2.0-alpha.7", "~> 0.1.5")
false

iex> Version.match?("0.2.0-alpha.7", ">= 0.1.5 and <= 0.2.0")
true

iex> Version.compare("0.2.0-alpha.7", "0.2.0")
:lt

Therefore:

~> 0.1.5 ≠ >= 0.1.5, < 0.2.0

How should ~> be represented in vers, considering pre-release ordering semantics?

I believe this also affects the ^ operator in NPM:

{
"description": "Construct VERS range from native npm range.",
"test_group": "advanced",
"test_type": "from_native",
"input": {
"native_range": "^2.0.18 || ^3.0.16 || ^3.1.6 || ^4.0.8 || ^5.0.0-beta.5",
"scheme": "npm"
},
"expected_output": "vers:npm/>=2.0.18|<3.0.0|>=3.0.16|>=3.1.6|<4.0.0|<4.0.0|>=4.0.8|>=5.0.0-beta.5|<5.0.0|<6.0.0"
},

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions