Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Desktop: Add OneNote Importer #11392

Open
wants to merge 168 commits into
base: dev
Choose a base branch
from
Open

Conversation

pedr
Copy link
Collaborator

@pedr pedr commented Nov 14, 2024

Following #10642 (comment) PR that was reverted to

Summary

We are adding a OneNote importer to Joplin Desktop. This change uses an implementation developed by https://github.com/msiemens/ to convert the binary OneNote backup into HTML.

To make it work with the Joplin project I made several changes to the project to be able to work on the WebAssembly environment provided by Electron. The changes include replacing Rust functions that don't exist on the WebAssembly environment with some alternative implementation for Node.js

Important

Project is not going to be build unless IS_CONTINUOUS_INTEGRATION environment variable is set during the yarn build process

To not require all Joplin developers to have Rust in their machine to work in the repository, we made the build process optional, only running the tests related to OneNote and build process if it has this flag enabled.


Duplicating README.md here for more context:

README.md

OneNote Converter

This package is used to process OneNote backup files and output HTML that Joplin can import.

The code is based on the projects created by https://github.com/msiemens

We adapted it to target WebAssembly, adding Node.js functions that could interface with the host machine. For that to happen we are using custom-made functions (see node_functions.js) and the Node.js standard library (see src/utils.rs).

How the OneNote Importer Process Works

The requirement for this project was to simplify the migration process from OneNote to Joplin. The starting point of this migration is to export the notebook from OneNote as a zip file containing files in the binary format used by OneNote.

The process looks like this:

  1. Unzip the backup file.
  2. Use onenote-converter to read and convert the binary files to HTML (this project).
  3. Extract the SVG nodes from the HTML to resources:
    1. Find all SVG nodes in the HTML file.
    2. Create SVG files from the nodes.
    3. Update the HTML file with references to the SVGs.
  4. Use the Importer HTML service to create the Joplin notes and resources.

See the InteropService_Importer_OneNote class in the lib project for details.

SVG Extraction

The OneNote drawing feature uses <svg> tags to save user drawings. Joplin doesn't support SVG rendering due to security concerns, so we added a step to extract the <svg> elements as SVG images, replacing them with <img> tags.

For each HTML file, we:

  • Mount the HTML in the document.
  • Find all the svg nodes.
  • Replace each svg node with an img node that has a unique title, which will be used as the resource name.
  • After editing the entire document, update the HTML.
  • Create the SVG images on the local disk with the title used in the replaced img tags.

After this, the HTML should look the same and is ready to be imported by the Importer HTML service.

Project structure:

- onenote-converter
    - package.json              -> where the project is built
    - node_functions.js         -> where the custom-made functions used inside rust goes
    ...
    - pkg                       -> artifact folder generated in the build step
        - onenote_converter.js  -> main file
    ...
    - src
        - lib.rs                -> starting point

Development requirements:

To work with the project you will need:

When working with the Rust code you will probably rather run yarn buildDev since it is faster and it has more logging messages (they can be disabled in the macro log!())

During development, it will be easier to test it where this library is called. InteropService_Importer_Onenote.ts is the code that depends on this and already has some tests.

Running tests and IS_CONTINUOUS_INTEGRATION

We don't require developers that won't work on this project to have Rust installed on their machine.
To make this work we:

  • Use temporary files, required only for building the application correctly (e.g: pkg/onenote_converter.js).
  • Skip the build process if IS_CONTINUOUS_INTEGRATION is not set (see build.js).
  • Skip some tests if IS_CONTINUOUS_INTEGRATION is not set (see lib/services/interop/InteropService_Importer_OneNote.test.ts).

The tests should still run on CI since IS_CONTINUOUS_INTEGRATION is used there.

Security concerns

We are using WebAssembly with Node.js calls to the file system, reading and writing files and directories, which means
it is not isolated (no more than Node.js is, for that matter).

Tests

While we don't have automate test directly for this project, we added several tests for the InteropService_Importer_OneNote component, which is using this newly added package.

Tests are set to skip unless IS_CONTINUOUS_INTEGRATION environment variable is set.

pedr and others added 30 commits April 1, 2024 07:15
@pedr pedr added desktop All desktop platforms import Related to importing files such as ENEX, JEX, etc. labels Nov 14, 2024
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
desktop All desktop platforms import Related to importing files such as ENEX, JEX, etc.
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants