New version of illuminate/contracts (12.32.5) broke the build

[depfu]

We've tested your project with an updated dependency and the build failed.

This version is either within the version range you specified or you haven't specified a version/range. To be able to test your project with the new version, we've taken the liberty of pinning the version for this branch and pull request.

name	version specification	new version
illuminate/contracts	^9.0	^10.0

Unfortunately, we encountered failing tests after pinning. This means that this new version is not compatible with your project and the test failure will potentially also happen on fresh installs.

If you have correctly specified a semantic versioning version range, you should probably also file an issue with the upstream project as they might have released an update that's breaking SemVer rules, which is not cool. (But then again, not all projects explicitly follow SemVer)

We've left the pull request open for you to investigate this issue. Please don't merge it as is, because, again, we've pinned the version of illuminate/contracts for this test run.

What changed?

✳️ illuminate/contracts (^9.0|^10.0|^11.0|^12.0 → 12.32.5) · Repo

Commits

See the full diff on Github.

Sorry, we couldn't find anything useful about this release.

[coderabbitai]

Important

Review skipped

Bot user detected.

To trigger a single review, invoke the @coderabbitai review command.

You can disable this status message by setting the reviews.review_status to false in the CodeRabbit configuration file.

---

_{Comment @coderabbitai help to get the list of available commands and usage tips.}

[claude]

PR Review: illuminate/contracts Version Update

Overview

This PR was automatically created by Depfu to test compatibility with illuminate/contracts version 12.32.5. According to the PR description, the build failed with this version, indicating a breaking change or incompatibility.

Critical Issues

🚨 DO NOT MERGE - Breaking Change Detected

• The PR description explicitly states: "Unfortunately, we encountered failing tests after pinning"
• This version breaks the build and should not be merged as-is
• The dependency has been pinned to an exact version (12.32.5) rather than using the semantic versioning range

Code Quality Review

❌ Dependency Version Pinning (Line 20)

"illuminate/contracts": "12.32.5"

Issues:

1. Breaks semantic versioning: The original constraint ^9.0|^10.0|^11.0|^12.0 allows for flexibility across Laravel versions. Pinning to an exact version removes this flexibility
2. Reduces compatibility: Users on Laravel 9, 10, 11, or earlier 12.x versions won't be able to use this package
3. Not production-ready: Exact version pinning is typically only used for testing purposes, not for library dependencies

Recommendation: Do not pin to exact versions in a library package. This is acceptable for applications but not for packages consumed by others.

📝 Formatting Changes

The entire composer.json has been reformatted from 4-space indentation to 2-space indentation. While this is cosmetic, it:

• Makes the diff unnecessarily large (154 line changes for essentially one dependency change)
• May not match the project's existing code style conventions
• Could cause merge conflicts with other PRs

Performance Considerations

✅ No performance impact from formatting changes
⚠️ Unknown performance implications from the illuminate/contracts update without seeing what failed in tests

Security Concerns

✅ No direct security concerns with the changes themselves
⚠️ However, the failed tests could indicate breaking changes that might affect security-related functionality

Test Coverage

❌ Tests are failing according to the PR description

• Need to investigate what specifically is breaking
• Cannot assess if the package is compatible with Laravel 12.32.5 without seeing test output

Recommendations

1. Investigate the test failures

   • Run composer test locally with this version pinned
   • Identify which tests are failing and why
   • Determine if it's a legitimate breaking change in Laravel 12.x

2. Check Laravel 12 compatibility

   • Review the Laravel 12 changelog and upgrade guide
   • Identify any breaking changes in contracts that affect this package
   • Update package code if necessary to maintain compatibility

3. Revert formatting changes

   • Keep the original 4-space indentation
   • Only change the illuminate/contracts line to minimize diff noise

4. Maintain semantic versioning

   • Once compatibility is confirmed, keep the range constraint: ^9.0|^10.0|^11.0|^12.0
   • Do not pin to exact versions in a library package

5. Create a proper fix PR

   • If code changes are needed for Laravel 12 compatibility, create a separate PR with those fixes
   • Update tests to ensure compatibility across all supported Laravel versions
   • Close this automated PR once a proper fix is in place

Conclusion

Status: ❌ SHOULD NOT BE MERGED

This PR successfully identified an incompatibility with Laravel 12.32.5, which is valuable information. However, the PR itself should not be merged because:

• Tests are failing
• Exact version pinning breaks compatibility
• No actual fixes are included

Next steps: Investigate the root cause of test failures and create a proper PR that maintains backward compatibility with Laravel 9-12 while fixing any issues discovered.

---

🤖 Review generated with Claude Code