SpacerPlacer is a powerful software for reconstructing ancestral CRISPR spacer arrays along a given phylogenetic tree. SpacerPlacer is respecting the chronological timeline of spacer insertions as defined by the order of spacers within the CRISPR arrays and uses this additional information to improve the ancestral reconstruction.
- Ancestral Spacer Array Reconstruction: SpacerPlacer allows you to reconstruct ancestral CRISPR spacer arrays based on a given phylogenetic tree.
- Identification of Ancestral Spacer Acquisitions, Deletions, Duplications, and Rearrangements: The tool identifies ancestral duplications and rearrangements within the CRISPR array.
- Spacer Deletion Rate Estimation: The software provides an estimation of spacer deletion rates within the CRISPR arrays.
- Analysis of Jointly Lost Spacers: SpacerPlacer calculates the average length of blocks of jointly lost spacers in the array.
- Optional: Phylogenetic Tree Reconstruction: In addition to spacer array reconstruction along a given tree, SpacerPlacer can also reconstruct phylogenetic trees based on the CRISPR spacer data.
The corresponding paper to SpacerPlacer is now published in Nucleic Acids Research: SpacerPlacer: Ancestral reconstruction of CRISPR arrays reveals the evolutionary dynamics of spacer deletions.
The paper is also available on bioRxiv: SpacerPlacer: Ancestral reconstruction of CRISPR arrays reveals the evolutionary dynamics of spacer deletions.
We presented a poster at the conference CRISPR2023, showcasing the features and applications of SpacerPlacer: SpacerPlacer Poster.
Please feel free to explore the paper/poster to learn more about SpacerPlacer and its applications.
At the moment, SpacerPlacer is supported on Linux. We do not guarantee that it will work on other operating systems. To install SpacerPlacer, follow these steps:
-
Clone the GitHub repository:
git clone https://github.com/fbaumdicker/SpacerPlacer.git
-
We recommend to use conda, as mafft is easily installed using conda (otherwise it needs to be manually installed). The latest version of conda can be downloaded from: https://conda.io/projects/conda/en/latest/user-guide/install/linux.html. Download a conda installer and install conda using the following command:
bash <conda-installer-name>-latest-Linux-x86_64.sh
-
Navigate to the cloned repository and install the required packages in a new environment:
cd SpacerPlacer conda env create -n <myenv> -f environment/environment.yml
With -n you can name the environment. You can choose any name you like or leave it out, as environment.yml provides a default name (spacerplacer_env).
-
Activate the environment:
conda activate <myenv>
-
You can run SpacerPlacer with the following command:
python spacerplacer.py <input_path> <output_path> [options]
"input_path" is a required positional argument. It specifies the input directory containing the input data. For the required format see the respective section. "output_path" is a required positional argument. It specifies the output directory where the results will be saved.
Available options can be found by running:
python spacerplacer.py -hYou can also provide the options in a config file. Then you can run SpacerPlacer with the following command:
python spacerplacer.py @<config_file_path>We provide example configs in the "configs" directory. You can use them as a template for your own config file and run them in SpacerPlacer as described above, e.g.:
python spacerplacer.py @configs/config_workflow_example_listeria_monocytogenes"@" specifies that the following argument is the path to a config file. The example configs use example data found in "example_data" directory. You can use them as a template for your own input data.
SpacerPlacer allows to predict the insertion orientation of CRISPR arrays and thus, indirectly, the transcription orientation and the leader end. Currently, the transcription orientation can be predicted within SpacerPlacer using the option "--determine_orientation".
If run with this option, SpacerPlacer will predict the orientation of the CRISPR arrays by running the reconstruction of the given CRISPR arrays in the given (forward) orientation and by reversing the arrays and running the reconstruction again. These two reconstructions are then compared. If the difference in likelihoods between the forward and reverse reconstructions exceeds a threshold, which can be provided by the user with "--orientation_threshold ", SpacerPlacer will predict the orientation accordingly. This orientation is then used for reporting details about the reconstruction and parameter estimates in the summary and result files.
As described in the section "Output" section, all information for reconstructions with both orientations is accessible in the respective directories. If the difference in likelihoods is below the threshold, SpacerPlacer will use the forward/provided orientation as default.
It is important to provide the CRISPR arrays in consistent orientations, as spacers might not be recognized as the same, if the orientations are not consistent.
The CRISPR array input data has to be provided in a specific format. We provide two alternative input formats: "spacer_fasta" and "ccf"/"crisprcasfinder". Trees can be estimated by SpacerPlacer based on the spacer arrays, but we generally recommend to provide trees, if available, in particular, to get interpretable results in parameter estimates. The following sections describe the input formats in detail. IMPORTANT: the input type should be specified using the option "-it" or "--input_type", default is "spacer_fasta".
SpacerPlacer can either run a single group or multiple groups of CRISPR arrays sequentially. Names are of course arbitrary and can be chosen freely. Each group should contain at least two arrays. If there is no overlap in spacers between the arrays, the results of SpacerPlacer will be relatively boring.
Note, that the group should be in a file with extensions ".fa", ".fasta", ".fna". Each fasta file contains the spacers of the corresponding arrays in the group structured as follows:
>array_1
3, 2, 1
>array_2
4, 2, 1, 7
>array_3
6, 5, 2, 2, 7
...
The first line after ">" is the identifier of the array or strain (arbitrary) and should be unique! The numbers in the example are the spacer IDs and separated by ",", but can be any string (that does not include "," and/or " "). Each spacer ID corresponds to a unique spacer sequence (or a group of spacer sequences, if you want). Repeats are not part of this format. The order of the spacers is important and should be the same for all arrays in the group. We expect the spacers to be ordered chronologically, where the insertion end is on the left and the distal end on the right, i.e. the first (leftmost) spacer is the youngest, while the last (rightmost) spacer is the oldest. Most importantly, the order of the spacers should be consistent for all arrays in the group. The order is not as important, if you use SpacerPlacer to determine the orientation, as both directions are run. Note, there is no need to provide reversed spacers, as SpacerPlacer will automatically reverse the spacers to run a reconstruction in reverse orientation (if the option is provided).
You may run a single group of CRISPR arrays in spacer_fasta format by running:
python spacerplacer.py <spacer_fasta_path> <output_path> -it spacer_fasta [more_options]or without specifying the input type, as "spacer_fasta" is the default.
If you want to run multiple groups subsequently in this format, the files should be structured as follows:
.
├── experiment # Top-level directory of run (the input directory provided to SpacerPlacer)
│ ├── group_1.fa # First group of CRISPR arrays
│ ├── group_2.fa # Second group of CRISPR arrays
│ ├── group_3.fa # Third group of CRISPR arrays
│ └── ... # etc.
└── ... You can then run SpacerPlacer with the following command:
python spacerplacer.py <input_path> <output_path> -it spacer_fasta [more_options]or without specifying the input type, as "spacer_fasta" is the default. "input_path" is the top-level directory of the run, in this example "/experiment".
SpacerPlacer can use data in CRISPRCasdb/CRISPRCasFinder output format. To get files in this format you can e.g. submit the genomic sequences to the CRISPRCasFinder web server (or extract existing arrays from CRISPRCasdb).
You then need to carefully select the output CRISPR array and place them into two folders as the CRISPRCasFinder interface is capable of predicting the orientation but always provides the spacers in the forward strand orientation. Be aware that since CRISPRCasFinder predicts the orientation internally the consensus repeat will appear different in the output.
CRISPRCasFinder only provides the forward strand orientation. So in order to ensure the correct representation you need to place all the files classified as forward strand into the "pos_strand" directory, and all the files classified as reverse strand into the "neg_strand" directory.
(Note: the folder names are different in the gifs. See above or in the examples for the correct folder names.)
The CRISPRCasFinder output is a set of files in fasta format containing only the spacers from the corresponding CRISPR arrays.
In this format each group of CRISPR arrays should be structured as follows:
.
├── experiment # Top-level directory of run (the input directory provided to SpacerPlacer)
│ ├── group_1 # First group of CRISPR arrays
│ │ ├── pos_strand # Forward strand CRISPR arrays
│ │ │ ├── array_1.fna # First array
│ │ │ └── ...
│ │ ├── neg_strand # Reverse strand CRISPR arrays
│ │ │ ├── array_2.fna # Second array
│ │ │ ├── array_3.fna # Third array
│ │ │ └── ...
│ ├── group_2 # Second group of CRISPR arrays
│ │ ├── pos_strand # Forward strand CRISPR arrays
│ │ │ └── ... #
│ │ └── rev_strand # Reverse strand CRISPR arrays
│ │ └── ... #
│ └── ... # etc.
└── ... where the file extensions should be ".fa", ".fasta", ".fna". Note, that the positive and negative strand folders can be empty. The arrays names need to be unique.
If the complete DNA sequence is in the file, as might be the case when getting data from CRISPRCasdb, delete the complete DNA sequence and keep only the spacers.
Examples of the format are shown in "example_data/workflow_example_listeria_monocytogenes" and "workflow_example_listeria_monocytogenes_all_strains".
Providing the arrays in the right orientation is critical, as spacers might not be recognized as the same, if the orientations are not consistent. CRISPRCasFinder does not always provide an orientation prediction and in some cases the predicted orientation might be wrong. If you are not sure about the orientation, it might be helpful to put an array in both folders (with different names) and check the results. Then if only one of those arrays shows spacer overlap, you have a likely candidate for a consistent orientation. If reconstructions show no overlap, you might want to check the orientation of the arrays again.
You can then run SpacerPlacer with the following command:
python spacerplacer.py <input_path> <output_path> -it ccf [more_options]alternatively for "ccf" you can use "crisprcasfinder". "input_path" is the top-level directory of the run, in this case "path-to-experiment/experiment". Note, that currently you need to specify the top-level directory not an individual group directory (even if you are only running one group).
SpacerPlacer will automatically convert the CRISPRCasFinder format into "spacer_fasta" format. The converted files will be saved in the output directory, with dictionaries detailing the renaming process. For more details see the section "Output".
Trees can be provided by the user. The trees MUST be in newick format.
If only a single fasta is run, the direct path to the tree can be provided using the option "--tree_path <path_to_tree>".
There are two ways to provide trees for multiple groups of CRISPR arrays. NOTE: in both cases the names of the trees need to be the same as the group names.
- The trees can be provided as separate files containing the tree as string in newick format (the choice of extension is irrelevant). To avoid issues, keep the tree files in a separate directory of the fasta files (or together in a subdirectory). The file names need to be the same as the group names, e.g.:
.
├── experiment # top-level directory of run
│ ├── group_1.fa # First group of CRISPR arrays
│ ├── group_2.fa # Second group of CRISPR arrays
│ ├── group_3.fa # Third group of CRISPR arrays
│ └── ... # etc.
└── trees # optional directory containing the trees
├── group_1.tree # Tree for the first group of CRISPR arrays
├── group_2.tree # Tree for the second group of CRISPR arrays
├── group_3.tree # Tree for the third group of CRISPR arrays
└── ... # etc.- OR you can provide the trees in a dictionary in a json file providing for each group (string) a newick tree (as string), e.g.:
{
"group_1": "((array_1:0.1,array_2:0.1):0.1,array_3:0.2);",
"group_2": "tree2 in nwk format",
"group_3": "tree3 in nwk format"
}The leafs of the trees MUST be named like the array names in the CRISPR array files. Inner nodes do not need to be named (then SpacerPlacer names them during the algorithm).
- Then you can run SpacerPlacer by referencing to the folder containing the newick trees using the option "--tree_path <path_to_tree_folder>".
- OR you can run SpacerPlacer by referencing to the json file (containing the trees for all experiments) using the option "--tree_path /.json".
An example for one tree in json format is given in "example_datasets/workflow_example_core_genome_tree" used in "configs/config_workflow_example_lm_wcgt".
SpacerPlacer will automatically save the input trees or predicted trees in the output directory (as a dictionary {group_name: tree in nwk}) in a json file.
The output of SpacerPlacer is saved in the output directory provided by the user. The folder contains a "summary.txt", "0_results.csv", "0_logger.log", and folders "additional_data", "detailed_results", "0_forward", and "_reversed", if the option "--determine_orientation" is used.
The "summary.txt" file contains a summary of the run. It contains information about the input data, the options used, and predicted parameters for each group.
The "0_logger.log" file contains a log of the run. It contains information about the run, warnings, and errors occurring during the run. The amount of information in the log file can be controlled by the user by adjusting using the option "--verbosity".
The most important results are saved in the "0_results.csv" file. Where each row corresponds to a group of CRISPR arrays. If "--determine orientation" is used, the parameter estimates are taken from the reconstruction with the predicted orientation by SpacerPlacer. If there is no certain orientation, the parameter estimates and information about the reconstruction are taken from the forward orientation.
For more detailed results see the protocol files in the "0_forward" or "detailed_results" folder. The "detailed_results" folder only exists, if the option "--determine_orientation" is used. They contain additional information about the reconstructions, where detailed_results contains the information about the reconstruction with the by SpacerPlacer predicted orientation. Note, that parameter estimation of trivial groups, "trivial" meaning without a single deletion, is not possible. Any predicted parameters for trivial groups are not reliable. "0_protocol_skipped.csv" contains groups that were skipped by SpacerPlacer and the reason for it.
The "0_forward" folder contains all visualizations of the reconstructions with forward/provided array orientation. The visualizations of the reconstructions and partial spacer insertion order (PSIO) graphs for each group (and the .dot files used for rendering the PSIO graphs with graphviz). <group_name>_rec shows the final reconstruction after the refinement step, while <group_name>_guide_rec show the first guide reconstruction (that does not follow the PSIO).
If the option "--determine_orientation" is used, the "0_reversed" folder contains the same information as the "0_forward" folder for the CRISPR groups reconstructed in reverse orientation.
The "additional_data" folder contains additional data, such as the input/predicted trees as a dictionary in a json file, the CRISPR arrays in SpacerPlacers internal format in a pickle file. The "work_folder" contains the temporary files generated for the alignment step with MAFFT. The "spacer_fasta" folder contains the converted spacer_fasta files, if the input was in CRISPRCasFinder format. Then there is also a file "<group_name>_spacer_name_to_seq.fa" referencing each spacer name to the corresponding DNA sequence and the orientation of the spacer DNA sequence. Note, this naming is done automatically by SpacerPlacer when converting the CRISPRCasFinder format to the spacer_fasta format.
The folder always contains a dictionary in a json file "<group_name>_spacer_name_to_sp_number.json", detailing the renaming process from the given spacer name to the internal spacer number used by SpacerPlacer (this is the numbering shown in reconstruction and PSIO visualizations).
To reiterate the spacer data is converted/renamed as follows:
- DNA sequences to spacer names to generate spacer_fasta files and determine spacer overlap between arrays. This step is only done, if the input format is from CRISPRCasFinder. The conversion is found in "<group_name>_spacer_name_to_seq.fa".
- Spacer names are converted to spacer numbers to run the reconstruction algorithm. This is done to guarantee that spacers numbers are unique during the algorithm. Note, that any additions to the spacer name (A, B, C, ...) show duplicate candidates in the Multiple Spacer Array Alignment. Each of those spacers have the same underlying DNA sequence (e.g. 9A, 9B are the same original spacer 9). This step is done for all input formats. The conversion is found in "<group_name>_spacer_name_to_sp_number.json". The spacer numbers are the numbers shown in the reconstruction and PSIO visualizations as colored rectangles. The spacer names (with duplicate candidates), are shown in gray as column headings in the Multiple Spacer Array Alignment in the visualized reconstructions. Thus, the information found in "<group_name>_spacer_name_to_sp_number.json" is also contained in any visualized reconstruction.
-
Not all options available for SpacerPlacer are described in this README. For a full list of options, run
python spacerplacer.py -h. -
As SpacerPlacer relies on ETE Toolkit 3, the visualization of the reconstruction will not work on (web) servers without a graphical interface (X backend). If you run into issues you can try X11 forwarding (if available), or running a virtual X server, e.g. with XVFB (see the ETE Toolkit tutorial). Alternatively, you can skip the visualization step by running SpacerPlacer with the option "--no_plot_reconstruction".
-
Parts of the reconstruction visualization png may be missing, if the size of the image exceeds 2^15 pixels in width and/or height. Solution: Either use the pdf output, which should be fine, or manually adjust the width and height by using the custom figure size options ("--figsize_rec" and "--dpi_rec").
-
macOS: We introduced an additional macOS script for mafft. We hope this allows the use of SpacerPlacer with Mac OS. If you encounter any issues, please let us know.
-
The estimation of the tree based on the spacer arrays is not optimized and thus can be quite slow, especially for larger group sizes.
-
SpacerPlacer is certainly not perfect. If the results are not as expected or errors occur, it might be helpful to:
- check the logfile (0_logger.log) for errors/warnings,
- check "0_forward/0_protocol_skipped.csv" and/or "0_reversed/0_protocol_skipped.csv" for skipped groups and the reason (e.g. groups with only one array are skipped),
- check if the input data is read correctly by SpacerPlacer, particularly, check if the input/output to/by MAFFT (in "additional_data/work_folder") is reasonable, and compare your input with the provided example datasets.
- check the orientation of the CRISPR arrays, if you use CRISPRCasFinder format. We aim to provide an easier to use CRISPRCasFinder integration and comprehensive clustering of provided arrays in the future.
If you encounter non-informative/unresolvable errors or the results are not as expected (or not understandable), please open an issue or contact us directly, and we will try to help you (and try to resolve the issue for future users).
The impact of a wrongly estimated tree on the reconstructed ancestral arrays can be quite large. Consider two close sister arrays are placed far apart in the tree. Then the reconstruction might lead to an accumulation of spacer acquisitions in the root. In turn, these can produce a lot of "hallucinatory" contradictions and pull up more spacers to the root. In most cases, these issues are either not too sever or can be seen and addressed by the user. First, misplacement of sister arrays is generally not too egregious, i.e. the misplacement happens in close sister clades. Then not too many "hallucinatory" contradictions are produced and the damage is limited to the few arrays contained in the same clades. Second, these "hallucinatory" contradictions are very likely to be observed by a knowledgeable user due to multiple reasons: a) arrays with large overlap are likely to stand out by themselves, b) there is an excess of insertion events at the most recent common ancestor and c) an excess of produced deletion events for all arrays in the clade. If such an issue is observed, it can be addressed by either correcting the tree, excluding the offending arrays or adjusting the insertion/deletion rate for the guide reconstruction. A large guide insertion rate (compared to the guide deletion rate) will allow the model to independently acquire spacers in far removed clades and can resolve the above issues. However, if the guide insertion rate is set too high, it can lead to the model acquiring the spacers only at the respective leafs, and thus producing reconstructions with multiple acquisition events for each spacer and no deletion events.
Note, that parameter estimation is strongly affected by the quality of the tree (and thus the timescale) and by the number of events, i.e. if enough variation is observable in the provided CRISPR arrays. In general, sample sizes are quite low for most datasets and thus the parameter estimates have high variance. We recommend to trust parameter estimates only for large datasets (multiple groups), in the best case, with high quality trees. Even then we recommend to only trust the median (or the mean, although it can be heavily influenced by outliers) of the parameters, which we found to be fairly accurate.
The impact of incomplete arrays is generally not too severe. As long as enough overlap exists to produce a PSIO, that sufficiently reflects the true insertion order, and you are not missing crucial overlap or huge numbers of spacers. Moreover, any issues will likely be very visible for the user. For instance, CRISPR arrays that were wrongly split into two separate arrays can likely be easily found (two rows in the spacer alignment "complete" each other).
