Skip to content

Set up a twin like RTOFS v2.5 #58

Closed as duplicate
1 of 1 issue completed
Closed as duplicate

Description

@sanAkel
  • NCODA configured SAME way.

  • Use (clean) initial conditions.

  • Prepare forcing fields that match those used in RTOFS v2.5.

  • Diagnose timing info on wcoss. Is MOM slow? Where? Which components?

  • Extend to using CICE ice/increment.

Further testing:

  1. Daily mean (archive) as background.
  2. FGAT. (HYCOM always runs with it ON; MOM6 there is/was some problem/development).
  3. No FGAT.

Activity

  1. self-assigned this
    on Apr 17, 2025
  2. sanAkel commented on Apr 28, 2025

    @sanAkel
    ContributorAuthor

    Use this tool to decode fit to observations

  3. sanAkel commented on Jun 24, 2025

    @sanAkel
    ContributorAuthor

    From @zgarraffo

    Path to experiment on hera: expt 14.1 /scratch2/NCEPDEV/marine/Zulema.Garraffo/FV3_RT/expt_14.1

    • Under that directory README are tests

    This is an experiment:

    • Initial run saved daily mean MOM6 archive and CICE6 archive.
    • Also hourly ocns. NCODA on the daily mean background field and daily mean background CICE6.

    Restarts from RTOFS converted to MOM6 and CICE6:
    /scratch2/NCEPDEV/marine/Zulema.Garraffo/FV3_RT/expt_14.1/rtofs.20250401_v2.5.a

    Taking restarts from ⬆ run (36 hours):
    /scratch2/NCEPDEV/marine/Zulema.Garraffo/FV3_RT/expt_14.1/rtofs.20250401

    Next day (did not finish):
    /scratch2/NCEPDEV/marine/Zulema.Garraffo/FV3_RT/expt_14.1/rtofs.20250402/

    Path source code:
    /scratch4/NCEPDEV/marine/Zulema.Garraffo/ufs-weather-model_2025

  4. zgarraffo commented on Jul 18, 2025

    @zgarraffo
    Collaborator

    Expt 14.1 failed at day 7. Rerunning it with a shorter thermal time scale, but have to check the incremental update creation utility (possible cause of failure).
    Started expt_14.2, similar to previous experiments for 2023: same 20250401 initial conditions than 14.1, instantaneous background, no ice assimilation, incremental update hours -6 to 0 from the analysis time, incremental update archive in the RTOFS-DA analysis levels.

    After the 1st assimilation, expt_14.1 and 14.2 look almost identical, but noisier than the previous MOM6 experiments.

    The initial forecast, before assimilation, 20250401, is similar to after assimilation (it was done with the default time steps, but will be chedked for DT_THERMAL=300. The hycom state is changed going to MOM, before assimilation

  5. sanAkel commented on Jul 19, 2025

    @sanAkel
    ContributorAuthor

    @zgarraffo would you be able to plot differences between 14.2 and v2.5.a (parallel)? And post here?

  6. zgarraffo commented on Jul 22, 2025

    @zgarraffo
    Collaborator

    -14.1 (daily mean background, -12 to 12 hours incremental update in layers, dt thermal=300s, day 20250407, noisy but didn't blow up
    -14.2 (instantaneous background, -6 to 0 hours incremental update in z, dt thermal=300 day 20250407, similar noise.
    -Hae-Cheol run a forecast only. Noticeable changes vs the initial rtofs archive in SSH off Brazil-Argentina in the forecast and in 14.1 and 14.2.
    Will do some difference plots.

    @zgarraffo
    Can you please add a table of what's in each experiment? How they differ? And what's their status? A link to presentation/ plots?

  7. added this to the Set up parallel run milestone on Oct 12, 2025
  8. sanAkel commented on Oct 13, 2025

    @sanAkel
    ContributorAuthor

    Results from @zgarraffo's experiments can be found here.

  9. sanAkel commented on Oct 29, 2025

    @sanAkel
    ContributorAuthor

    @zgarraffo reports completion of the following plots:

    She concludes:

    • The run with fgat improved the SST error.
    • Maybe the run is acceptable once the forcing is computed every 1-hour and 3 hour.
      • Top panel left: MOM6 with fgat, center: MOM6 without fgat, right: RTOFS
    Image
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Labels

enhancementNew feature or requestv3-devDevelopment for RTOFS v3

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions