Implement auto-passwords mode #222
Conversation
This mode is automatically enabled iff: - The password field is disabled - Normal login is disabled - Automatic login is enabled In this mode, the login hash cookie acts as the only needed authentication. It is assigned automatically when the user posts something for the first time, and allows them to redact all comments made while still in possession of said cookie.
CyberShadow
force-pushed
the
autopasswords
branch
from
208bd00
to
7c833ab
Compare
|
Unfortunately, no. Not only is this a new feature, which aren't being considered for 2.0, but it also introduces a major security problem that the code (to the best of my memory) makes no effort to prevent. This being the permanence of the random login token, which allows an attacker infinite time to generate a matching token via a rainbow table lookup or even bruteforce. If they can guess the token they have complete access to the comment including the email address, and they would be able to edit the comment to replace it with SPAM or defamatory language. The reason this commit is relatively small, is because this feature is planned for a future release, as such most of the functionality to allow it already exists in the code. However, because of the security implications of such a feature, I have not implemented it. Mainly because I have not thought of a logical way to solve the underlying problem. That is, a way to make the randomly generated login token temporary or more difficult to guess without a significant performance impact. I should probably close this request, but I also like to keep it open to remind myself to implement this feature. And now with this explanation of the problem, perhaps more people will suggest ways to fix the issues I have with the approach. |
Following this logic we should stop using public-key cryptography, because it's "possible" to brute-force a private key from the public key? |
This mode is automatically enabled iff:
In this mode, the login hash cookie acts as the only needed
authentication. It is assigned automatically when the user posts
something for the first time, and allows them to redact all comments made
while still in possession of said cookie.
Fixes #212.
Soft dependency on #220 to allow disabling the password field via the administration panel.