Problem
There seems to be a gap in the current project-local skills workflow.
Summary
npx skills add supports project-local installation and writes a project-scoped skills-lock.json, but npx skills
check and npx skills update do not appear to consume that lock file.
As a result, project-local skills can be:
- installed
- listed
- restored
but not actually checked/updated through the normal check / update flow.
Expected behavior
If a skill is installed project-locally and recorded in skills-lock.json, I expect one of these behaviors:
- npx skills check checks project-local tracked skills
- npx skills update updates project-local tracked skills
- or there is an explicit project-scoped variant for check/update
Actual behavior
In my project:
- npx skills ls --json correctly lists project-local skills
- skills-lock.json contains the installed project-local skills
- but npx skills check does not seem to use that file
- and npx skills update does not update those project-local skills
In practice, I can see project-local skills installed under .agents/skills/, and they are recorded in skills-
lock.json, but check / update still behave as if only the global lock state matters.
Reproduction
-
Install one or more skills as project-local:
npx skills add vercel-labs/agent-browser
-
Confirm they are listed as project skills:
npx skills ls --json
-
Confirm they are recorded in:
skills-lock.json
-
Run:
npx skills check
npx skills update
Why this seems inconsistent
The project-local install flow already creates a version-controlled lock file (skills-lock.json), which strongly
suggests project-local tracking is a first-class concept.
But without project-local support in check / update, the workflow feels incomplete:
- install works
- listing works
- lockfile exists
- update path is missing
Proposed Solution
Please support project-local skills in the update flow.
Possible options:
- make check / update read both global and project-local lock state
- add --project variants
- or automatically use skills-lock.json when running inside a project that has one
Alternatives Considered
No response
Additional Context
No response
Problem
There seems to be a gap in the current project-local skills workflow.
Summary
npx skills add supports project-local installation and writes a project-scoped skills-lock.json, but npx skills
check and npx skills update do not appear to consume that lock file.
As a result, project-local skills can be:
but not actually checked/updated through the normal check / update flow.
Expected behavior
If a skill is installed project-locally and recorded in skills-lock.json, I expect one of these behaviors:
Actual behavior
In my project:
In practice, I can see project-local skills installed under .agents/skills/, and they are recorded in skills-
lock.json, but check / update still behave as if only the global lock state matters.
Reproduction
Install one or more skills as project-local:
npx skills add vercel-labs/agent-browser
Confirm they are listed as project skills:
npx skills ls --json
Confirm they are recorded in:
skills-lock.json
Run:
npx skills check
npx skills update
Why this seems inconsistent
The project-local install flow already creates a version-controlled lock file (skills-lock.json), which strongly
suggests project-local tracking is a first-class concept.
But without project-local support in check / update, the workflow feels incomplete:
Proposed Solution
Please support project-local skills in the update flow.
Possible options:
Alternatives Considered
No response
Additional Context
No response