Skip to content

Conversation

osiire
Copy link

@osiire osiire commented Feb 7, 2019

I'm using parseback in my project, but parsing is very slow due to many whitespaces.
In practice, there is no DSL does not have whitespace.
I have introduced a lexing phase before the PWD, the parsing speed became very fast.
Here are 3 patterns of benchmark results in my box.

no optimize

+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,173775.851188,2312.746723,"ops/s",2
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,18241.987633,984.304636,"ops/s",4
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,5678.154039,71.475780,"ops/s",8
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,2642.946283,89.420557,"ops/s",16
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,1169.474335,37.347710,"ops/s",32
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,371.850145,6.763177,"ops/s",64
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,141.861952,4.194896,"ops/s",128
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,22432.031980,982.794937,"ops/s",2
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,3065.175752,40.800879,"ops/s",4
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,628.646364,7.093002,"ops/s",8
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,127.711043,3.572157,"ops/s",16
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,30.057644,0.463080,"ops/s",32
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,5.685695,0.246421,"ops/s",64
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,1.579336,0.116543,"ops/s",128
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,150796.908074,1527.348563,"ops/s",2
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,60145.657071,2153.397558,"ops/s",4
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,25767.637041,1330.493737,"ops/s",8
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,13851.684348,216.750698,"ops/s",16
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,6592.322566,303.507154,"ops/s",32
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,2455.269600,38.373447,"ops/s",64
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,1492.020733,21.215706,"ops/s",128

no optimize(add whitespace)

+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,132619.563099,2747.014005,"ops/s",2
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,16931.974282,640.734251,"ops/s",4
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,5802.609738,154.647659,"ops/s",8
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,2323.263571,49.327300,"ops/s",16
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,890.420544,48.637698,"ops/s",32
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,369.755234,27.868797,"ops/s",64
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,92.007267,5.009416,"ops/s",128
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,6264.225232,227.800277,"ops/s",2
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,905.146495,31.420769,"ops/s",4
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,183.503893,3.275698,"ops/s",8
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,36.405825,0.545524,"ops/s",16
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,8.060280,0.205061,"ops/s",32
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,1.801275,0.128898,"ops/s",64
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,0.356215,0.046763,"ops/s",128
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,119033.918128,7822.590611,"ops/s",2
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,52391.733969,1120.222661,"ops/s",4
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,23464.677710,638.255485,"ops/s",8
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,10799.153141,652.494521,"ops/s",16
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,4477.935194,276.564212,"ops/s",32
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,2788.747861,57.186063,"ops/s",64
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,1382.957582,31.359118,"ops/s",128

lexing optimize(add whitespace)

+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,169928.693894,4828.383320,"ops/s",2
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,17080.524603,1153.686539,"ops/s",4
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,5467.070697,490.304521,"ops/s",8
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,2167.957922,174.578779,"ops/s",16
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,904.012384,24.496258,"ops/s",32
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,394.103533,6.246434,"ops/s",64
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.gllRun","thrpt",1,20,110.933693,4.439783,"ops/s",128
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,22831.346090,309.065844,"ops/s",2
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,2764.269407,130.351963,"ops/s",4
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,531.611580,49.118742,"ops/s",8
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,123.734994,10.489502,"ops/s",16
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,34.538655,2.236450,"ops/s",32
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,7.693930,0.275773,"ops/s",64
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.parsebackRun","thrpt",1,20,1.557181,0.021734,"ops/s",128
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,123540.595553,1857.826577,"ops/s",2
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,54996.680269,1056.356606,"ops/s",4
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,20867.465192,2223.796593,"ops/s",8
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,10111.816131,1135.447739,"ops/s",16
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,5587.119579,253.280717,"ops/s",32
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,2658.565723,56.281985,"ops/s",64
+"parseback.benchmarks.ArithmeticBenchmarks.spcRun","thrpt",1,20,1477.770367,132.052776,"ops/s",128

Lexing before PWD is as fast as non-whitespace input even if the input has whitespaces.
I suggest you introduce a lexing phase before parse.

@osiire osiire changed the title lexing before parse lexing before parsing Feb 7, 2019
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant