Absorb LSC boundary mechanisms into JC - #2
Merged
Conversation
Files: add fact_trust_envelope, lsc_boundary_status, taint, output_firewall, review_packet, io_contracts, lsc_boundary_io_contracts, lsc_boundary_absorption docs, snapshot/final reports, memory.md, and 8 lsc boundary test files; update root boundary docs, post_freeze_surface, proof_trace_renderer, result_exporter, and mcp_server. Root cause: LSC assets contain useful engineering boundary protocols, but directly copying LSC legal objects or result semantics would pollute JC formal semantics and trigger route-back to legal-math-modeling. Project knowledge: LSC statuses are JC engineering aliases only; USER_ASSUMED/DISPUTED/UNKNOWN produce hypothetical, review-only, missing-fact, conflict, or review-packet outputs without changing verified_fact, DecisionStatus, Horn closure, attack/exception/priority/permission, certificate acceptance, formal proof claims, or fail-closed behavior. Impact: adds auditable boundary metadata and MCP/renderer machine state preservation while keeping checker/evaluator semantics unchanged. Verification: 35 lsc boundary tests passed; targeted handoff regression passed with 40 passed and 4 skipped; MCP manifest/post-freeze tests passed with 16 passed; python mcp_server.py --test passed; git diff --check reported no whitespace errors, only line-ending warnings. GitHub Actions is blocked because gh auth status reports an invalid token.
Files: update reports/lsc_absorption_final_report_2026-07-03.md with GitHub Actions CI run metadata. Root cause: Phase 11 could not be marked complete until ci.yml was triggered and watched on the migration branch. Project knowledge: ci.yml only auto-runs on main push, so branch CI for codex/lsc-boundary-absorption requires workflow_dispatch. Impact: final report now records github_actions_status=passed, run_id=28636003678, URL, and conclusion=success. Verification: gh run watch 28636003678 --exit-status passed; gh run view reported completed/success; git diff --check had no whitespace errors.
Files: update reports/lsc_absorption_final_report_2026-07-03.md with run 28636199941, headSha evidence, corrected 20808 proxy note, and run-id fixed-point caveat. Root cause: the prior final report recorded the first CI run, while a later report commit had a separate successful CI run that needed to be made explicit for strict audit. Project knowledge: writing a post-CI run id into a tracked report creates a later commit, so the authoritative final-head proof is the newest ci.yml run whose headSha equals the pushed branch HEAD. Impact: report now distinguishes the migration commit CI from report-updated head CI without changing runtime code. Verification: Select-String confirmed run metadata; git diff --check reported no whitespace errors, only line-ending warnings.
Files: docs/lsc_boundary_absorption.md, memory.md, reports/lsc_absorption_final_report_2026-07-03.md. Root cause: post-absorption report needed current cross-repository evidence after legal-math-modeling was consolidated to main and Deli remained source-clean. Project knowledge: legal-math CI is specification-boundary evidence only; JC runtime metadata is not a Lean proof claim, and Lake Build + Scan run 28645132034 remains in progress until GitHub Actions returns a conclusion. Impact: documentation/reporting only; no verified_fact, DecisionStatus, Horn closure, attack/exception/priority/permission, certificate checker, or formal proof semantics changed. Verification: targeted LSC boundary pytest 35 passed; handoff/MCP regression pytest 40 passed and 4 skipped; manifest dispatch 2 passed; post-freeze surface 14 passed; mcp_server.py --test passed; pre-release L1 pip check and pip-audit passed; pre-release L2 secret/user-path/private-IP scan returned zero findings; git diff --check reported no whitespace errors.
Files: reports/lsc_absorption_final_report_2026-07-03.md. Root cause: legal-math Lake Build + Scan run 28645132034 completed after the prior report update and needed to replace the temporary in-progress status. Project knowledge: legal-math main run 28645132034 validates the companion repository source SHA a3a015941f75091c87d57aa956e712f1546dd7d4; it remains proof-boundary evidence and is not a Lean proof claim for JC runtime metadata. Impact: reporting only; no runtime, certificate, fact-verification, or formal semantics changed. Verification: gh run watch 28645132034 --repo laubeing-droid/legal-math-modeling --exit-status completed successfully; gh run watch 28648135682 --repo laubeing-droid/juris-calculus --exit-status completed successfully for the previous branch head; git diff --check passed with line-ending warnings only.
laubeing-droid
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Jul 3, 2026
Files: reports/lsc_absorption_final_report_2026-07-03.md. Root cause: after PR #2 merged, the final report needed the authoritative PR URL, merge commit, and main GitHub Actions run evidence. Project knowledge: PR #2 merged codex/lsc-boundary-absorption into main at 44a70bd; main CI run 28648854494 passed for that merge commit; branch CI run 28648547747 and legal-math Lake run 28645132034 passed. Impact: reporting only; no runtime, certificate, fact-verification, or formal semantics changed. Verification: git diff --check passed with line-ending warnings only; gh run watch 28648854494 completed successfully before this report evidence commit.
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
1 participant
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Scope
Absorb only LSC transferable boundary mechanisms into JC:
Explicit non-migration
This PR does not migrate LSC legal objects, Deadline/Fee/Interest/Jurisdiction/Citation tools, AgentSkill, CLI/API, China-law concrete rules, or P1/P2 merits judgment.
Cross-repo evidence
Local verification
Formal boundary
Runtime metadata imported from LSC is engineering metadata only. This PR does not claim a new Lean theorem family and does not change verified_fact, DecisionStatus, Horn closure, attack/exception/priority/permission semantics, certificate checker acceptance, or formal proof claims.